35 Top WrestleMania Performers In WWE History

16. Seth Rollins (5-1)

Regardless of how Seth Rollins fares this year, he will likely see his position climb on this list, simply given the significance of his WrestleMania matches.

Rollins won his first two Mania matches as part of the Shield at 29 and 30, but it was his performance at 31 that vaulted him onto this list. The Architect lost a match early on to Randy Orton, but his night wasn’t over. Rollins used his Money in the Bank briefcase to turn the WWE World Heavyweight Championship match between Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar into a triple threat, and then would emerge victorious, becoming the first person to cash in the briefcase at WrestleMania.

Sadly, Rollins missed out on Mania in 2016, but he rebounded at WM 33 to defeat Triple H and captured the Intercontinental Championship at WM 34.