Battleground will go down as one of the more underwhelming PPVs in recent memory. It really seems to serve solely as a placeholder event, with very little resolved. The immediate reaction has been generally negative, and with good reason. Like a car stuck in the mud, WWEs tires were spinning Sunday night, but the vehicle didnt really go anywhere. However, there are a couple glimmers of hope buried within this subpar special event, a few things that hopefully provide something to build upon. But lets not try to polish this one up too much: even some of the positive developments from Sunday night are tempered by some drawbacks. So as WWE begins its careening course toward SummerSlam, what actually emerged from Battleground? And how do these developments fit the narrative going forward?
4 Positives...
4. AJ And Paige Finally Have A Real Title Match
If were going strictly by match time, AJ and Paige improved threefold from their previous two matches combined. In trading the Divas Championship between them, their first two encounters lasted less than two-and-a-half minutes total. Neither match really got started or went much beyond a ridiculously brief attack by the champ before the challenger surprised her and scored the pinfall. Sunday night, they at least had a seven-minute match that had some flow to it. There is plenty to complain about here the total lack of any real development in their storyline or characters, a completely clean win for the champ but for the first time in three matchups, two of the more capable female wrestlers actually got to go out there and have a match. We also got to see Paige on offense more in this match than probably all of her title defenses against Alicia Fox combined, so thats another plus. But for this match to actually mean something, there needs to be some movement forward with Paige. No one is buying her fangirl/best friend act (including the announcers, which is a surprisingly smart move), but she needs to start showing some cracks in this façade soon. Perhaps Paiges foot being under the ropes on the pinfall or using the ropes to try to pin AJ would show a little color.
3. Cena Plays Some Subtle Notes
Its somewhat surprising that a wrestler who has a signature move thats also a euphemism for male masturbation is portrayed as a morally upstanding character. Dont misunderstand: John Cena is not characterized as an infallible human being, but in the ring, hes often presented as an upright guy who doesnt take shortcuts. Hes the ultimate good guy, a person who stands there and smiles goofily as fans chant, Cena sucks! Last night, there was a moment that stood out. Maybe its nothing, but it seemed completely out of character for Cena. Roman Reigns powered out of Kanes chokeslam and then speared him. Cena broke up the pinfall then tried to pin a downed Kane himself. Its just not something youd necessarily expect, especially since it was Reigns who hit the knockout blow (if Orton had RKOd Kane, it wouldnt have been noticeable). Cena trying to steal one from Reigns stood out for a brief second. Cena definitely is noticing that Reigns is the new golden child, the one being groomed to lead WWE into the future. We all saw it at the end of Raw a couple weeks ago when Cena and Reigns took turns raising each others hand to boos (Cena) and cheers (Reigns). When they were finally alone in the ring Sunday night, Cena rubbed his hands together as if to say he was anxious to find out who the Alpha male was. And while no one expects Cena to become a bad guy, it would be nice if hes starting to show some shades of grey as a character. Maybe hes intimidated by Reigns and his standing with the fans. Of course, if we get a healthy dose of Super Cena for the next three months, then all of this means nothing.
2. Wyatts And Usos Steal The Show
If you ordered the WWE Network right after last weeks free preview ended, then you got your moneys worth with the first match of the night. Hearing Jerry Lawler wax about the good old days when most title matches were two out of three falls gave it a special feeling, that this was going to be a war that harkened back to the battles between the British Bulldogs and the Hart Foundation. And the Wyatts and Usos did not disappoint. They put on a masterful performance that had fans on the edges of their seats for the last 10-15 minutes. It was the kind of tag team wrestling that longtime wrestling fans love to see and that even the most inexperienced fan can pick up on almost immediately. Sure, there was a lot of immediate armchair booking over whether the Wyatts should have won here since the Usos have beaten everyone, but lets be realistic: The Usos have held the belts for just over four months. That might seem like a long time, but it really isnt. The Shield topped out at just under five months, and even Kofi Kingston and R-Truth topped four months as tag champs. Keeping the straps on a hot team makes them mean something, and hopefully will make when they lose them all the more significant. Could the Usos have lost the titles at Battleground to the Wyatts and it been the right move? Absolutely. But keeping the titles on the Usos isnt necessarily the wrong move provided they dont keep them there past the expiration date.
1. Ambrose And Rollins Advance Angle Without A Match
Last nights non-match between Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins seems to have divided wrestling fans. Some feel that it was a case of bait-and-switch from WWE, not delivering a major match they had advertised. Others believe it was a brilliant piece of storytelling and angle advancement that felt more realistic than any match would have been. If youre watching WWE solely for match after match after match, then the Old School programming on WWE Network is probably better suited for you. The simple truth is that pro wrestling today has plenty of angles (or storylines) that play out on television. A lot of it takes place within the ring, but a good amount happens backstage or in promos. These storyline developments can be death a lack of action between unconvincing characters or too much humor and childish antics will spell the end of fans interest. But with Ambrose and Rollins, you have two guys who have all the goods. They can go in the ring. They can deliver on the mic. And they are presenting a feud that hasnt been seen in WWE for some time. Its reminiscent of the early Rock/Austin feuds over the Intercontinental Championship, when a lot of the action took place in promos or outside the ring (including once on a bridge). Its no wonder that Ambrose is drawing comparisons to an early Steve Austin with his ability to connect with the crowd as a manic brawler who doesnt wait for a bell to ring to begin assaulting his opponent. You can feel the hatred dripping from both men, and thats why Sunday nights backstage brawl, their ringside melee and Ambroses ambush in the parking lot worked so well. Sure, there was no match last night, but Rollins and Ambrose brawled convincingly for nearly 10 minutes. It felt so much more realistic than any match would have, and it made fans want to see them tear each other apart even more. So unless youre a member of the instant gratification society, you will certainly get what you want soon enough. Now click below for four negatives from the show...
4 Negatives...
4. Rusev Non-Finish Was Pointless
WWE needs to make up their minds about Rusev. Is he an unstoppable monster who will make his way to the top of the card? Or is he destined for midcard greatness and currently is serving as a vehicle to remake Jack Swagger? Rusev technically won by countout at Battleground, presumably as a means to stretch the battle between Russia and America for at least one more PPV while keeping him undefeated. But for Rusev to be on his heels for half of the 10-minute match with Jack Swagger, it was the wrong play. Swagger is a guy who has been treated like a jobber to the stars for the past year. Whenever the Real Americans lost a tag match, it was Swagger looking up at the lights. Suddenly, Swagger stands up for America, and he is able to repel a Bulgarian Brute who recently has bulldozed former IC champ Big E and former WWE and ECW champ Rob Van Dam. If WWE is bent on finally building up Swagger properly after years of half-hearted pushes, then thats fine. But if hes going to be jobbing to Kofi Kingston and Bo Dallas in a month, then there was no reason that Rusev shouldnt have won convincingly. Having him win by countout and then beat him up after the bell wasnt productive.
3. Bray Wyatt Keeps Losing
At WrestleMania XXX, John Cena overcame his deepest doubts and demons to beat Bray Wyatt. Wyatt then enlisted the help of his family and a 10-year-old boy to defeat Cena, before Cena stood tall in the rubber match. Coming off a high profile feud that he lost, Wyatt got paired with another great talker in Chris Jericho. It seemed like this would be a perfect match, with Y2J showing in his recent runs little hesitation in putting over new faces (Fandango, anyone?). And then Jericho won clean as a sheet at Battleground. Wyatt needed a victory Sunday night to get back on track. It could have been by dubious means to set up a rematch. He could have lost after interference backfired. If WWE is building to a big rematch at SummerSlam, Bray losing in the center of the ring without a hint of controversy or doubt was the absolute wrong way to do. Sure, Wyatt has said before that wins and losses dont matter much to him, but at some point very soon, fans are going to lose patience beyond the ultra-cool entrance and tune out.
2. Miz As IC Champ Is Awful
Who else was surprised at how entertaining the Intercontinental Championship battle royal was? Sure, it wasnt a great match, but it had points that were pretty good and kept fans interested, with Sheamus threatening to unify the secondary titles, Bo Dallas looking to inspire people as their IC champ, and fan-favorite Dolph Ziggler making the final two. And then Miz emerged from hiding to dump Ziggler to win. No, seriously. The Miz, who hasnt done anything of consequence in the ring for the past year, came away as Intercontinental Champion by lying on the floor feigning injury for three-quarters of the battle royal. Its a hackneyed, overdone finish that should not be seen in a WWE ring again. (The last time it was successful was Santinos near-win in the 2011 Royal Rumble.) Going into the battle royal, there were a couple picks that conventional wisdom said would be logical winners: Bo Dallas needs to either sink or swim, and an IC title run might help determine which way hes going. Sheamus could unify the two secondary titles (which still might happen given Mizs victory last week over the Celtic Warrior). Cesaro is treading water and was originally thought to be the favorite in the number one contenders tournament that Bad News Barrett won a couple months back. Even Ziggler had standing as an outlier who would be believable if WWE wanted to surprise people. But Miz? Hes not drawing heel heat, hes drawing what people often refer to as X-Pac Heat. Fans want him off their screen and out of the ring. Hes really not as bad as people make him out to be at times, but Sunday night was just a terrible move. Miz has been back for two weeks. At least let people develop the right kind of hatred for him before pushing him as IC champ.
1. No Surprises Or Big Developments Whatsoever
Pop quiz: What was the big shocker, the big takeaway from Battleground? If youre struggling to come up with something, then you see what the biggest problem about Sunday night was. To call Battleground a placeholder of a PPV would almost be an understatement. A new IC champ was crowned, but what else came of it? Rusev/Swagger ended in a countout. Bray Wyatt lost clean. And Cena found a way to overcome the odds. But most importantly, there was no development that came out of the four-way title match. There was no mention of Paul Heymans Plan C, and Triple Hs Plan B was rendered unavailable by Ambrose. Blowing one of Brock Lesnars limited appearances unannounced would not have worked, but even an appearance from Heyman at the end letting Hunter know that Plan C was available and ready to go would have been something, which is better than nothing. If WWE is going to sell the Network on the promise of must-see TV, then their special events need to deliver. Storylines need to move forward at these events, not just on Raw. Aside from an outstanding tag title match and a great Ambrose/Rollins brawl, a nonsubscriber didnt miss anything. And that wont help drive subscriptions. Not every PPV needs to be a WrestleMania, but WWE has to put a better foot forward.