2 Ups And 4 Downs From Last Night's WWE NXT (23 Sept)

Asuka debuts on an uneven night for NXT.

By Adam Blampied /

Last night's NXT was something of a hollow affair. Despite the next NXT TakeOver special, now revealed to be called TakeOver: Respect, being just a fortnight away, the company really took its foot off the gas in terms of build. Apollo Crews vs Tyler Breeze was announced, sure, and the two had a tiny encounter backstage, but it was strange, with Apollo acting like more of a jerk than Breeze. Very little of narrative purpose was accomplished tonight, except of course for the debut of Kana, aka Asuka, which was intriguing, if a little physically underwhelming. Bayley and Sasha Banks were only highlighted in the form of a video package, Crew and Breeze feels like a arbitrary matchup, not improved by an odd backstage segment and, most baffling of all, there wasn't a Dusty Rhodes classic quarter final match. Considering that the classic will take up the lion's share of the special in two weeks time, the decision to farm out 2 of 4 quarter final matches to live events rather than TV tapings is a bizarre and frustrating move on behalf of the company. Last night's card (w/finishes) Eva Marie vs Carmella Eva Marie wins via countout after Carmella lands badly on the outside. Tyler Breeze vs Bull Dempsey Breeze pins Bull using the ropes for leverage. The Vaudevillains vs Blake and Murphy (NXT Tag Team Championship match) Gotch pins Blake after the Whirling Dervish.

Advertisement

Downs...

4. Eva Marie Losing The Battle With The Crowd?

The Eva Marie experiment is struggling. Right now, NXT appears to be shifting the narrative on All Red Everything (which is now, and will always be, a terrible nickname). A few months ago, when it was first revealed that Eva would be gracing NXT with her presence, the story looked fairly simple. Eva Marie used to be the worst worker on the Divas' roster (no mean feat) but after hard work and training she was going to bust her ass in the ring and slowly win back the crowd. Yeah, not so much. The crowds have not warmed to the flame-haired diva in the slightest. Instead, the personal attacks seem to have intensified. Eva's very public botch two weeks ago, where she forgot to kick out and the referee had to cover for her, have ramped up the heat on her to near-nuclear levels. The chants are getting vicious; alongside the standard cruelty of "You Can't Wrestle", the fans took to bellowing "All Botch Everything" and, "Super Dragon", which is the super-smark equivalent of chanting "JBL" on Raw. It's hard to know how much Eva Marie was ever intended to be a babyface - her entrance, aggressive in-ring style, and natural demeanour all exude 'heel' - but any redemptive quality of this storyline seems to be out the window, exemplified by the frustrating end to her match with Carmella last night. NXT have chosen to play up the narrative of Eva winning by chance rather than merit, and poked the angry fans with a countout. NXT fans are used to seeing actual finishes in their matches, and associating Eva with disappointment in that area is a risky strategy for NXT to pursue, but with the fans as vocal as they are, do they have any other choice?

3. Bulk Fit

Bull Dempsey's career progression certainly rhymes with Bull-Fit. The good news is that the crowd have gotten behind this new, fun-loving Bull Dempsey, the adorable clown who slaps his belly and plays up to the cries of "This is Bull-Fit". The problem is, he's still losing. Once again, Bull Dempsey ended up with his ass laid down for that 3-second tan. The story now follows Tyler Breeze to his next encounter, this time with Apollo Crews. Bull is left behind. Wins and losses don't mean everything in this industry, but a trends of losses can really sour the public on a character quickly. Since the revamp of his persona, Bull is 1-2 on TV, which forces a fan to ask, how much more can Bull take before the shine is off the apple? Also, despite fitness being the backbone of his new gimmick, Bull certainly hasn't seemed to have slimmed down in any meaningful way. In fact, short of a new boxing robe, Bull's appearance hasn't changed at all. For some reason, he still slaps his belly, bigging up the fact that he's unhealthy, rather than on the road to self-discipline. He should be doing pushups in the ring, not amplifying his chubbitude. Let's hope that Dempsey can start adding some Ws to his TV record soon, otherwise the fans behind him might stop chanting "Bull-Fit", and start chanting ... well, you work it out.

2. It's All Talk

NXT only gets an hour of programming a week, unlike the main roster which clocks in at a ridiculous seven when you include Main Event and Superstars. Very often this works in NXT's favour - not over-exposing its stars, and forcing the bookers to pare down the 'entertainment' and ratchet up the 'sports'. Most weeks, NXT is able to fit five or even six matches into its tight running time. Not so this week. The card ran at a mere three matches and, considering one of those starred Eva Marie, it's hard for the majority of the NXT audience at home not to feel a little short-changed. The card was simply crammed full of talking. Segments came in from the Hype Bros, Jordan & Gable, Samoa Joe & Finn Balor, Enzo & Big Cass, Apollo Crews & Tyler Breeze; there was a long segment hosted by Kyle Edwards who broke down the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team classic, there was a lengthy video package highlighting the Bayley/Sasha Banks match; the Asuka segment was all talk and no physical confrontation. Add on top of that all of the requisite advertisements for T-Shirts and other Network programming and I couldn't help but thinking: "Yo, Goober, where's the meat?" Not every week can't be stuffed with matches, but the fans have come to expect more from NXT. Better time management, less chat and more in-ring action per minute that the filler-bloated monster that is Monday Night Raw. This is even more peculiar considering that there's supposed to be this big tournament going on. Speaking of which...

1. What Happened To The Quarter Finals?

Seriously, what happened? We won't get to see half of them?! WWE know that most people who watch NXT don't live in Florida, right? It's madness that live events would get to watch the Tag Team Classic quarter finals and the infinitely bigger TV crowd is forced to enjoy piecemeal highlights. It's understandable that not all of the qualifying stages would be shown, but to go a week without a single Classic match on TV makes zero sense. A tournament is an absolute gift for a booker. A series of matches with in-built stakes, which only get higher with each passing match. So far there have been 10 matches as part of this tournament, and the TV audience has only gotten to see 5. Their anticipation for the final isn't rising anywhere near as high as it should. Why have half of these matches been reduced to highlights packages hosted by Kyle Edwards, who looks he plopped out the same 'overproduced bland white guy' machine that gave us Michael Cole and Tom Phillips? After all the recent successful touring that NXT boasts about, I can't believe that live event attendance is struggling enough to need the boost of Tag Classic matches. It's unlikely, so why, after upsetting Solomon Crowe and Adrian Flipping Neville, do Jordan and Gable have to battle off-camera in their quarter final?! It's severely reducing the TV audience's investment in the tournament. I DON'T CARE ABOUT KYLE EDWARDS OR ANY OF THE THINGS HE HAS TO SAY.

Ups...

2. The Vaudevillains Shine

There are only two ups this week. It's slim pickings. Despite losing to Dash and Wilder in the quarter finals of the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic (in a match that we didn't get to see), The Vaudevillains successful retained their championships last night, and did it with no shortage of style. The NXT audience have tried their best with Blake and Murphy, they really have. The "Come on Blakey, Let's Go Party" chants were hilarious, but ultimately there is nothing for the audience to latch onto with the hairy duo. They are a bit dumb, and occasionally look stupid, and that's it. With their charismatic manager, Alexa Bliss, being run out of the match early into the runtime, it just highlighted how much dynamism the pair lack when left to themselves. Having villains that the fans weren't inspired to hate hurt the match, but thankfully The Vaudevillains have personality to spare. English and Gotch's move-set is flashy, on-theme and innovative. Simon Gotch is constantly finding new ways to flamboyantly kick his opponents and Aiden English is slowly mastering the crowd-popping comeback sequence, his kip-up into a masculine flexing pose eliciting a "That Was Manly" chant from the fans at Full Sail. The Vaudevillains carried the match to a positive rating, and fans should cherish their title run while they still can, because one cannot hope but have apprehension should they be called to the main roster. Former champs The Lucha Dragons and the Ascension have blended into the background on Raw and Smackdown, and with The Vaudevillains' overtly cheesy gimmick, you have to doubt that the main roster writers will be able to handle the two strongmen without dumbing them down to comedic pratfallers. It makes me sad and afraid to picture English and Gotch in a backstage segment, advertising WWE's new range of action figures and ring play-sets. As they demonstrated last night, they are much better than that.

1. There's Madness Behind Asuka's Eyes

The big story from last night is the debut of the wrestler formerly known as Kana. William Regal did a masterful job of getting the audience pumped for seeing 'the hottest free agent in the world' and when the newly-christened Asuka (pronounced Asska) stepped out onstage, she didn't disappoint. She walked onstage wearing the doll's mask, which we can all agree is really, really creepy, but when it was removed she became this whirligig of exuberance. She seemed more like an excitable teenager than the unnerving warrior that her hype vignettes implied. She greeted the crowd with fist pumps and whoops of joy. And then she was interrupted. Dana Brooke and Emma came down to 'welcome' her to the roster and, first things first, is this just the standard way that WWE introduces massively important Asian superstars? When Hideo Itami debuted in NXT, he was greeted by a two-on-one assault by The Ascension, and now Asuka has to deal with Dana and Emma. Similarities aside, Asuka's response to being dismissed by the two hotshot blondes was intriguing. She obeyed their instructions to leave, slowly walking out of the ring and up the ramp, before turning and flashing a deeply sinister smile at the two women, before finally leaving. With Kane flipping between monster and stooge on Raw, split-personalities seem to be the 'in thing' right now, and there is a dormant vein of pitch-black darkness beneath Asuka's bubbly exterior. Rather than respond to Emma and Dana's rudeness with the standard display of physical dominance, Asuka went for unsettling her opponents instead, which is a subtlety rarely seen on WWE programming, and a welcome change of pace. I'm looking forward to seeing where this is heading.