20 Shocking WWE Plans You Won’t Believe
Some ideas are best left in the trash...
Professional wrestling would be nothing without storylines. Great matches remain the sport’s bread and butter, but they’d be half as exciting without a strong build between two compelling characters. At its heart, wrestling is an athletic storytelling medium, and its narratives are just as important as its competitive aspects.
Everything you see on WWE television is devised by the creative team and rubber-stamped by Vince McMahon. Sometimes, it produces magic like the legendary Stone Cold vs. Mr. McMahon feud, or the Hulk Hogan/Randy Savage/Miss Elizabeth triangle. Other times? Oh boy…
Unfortunately, WWE’s creative team are responsible for some of the most cringeworthy ideas to ever hit mainstream television. Latter day WCW might hold the benchmark in this department, but WWE’s track record is blemished by terrible ideas like Katie Vick, Mae Young birthing a hand, and Chavo Guerrero’s reinvention as Kerwin White.
These angles show WWE at their absolute worst, but their cutting room floor is a minefield of shocking idea that never made it to television. As outlined in our book, Shocking Wrestling Plans You Won’t Believe Almost Happened, WWE have aired some of the most embarrassingly bad angles in wrestling history, but their list of scrapped ideas is a real horror show.
Who knows what the company would look like if some of these brainwaves had ever come to fruition. Here are 20 shocking WWE plans you won’t believe.
20. Mark Jindrak In Evolution
Evolution are one of the last truly great WWE stables. Triple H, Ric Flair, Randy Orton, and Batista represented several generations of wrestling excellence, and at the peak of their powers, they were utterly dominant. There was a period of time where Evolution held all of Raw’s titles (the Tag Team, Intercontinental, and World Heavyweight Championships) and while Flair and Triple H were already established megastars, the group was the making of Orton and Batista.
It could have been oh so different had WWE followed through with their original idea, though: Mark Jindrak was originally pegged for Batista’s spot as Evolution’s Arn Anderson-esque enforcer. WWE went so far as to shoot a number of vignettes with Jindrak in the group, but the former WCW Tag Team Champion was pulled without explanation.
Jindrak has since revealed that he “wasn’t ready” for the spot, and that it was “his to lose” and he “dropped the ball.” It worked to his detriment: Jindrak was released from WWE after a meagre four-year run largely spent propping up the midcard, while Batista became a multi-time world champion and surefire Hall of Fame inductee. Jindrak has since forged a strong career for himself in Mexico, but he must be kicking himself that the Evolution run never came to pass.
19. Snitsky & Heidenreich Beat The Streak
WWE have come up with some pretty whacky ideas on how to break The Undertaker’s WrestleMania winning streak over the years. Brock Lesnar’s ‘Mania 30 triumph over The Deadman remains a divisive topic among wrestling fans, but when you consider some of the other options WWE had in mind, Lesnar’s win feels entirely justifiable.
Mark Henry was pencilled-in to beat Taker at the height of his Hall of Pain powers at WM 22, but creative changed their mind and Henry lost their Casket Match. Five years later, Sting was offered the chance to beat the streak but declined WWE’s contract offer, and Nexus leader Wade Barrett was pegged as a potential streak-beater after attacking Undertaker at Bragging Rights 2010. Instead, the Nexus died a horrible death, and Barrett never fulfilled his main event potential.
The most bewildering idea of all, however, revolves around Snitsky and Heidenreich. With the former best known for killing Lita’s unborn child and the latter reading poetry and impersonating a Road Warrior, this wonderful duo were set to collide with (and defeat) Kane and Undertaker at ‘Mania 21. Thankfully, the match never happened: Kane was injured, and instead of seeing Taker lose to two of the clumsiest oafs in WWE history, fans watched him beat Randy Orton instead.
18. And That's The Bottom Line... 'Cause Chilly McFreeze Said So
Steve Austin is rightly considered one of the most important (and popular) wrestlers of all-time, but his time at the top was relatively short. Though he debuted in 1989, Austin didn’t become a legitimate top star until after he’d won the 1996 King of the Ring tournament, and he was retired by 2003. Still, Stone Cold’s legendary run secured his place in folklore, and it kicked-off with his infamous “Austin 3:16” promo at KOTR ‘96.
Austin reinvented himself as a beer-drinking, anti-authority badass, and nobody could touch his popularity at the time. Had creative gone with their original idea, however, Austin may have never gotten off the ground.
Unhappy with his existing “Ringmaster” gimmick, the writers offered Austin a number of alternative nicknames including Fang McFrost, Ice Dagger, and the best of the bunch: Chilly McFreeze. Fortunately, Austin hated all of them, and floated the “Stone Cold” nickname to Vince McMahon. The boss loved it, and thus the Attitude Era’s most iconic gimmick was born.
Who knows where Austin would be today had he become Chilly McFreeze instead of Stone Cold, but it’s hard to imagine a man with a name that sounds like an ice pop becoming a six-time WWE champion.
17. A Triple H Vs. Mike Tyson Boxing Match
A Triple H Vs. Mike Tyson Boxing Match
Mike Tyson and WWE have a solid working relationship. The former boxing champ famously served as a DX-affiliated enforcer during Shawn Michaels and Steve Austin’s WrestleMania XIV match, but he turned on HBK and knocked him out after counting the pinfall for Austin.
Earning a cool $3 million for his first appearance, Tyson returned in 2010 to reignite his DX allegiance after turning on Chris Jericho during a tag match, and he was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2012.
WWE had another twist for the tumultuous DX/Tyson relationship in mind, however. WrestleMania X7 is regarded as a near-perfect wrestling event, and Triple H’s brutal, chaotic brawl with The Undertaker stands as one of the night’s best matches. WWE’s original plans involved The Game and Tyson competing in a boxing match at the event, however: presumably ending with Tyson putting Triple H out of his misery in convincing fashion.
The idea was canned, and instead of feeding one of their biggest heels to a legendary boxer, WWE booked him in one of the best matches of his career.
16. Edge The Deaf Mute
Edge retired from professional wrestling as not only one of the most celebrated tag team wrestlers of all-time, but a highly-decorated world title-level singles wrestler. The Rated R Superstar acquired an impressive 11 world title reigns to compliment his 14 tag title belts, and on April 11th, 2011, Edge left the business as one of the most decorated wrestlers ever.
It could’ve been entirely different had WWE followed through on their original plans, however. Edge debuted in WWE as a misfit loner character before eventually joining up with Christian and Gangrel in The Brood, but the writers originally intended for him to portray a deaf mute instead. The suggestion was that Edge was an uncharismatic wrestler who couldn’t talk, and needed an outlandish gimmick to mask his weaknesses as a performer.
Who came up with the idea? Vince Russo, of course!
The idea was fortunately scrapped, and Edge would prove the ridiculousness of Russo’s “uncharismatic” claims throughout his career. Given WWE’s lack of sensitivity when portraying other handicapped gimmicks (hi, Eugene), it’s likely that such a move would’ve left Edge’s career dead on a arrival, and instead of becoming a Hall of Famer, Edge would be remembered as another Mantaur or Max Moon.
15. Triple H Wins King Of The Ring 1996
King of the Ring 1996 was the defining moment of Steve Austin’s career. On that night, Austin became “Stone Cold,” and launched one of the most iconic main event runs in WWE history. Without it, it’s hard to imagine where he’d be in the WWE hierarchy, particularly given the Ringmaster gimmick’s lukewarm reception, but he certainly wouldn’t be as revered as he is today.
Remarkably, Austin wasn’t originally supposed to win the tournament. WWE creative had originally earmarked Triple H as the winner, but those plans were nixed following the infamous MSG Incident in May 1996.
Triple H and his fellow Kliq members Shawn Michaels, Kevin Nash, and Scott Hall broke character to hug in the ring following a match between Michaels and Nash (performing as Diesel) at the time. Nash and Hall were set to depart for WWE, but the Kliq opted to break kayfabe for one last moment of camaraderie before the group was shattered.
The punishment fell on Triple H. Hall and Nash were off to WCW, and HBK was the WWE Champion at the time, effectively rendering him bulletproof. WWE scrapped the idea of Triple H becoming King of the Ring, but it mattered little in the long-run: he became Intercontinental Champion by October, and later, one of the most dominant heels in WWE history.
14. Kassius Ohno In The Shield
Roman Reign’s ongoing push as WWE’s “top babyface” remains one of the New Era’s biggest bugbears. WWE have tried almost everything to get Reigns over, but even aligning him with the uber-popular Sasha Banks and pushing him against the loathed Rusev haven’t worked. Try as they may, WWE have continually failed in their quest to make Reigns “The Guy,” and there’s little suggestion that they’ll stop swimming against the tide any time soon.
He might not be in this position had WWE gone with CM Punk’s idea for The Shield, however. The group made a tremendous impact in WWE, and helped sow the early seeds for Reigns, Seth Rollins, and Dean Ambrose as main event stars. Reigns was the group’s burly enforcer, but his limitations were greatly exposed when forced into a bigger role as a singles star, and he wasn’t even the group’s first choice.
Punk had originally pushed for Kassius Ohno (better known as Chris Hero) to fill Reigns’ spot in The Shield, but WWE decided otherwise. It remains one of the biggest “what if” moments in recent WWE history: Ohno was released from WWE for failing to control his weight, but he’s an excellent professional wrestler who’s as adept on the mic as he is in the ring. Would he have succeeded where the clumsy, awkward Reigns has failed? We’ll never find out.
13. John Cena Vs. Jay Z
John Cena put himself on the map with the Vanilla Ice-inspired white rapper gimmick that kicked-off his ascent to superstardom. Though Cena’s actually a half-decent rapper for a professional wrestler, he almost found himself woefully out of his depth at WrestleMania 19, and should probably count himself thankful that WWE couldn’t follow through on his original plans.
Cena spent much of WM XIX’s build-up trying to goad celebrities into battle rapping him at the show. Jay Z and Beyonce were widely rumoured to be in attendance, so Jay naturally became the subject of Cena’s open invitations. Cena and Jay (who is generally considered one of the greatest rappers of all time) were set to square-off, but Jay Z had to cancel, and the plans were altered.
Fabolous, another New York rapper, was scheduled to fill the void, but he cancelled and opted to attend another event instead. WWE’s compromise was to instead have Cena aim his raps at a set of Jay Z and Fabolous cardboard cutouts on Mania’s pre-show, which is probably a good thing. Cena’s “Doctor of Thugonomics” act was still in its early stages, and the last thing he needed was to be lyrically outclassed by a professional rapper on the biggest stage of them all.
12. New Jack Stabs John Cena
Chances are high that if you know who New Jack is, you’ll also know that he’s a legitimate lunatic. The former ECW wrestler is better known for his penchant for craziness than any of his actual wrestling accomplishments, and his willingness to take ridiculous bumps and go way too far make him one of the most dangerous men in the business. Seriously, look up the Mass Transit Incident and the Danbury Fall…
You’d think that New Jack’s reputation would make him a persona non grata in the industry, but no. In fact, WWE considered bringing him in for a brief period in 2004. Carlito had just made his debut by beating John Cena for the United States title, and later that night, Cena was storyline stabbed at a Boston nightclub. All the signs pointed towards Carlito, but his bodyguard Jesus was eventually revealed as the perpetrator.
The original plan, however, was to have New Jack come in as the villain. Instead, New Jack and WWE couldn’t agree on terms, and Jesus was added as a last minute replacement. While New Jack would’ve been entirely believable in this role (he once stabbed indy wrestler William Jason Lane nine times during a match), it’s hard to think of a man less suited to WWE’s squeaky clean product.
11. Melina The Man
Though best known for THAT ring entrance as MNM’s valet, Melina forged a nice little career for herself in WWE, and while she had her detractors, she was a two-time Divas Champion and three-time Women’s Champion by the time she left. Unfortunately, she was also the subject of some truly atrocious canned ideas during her WWE tenure, one of which played on her real-life fling with Batista in 2006.
In a typically tasteless WWE fashion, Melina was featured in a series of backstage vignettes attempting to seduce Batista. She’d eventually appear in a press conference to accuse Batista of forcing himself on her, before threatening legal action against The Animal. Melina recruited Mark Henry as “personal protection” and the angle faded away, but it could’ve been so much worse.
WWE’s original plan was to reveal that Melina was hiding a big secret all along: she was a man. Batista was supposed to eventually prove that not only were Melina’s accusations false, but so were her gender claims. Stephanie McMahon was fortunately on hand to scrap the angle as she felt it’d ruin Melina’s WWE career, but she managed to do a pretty good job of that herself later on...
10. WrestleMania XV's Main Event
Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock’s WrestleMania series is one of the most iconic match trilogies in wrestling history. As the Attitude Era’s two biggest stars, Austin and The Rock collided at ‘Mania XV, X7, and XIX, with Austin winning the first two matches, and Rocky coming-out on top in the final clash.
The first match was instrumental in establishing the tone for both wrestlers’ later careers, but it almost didn’t happen. Instead, WWE originally had the idea of including Mankind and making it a Triple Threat for the WWE Championship, seemingly with Austin still coming out on top.
Not only that but Shawn Michaels, who was WWE Commissioner at the time, was secretly pulling strings behind the scenes to have Austin removed from the match all-together. Michaels allegedly suggested that Vince McMahon book a classic singles match between The Rock and Mankind instead, but while Vince agreed that the match should be one on one, he went with Rock and Austin.
The proposed Triple Threat would’ve still been a good match, but would Rock and Austin have one of the greatest WrestleMania rivalries of all-time. Would this have developed to such a level had Mankind been included at XV? It’s highly doubtful.
9. The Undertaker Hatches
Who knows where WWE would be without The Undertaker. The Deadman’s unparalleled longevity and mystique have made him the most important wrestler in WWE history, and a cornerstone of the company’s success for the best part of three decades. Without him, there’s a strong chance WWE wouldn’t have made it through the Monday Night Wars, and he remains a star attraction even today, at the ripe old age of 51.
The Gobbledy Gooker, meanwhile, might just be the most universally maligned gimmick of all-time. WWE’s dancing turkey hatched from an oversized egg on the same night that Taker debuted, but the gimmick was quickly shelved due to an overwhelmingly negative crowd response. Lord knows what convinced WWE that a man in a turkey suit would be a good addition to their talent roster, but never mind…
Hector Guerrero was eventually chosen to become the Gobbledy Gooker, but he wasn’t WWE’s original choice. Instead, Mark Calaway was set to debut as the Gooker rather than The Undertaker, and instead of establishing one of the longest, most impressive resumes in WWE history, he’d have likely been out of the company in a matter of months.
8. Goldust's Breast Implants
Dustin Runnels deserves all the credit in the world. Not only is he an incredibly underrated wrestler, but he’s endured some of WWE creative’s very worst ideas, and more importantly, he’s made them work. The flamboyant Goldust gimmick should’ve been a huge flop, particularly when he kissed Ahmed Johnson, but Runnels owned it, and it speaks volumes of the strength of his portrayal that he’s still going strong today.
Despite all this, Runnels was dedicated to his act to a worrying degree. He allegedly wanted to take Goldust’s sexually ambiguous cross-dresser character to the next level, and approached Vince McMahon with one of the weirdest wrestling ideas you’ll ever hear: “pay me $1 million, and I’ll get breast implants.”
The idea was that WWE would film the surgery and use it as part of an angle, but Vince rejected it without question. McMahon has since tried to rubbish the claim, but Vince Russo later confirmed it in his biography, stating the move was “sheer desperation” from Runnels, who would’ve likely come to his senses in the end.
7. Fake Kane: Not Actually Fake
WWE love a bad imposter angle, though 2006’s “Fake Kane” story was a little different to WWE’s attempts at recreating Diesel and Razor Ramon in the 90s. Kane spent several weeks haunted by voices from his tortured past, and it came to a head on a May episode of Raw. An imposter Kane (wearing Kane’s old mask and ring attire) Chokeslammed him during a match with Shelton Benjamin, and the feud began.
Kane and Fake Kane would continue duking it out over the coming weeks, but the story quickly faded from prominence. In June, Kane threw his Fake mate out of the arena before ripping off his mask and stating “I believe that this is mine.” Kane would then take a few months off from WWE television, and the angle was never heard from again.
Drew Hankinson (better known as Luke Gallows) played the role, but the original conclusion was scrapped. “Fake Kane” was supposed to be revealed as Kane himself, with the story being that this imposter was the real Kane all along, and that Glenn Jacobs’ Kane had stolen his identity and kept him imprisoned for a decade.
The move was designed to allow Jacobs to retire and WWE to retain the Kane character, but Jacobs reconsidered, and the idea was scrapped.
6. Muhammad Hassan: World Heavyweight Champion
Muhammad Hassan was an absolute heat magnet. His aggrieved Arab American gimmick made him feel like The Iron Sheik’s spiritual successor, and he got off to a great start. After a month on television, Hassan was the most hated heel in WWE, and his sharp portrayal saw him gain high profile matches with the likes of Hulk Hogan, Batista, and John Cena.
Sadly, WWE soon eroded everything that made Hassan so effective. They took him from an angry, oppressed Arab American to a cartoonish terrorist act that pushed the envelope a little too far. It culminated with Hassan and five masked men attacking The Undertaker with clubs and piano wire at the Great American Bash ‘05, before carrying him away to the backstage area.
Three days later, the London bombings took place, and WWE were rightly thrown to the wolves.
All plans for Hassan were immediately scrapped, including the grandest of them all. It’s believed that WWE were set to capitalise on Hassan’s monster heat by having him defeat Randy Orton for the World Heavyweight Champion that summer. Capturing the belt would’ve made Hassan the youngest champion in WWE history, and winning it in America’s capital - Washington DC - would’ve made him the most hated man alive.
WWE’s chronic lack of subtlety and terrible timing soon put an end to that.
5. Chyna: WWE Champion
Chyna broke new ground for female wrestlers in WWE. Though often the subject of DX’s crude humour, she was the most dominant woman in the company, and someone equally capable of stepping up and battling her male counterparts. This was hammered home during her feuds with Chris Jericho and Jeff Jarrett, and she remains the only woman to ever hold the WWE Intercontinental Championship.
WWE had far bigger plans for her in 1999, however. The company were already smashing preconceptions with Chyna’s run, but for a brief period of time, she was actually set to become WWE Champion. The idea was that she’d overcome Steve Austin at SummerSlam ‘99, but despite becoming number one contender in the event’s build-up, but she lost the spot to Mankind a few weeks before the PPV.
The whole idea was reportedly Vince Russo’s idea, but WWE decided Chyna just wasn’t ready for the shot. It was likely the right decision: Chyna wasn’t the most exciting wrestler in the world, and her two runs with the IC Title aren’t exactly fondly remembered. For all she brought to the business, Chyna was never a top tier performer, and her run as WWE Champion would’ve likely caused the company some major headaches down the line.
4. Linda McMahon Killed Vince
In one of the most poorly-timed moves in wrestling history, Vince McMahon was “killed” on a June 2007 episode of Raw. A segment at the end of the show showed Vince entering his limousine moments before it exploded in a ball of flames, and moments later, WWE.com uploaded an article stating that Vince was missing presumed dead.
Speculation mounted, and two weeks later, WWE planned a three-hour long memorial to Mr. McMahon, who was presumably never coming back. Unfortunately, this coincided with the actual death of Chris Benoit and his family, and instead of acting as Vince’s obituary, McMahon opened the show to reveal that his death was part of an angle, and WWE aired an equally ill-timed Benoit tribute instead.
Vince revealed a few weeks later that he’d faked his own death to see what people really thought of him, but this wasn’t the angle’s intended conclusion. Instead, Linda McMahon was supposed to be revealed as her husband’s murderer, and after her arrest, Mr. Kennedy would rise to power as Vince’s illegitimate son.
The story would’ve seen Kennedy misuse his power to enter the WWE Championship scene, before Triple H eventually returned to challenge his ownership of the company. Instead, Hornswoggle was eventually revealed as Vince’s son, and Kennedy’s monster push never materialised.
Great job, guys.
3. Baron Von Bava
The Gobbledy Gooker, Bastion Booger, The Shockmaster: chances are high that when you consider wrestling’s worst gimmicks, these names come up. If WWE creative had their way in 2004, however, Baron Von Bava would likely be the first name on your list.
Pitched by ex-WWE writer Dan Madigan, Baron Von Bava was, in short, a Nazi cyborg stormtrooper frozen in the 1940s by German scientists who were terrified of losing the war, and wanted to preserve their legacy by freezing one of their best soldiers.
Yes, really…
When he was unthawed in 2004, BVB would be completely unaware of his surroundings, and operate as though he was still in World War 2. He’d continued to carry out Hitler’s work on air, but it got worse: Paul Heyman, who is Jewish, was pitched as the man who’d awaken the Baron from his slumber and turn him loose on the world.
WWE have dished-out more than enough racially insensitive gimmicks over the years, but Baron Von Bava was a step too far for Vince McMahon. Shortly after Madigan had reportedly goose-stepped around the room to demonstrate BVB in action, Vince grabbed his coat and left without saying a word. BVB was was rejected in the coldest way possible, but it’s no less than what the idea deserved.
2. McMahon Family Incest
Mark Henry’s flirtations with Mae Young and David Flair’s WCW relationship with Stacey Keibler were bad, but WWE almost produced the mother of all terrible wrestling romance angles a few years ago. Vince McMahon has come up with some incredibly creepy suggestions for his daughter Stephanie over the years, but none are worse than this.
WWE announced that Stephanie was pregnant with her first child in 2006, and Vince thought it’d be a good idea to write the pregnancy into an on-air storyline. The story goes that Vince called Steph into his office one day and proposed an incest storyline, which would ultimately culminate with Vince claiming that he was the father of Stephanie’s child.
Stephanie, of course, shot the idea down immediately, but Vince wasn’t deterred. Instead of realising the idea’s stupidity and canning it outright, Vince proposed that Shane be the father instead... because that’s so much better, right?
Again, Stephanie dismissed the angle, but it does make you wonder what goes on inside Mr. McMahon’s head. He has pitched a number of incest angles over the years, including a brother/sister romance between Ken and Ryan Shamrock, and another between Paul and Katie Lea Burchill.
The Stephanie pregnancy angle remains the most worrying, however. That’s his actual, real-life daughter, for crying out loud...
1. WCW Lives
On March 26th, 2001, the wrestling world changed forever. Vince McMahon officially brought the curtain down on the Monday Night Wars by purchasing WCW for a paltry $2 million, and as his son Shane waltzed out on the last ever edition of Monday Nitro, the stage was set for the biggest angle in wrestling history.
Sadly, The Invasion was a rank failure. WWE’s inability to acquire WCW’s biggest names, insistence on watering down the Alliance side with WWE turncoats, and inconsistent booking made for a huge missed opportunity. The story diet a slow, depressing death, and WCW was soon forgotten about.
This wasn’t the original plan, however. WWE’s intentions were to keep WCW going under the WWE corporate banner, and run the dead company as its own promotion. WCW would be pulled from the air for a couple of months before eventually returning as its own brand, and WWE even went so far as to produce a trailer for the proposed “WCW Live” show.
The plan started falling apart when WWE struggled to secure a network timeslot. Raw provided TNN’s highest rated show at the time, but the network refused WWE’s request for a primetime WCW slot. There were offered 11pm-1am on Saturday nights instead, but this wasn’t suitable.
The Invasion’s early days saw a number of WCW segments appear on Raw and SmackDown, including an infamously bad WCW Title match between Booker T and Buff Bagwell. The match went down so poorly that Vince fired Bagwell shortly after, and when other WCW-centric segments bombed, WWE scrapped the plan entirely.