20 Major WrestleMania Matches We Didn't Get

How different the annals of WrestleMania history would have be.

By Justin Henry /

Wrestling's not all that different from legitimate sports in a number of regards, among them the 'what could have been' instances. In sports, it could be one play in a game that, had it gone just a smidge differently, could have swung an entire outcome. For wrestling, it comes down to decisions, both from the office and the workers. Had all hands on deck agreed to go a certain way with a proposed idea, wrestling history as we know it could be much different in many aspects. WrestleMania lore is loaded with ideas that ended up crumpled and littered on the power broker's floor. Maybe an injury changed fate. Maybe somebody exercised creative control and killed an idea. Perhaps Vince McMahon himself, going through one of his many abrupt changes of heart, decided to roll in a different direction, as he's apt to do. The twenty matches that follow were indeed in some sort of planning stage. A few of them were even announced on WWE television, before being scrapped for entirely different ideas. Quite a few of them would have given their respective WrestleManias an entirely different sheen, and changed the course of WWE history as we know it. In other words, 'what could have been'.

20. Hulk Hogan Vs. Zeus (WrestleMania 6)

Using this logic, WrestleMania 23 should have featured either John Cena vs. Robert Patrick, or Kane vs. one of the dopey delinquents he murdered in See No Evil. Zeus, of course, was B-movie actor Tony Lister, who played the Drago to Hulk's Rocky in No Holds Barred, a WWE-produced movie vehicle released in the spring of 1989. One rumor through the ages states that a Hogan/Zeus match for the SkyDome WrestleMania would have been a lock had the movie done well at the box office. No Holds Barred made money, more than doubling its US$8M budget, but the feud was instead relegated to the SummerSlam/Survivor Series circuit. Imagine the alternate history timeline where fans miss out on Hogan's "Ultimate Challenge" with Warrior, instead getting Zeus' incredibly-rote offense.

19. Hulk Hogan Vs. Ric Flair (WrestleMania 8)

This clash of the icons was certainly supposed to happen. After Flair won the WWF Title in the 1992 Royal Rumble, Hogan was announced as his WrestleMania opponent by President Jack Tunney in a kayfabed press conference that aired on the company's weekend shows. So what happened? One theory offered by many, notably Bret Hart, is that the house show matches between Flair and Hogan hadn't drawn well, and they'd be playing a stale hand at WrestleMania with the match on top. Bruce Prichard adds that it was thought a Flair/Randy Savage match had more potential, while Hulk was paired with Sid Justice. It made sense for Flair to drop the belt at WrestleMania, and Hulk was taking a sabbatical in light of his damaged public image, so giving each man a different opponent made a little more sense.

18. Bret Hart Vs. The Ultimate Warrior (WrestleMania 9)

Upon becoming the WWF Champion in 1992, Hart was informed that the idea was to keep him as titleholder for a year or so. While that didn't happen, if the original idea is to be believed, then Hart would have needed a high-profile opponent to go over on at WrestleMania. Warrior was a possibility, something Hart faintly alludes to in his 2007 book. Although he doesn't explicitly say that the match was a done deal, he does say that Warrior's firing in November 1992 prevented him from being the one to put Hart over in April, something Hart was relishing the idea of. Instead, we got the infamous Hart --> Yokozuna --> Hogan switcharoo in Las Vegas, something that Hogan didn't seem to appreciate when he ran down the WWF and the belt itself during a May 1993 interview in Japan.

17. Macho Man Randy Savage Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania 9/10)

The timeframe on this is a bit vague, but the 1993-94 calendar seems to be where this proposed idea most likely takes place. Savage was finding himself on the sideline more and more, benched while McMahon fortified the ranks of the younger generation. As history would show, this continued slight didn't sit well with the Macho Man. Savage proposed to McMahon a feud with young Michaels that would conclude with Savage putting over the 'Heartbreak Kid' in a star-making performance. Savage wanted to not only give a new star a concrete endorsement in the ring, but also show that he still had it as a wrestler. McMahon instead nixed the idea, and Savage watched WrestleMania IX from behind the announcer's desk. Little more than a year and a half later, he was treated as a headliner once more - in WCW.

16. Razor Ramon Vs. Goldust (WrestleMania 12)

The logical blow-off to the Ramon/Goldust feud that began in the final weeks of 1995 was to have been a 'Miami Street Fight', where perhaps Ramon bludgeons Goldust into oblivion for all of his unrequited passes. Instead, Goldust faced a returning Rowdy Roddy Piper in a 'Hollywood Backlot Brawl' with Ramon sitting home on a six-week suspension for a drug test failure. While a marijuana-related infraction could have been easily swept under the rug, McMahon's justification for the suspension ran deeper. In February 1996, the real-life Scott Hall gave his notice, announcing that he had signed with WCW, a deal that would officially take effect in May. McMahon sent Hall home, depriving him of a WrestleMania payoff out of spite.

15. Vader vs. Mankind (WrestleMania 13)

Four years earlier, Vader and Cactus Jack embarked on WCW's best feud of 1993, even with the silliness of an amnesia-plagued Cactus roaming the streets of Cleveland factored in. Their matches were the hard-hitting stuff of legend, and a 1994 incident in Germany in which Cactus lost part of his ear during a match with Vader had yet to be properly exploited. Mick Foley has indicated that a match between he and Vader was in the cards, but the company had opted to have the two team first, then have a falling out, which would take place long after WrestleMania, so timing was one issue. Another theory floated by Foley is that had he done an emotional interview promising revenge on Vader for the lost ear, it may have overshadowed the rest of the card's build.

14. Shawn Michaels Vs. Bret Hart (WrestleMania 13)

Early plans for the expected WrestleMania 12 rematch would see Bret regain the belt from Michaels, only to lose it back to him down the line, after which Hart would shake Michaels' hand as an endorsement. McMahon altered the plans to not include the belt as late as the first week of February 1997, claiming that it was 'too predictable'. Faced with the prospect of losing the belt to Sid, and then losing to Hart a month later, Michaels suddenly revealed that he had a potentially career-ending knee injury and handed the belt back to the office. The move came under intense scrutiny because of the its timing. Alas, Michaels' decision led to Hart battling Steve Austin at WrestleMania 13 in what may be the greatest match in WWE history.

13. Bret Hart Vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin (WrestleMania 14)

It's funny: Hart never definitively put Austin over, even as a heel. Granted, had the circumstances come up, Hart would have had no problems putting over a respected star of Austin's caliber clean as a sheet, especially if he got to be the one to thrust the WWF Championship into Austin's possession. Austin was getting the WWF Championship at WrestleMania 14 anyway, and with long-term planning, the idea of Hart putting over the undeniable top star in the promotion to complete the ascent was a very strong possibility. Then, wouldn't you know it, Vince decides he doesn't like Hart's loaded contract, and yada yada yada, Montreal happens, and now it's Michaels doing the honors. One wonders how Mike Tyson would look in a Hart Foundation shirt, though.

12. Cactus Jack Vs. Terry Funk (WrestleMania 14)

Before Funk officially broke his latest retirement to don the attire of Chainsaw Charlie, an idea came about that would see him renew his ultraviolent rivalry with Cactus. The proposal would see Cactus and Funk battle to an extent never before seen in the WWF, even in a time when the company was ramping up its own violent levels. The plan would be that Funk and Cactus would tape their match sometime in the week before WrestleMania, and the match would be inserted into the card itself. Why? Because the idea was to pit the two in a barbed-wire, exploding-ring deathmatch at Funk's Double Cross Ranch in Amarillo, TX. It would never come to that, as Cactus and 'Chainsaw' teamed up to face the New Age Outlaws.

11. Triple H vs. Ray Lewis (WrestleMania 17)

Accounts of this story vary, but there's always some combination of Triple H vs. punishing linebacker Lewis therein. Given the timing, Lewis would have been coming off a win in Super Bowl 35, in which he was the game's MVP. It would have also come a year after Lewis was charged in a double-homicide in the Atlanta area, so the media attention and controversy would have been to Attitude Era WWE's liking. The Rock's version of the story is that he would've teamed with Lewis (his former teammate as a Miami Hurricane) against Triple H and an unspecified heel. Scheduling could not be worked out, and Triple H had to settle (as if that's the word) with working against Undertaker. It begs the question if WrestleMania 17 would have been as legendarily epic as it is with these alterations.

10. Vince McMahon Vs. Mick Foley (WrestleMania 17)

Among Foley's regrets during the course of his storied career, he rues not accepting a match with McMahon when it was proposed to him. Foley had officially been retired for one year at the time, and was sticking to his word. He did, however, agree to play guest referee for what the match would actually become. The Vince vs. Shane McMahon match tied together the purchase of WCW, Vince's mistreatment of wife Linda, mistreatment of mistress Trish Stratus, and his firing of Commissioner Foley in one deliciously-overbooked package, so it's hard to argue with what we got instead. Still, given what Vince is willing to take as comeuppance in order to enthrall the audience, the idea of him trying to survive a hardcore war with Foley is a tempting one.

9. Kurt Angle Vs. Sting (WrestleMania 18)

Angle and Sting had some notable clashes in TNA over the company's World Championship, particularly at the third Bound For Glory, but it could have come to pass much earlier. Instead of making his long-awaited WWE debut in 2014, Sting could very well have joined the Titan giant when it was still called WWF. Former WWE writer David Lagana revealed in 2011 that Sting would have been brought in well before the nWo-laden WrestleMania, going one on one with the promotion's Olympic hero in Toronto. Sting, however, was unwilling to commit to the grueling full-time schedule of a WWF performer, and the deal fell through. Other than the occasional match in 2002-03, Sting wouldn't regularly wrestle again until 2006, when he began an eight year run with TNA.

8. Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs. Hollywood Hogan (WrestleMania 18)

Perhaps the biggest one-on-one match in wrestling history that has never, ever taken place. The return of Hogan in 2002 opened up the floodgates of possibilities that would pit the company's most prolific elder against a litany of Attitude Era icons in dream match after dream match. Make no mistake, Hogan's showdown with The Rock still induces goosebumps a decade and a half later, but it could have been a different match. Hogan was up for working with Austin, but the feeling wasn't mutual. Austin was going through a rough stretch creatively and emotionally, and felt that the aging Hogan would've been trailing him physically. Austin did say in 2014 that he regrets being stubborn, and puts over Hogan's match with Rock as an all-timer.

7. Eddie Guerrero Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania 22)

Around the eighth anniversary of Guerrero's passing, former WWE creative teamer Court Bauer revealed a tantalyzing plan for WrestleMania in Chicago, pitting two of the most complete performers in wrestling history, that had also never squared off before, in a one-on-one clash for the ages. According to Bauer, the suggestion for the match came from Bruce Prichard, and it was pitched less than 48 hours prior to Guerrero's untimely death. Their careers were to be paralleled in a similar fashion to Michaels and Jericho's in the build to WrestleMania 19, their commonalities presented in a way that showed that both stars were neck and neck, legacy-wise. Instead, Michaels warred with Vince McMahon, and Guerrero's death was controversially invoked for Rey Mysterio's run to the World Heavyweight title.

6. Kurt Angle Vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania 22)

Speaking of Mysterio's title win, it came at the expense of Angle, after the luchador pinned Randy Orton in a triple threat match at the event. According to Angle, The Undertaker himself went to McMahon, and suggested the idea, and it appears that their tremendous match at February's No Way Out was simply the 'consolation prize'. In addition to Angle's claim, he goes on to say in a 2011 interview that Undertaker had volunteered to sacrifice his streak (by now 13-0) to put Angle over. The claim is a dubious one, since Angle seems to be the only one suggesting it. It would take eight years before the streak would officially come to an end, coincidentally at the hands of another amateur wrestling legend.

5. Chris Jericho Vs. Mickey Rourke (WrestleMania 25)

In 2008's The Wrestler, Mickey Rourke killed it as a hard-luck veteran grappler unable to let go of the last vestiges of the spotlight. The critically-acclaimed performance drew WWE's attention, and Rourke was to bring his Randy "The Ram" Robinson skills to life against cantankerous Jericho. Considering the acting chops of both men in not-so-different fields, the story held much promise. Rourke threw out the kayfabed challenge during an interview at the SAG Awards in late-January 2009, several weeks before the planned match announcement. As a result, Rourke's handlers talked him out of taking the match, fearing it would hurt his chances at an Oscar for Best Actor. Rourke pulled out of the high-profile encounter, but did get to deck Jericho following Jericho's substitute match at the big event.

4. The Undertaker Vs. Sting (WrestleMania 27)

By early-2011, Sting's contract with TNA had expired. Videos began airing on RAW that promised some major happening on the February 21 episode of the show. Suddenly, the talk of Undertaker vs. Sting came barreling out of the woodwork, and a WrestleMania match looked like it was going to happen. Sting's WWE debut would come as an attempt to end the 18-0 streak. Except it didn't. Sting admitted he was approached by WWE with an offer of that very match, but he turned it down. Sting would re-sign with TNA, and explained his motives by saying he still didn't trust WWE's word after he'd seen so many WCW alums get cut off and thrown aside after the 2001 sale of the company.

3. Big Show Vs. Shaquille O'Neal (WrestleMania 28)

As far as celebrity matches go, this one felt like a natural. The jovial and towering Shaq is a longtime wrestling fan, and possesses the frame and the low-key charisma to have been a wrestling star had he pursued that career instead of basketball. As a RAW guest host, Shaq took part in a skirmish with Big Show in the summer of 2009, and rumblings were that another confrontation seemed likely. As late as the first couple months of 2012, O'Neal was insisting that he would wrestle Show on the grand stage, which WWE denied, even releasing a statement on WWE.com that said O'Neal's claims were false. The hype had picked up such steam that prior to WWE's public comment, the match felt like a mere formality.

2. CM Punk Vs. Triple H (WrestleMania 30)

My, how ugly this one became. There was once a time where the WrestleMania 30 card would feature Randy Orton vs. Batista, Sheamus vs. Daniel Bryan, and Triple H vs. CM Punk, which vocal fans had no interest in seeing. Following Punk's exit from the maligned 2014 Royal Rumble match, he engaged in a tense meeting with Triple H and McMahon, which led to his walking out of WWE, seemingly for good. Punk claims that Triple H could only scowl as he claimed that a match with him at WrestleMania was hardly meaningful, no matter how many times they insisted it was a 'main event' (the only 'main event' is what goes on last). Punk asked if it were truly a main event, if he'd get the same payoff as Orton and Batista, which everyone knows would be no. Despite assuring Punk that Hunter would lose, Punk scoffed, and took his leave.

1. The Rock Vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania 30)

Much like the Rock/John Cena "Once in a Lifetime" clash for WrestleMania 28, a match pitting Rock and Lesnar was to have been set up one year in advance. At WrestleMania 29, Rock dropped the WWE Championship to Cena in an 'old guard loses to current generation' match. The following night on RAW, the opening salvo of the Rock/Lesnar storyline was to take place, presumably with Lesnar injuring Rock and putting him out of commission. In truth, Rock was legitimately injured at WrestleMania, suffering torn pelvic muscles and tendons during the lengthy main event. Rock ended up no-showing Raw that night, and decided to put all ring-activity on hold, so as to not jeopardize his film career. As for Lesnar, his WrestleMania XXX experience was probably more unforgettable than anything he and Rock could've done together.