3 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW: Battle Of The Belts

AEW stretch things too thin; Britt Baker retains; Battle Of The Belts = Rampage?

By Jamie Kennedy /

AEW

AEW could've subtitled Battle Of The Belts, 'For Those Who Just Didn't Get Enough On Friday's Episode Of Rampage'. Too long? Well, BOTB wasn't. It clocked in a just over 60 minutes in length, and that'll feel like a bit of a disappointment to those fans who were expecting more.

Advertisement

Listen, the show wasn't bad - it zipped along and featured wrestling that ranged from solid enough-really good, but yours truly left the experience wondering if Tony Khan could've made this a bigger deal. It lacked the sparkle and shine people have become accustomed to with All Elite hype, and there were a lot of top names missing that could've helped make the night special.

The entire experiment came across as half-baked, which isn't good enough.

Advertisement

On the plus side, the opener defied expectations going in to steal match of the night honours. Typically though, some wonky psychology really stopped it from going a notch higher. Elsewhere, Riho's latest flirtation with the Women's Title came to an end, and AEW used the night to set up several other bouts on Dynamite.

Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from a card that really should've been more memorable.

Advertisement

Downs...

4. The Name

AEW

This is nitpicking, but 'Battle Of The Belts' implies that 'Champion vs. Champion' matches are on the menu. They weren't though, not on AEW's latest special. That's why 'Battle For The Belts' would've been a better name for Saturday's night hour-long championship love-in.

Advertisement

Is that too picky? This writer feels like that might be a little too picky, but he's also torn - names are important. They either set the tone for what should be expected, like All Out (AEW will literally go all out to entertain you) or just signify a changing of the wrestling guard (Revolution).

This delivered neither.

Advertisement

The event title is something Khan and chums should've obsessed over beforehand. They didn't need to frame this the way they did; BOTB could've been called something else just as easily without losing any interest.

3. No World Title

AEW

This is getting a 'Down' too.

Advertisement

Where the f*ck was the AEW World Title, and why wasn't it featured on this showcase of championship gold? All Elite were putting on the first Battle Of The Belts, so you'd think they'd make an effort to book Hangman Page (y'know, the reigning World Champion) on the card.

Nope, and who knows why? What a strange decision. If anything, that Hangman vs. Bryan Danielson rematch from Dynamite should've been kept back for this event that was...centred around big time matches for the belts. AEW could've made the night PPV-ish instead of just a routine premium live event.

Advertisement

Sure, that's a light-hearted dig, but come on. It was an insult to this show's credibility that Page wasn't involved at all. Way to make your new concept look flat, lads. If WWE booked a title-centric event and didn't put one of the World Titles on, people would (rightly) moan.

Tony isn't getting a pass here.

Advertisement

2. The FTW Title Made It In?!

AEW

Ricky Starks is a fine up-and-coming talent in AEW circles, but neither he nor his FTW Title deserved to be on the show ahead of the World or Tag-Team straps. FTW is the least-essential belt in this promotion, and it's literally presented as a championship that's not married to any one organisation.

Advertisement

Yet it was on the line up for a card all about AEW belts. OK?

On the whole, Starks vs. Matt Sydal was a solid-if-unspectacular match. There was never any real threat of a title switch, and the post-match shenanigans involving Dane Martin, Lee Moriarty and Powerhouse Hobbs kinda made the latter look like a tool who can't handle business.

Advertisement

Back to the original complaint; FTW shouldn't have been leap-frogging other, more prestigious championships at BOTB. AEW got this one wrong. If nobody wants to admit it, fine, but don't pretend that Taz's made-up prize is more important than officially-recognised titles.

1. They Ruined Their Own Psychology

AEW

First off, Dustin Rhodes deserves praise for doing some of the sh*t he does aged 52.

Advertisement

However, he and Sammy Guevara trod on their own toes and spoiled an otherwise-spirited show of psychology on Saturday night. Their interim TNT Title bout kicked off with some neat storytelling that suggested the older Dustin was knackered and couldn't hack the pace Sammy was setting.

From there, Sammy sold a knee injury before trying some ill-advised dive spots and springboards anyway. Fine - that could be excused by the announcers as Guevara showing off his never-say-die spirit. Then, he genuinely refused to die when Dustin hit a Destroyer off the ring apron through a table.

Advertisement

If they were going to use that, it needed to be the finish. You can't have wrestlers surviving that kind of bump for a near fall 20 seconds later. That's the kind of nonsense John Cena used to get pelters for! AEW knew Guevara was going to win, so they should've edited that spot out of the match.

Ups...

3. Sticking It Back On Sammy

AEW

Right, enough grumbling like an old fart who wants wrestling to bring back the humble arm drag as a finish.

Advertisement

AEW were not at fault for Cody Rhodes missing the show. They had a decision to make, and they quickly inserted his brother Dustin into the match with Guevara and turned it into an interim title crowning. It's hard to argue with their logic there, because now they've got another match to build towards rather than doing nothing.

Plus, Cody can whinge about beating Sammy on Christmas Day then seeing the Inner Circle man win gold again when he was on the bench. Those are promos Rhodes must cut before that title unification match (whenever it's going to happen).

Advertisement

At first, it did seem like Dustin would get the belt and set up another brother vs. brother clash heading into Revolution, but that wasn't to be. AEW, correctly, view Sammy as the priority and a future linchpin they can build around.

2. As Good As Interim Can Be

AEW

Then, even better, the company went with Daniel Garcia challenging for the interim TNT Title during Cody's absence. Garcia entered the ring during Sammy's victory celebrations and went nose-to-nose with the new provisional champion. That got blood pumping in the stands, which is good sign.

Advertisement

All that hard work AEW has put into establishing Garcia as a threat is starting to pay off. Now, midweek, he'll wrestle Guevara in a battle of two young lions who should be considered amongst the leading lights for All Elite's future. Sammy sent out the challenge in a post-match promo, and Daniel will presumably accept.

This is a best-case scenario for everybody. Cody can take some time out to heal up, and Sammy can put on a dazzler vs. the hungry-as-f*ck Garcia with the interim TNT prize on the line. AEW did a snazzy job of making the belt seem sought-after here.

Advertisement

That's all anyone can ask for.

1. Britt Baker Keeps Her Title

AEW

Well, praise be to the wrestling lords.

Advertisement

Britt Baker defeated Riho to retain her AEW Women's Title in a so-so main event. Despite some hiccups (the bout really lagged during the middle portion, and some of Riho's selling was a little too spotty to mean much), the ending had fans on their feet. That's a win for these women.

Excalibur bizarrely claimed that Britt's win was a tainted one. Not quite, mate. Did Rebel and Jamie Hayter interfere on the champ's behalf earlier? Yes, absolutely, but Rebel had been punted from ringside by the ref before Baker used her Lockjaw finisher to make Riho tap in the centre of the ring.

Advertisement

The big plus here is that Riho didn't become champ for a second time. She would've been a step in the wrong direction for a division that's starting to heat up, and she's definitely not the right woman to end Britt's lengthy reign.

What did you think of AEW's Battle Of The Belts? For more like this, check out 5 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Jan 7) and 4 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (Jan 7)!

Advertisement