20 Worst WWE Wrestlers Since 2000

Hell is an endless loop of Eva Marie matches.

By Andy H Murray /

WWE

As the biggest wrestling promotion in the world, WWE's pull is unparalleled. Their mainstream spotlight, financial clout, and acclaimed developmental system means a contract with them remains the end goal for many wrestlers. There are exceptions (Kenny Omega, for one), but for the most part, Vince McMahon can sign whoever he wants, whenever he wants, and countless world-class performers have passed through his company over the decades.

Advertisement

Having 'WWE' on your resumé doesn't make you a great worker, though. Most of the sport's biggest stars eventually find their way to the company, but the McMahons have wasted a lot of money on truly atrocious wrestlers, particularly in the modern era, where general in-ring standards have never been so high.

For our criteria, we'll stick to full-time wrestlers so as not to complicate matters by including the likes of Michael Cole and Jonathan Coachman. Competitors will be judged primarily on their in-ring ability, too, with some small considerations for other aspects of their performances, like charisma and believability.

With that in mind, let's take a look at the skill-deficient duds who've spent the past 17 years sullying WWE's reputation as the world's top promotion.

20. Mason Ryan

It isn't hard to see what Vince McMahon saw in Mason Ryan.

Advertisement

Standing at an impressive 6'5", the brawny Welshman's physique looked as though it was carved out of Greek marble, but like so many before him, this was all Ryan had. He worked a wrestling style typical of other failed musclebound big men, exuded little-to-no charisma, and struggled to carry himself with any intimidation or star power. He was all aesthetics, and his failure was as predictable as his initial push.

Hurried out of developmental in 2011, Ryan was given a wet fart of a debut on an episode of Raw. He was introduced as the latest member of CM Punk's Nexus by interfering in a match between his leader and John Cena to a tepid crowd reaction, and spent spring backing up the former 'Voice Of The Voiceless.' Injured in June, he didn't return until September, but was soon shunted out of the spotlight, and only made a handful of appearances before suffering relegation to NXT in January 2013.

Released by WWE in 2014, the skill-deficient bruiser isn't even active on the independent scene these days.

19. Mordecai/Kevin Thorn

The nicest thing we can say about Kevin Fertig's WWE career is that the company at least packaged him with a couple of moderately interesting gimmicks. As Mordecai, he was a religious zealot with a striking all-white look, while his next character, Kevin Thorn, was branded as the 'ECW Vampire,' and was a fixture on the brand for over a year. Regardless, neither of these personas brought long-term success to Thorn, whose WWE career took numerous twists and turns through WrestleCrap country.

Advertisement

Thorn was with the company for two different spells, first from 2002-2005, then again between 2006 and 2009. Both saw him sent back to developmental for further seasoning prior to his release. This should tell you everything you need to know about his wrestling abilities, but for clarification's sake, he was never able to evolve beyond his clumsy early days, specialising in the kind of bumbling, rudimentary offence typically associated with the sport's bottom rung.

The Mordecai gimmick retains its cult appeal, and Fertig still works it on the indies, but he always looked out of his depth when competing for the world's biggest promotion.

18. David Otunga

Though most of The Nexus' low-level grunts were quickly jettisoned from WWE once the angle had ran its course, David Otunga has somehow parlayed it into a seven-year run with the company. This is baffling, as not only is the Harvard Law School graduate WWE's most vanilla commentator, but he was a woefully unconvincing all-rounder during his run as an active wrestler.

Advertisement

Otunga's physique ticks one of Vince McMahon's biggest checkboxes, and the company likely thought they could use his marriage to Jennifer Hudson to draw eyes to the product. Neither mean anything if the wrestler in question can't work, though. This was certainly the case for the uncharismatic Otunga, who wrestled with all the fire and passion of a deflated beach ball, and exhibited no noticeable improvement throughout his five-year run.

There have been several long periods of time where WWE have literally paid Otunga to do nothing, with the former Nexus man regularly going missing from television. This continued in 2017, when Booker T replaced him in Raw's announce booth. Now, David's contributions are restricted solely to pay-per-view Kickoff Show panels, which is probably the best place for him.

17. KroniK

While the brevity of their WWE tenure almost excluded them from our list, the fact that KroniK were able to tank their mainstream wrestling careers on the back of a single, disastrous pay-per-view match means their spot is more than justified.

Advertisement

Bryan Clark and Brian Adams weren't part of the initial WCW invasion, but joined WWE in September 2001, having had their initial contracts dropped following the takeover. They were immediately thrust into a mainline feud with WCW Tag Team Champions Kane and The Undertaker, which would've ideally established them as major players. It didn't, though. Their Unforgiven 2001 bout was a disaster, and KroniK were the culprits, with their sloppy, mistimed offence spawning many a noticeably disjointed spot.

It was one of the worst WWE matches of the past two decades, and The Brothers Of Destruction were so angered by Clark and Adams' that the company felt compelled to send them to OVW for further seasoning. KroniK refused, and they were cut loose just 21 days after signing, marking Brian and Bryan as a set of colossal post-Invasion failures.

16. Shawn Stasiak

Not all second generation stars are created equally. While The Rock, Bret Hart, and Randy Savage are among the most recognisable performers in wrestling history, countless have others fallen by the wayside over the years. Having a famous surname can help, but it brings no promise of success, as proven by Shawn Stasiak's example.

Advertisement

His father, Stan, was a transitional WWWF Champion who bridged the gap between Pedro Morales' sole reign and Bruno Sammartino's second, but Shawn was never anything more than a lower-midcarder. Cut from his initial contract in 1999, he returned two years later as part of the Invasion. He was only there to make up the numbers, though: cast with a go-nowhere putz gimmick, Stasiak's role was barely supplemental, and he was released just over a year after re-signing.

A Dory Funk Jr. trainee, Shawn was painfully dull between the ropes, and brought little more than a set of rudimentary holds and moves to the table, and his charisma shortfall made his work a chore to get through. Sure, his consistently terrible creative direction didn't help, but Stasiak was never fit to make the grade at this level.

15. Tamina

A WWE Superstar for the best part of a decade, Tamina his shown little-to-no growth of development throughout her career, and must go down as one of the worst wrestlers to ever hold a high-level wrestling contract for such a long period of time.

Advertisement

Tamina has never been convincing. She's slow, basic, sloppy, and entirely unconvincing, even in her limited role as a bodyguard. Unfortunately, she has never grown into the powerhouse gimmick the company have always pinpointed for her, giving the impression that she was shoehorned into WWE on the back of her lineage.

The problem is that said lineage is all Tamina has ever really had, but the company can't even use it to put her over anymore. Her father, Jimmy Snuka, passed away amidst controversy surrounding the unsolved Nancy Argentino murder trial, and while the case was ultimately dismissed as 'Superfly' wasn't mentally fit to continue, few fans would tolerate a eulogisation.

Now among WWE's most tenured women's wrestlers, Tamina is still the same performer she was upon walking into the business, with her lack of finesse, charisma, and presence sullying everything she does.

14. Luther Reigns

His namesake, Roman, might be the most divisive wrestler in WWE today, but 'The Big Dog' is in a completely different universe to Luther Reigns as far as talent goes.

Advertisement

The former Horshu was given an immediate rub as part of Team Angle in 2004. This allowed him to work against esteemed opposition like Eddie Guerrero and Big Show from day one, though he was also used as a henchman.

A big push seemed to be on the cards in early 2005, when Reigns and Mark Jindrak were booked against The Undertaker, with Luther wrestling 'The Deadman' in a truly awful bout at that year's No Way Out pay-per-view. This 12-minute failure of a match made it clear that Luther wasn't cut out for a big singles run, yet WWE kept him in the spotlight in the build to WrestleMania 21, though he fell off shortly after. By May, he'd been relegated to Velocity - a far more appropriate stage for his "talents."

Reigns wrestled only two independent bouts before retiring later that year, and though his run was short, he's ultimately remembered as an over-exposed Ruthless Aggression dud.

13. Hornswoggle

An easy pick for our list, Hornswoggle's WWE run saw him engage in a number of fun, light-hearted comedy moments (Extreme Rules 2014's WeeLC match remains an unironic gem), but was largely useless between the ropes, though his matches will never be what he's remembered for.

Advertisement

El Torito, his WeeLC opponent, was a genuinely great worker, but not 'Swoggle. He was a pure comedy performer, and while fine in his role, there's no escaping the fact that this made for some of the worst television in modern WWE history, particularly when he tried to wrestle. His matches were almost always derailed by shenanigans. If that's your thing, then fine, Hornswoggle did his job, but he was a loathsome presence for many.

The wee man's most egregious in-ring phase came in 2007, when he inexplicably became WWE Cruiserweight Champion, sounding the belt's death knell. While the division had never been treated with a great deal of respect, Hornswoggle's coronation was the point of no return. The belt was retired two months later, and if it weren't for the division's revival in 2016, the former Little Bastard would forever live on as its final champion.

12. Heidenreich

An unfortunate victim of some of the Ruthless Aggression era's absolute worst creative direction he may have been, but Heidenreich's failings had as much to do with his shortcomings as a performer as anything else. The former NFL hopeful wrestled like a broken action figure. Slow, clunky, and awkward, his movements were as uncoordinated as his moveset was basic, and he remains one of the worst opponents The Undertaker ever faced.

Advertisement

Their feud flopped. Not even Paul Heyman's presence as Heidenreich's manager could compel the crowd into taking the red-clad plodder seriously, and their Royal Rumble 2005 Casket Match was so bad, it prompted WWE to scrap a planned WrestleMania 21 tag clash that would've also featured Kane and Snitsky.

Heidenreich was a total bore, and his push was baffling. Each of his gimmicks flopped, from his early days as a psychotic poet to his closing run in the needless Legion Of Doom revival, and he didn't even achieve enough success to be considered a flash in the pan. Still, we'll never forget the time he attempted to molest poor Michael Cole in a backstage segment.

11. Kenzo Suzuki

WWE don't exactly have a shining track record when it comes to booking Japanese wrestlers. While Tajiri and Kaientai became fun midcarders, the legendary Ultimo Dragon was left to rot on C-shows, Yoshi Tatsu was entirely unconvincing, and Shinsuke Nakamura has had his once captivating aura greatly exposed on the main roster. They weren't absolute failures, but none was used particularly effectively.

Advertisement

Kenzo Suzuki shits near the top of the list of Japanese flops. He's mostly remembered for his spell as an ironic pro-USA heel and that tag team with René Duprée, but he was plucked from obscurity and thrust into the spotlight entirely too early. WWE snapped him up following a failed excursion for Riki Choshu's World Japan promotion, and threw him on television after an all-too-brief developmental run, with Kenzo and his wife, Hiroko, failing to get over.

Pulling him out of OVW was problematic, but so was signing Suzuki in the first place. He was far too early into his pro wrestling education to be competing at such a level, and his performances weren't just subpar: they were god-awful.

10. Ho Ho Lun

The Cruiserweight Classic's global focus saw WWE recruit sub-205lb wrestlers from all corners of the globe in summer 2016, and while many shined, the tactic necessitated dipping into shallow talent pools away from conventionally strong markets like Mexico and Japan. Thus, guys like Ho Ho Lun found themselves competing under WWE's banner.

Advertisement

The Hong Kong native deserves full credit for single-handedly building the territory's wrestling scene from scratch. As a trainer, gym owner, and promoter, he is widely credited for bringing the sport to HK, but his flaws were exposed as soon as he landed on the big stage.

Lun looked lost in the CWC. He clearly had some athleticism, but there were various points throughout his matches with Noam Dar and Ariya Daivari where he looked completely overawed by the situation, and didn't have a clue what to do next. Surprisingly, WWE opted to sign Lun in the aftermath, though he barely made it onto NXT television prior to his August 2017 release. This is for the best, as everything we saw of the 30-year-old suggested he was an awkward, uncomfortable, and inexperienced performer incapable of fulfilling even an enhancement role.

9. Jackie Gayda

Jackie Gayda's history of failure extends well beyond the notorious flopped 2002 tag match pitting her and Chris Nowinski against Bradshaw and Trish Stratus, but boy, what a flop it was.

Advertisement

Taking place on a random, inconsequential episode of Raw, the bout was a complete disaster. Much of this stemmed from Gayda's performance. Just one month removed from her stint on Tough Enough's second season, it was abundantly clear that Jackie wasn't ready for television, as she and Trish botched their way through several awkward exchanges. The worst moment came towards the end, when she sold her opponent's flying Bulldog several minutes too late, prompting Jim Ross to groan "mercifully, it's over," at the bout's conclusion, putting a bow on its failure.

To be fair to Jackie, this was just the fourth televised bout of her career, and she had never even set foot in a wrestling ring prior to Tough Enough. Her collapse wasn't her fault, but that doesn't exclude her from consideration. The fact is that Gayda just wasn't suited to an in-ring role, and WWE realised this, re-positioning her as a manager for much of her run.

8. James Ellsworth

Full credit to James Ellsworth for essentially hustling a single squash match loss into a two-year contract with the world's biggest wrestling promotion, but he should never have been pushed to such a high level of prominence. The original Dean Ambrose/AJ Styles angle was extended well beyond it's natural lifespan, and while 'The Chin That Eats The Pin' was okay in his role as Carmella's subservient sidekick, he was never going to become a WWE-calibre performer, especially between the ropes.

Advertisement

He got over, but Ellsworth was never a good worker. He was badly exposed in the Styles bouts, even though all four were crammed with smoke and mirrors to mask his deficiencies. Each was a turgid watch, and while Ellsworth's shoddy performances helped push his gimmick as a subpar wrestler in well over his head, not even the company's best all-rounder could drag something acceptable from him.

James' saving grace is that he was rarely called upon to compete, and wrestled just two televised bouts in 2017. Regardless, he's one of the most misplaced WWE Superstars of all-time, bringing backyard-level skills to the planet's biggest stage.

7. Snitsky

Best known for his involvement in the god-awful Kane/Lita romance angle (during which he punted a doll intended to represent their actual baby into the crowd), Snitsky isn't just one of WWE's worst big men of all time, but a historically cringe-worthy performer who featured at the heart of some of the modern era's absolute worst programming.

Advertisement

Snitsky's direction was appalling. From his union with Heidenreich to his days as a foot fetishist, he was an intergalactic disaster, and these creative atrocities were reflected in the ring.

On a list full of big, ungainly ogres, Gene stands out for his flaws. He was never able to project the required aura of intimidation, and always felt more like a guy playing pro wrestling than an actual monster, thus breaking the audience's immersion every time he was on-screen. Somehow, Snitsky was able to last more than four years as a full-time main roster performer, never once looking convincing in his role, even when portraying a comedic goofball.

Snitsky was certainly memorable, but for continually derailing the product rather than bringing any tangible positive qualities to the table, hence his lofty positioning.

6. Lana

She's one of WWE's best modern managers, but Lana might be the worst wrestler on WWE's active roster today. The company's attempts at reinventing her as an in-ring competitor were a disaster, and while 'The Ravishing Russian' hasn't worked a televised bout since October 2017, she remains active on house shows, and will soon compete in the upcoming Mixed Match Challenge series.

Advertisement

Lana was hot-shotted into a SmackDown Women's Title program at a time when she had just one televised bout to her name. Naomi handily defeated her at Money In The Bank 2017, but the match was well beyond the standards expected in the post-Revolution division. Lana followed this with a pair of quick squash defeats to the champ, dealing untold damage to her credibility as a performer, though her complete lack of seasoning meant a prolonged push was always unlikely.

Her failure is entirely WWE's fault, as Lana was expected to work a PPV title fight after just 35 bouts on the NXT house show circuit. Perhaps she'll eventually put the pieces together between the ropes, but at the moment, her in-ring run must be considered a giant flop.

5. Nathan Jones

You can't talk about failed wrestling giants without bringing Nathan Jones' name up. Standing at an impressive 6'10", and tipping the scales at 335lbs, 'The Colossus Of Boggo Road' had the size, look, and background down. A former world strongman champion and mixed martial arts competitor, Jones entered professional wrestling in 2001, and signed with WWE two years later, with the company exploiting his legitimate criminal record to put him over as a quasi Hannibal Lecter.

Advertisement

This character was quickly abandoned, and Jones was introduced as The Undertaker's protege instead. Aligning with one of the company's biggest stars should've given him a rub, but alas, Nathan was terrible. He barely lasted a month before WWE sent him down to Ohio Valley Wrestling, though he was eventually brought back with another light convict gimmick.

It was immediately clear that the developmental stint wasn't successful. Jones was the same discombobulated mess as before, and while he was adept good at conveying intensity, he was always let down by lacklustre ring work. The experiment ended with his resignation in December 2003, and Nathan retired soon after.

4. Viscera

It's mind-blowing that Viscera was given so many opportunities to succeed in WWE.

Advertisement

The 500lber had three individual runs with the company, and was crowned an unpopular King Of The Ring winner in 1995, but failed to get over as a main eventer. He returned for a second run as a Ministry Of Darkness goon from 1998-2000, before coming back again in 2004, when he was positioned as 'The World's Largest Love Machine' in a toe-curling romance angle with Lilian Garcia. He was eventually released in 2008, having last played the one-dimensional Big Daddy V on the ECW brand.

Once considered among the most dangerously clumsy wrestlers in the business (Kevin Nash famously stated that Viscera had injured "six or eight" colleagues back in 1995), Big Vis at least learned how to stop hurting his peers, but he was always a plodder. His massive size meant he moved at a glacial pace, and rendered him incapable of executing all but the most basic of moves. The 2004-08 run was a sham, and his worst in-ring offering came at New Year's Revolution 2006, when he and Shelton Benjamin torpedoed an otherwise mediocre pay-per-view.

3. Eli Cottonwood

It's hard not to feel sorry for Eli Cottonwood. The seven-footer reportedly spurned a career as a professional basketball player to chase his wrestling dream, but it backfired spectacularly. Though incredibly brief, his NXT run was more than enough to leave his countless shortcomings burned into the minds of WWE fans everywhere, so grand a disaster was his time on the show.

Advertisement

Cottonwood competed on NXT's second season, but was mercifully eliminated in the eighth week of competition, having amassed an in-ring record of two wins and two losses. Though short, these bouts presented a performer who was in so far over his head, he was close to drowning. Eli's movements were stunted, his arsenal limited, and he often looked lost between the ropes, particularly when charged with controlling matches. The charisma wasn't there either, as evidenced by whatever the hell this is supposed to be.

The epitome of a generic, over-pushed giant, Cottonwood returned to the FCW developmental system after his spell on NXT, and never re-emerged on mainstream wrestling television. Not even Vince McMahon's well-known big guy fetish could save him.

2. Eva Marie

WWE knew exactly what they were doing with Eva Marie. She was one of the most skill-deficient in-ring performers in modern wrestling history, and the company used this to their advantage, using Eva to mercilessly troll mainstream and developmental audiences alike.

Advertisement

Her late-career SmackDown run was particularly well done, with the writers using constant misdirection to make her one of her division's biggest heels. NXT was where Eva really shined, though. She drew nuclear heat from the workrate-focused Full Sail University crowd who knew she was dreadful in the ring, and were aghast that she'd invaded their safe haven. This peaked in January 2016, when Eva unbelievably eliminated Asuka from a battle royal, and there was a real fear she'd eventually became NXT Women's Champion. Fortunately, things never went this far.

Eva's whole act was built upon her being an awful wrestler, and awful she was. Her original push was Attitude-esque in that it took an inexperienced model and thrust her into an unjustifiable spotlight, and while WWE should be commended for turning this on its head by the end, nothing can erase her ghastly, botch-ridden bouts.

1. The Great Khali

Who other than The Great Khali - a man who struggled to walk down the ramp, let alone work a match - could possibly top such a list? The massive Indian remains the benchmark against which all other failed giants are compared, but while many were similarly atrocious between the ropes, none plied their trade in such a huge spotlight for as long as the 'Punjabi Playboy' did.

Advertisement

Khali's push amplifies his egregiousness. His monstrous size meant the company threw him into a feud with The Undertaker from day one, and he kept flirting with the main event scene for much of his early run. It peaked in 2007, when Khali was inexplicably crowned World Heavyweight Champion. A short reign, it was nonetheless long enough for him to go down as one of the worst title-holders of all time, with his plodding main events poisoning many a card.

Drifting into a freak show role towards the end of his run favoured Khali, but he was still the worst wrestler in the company, with his performances bringing more pain to the audiences (and the man himself, apparently) than his opponents. We should all thank the heavens that he didn't return to a full-time role after re-emerging at Battleground 2017.

Advertisement