20 Greatest WWE SummerSlam Matches Ever

With the 2014 version just around the corner, we take a trip down memory lane and remind ourselves just how good this event can be.

By Chad Matthews /

Sunday marks the night of the twenty-seventh annual Summer Classic in professional wrestling's premier worldwide promotion. Summerslam is WWE€™s second biggest event, having taken on an identity similar but not equal to WrestleMania for the middle months of the calendar. Some might argue that the Royal Rumble is Vince McMahon second greatest pay-per-view creation, but it is so directly linked to WrestleMania that it has never been asked to stand on its own like its August counterpart. As such, no event but Mania has, since its inception, created the list of memories that has Summerslam. Along the way, it has played host to a plethora of classic matches that only €œThe Show of Shows€ can rival and, on some occasions, has even managed to outshine its big brother. For the last twenty years, it has been difficult for WWE to distinguish certain PPVs when they feature one or more per month, but Summerslam has managed to remain exceptional. With the 2014 version just around the corner, let us celebrate the greatest 20 matches in the history of Summerslam.

20. Randy Orton vs. Chris Benoit - World Title (2004)

The night that Randy Orton became the youngest World Champion in WWE history was an interesting one. After being often criticized for his mistimed spots or chinlock of doom or mega-push that many felt was unwarranted, Orton had a Canadian crowd supporting his efforts to win the big gold belt from their countryman. Who would have thought that Chris Benoit, instead of getting a hero€™s welcome at the second biggest PPV of the year, would get a reaction that paled in comparison to the brash youngster€™s? For much of 2003 and 2004, people ragged on Orton like crazy. Yet, he had an outstanding 2004 leading up to Summerslam. In two victories over Mick Foley, Orton gained a lot of credibility as both a character and performer, setting himself up to be a legitimate threat to the World Champion by August. At Summerslam, Orton€™s defeat of Benoit in a borderline classic match was the culmination of a lot of hard work by both Orton, himself, and WWE creative. There was not much time to celebrate the victory, as the most ill-fated face turn in history came right afterward. It was a bittersweet night for Benoit and his fans. They had waited a long time to see him win the big one and, though he did well in a five month reign with the title, the WWE moved on and the main-event chapter of Benoit€™s career ended.

19. Batista vs. John Cena (2008)

Batista vs. John Cena was an epic first encounter between the WWE€™s top two stars of the era. When they both ended up on the same show back in the summer of 2005, shortly after each had won their first respective World titles, mental seeds were watered for a major showdown. The seeds had been planted at the €™05 Rumble that saw the two hit the ground at the same time and the match restarted before Batista eventually won the Battle Royal and defeated Trips in Mania 21€™s main-event. By the time 2008 rolled around, the seeds had sprouted for a memorable match that shockingly took place at anywhere other than WrestleMania. Cena, by that point, had firmly taken over as the company€™s top dog, though Batista was not too far behind in the pecking order €“ a very strong beta to Cena€™s alpha. While not as good as their WrestleMania XXVI match, Cena-Batista 1 was quite entertaining. It would have been difficult to mess up the first battle between guys like them at a time like that. In one memorable spot, Batista caught Cena in mid-air during a flying Billy Gunn-style leg drop and countered into a vicious powerbomb that may have been the straw that broke the camel€™s back, so to speak, inside Cena€™s cervical spine, as surgery was required right after. It was a memorable match.

18. Ultimate Warrior vs. Rick Rude - WWE Intercontinental Championship (1989)

One of the most underrated matches in Summerslam history was the rematch from Mania V between the Intercontinental Champion Rick Rude and the Ultimate Warrior. The Mania match had been sloppy, while also being thoroughly entertaining thanks to Rude€™s selling and charisma. The Summerslam match was one of the best performances of Warrior€™s career and one of the greatest carry jobs of Rude€™s. It went off without a hitch. Everything that they did in the 16-minute match clicked. They traded momentum back and forth, keeping you guessing as to which one of them would walk away with the IC title. You assumed that Warrior would regain the gold, but Rude did a great job of making you think that perhaps he would find a way to win again. While the drama was greater in other Warrior matches, specifically citing the Mania matches with Hogan and Savage, the quality of the counters in this match with Rude might have been the most impressive that Warrior ever produced. Ravishing Rick really did an incredible job. You have to think that he must have been exhausted, both physically and mentally, by the time Roddy Piper showed up, signaling that they go to the finish of Warrior winning back the belt. There is a look on Rude€™s face after the match - satisfaction subtly creeping onto his face in the midst of him selling the anguish of losing the title.

17. Chris Jericho vs. John Cena - WWE Championship (2005)

After John Cena made his famous 1st pick in the draft appearance on Chris Jericho€™s €œHighlight Reel,€ Y2J targeted him and his WWE title just months before his contract ran out and he took his first hiatus from wrestling. Jericho vs. Cena was announced some 7 weeks prior to Summerslam, which was quite advanced for a non-Mania match in the modern era. They had a really good feud and it was nice to see Jericho back in the spotlight, challenging Cena to step up in the character department in his first consistently live experience on Raw. The Cena vs. Y2J storyline made Summerslam €™05 feel like more than just your every day PPV. Behind the scenes, Jericho had once pegged Cena as a star of the future back in 2002 and did not understand the hate that people threw his way when Cena was coming up through the ranks. He seemed to revel in the chance to help Cena progress in his career as €œThe Champ.€ Subsequently, their chemistry was unmistakable and Cena improved a lot from working with Jericho. As a fan of Jericho€™s work, it was also nice to see him back in the main-event right before he left. It was a performance from both of them worthy of praise, but it was also historically significant for being the first match that featured the crowd€™s dueling chants, half in favor of Cena€™s heroic persona and the other against.

16. Steve Austin vs. Kurt Angle - WWE Championship (2001)

The WWE Championship match between Steve Austin © and Kurt Angle was the match of the night at one of the best Summerslams of all-time. Angle was coming off a very good couple of months where he began rounding the corner into one of the elite workers in the business. Good God that man was a prodigy, was he not? Less than three years after he had begun training to be a pro wrestler, he was out there having a classic match against one of the other greats of all-time. Austin was trying so hard to be a heel and, low and behold, it actually seemed to work on the San Jose crowd that night. He was going nuts as a character, giving new meaning to the phrase €œtough love€ in regards to his relationships with his underlings in the WCW/ECW Alliance. Angle had been a heel just a couple of months before, but his matches on Raw with Chris Benoit and at King of the Ring with Shane McMahon €“ both iconic leaps forward for Angle€™s performance level €“ made the audience take notice and turn him into a protagonist. Since both were trying to get over new characters, it made for an interesting dynamic between Austin and Angle. The match at Summerslam made Angle sympathetic for the first time and showed that he could successfully play the role of the main-event babyface should the need arise.

15. John Cena vs. Randy Orton - WWE Championship (2007)

Randy Orton€™s career hit a massive bump in the road in September 2004 when he lost the World title to Triple H after one of the most ill-advised and poorly handled face turns in wrestling lore. When you think of where he was seemingly headed when the decision was made to turn him into a babyface and put it against what he went on to do between Unforgiven €™04 and the summer of 2007, it is hard not to think of what might have been. By the time that the road to Summerslam €™07 began, Orton had done enough to earn back the confidence of the WWE higher ups that they put him in the biggest feud of his career. He was developing the reputation, after taking out HBK, as more than just a Legend Killer. He was morphing into the Viper €“ a cold hearted, sadistic force to be reckoned with. John Cena was the WWE Champion and had been for nearly a year as of August, during which time he was rounding into form as the face of the company and a great performer in between the ropes. The question began to linger: who will be the one to dethrone The Champ? When it was announced that Orton would be the challenger at Summerslam, it seemed like we had our answer. The excitement in seeing that encounter was undeniable given their history.

14. Bret Hart vs. Undertaker - WWE Championship (1997)

The main-event between Bret Hart and Undertaker at Summerslam €˜97, with HBK as the special guest referee, was a lot more than just an on-screen storyline. So much animosity existed between Bret and Shawn and, in real life, Taker was one of those balancing forces that kept the locker room melting pot from boiling over. Shawn and Bret may have hated each other, but they both respected the Deadman. While the Bret-Taker title match was a vehicle to start the HBK vs. Taker feud that culminated in the first Hell in a Cell match two months later, it was also a dream match for that era. In a similar fashion as the HHH vs. Taker w/ HBK as ref scenario from Mania 28, Bret and Taker had faced each other numerous times before, but the Summerslam €™97 setting was their biggest stage. Adding the HBK dynamic made it a little more intriguing. The three biggest stars of the pre-Austin era; the three guys that had carried the WWE during some of its darkest days in the same ring for one epic Summer Classic title bout that, when you think a little deeper about it, was a 30-minute portrait of the New Generation in review. Bret and Shawn were constantly tiptoeing around each other, with occasional moments of tension rising to the surface and erupting before our very eyes. The Taker was trying to do his best to take the focus away from their confrontations, caught in the middle whether he wanted to be or not.

13. Christian vs. Randy Orton - No Holds Barred For WWE Championship (2011)

The summer of 2011 was most famous for the Pipe Bomb and the Punk vs. Cena feud that followed, but there was another classic rivalry that season between Randy Orton and Christian over the World Heavyweight Championship. It culminated in a No Holds Barred match at Summerslam after they traded the World title from May to July. Several amazing matches took place in their series, but arguably none better than the finale. Edge coming out prior to the match to basically put Christian€™s whiny character in his place set the tone and Christian, as usual, did a great job of overcoming what seemed like sure defeat to make it look like he legitimately had a chance to sneak out another win. Orton, meanwhile, was riding a wave of great matches. He and Christian brought out the best in each other and both went on a phenomenal hot streak from April to September, having a quiet game on Smackdown of €œWho€™s the best?€ The story told throughout the late spring and summer had so many layers to build on for their Summerslam match and they did quite well to utilize much of what made each of their other three PPV matches and their TV MOTY special. They stole the show right out from under Cena-Punk and kudos to the WWE for giving it the chance it deserved to do just that.

12. Brock Lesnar vs. The Rock - WWE Undisputed Championship (2002)

2002 brought a major change to the WWE. With two weekly multi-hour television programs and two and a half companies worth of talent, the WWE made a bold move in splitting up the rosters with one traveling group plying their trade on Monday Night Raw and the other doing their thing on Thursday Night Smackdown! It was expected to create new stars a little easier since there would not be as much of a log jam at the top. At the same time, WWE was also going through the emotions of a quite understandable loss of brand identity after Attitude ended. Brock Lesnar was the first new star that they created after the split and he was expected to help usher in a new era. Battling in the final match contested for the Undisputed Championship at Summerslam, the relative rookie with all the untapped potential in the world had to go out and try to follow arguably the greatest match in Summer Classic history. The Rock was known for being able to elevate his game, but Lesnar was an unknown. It was a high pressure situation. Rock could handle it, but what of Lesnar, the Next Big Thing? And then the match started...and 16 excellent minutes later, a highly entertaining story had been told. While not at the level of the Non-Sanctioned Street Fight that went on right before it, The Rock and Brock Lesnar's match far exceeded expectations and delivered a relative classic match of their own.

11. Hulk Hogan vs. Shawn Michaels (2005)

Summerslam 2005 was one of the best examples of how the €œBiggest Party of the Summer€ can and should be built in a similar fashion to WrestleMania. Despite numerous PPVs to get through before Summerslam that year, WWE started hyping the August event two months in advance, directly, and right after Wrestlemania, indirectly. Seeds were planted for the Legend vs. Icon match between Shawn Michaels and Hulk Hogan after HBK asked the Hulkster to come back for €œone more match€ to help him fend off that year€™s version of the anti-USA gimmick. In reality, Hogan needed to test out his new hip. Since he worked at Backlash and got through it, they had him come back from time-to-time to wrestle on Raw. It was after one such occurrence when HBK clocked Hogan with Sweet Chin Music and began his brilliant, albeit brief, 2005 heel turn. The HBK-Hogan hype featured numerous classic HBK segments; including the spoof of Larry King€™s show where Michaels hilariously impersonated Hogan and the final Raw before the show emanating from Canada where he tapped into his 1997 self and channeled some old aggression toward Bret Hart. The match was an unquestionable Summerslam classic. HBK bumped around like it was 1992. Because Hogan was so immobile, the match relied on Michaels to do virtually all of the work and he delivered what was one of his most underrated performances. They told a good story, Hogan bled buckets, and Michaels carried the way to a great match. Did HBK oversell? Surely, but it made, rather than took away, from that match.

10. Mr. Perfect vs. Bret Hart - WWF Intercontinental Championship (1991)

Mr. Perfect dropping the Intercontinental Championship to Bret Hart was one of the greatest examples of intestinal fortitude in wrestling lore. Perfect was mightily struggling with a back injury, at the time, to the point that he had settled on post-match retirement. However, it did not stop him from one of his top performances. He made Bret look like a star at a time when the Hitman needed something to kick start his singles run. You have to ask yourself if Bret would have been able to step up to the next level if it were not for being so strongly put over by a guy like Perfect who the fans had come to respectfully dislike enough that it mattered when he lost. When many fans think of Perfect, they think of this match. When WWE announced him for the 2007 Hall of Fame, yours truly immediately thought of this match. It was also Perfect vs. Bret that started the trend of Summerslam being the showcase for the Intercontinental title. Some of the greatest IC title bouts of all-time took place at the Summer Classic and it began with this match.

9. CM Punk vs. Jeff Hardy - Tables, Ladders, Chairs Match For WWE World Title (2009)

Summerslam €™09 was best known for two things and each involved the competitors in the main-event for the World Heavyweight Championship. Perhaps the most internet friendly of the great memories of the event was it being the culmination of the first of two WWE €œSummers of Punk.€ CM Punk had long been a very good wrestler with a nice following of loyal supporters from his days in the indies, but some fans had been wondering if they were ever going to see this incredible all-around performer that they had been hearing about since his debut three years earlier. It was common to be disenchanted with Punk. He was awfully bland as a character that had been so hyped by several people whose opinions were respected. Then, he turned heel. That was all it took. From that point on, it was like a light bulb going off in the collective heads of all the doubting fans. €œOh, that€™s what they were talking about.€ Punk won the World title, lost it, and then got this rematch with TLC rules. His opponent was the other half of the best known aspect of Summerslam €™09: Jeff Hardy. The enigmatic superstar reached the pinnacle of his career with this main-event. Never before had he been a bigger star and never will he likely be again. Jeff Hardy€™s near two-year run as a headlining singles star culminated in his TLC match with Punk. A month later, he was gone.

8. The Dudley Boyz vs The Hardy Boyz vs Edge & Christian - Tables, Ladders, And Chairs Match For WWE Tag Team Titles (2000)

Edge and Christian teamed up to battle the Hardys and Dudleys in the first official Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match for the Tag Team titles. Though the Triangle Ladder match at Mania that year featured all of the same weapons, it was a longer match and there was no pre-bout expectation that each man€™s specialty gimmick would come into play. This time around, there would be a lot more pressure to top the previous effort, get even more creative, and deliver in less time. The TLC match cut a blistering pace and featured spots that should have included a warning label for motion sickness. Fans should be proud of those men for putting their bodies on the line to put themselves on the fast track to greater success in wrestling, while also saddened that it took them punishing their bodies to that extent to draw the reactions required of headlining acts. Is not the definition of insanity to do the same thing over and over again and expect a different result? These men knew that they would take it to the extreme after Mania 2000 and they were asked to do it again at Summerslam and then again at Wrestlemania X-Seven and yet again on Smackdown€it was an absolutely insane time in tag team wrestling and, all the while, it was insanely memorable€

7. The Rock vs. Triple H - Ladder Match For WWE Intercontinental Championship (1998)

It is hard to forget the Summerslam €™98 poster with Steve Austin and Undertaker fighting each other with pieces of the Statue of Liberty and Empire State Building or the theme song chosen for that event: €œThe Highway to Hell€ by AC/DC. Austin-Taker was huge, but it turned out not to be the most memorable. The match that stole the show was The Rock vs. Triple H for the IC title in a Ladder match. Trips and Rock had such a great rivalry throughout their careers, but one of the things that drew fans to their work as main-event players was that they started their series in the mid-card, worked their way up to the headlining status, and then took the next step up to feuding over the WWE Championship. The height of their upper mid-card story was when each was heading up popular factions. Rock was the IC Champion and had been for all but about a minute of the previous nine months when Triple H faced him at Summerslam in a battle of (even at that point) sure-fire future Hall of Famers (based on their predicted upward trajectory). It was not a Ladder match featuring the typical exhibition in high spots. In fact, of any Ladder match in history, this was probably the least spotty of them all. Neither was known for their high risk bump taking, so they relied on their animosity toward one another and the story that naturally flowed from it to make this, still, one of the greatest Ladder matches of all-time.

6. Daniel Bryan vs. John Cena - WWE Championship (2013)

Cena and Bryan produced something very memorable that is already a candidate €“ after just one year of reflection €“ for Summerslam€™s greatest match. It is important to remember that it was the beginning of the story and WrestleMania XXX was the payoff. Bryan eventually became WWE Champion, allowing the people that were undoubtedly disappointed with WWE€™s failure to pull the trigger on Bryan keeping the title at Summerslam to, now, look back at the totality of the situation and smile. The Summerslam 2013 chapter of the saga, Bryan vs. Cena plus the aftermath, was an outstanding, 4-star plus match. It was utterly phenomenal. Bryan was everything that you would expect him to be in a WWE style main-event. He was markedly different from the man who faced CM Punk 15 months prior at Over the Limit '12. All the same battle-tested, indy-hardened work was evident, but he added some flash. In 2013, he truly rounded into form as one of the best "WWE style" workers on top of the brilliance that he already brought with him as the best technical wrestler in the game. Cena, as usual, stepped up and added another classic to his resume. Bryan made a wise choice that night in using the running/diving knee to the head as his finisher. Who could get up from that? The timing of the pin was perfect. After the camera panned to the most lively Los Angeles crowd since Warrior vs. Macho Man in 1991, all of them in unison chanting "Yes!" and pointing to the sky, Bryan put down the face of the WWE CLEAN in the middle of the ring.

5. Brock Lesnar vs. CM Punk - No DQ Match (2013)

Did that match live up to the hype or what? On the night of, it was a genuinely unpredictable match that did a great job of adding layer after layer of drama. Paul Heyman's involvement was well-timed and placed. Punk's blood thirsty attitude toward gaining retribution blinded him from the legitimate opportunities that he had to defeat Brock, making him look like just as much of a star - if not more - than he looked in defeats at the hands of Undertaker and The Rock earlier that year. Hindsight is 20/20, but you wonder what Punk might have done had he eventually gotten a win over one of those all-time big stars with their "name value." There should be no questioning that CM Punk was a star. 2013 gave us confirmation that he would be a major player in the WWE until his body gave out or his attitude soured. If he had stayed the course, he would have finished his career as one of the top 15 WWE stars of the WrestleMania Era and eventually main-evented a WrestleMania. He became the current generation's Shawn Michaels - he never ceased to deliver in big match scenarios. With him as a top star, fans were blessed to receive multiple classic matches per year that will be talked about fifteen years down the line in the same breath that they do for the matches of HBK, Bret Hart, Eddie Guerrero, and others. Anyhow, Brock and Punk delivered a Match of the Year candidate and one of the best Summerslam matches of all-time. The Best vs. The Beast was excellent.

4. Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart (1994) - Steel Cage Match For WWE Championship

Unquestionably, Mr. Summerslam was Bret Hart. He was as obvious a choice as HBK was for Mr. WrestleMania. The Hitman€™s Summerslam resume is full of classic matches at every level that the WWE offers championships. Perhaps the finest of those classics is the Summerslam €™94 Cage match with Owen Hart, which continued the rivalry that had initially culminated in a breathtaking blueprint for future generations to follow at WrestleMania X. This go-round, Bret was the WWE Champion and Owen was getting his only PPV World title match of his career. Inside the old school blue cage, Bret and Owen put together a unique match that is not universally accepted. Some people loved it, while others found it to be lacking in elements that had traditionally been the cornerstones of the gimmick. Even though it did not feature blood and violence, it made up for it with an unmatched psychology toward winning the match. The entire bout was based around outwitting the opponent to escape the cage via the door or over the top. There was no wasted motion and every little thing mattered. For thirty brilliant minutes, Bret and Owen worked on the turnbuckles, the side of the cage, near the door, and at the top of the cage. Unlike most cage matches, the ratio between attempting to get out of the cage to the content contested on the mat was heavily skewed toward the former. In one of the more dramatic finishing sequences you will see in a match of this type, Bret dropped to the floor off the outside wall of the blue steel as Owen, right beside him, got his foot hung up in one of the cage squares.

3. Edge vs. Undertaker - Hell In A Cell Match (2008)

Summerslam €™08 featured the Hell in a Cell payoff match to the Edge vs. Undertaker rivalry that main-evented WrestleMania that year and headlined three other PPVs, as well. Their series of matches may have been the most underrated championship feud of all-time. They had so many great matches in such a short span, including the supremely undervalued TLC match from two months prior to Summerslam. Taker was Edge€™s greatest opponent and Edge, quietly, one of Taker€™s. Their Hell in a Cell match was a classic that redefined what to expect from the modern version of the gimmick. Edge vs. Taker is the modern blueprint. Long gone are the days where a guy like Mick Foley is jumping off the Cell, which is of course considerably taller than it used to be. Yet, with Edge spearing Taker through one of the Cell walls, we were given the sight of how to still have a violent edition within reason. The creativity, perhaps, should now stem not from what you can do off the top, but in how you can bust through the sides. A second spear involving all three announce tables took the hardcore nature up a notch, as well, so when you add in the tables, ladders, and chairs, the storytelling that pieced together the key moments of their on-again, off-again 18 month saga, and the satisfying babyface victory, you have one of the top 5 matches in Summerslam history.

2. Bret Hart vs. British Bulldog - WWE Intercontinental Title (1992)

1992€™s Summerslam was best remembered for its main-event. Despite a WWE title match that was a rousing success, nobody thinks of it when they think of Summerslam €™92. Bret Hart vs. British Bulldog clash was absolutely fabulous. The venue was perfect. The weather held up for the open air stadium. Over 80,000 British fans packed Wembley Stadium and were given the chance to see their countryman, Davey Boy Smith, tackle the Hitman, Bret Hart, for the world€™s third most prestigious wrestling championship. The atmosphere was unique. The home stadium for England€™s national football team, Wembley seemed more like it was hosting a major soccer match than a wrestling exhibition. That was, in large part, thanks to Bret putting together a highly dramatic piece of work filled with numerous twists and turns similar to England taking on West Germany in the €™66 World Cup Final. It was one of the finest performances of Bret Hart€™s career, as he captained the effort en route to a match that stole not just the show, but Match of the Year honors. It vaulted Bret to the main-event, as Vince McMahon sat ringside for a direct view of Hart€™s excellence in executing a classic in the first (and only) IC title match to go on last at a WWE PPV (without the WWE title also on the line). After a performance like that, it gave Vince the confidence in Bret that he could carry the ball. For Davey Boy, it was the biggest moment in his career. Never again would he win in such a pressure packed situation in front an audience so large.

1. Shawn Michaels vs. Triple H - Unsanctioned Match (2002)

Shawn Michaels was one of the most honored performers in the history of WWE before he made his comeback from a back injury that had shelved him for four years. It was a long time to be away, though. When it was announced that he would be facing Triple H at Summerslam 2002, fans that had seen him at his previous peak were awash with equal parts anticipation and anguish. Could he really still go after that lengthy a hiatus? Remembering him for anything but top notch wrestling matches would have been difficult for a lot of fans, so the pressure was on for HBK and HHH. As it would turn out, the trepidation that anyone had felt pre-match proved to be unfounded after the match was over. What a perfect story they told. Agony, triumph, evil, heartache, passion, and compassion all wrapped up into one masterful performance for the ages. It was an emotional rollercoaster. Give all the credit in the world to Triple H for targeting HBK€™s back as sadistically as he did. It made even the smartest of wrestling fans cringe for Michaels, who should, in turn, also be given heaps of praise for how well he sold the injury until he kipped up and assured everyone that he was OK. In some comeback matches, the ring rust is rather noticeable and understandable. With Michaels, it looked as if he never left.