3 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE NXT (January 18, 2017)

Neither glorious nor inglorious.

By Michael Sidgwick /

NXT, by the very nature of the programme, is in a constant state of flux - but, unlike the brand’s apex year of 2015, the winning conveyor belt formula is in danger of spluttering.

Advertisement

TakeOver: Brooklyn, on August 22, 2015, was headlined by Finn Bálor Vs. Kevin Owens - a ladder match battle between two of the most fawned-over indy darlings on the planet - but it wasn’t even the best thing on the card. Match Of The Night - arguably Match Of The Year - honours went to Bayley and Sasha Banks’ gripping and emotional Women’s Title bout. Observing the action at ringside was Asuka. The conveyor belt cycled along with perfect momentum.

The plight of the Women’s division - which is so thin on over acts that the creative team has been compelled to hang a lantern on the lack of competition - crystallises the gradual decline of what was the most beloved wrestling (operative word) brand on the planet.

Advertisement

That this week’s episode of NXT failed to deliver too much in the way of entertainment value, even without an appearance from the X-Pac heat generators that are Billie Kay and Peyton Royce, underscores that the rot makes no concession to gender…

Downs...

2. Percy Watson's Commentary

WWE.com

For the umpteenth week in a row, it took me half an hour to realise that Percy Watson was even at the booth.

Advertisement

It’s not as if he said anything insightful either. Perhaps the Full Sail din had dimmed just long enough for his quiet, generic tones to ring out. As Damo was finally confirmed as the fourth member of SAnitY, Watson emerged from underneath his rock. “I think SAnitY just got a new member!” he pointed out, helpfully. On the few occasions he managed to pipe up, he uttered nothing insightful. “I’ll tell you one thing,” he tried to gravely intone as he surveyed the damage incurred by Shane Thorne, in a hastily re-taped beatdown angle, at the hands of The Revival: “It’s not good.”

Watson is succinct, if nothing else. He’s new to a game which, to be fair, far superior talkers than him have struggled with. One Mick Foley had a stint in the SmackDown booth that was anonymous as it was brief.

Advertisement

The man had bags of personality when he starred in season two of the original, inexplicable, counterproductive game show that was NXT, pre-Full Sail reorientation. Maybe a heel turn - that failsafe litmus test of personality discovery - is required.

1. A Dearth Of Star Power, A Dearth Of In-Ring Action

WWE.com

Make no mistake - Roderick Strong, at his best, is more than capable of putting on a show. But, realistically, he is synonymous with the downfall of Ring Of Honor, post-2000s heyday. That’s not a slight - better workers than Strong have been unable to sustain business in what is a cyclical industry - but he did not arrive in Orlando dripping with same acclaim as Sami Zayn, Neville et al.

Advertisement

The injury to Austin Aries has had an indirectly adverse effect on his positioning in NXT. Suddenly a babyface, only in that he is set to do battle with a heel in Andrade “Cien” Almas, it’s clear that the programme has been thrown together. His match opposite Steve Cutler was little more than a squash, the reaction to which was naturally subdued, given the suddenness with which he has turned.

Elsewhere, the backstage segment, setting up a match between No Way Jose and Kona Reeves was awkward, promising a match of house show quality at best.

Advertisement

The in-ring action was non-existent - though Nikki Cross’ awesome character work in the opening squash made up for her lack of ring time - but there were mitigating factors at play. The third and final match, between The Revival and TM61, was truncated by Shane Thorne’s injury. It at least developed The Revival act, while it lasted; the team, now calling themselves the greatest of all time, succumbed to a shock early loss. It adds - or added - an interesting wrinkle to the tag division, but external forces appear to have put paid to that development.

Ups...

3. Corey Graves' Commentary

WWE.com

Corey Graves is the best thing to happen to the WWE commentary booth since Jim Ross was taken ‘round back and shot in the face.

Advertisement

No one-dimensional heel colour commentator, he is as equally proficient at building up what’s left of the decimated NXT babyface roster. The second match, pitting Roderick Strong against Steve Cutler, was as good as one can expect from an in-house developmental prospect with just over two years’ worth of experience - i.e., not very.

But Graves’ work at the desk portrayed an average-at-best talent as a vicious tactician. As Cutler drove his knee into Strong’s back, Graves sold it with more conviction than Strong did - and he used just one word to do it. “Jesus,” he said, his hushed whisper doing more than any histrionic bluster could. Of course, Graves is more than capable of turning up the volume. His fan boy infatuation with Bobby Roode - “This is mesmerising! This is awe-inspiring!” - will never not be funny.

Advertisement

His Bobby Heenan/Ric Flair tribute adds so much to Roode’s act, too - and he lays it on with so much conviction that, hilariously, it borders on Jerry Lawler/Sable territory.

2. Storyline Development

WWE.com

Midway through the programme, Tye Dillinger addressed his future in an interview segment. It was a decent performance; his delivery was as earnest as it was engaging, and he generally came across as the likeable bloke he is.

Advertisement

He was soon interrupted by the SAnitY faction of Eric Young, Alexander Wolfe and Nikki Cross. Incidentally, the faction’s theme, CFO$’s ‘Controlled Chaos’, deserve praise, lost as it has been amid the gloriousness of, erm, Bobby Roode’s ‘Glorious Domination’. Those deranged time signatures capture the tone of the act perfectly.

The segment dragged on when Eric Young suggested that Dillinger join the group. “I know, I’m laying a lot on you right now,” Young said. That wasn’t strictly true; he more or less used ten sentences to deliver the same point. The endgame was predictable - it was obvious that Dillinger was going to refuse what Young then turned into a demand, only to receive a pummelling at the hands of Damo - but it was a logical development which set-up an intriguing midcard match at TakeOver: San Antonio.

Advertisement

The segment achieved its dual objective of capping Damo’s arc and reorienting the Dillinger character. The latter’s San Antonio match opposite Eric Young should bolster the undercard nicely - and unlike Andrade “Cien” Almas Vs. Roderick Strong, it hasn’t sprung from out of nowhere.

1. A (Just About) Good (Enough) Main Event Segment

WWE.com

The heavily-hyped contract signing main event segment, setting up Bobby Roode’s San Antonio challenge of Shinsuke Nakamura’s NXT Championship, delivered - in spite of itself.

Advertisement

It started gloriously enough, even if the TakeOver: Dallas ticket stub presented to Nakamura last week was a retconned MacGuffin. Bobby Roode was in fine form, distancing himself from the universal praise bestowed upon Nakamura from all angles. “I’ve followed your career in Japan,” he surmised. “I never really thought you were worth my time,” he added, to searing heat.

That heat was doused when the segment degenerated into the sort of playground mudslinging which has smeared RAW in sh*t for years. As funny as it was, Roode’s mimicking of Nakamura’s hair and mannerisms was hardly fitting of a serious, high stakes main event series. He poked fun at his outfit, too.

Advertisement

What is it with WWE and clothes? What does the company find so funny about them? Nakamura’s red leather jacket was treated with the same disdain as Chris Jericho’s scarf. How does one man making fun of another man’s clothes build hype for a wrestling match?

It ended well enough - Nakamura’s “I’m gonna kick your head off” capper drew the required gasps - but the oddly comedic tone very nearly undermined a segment that really should have written itself.

Advertisement

Star power saved it - but, ominously, that star power is in short supply elsewhere.