What Cody Rhodes's "lovestache" lacked in body, it made up for in sheer popularity. The only 'stache on the list with its own t-shirt, its presence distracted fans long enough to stop chanting "We want Goldust" for a while. He shaved it off on "The JBL & Cole Show," and now sports gold facepaint where it once lived, but at any moment, the "lovestache" could return.