One of the biggest surprises of the night was that Spud actually managed to defeat O'Shea, nailing him with the Underdog for the victory. Considering that Spud wouldn't lose much credibility by being defeated by O'Shea, but O'Shea certainly would with a defeat from a guy like half his size, it's pretty surprising they didn't give the win to O'Shea. After all, if they want his "new" gimmick to succeed, they need to build him up, not knock him down before he has a chance to establish himself.