3 Ups And 4 Downs From Last Night's WWE Smackdown (Oct 18)
Ellsworth Vs. Styles II.
We're nine days removed from No Mercy and a month out from Survivor Series, but make no mistake, the buzz about this week's Smackdown was for one reason and one reason only - James Ellsworth, the world's favorite enhancement talent and the man with two hands and a fighting chance, challenged AJ Styles for the WWE World Championship.
Implausible? Yes. Comical? Absolutely. Make no mistake, though, fans were behind Ellsworth - both on the Internet during the week-long build to his match and live in Denver. With that momentum - plus the antics of Dean Ambrose - could he pull off the greatest upset in WWE history?
You can probably guess the answer, but that match wasn't all that Smackdown had to offer. Many of the threads from last week and No Mercy were left hanging, meaning that The Miz, Dolph Ziggler, The Spirit Squad, Rhyno, Heath Slater, Naomi, and Alexa Bliss were all in action. While the blue brand seems to be coasting on the programs that have already been established in previous weeks, the formula seems to be working - for the most part.
Here are 3 ups and 4 downs from October 18's Smackdown:
Ups...
3. Reversal Of Fortune
In a bout announced on last week's Smackdown, Alexa Bliss was in action against Naomi. The two battled at No Mercy when Naomi substituted for the injured Smackdown Women's Champion Becky Lynch, and at that show, Naomi picked up the win.
This time, Bliss was looking to build some momentum heading into her rescheduled title match with Becky, which will take place in three weeks. The bout was a great contest, with Naomi pulling off some high-risk offense and Bliss playing a solid heel. The ending was a little abrupt, as Bliss knocked Naomi off the top rope and hit Twisted Bliss for the win, but the match still delivered.
After the bout, Bliss told Becky in a post-match interview that the fairy tale was over, and that she'd be taking the Smackdown Women's Title. So is it fair to say that at this point, both of the Women's Title feuds in WWE are better than both of the Heavyweight Title feuds?
2. It's 2006 All Over Again
Last week on Smackdown, Tag Team Champions Rhyno and Heath Slater saved Intercontinental Champion Dolph Ziggler from a three-on-one beating at the hands of The Miz and The Spirit Squad. That lead to this week's six-man tag team match.
The bout was simple and straightforward, but there was nothing wrong with it - it was a typical heated WWE multi-man tag. The heels got the heat on Dolph (leading to unlikely chants of "We want Slater!") and everything was solid. Eventually, Dolph tagged Slater, who ran wild on the heels. Rhyno hit Mikey with a Gore, but a shot from The Miz allowed Kenny to role Slater up for the pin.
Presumably, the win by The Spirit Squad means that they're the number one contenders to the Smackdown Tag Team Titles. That's fair - I've said it before, but they're a more credible team than Breezango, The Hype Bros, or The Ascension. They shouldn't win, but they make a good addition to the blue brand's roster.
1. Two In A Row
Finally, it was time for James Ellsworth's WWE World Title shot against AJ Styles. Daniel Bryan told Dean Ambrose that he couldn't referee the bout, but his concession that Ambrose could take on another role opened the door for some hijinks.
Ambrose worked as the ring announcer and the timekeeper, doing anything he could to distract Styles. "The Phenomenal One" was still dominant during the bout - despite Ellsworth's unique features helping him slide out of a chinlock - but Ambrose's constant interruptions eventually allowed Ellsworth to trip the WWE World Champion up on the ropes, then hit him with a superkick (called "No Chin Music" by David Otunga) for a two count.
Ambrose kept chiding Styles, eventually making him so angry that he refused to stop attacking Ellsworth against the ropes and got disqualified. That gave Ambrose the opportunity to run in and plant Styles with yet another Dirty Deeds.
I'm not sure why they protected James Ellsworth (though he is 2-0 against Styles), but this was a really funny main event in a way that built up the Ambrose-Styles program nicely. This show ended on a high note.
Downs...
4. Buried
Smackdown opened with Randy Orton cutting a promo on Bray Wyatt but - once again - Wyatt responded with a video message on the Titantron. This time, he was laying in a casket, promising to fight Orton to the finish.
That brought out Luke Harper, who took on Orton in the show's opening contest. Harper overpowered Orton early, but when the tide turned, Bray Wyatt came out from the back - in his coffin, with sheep-masked attendants wheeling him down. Wyatt left the coffin and watched the bout, but when Orton was about to hit the draping DDT, he ran in for the DQ.
They laid Orton out and opened the casket to deposit him, but Kane was inside. The babyfaces fought off the heels, but before they could hit their finishers, the lights went out. When they came up, Wyatt and Harper were gone.
I'm not sure if this means a casket match is coming up at Survivor Series, but this segment was just more of the same wheel-spinning we've seen from this feud. The fact that there's another month left to go is not encouraging.
3. Curt Hawkins Wastes Time
Smackdown promised, at long last, to feature the in-ring return of Curt Hawkins. Apollo Crews was ready to meet the former WWE Tag Team Champion in a singles match, but Hawkins wasn't about to simply come down to the ring. He made his way to a boastful voice-over a la Eva Marie (except he had recorded it himself).
Hawkins got in the ring and began cutting a promo on Apollo Crews, leading the former NXT star to knock him down with a punch. After that, a furious Hawkins accused Crews of ruining his debut, then headed to the back, refusing to wrestle.
This is basically the exact same thing WWE was doing with Eva Marie prior to SummerSlam, and I guess they really want to do it, because they're not even waiting for Eva to get back - they just transferred the angle to someone else. Like with Eva Marie, though, it's not interesting, and the eventual payoff isn't going to be worth it. The whole thing feels like a colossal waste of valuable TV time - it's not like this is the three-hour show.
2. Time To Shoot!
The top-of-the-hour segment saw Carmella come down to the ring, promising to dish out the truth about Nikki Bella. That brought out Bella herself, who was interested in seeing exactly what her foe could possibly say. Carmella was unfazed, though, and dropped the bombshell: Nikki is dating... John Cena!
Needless to say, this was a bit underwhelming. Bella even acknowledged that it's no secret - despite the fact that she doesn't talk about it on Smackdown, she's been very open about her relationship on reality TV and social media. Carmella went one step further, though, telling Bella that she was only where she was because of Cena, then airing a Total Bellas highlight video designed to make Bella look "needy."
Bella blew it off, talking about how Carmella was undermining her as a woman, but Carmella maintained that she was with Cena for her personal gain, then left. This was a really underwhelming segment, as Carmella's material was nonsense and Bella, despite trying, also fell flat. This feud hasn't been that bad, all things considered, so hopefully this was just a misfire.
1. A Change Of Plans?
Alexa Bliss versus Naomi wasn't the only No Mercy rematch on Smackdown - Jack Swagger and Baron Corbin also faced off against one another. At the PPV, Corbin defeated Swagger after a thumb to the eye, showing that the company still wanted to protect "The All-American American" shortly after his Smackdown debut.
This time, things were totally different. Even though Swagger knocked Corbin down to start, "The Lone Wolf" immediately started dominating the former World Heavyweight Champion. He laid Swagger over the guardrail and rained forearms onto the back of his head, then threw him in the ring and quickly hit the End of Days for the pin.
To be fair, there was nothing wrong with this match - I'm not a fan of Corbin, but this is how you put someone over. The reason that I can't give it a thumbs up, though, is that I've seen how WWE books for far too long. There's no evidence that this is reflective of future booking plans, and Swagger could just as easily dominate Corbin on next week's show.
It's unfortunate that a lack of consistency makes even potential victories fall flat.