4 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (5 Jan)

Page vs. Danielson II, Cargill vs. Soho for the TBS Title, Tag Title match, CM Punk shoots & more!

By Andy H Murray /

AEW/Scott Lesh

As far as weekly television shows go, last night's AEW Dynamite will go down as one of the biggest of the year.

Advertisement

It could hardly have been more significant. The switch from TNT to TBS is a major change in itself despite the two station's similar viewership numbers, given pro wrestling's history on AEW's new home, and the card was loaded up with big-time matches and segments.

Bryan Danielson challenged 'Hangman' Adam Page for the AEW World Championship in a rematch of last month's ripping first encounter, which finished as a time-limit draw. Elsewhere, Jurassic Express challenged for the Lucha Brothers' AEW World Tag Team Titles under the guidance of Christian Cage, while AEW appropriately crowned its first TBS Championship as Jade Cargill and Ruby Soho met in the tournament finals.

Advertisement

This lot, plus pre-advertised appearances from Chris Jericho and MJF, made last night's Dynamite a can't-miss show before it aired. It's unfortunate, then, that much of what aired was far from can't-miss, and that big chunks of this show either didn't hit the required levels of quality, or didn't resonate as they should have.

Let's light the fuse...

Advertisement

Downs...

4. Jurassic Express' Big Moment Falls Short

AEW

It should have been great, Lucha Brothers vs. Jurassic Express, but fate dealt the wrestlers a bad hand in the form of Rey Fenix's injury, the match preceding that unfortunate moment wasn't as cohesive as it perhaps could have been, and Jungle Boy and Luchasaurus' big moment fell flat.

Advertisement

That last part stinks. Jurassic Express celebrating with the Tag Team Championships, then facing off with almost every tandem on the roster (who gathered on the stage), didn't register as a huge, cathartic triumph. It should have, given how beloved this team (and Jungle Boy in particular) is, but when the match itself isn't all that satisfying, the outcome often underwhelms.

Lucha Bros. and Jurassic worked hard, at least, delivering a number of eyeball-popping spots, including a spectacular Destroyer that saw Jungle Boy leap over Luchasaurus and Penta El Zero Miedo to plant Fenix. Later, Luchasaurus Chokeslamming Fenix through the table could be hailed as another adrenaline-pumper if not for the gruesome injury.

Advertisement

Ultimately, the match wasn't fluid or cohesive enough to register as a wild, crazy spotfest and there weren't enough slower moments to classify it as a more classically styled tag bout. It was somewhere in between - and muddled as a result.

3. Chris Jericho Drags Down Diet Raw Segment

AEW

What felt like a bland WWE Raw segment played out as Chris Jericho made his return to Dynamite, hitting the ring for a short promo on 2point0, who quickly came out to answer him.

Advertisement

That's when things got sucky. Matt Lee and Jeff Parker tried desperately to sell Jericho's awful jokes, putting them over as if the Inner Circle leader had just sh*t on their mothers, but they couldn't save the segment from the low-level dreck Jericho often resorts to on this babyface run. Calling Lee "Squarehead" and Parker "Pinhead" isn't funny, even on a crude, playground level, and that the crowd responded to these with little enthusiasm compared to how they sang Judas moments earlier shows this isn't a minority opinion.

Eddie Kingston, Santana, and Ortiz saved Jericho when 2point0 struck following a Daniel Garcia ambush, theoretically putting additional heat on their Rampage trios match.

Advertisement

2. TBS Title Match Underwhelms

AEW/Scott Lesh

Theoretically a great styles clash between a plucky, experienced wrestler and a growing powerhouse, both of whom come off incredibly well on television, Jade Cargill vs. Ruby Soho was a clunky match that undermined the occasion of Cargill becoming the first TBS Champion.

Advertisement

Ruby gave Cargill plenty, but showed little fire in her comebacks and struggled for explosiveness when attempting to chop down the giant. Such things are essential when facing a size discrepancy. Though Soho showed she wouldn't be intimidated here, she was still, theoretically, the underdog, but her offensive work was tepid compared to Thunder Rosa's opposite Jade last week.

Mercedes Martinez's attempted interference was interrupted by Rosa, who brawled her to the back. Later, Mark Sterling was ejected from ringside after screwing around on the apron. Outside involvement was therefore kept to a minimum, though Sterling's moment, in particular, felt heavy-handed.

Advertisement

Most cumbersome of all was the final minute or so, as a disruptive botch struck the match when Ruby attempted to counter Jaded into a pin attempt. Moments later, the unsteady set-up of Cargill's finisher from the second rope dealt further damage to the flow.

1. Spooky Stuff Follows Ineffective Semi-Squash

AEW

As an extended squash match, Malakai Black's defeat of Brian Pillman Jr. wasn't as emphatic or impactful as it needed to be. It's fine giving Pillman comeback spots, particularly after his featured storyline with MJF a few months ago, and that the social media video of him learning counters to Malakai's heel kick played into the story was appreciated as well. Regardless, Black needed to look like a killer coming out of this.

Advertisement

And he didn't.

Last week's Griff Garrison match was a more effective flattening with greater fire and harder-hitting work from Black. Still, at least the finish looked good, with Malakai finally landing the kick, then pinning Pillman with a knee across his throat.

Advertisement

It's the post-match that really cements this as a down, though. The Lucha Brothers came out as Black threatened to inflict further punishment on Pillman and Julia Hart. Then, the lights went out. When they came back on, the opposing sides had swapped positions: Black had gone from the ring to the ramp, and the Lucha Bros. the opposite.

One of two things happened here:-

Advertisement

1. The two sides passed each other on the ramp and somehow didn't notice the other's presence, which, despite the lights being down, is ridiculous.

2. They teleported, which is even more ridiculous.

Advertisement

We're getting borderline supernatural with Malakai's character, now, and it flies in the face of what makes AEW so great when Dynamite is firing on all cylinders. It's time to tone it down.

Ups...

4. Wardlow Keeps On Delivering

AEW

It's great, this Wardlow Powerbombing Jobbers bit, and it's really catching on with AEW crowds now, with last night's responding more positively to it than any other up to this point.

Advertisement

Wardlow's pumping of Antonio Zambrano was preceded by Shawn Spears hitting the enhancement talent with a C4 for screwing around on the outside. Firmly fed up of Spears and his bulsh*t, Wardlow scowled at first, then smiled, running through the Powerbomb routine with five repetitions this time, cementing his dominance with another win.

Spears spent this time calling for economy on the outside. Afterwards, he celebrated enthusiastically, going for a high-five that Wardlow didn't return on their way up the ramp.

Advertisement

This continues to be a strong contrast of characters and styles en route to the inevitable Wardlow face turn. He's in a great spot at the moment - and getting over too.

3. Serena Deeb Is Brilliant

AEW

It was about time AEW let Serena Deeb dive all the way into the Professor of Professional Wrestling character she perfected through social media promos while injured. They did it last night, as Jim Ross (who remains the GOAT in these scenarios) conducted a sitdown interview with the aggrieved Deeb, who gets another slice of Hikaru Shida next week.

Advertisement

Bitter, salty, and emphatic, Serena was great here. She said that all she ever wanted from Shida was civilized matches, but the former champ didn't meet here there. Shida, Deeb claims, deals in fluke victories, which Serena doesn't accept.

Deeb went through the gears as the promo progressed, amplifying her assertiveness as she claimed to have paid enough dues for everyone in the locker room. Why do they call her The Professor of Professional Wrestling? "Because I have a PHD in this sh*t." A great line.

Advertisement

This feud has done nothing but deliver in the ring so far. Next week should be no exception, and it's great to see the company giving time to a non-title program while highlighting this great, great Deeb character too.

2. CM Punk & MJF Take Shots

AEW/WWE

The WWF barbs will get most of the headlines, but the entire CM Punk/MJF deal was fire from start to finish last night.

Advertisement

MJF was supposed to flatten Shawn Dean. Punk stopped this from happening, drilling Dean with a Go 2 Sleep to trigger a disqualification that means MJF technically starts 2022 with a 0-1 record. The announcers made a big deal of this, as did Max, who bit back when Punk claimed he'd be doing the same thing every time MJF steps into the ring with him.

The duo went back and forth on each other with their usual levels of bile and spite, then delivered the big talking points. MJF, who claimed Punk needed him to keep his edge, took issue with his foe likening himself to Roddy Piper. Piper, he claimed, was good enough to headline WrestleMania, taking aim at Punk's failure to do so, then teasing his own future by suggesting he might main-event the WWE mega-show someday.

Advertisement

Punk's response?

"If you think the grass is much greener on the other side, be my guest. Go ahead, leave, main-event night four of a buy-one-get-one-free extravaganza and then get released faster than you last hit the sack. When you come back, I'll still be here and that *ss-kicking will be waiting for you."

MJF teased relenting, doing a phenomenal job of building the crowd up to think they were going to get what they want. Then, like a pro, he dropped the bomb. CM Punk wrestles Wardlow next week.

Advertisement

Another body for MJF to hide behind - and another hurdle for Punk to leap over.

It's a phenomenal storyline, and so was the segment. Informed by Punk's AEW run to date and true to both characters, it's as real and believable as modern pro wrestling gets.

Advertisement

1. Page vs. Danielson II: A Perfect Sequel

AEW/Scott Lesh

Bryan Danielson and 'Hangman' Adam Page couldn't have done a better job of delivering a second match that was cut from the same cloth as their sensational first outing, but sufficiently different, making it a clear, perfect progression.

Advertisement

Their first match went 60 minutes. This one? 29. This is primarily down to the difference in intensity. Danielson and Page working another hour-long match at this clip wouldn't have been believable. While the first wasn't exactly lacking vigour, the sequel took it to the next level. A knockdown, brutal, attritional fight, it was soaked in claret as both men were busted open, with the wrestlers' increased urgency established when Hangman went for the Buckshot Lariat within the first minute or so.

The Buckshot was key to the story. It took Page 60 minutes to hit Danielson with it the first time, leading, surely, to the pinfall. But the time limit elapsed. Here, Page identified it as the key to victory, going for it on several occasions, while Bryan attempted to nullify its impact by working Page's arm over. Bryan knew that the Buckshot meant doom for him - so he tried to take it away from him.

Advertisement

When Page was busted open, Danielson focused on the wound instead. He dropped Hangman face-first and hammered away on it with cruel blows, but was eventually hoisted from his own petard. When attempting to recreate the grim brutality of Nigel McGuinness' skull being pulled into the ring post in their ROH Unified 2006 classic, Danielson was scouted. He became Nigel as Page brutally yanked him into the steel - and Page became Danielson.

Bloodloss-induced exhaustion came into play as the match progressed. Bursts of energy and fire became more precious, and a tough, gruelling struggle that was somehow twice as exhausting as the first (despite being twice the length) concluded, as it should have, via Buckshot Lariat.

Advertisement

Page retained following a sensational World Title match, and an early clubhouse leader for Match of the Year 2021. The first bout was the making of him as AEW World Champion. Here, both he and Danielson demonstrated clear growth, building on what they'd learned in their first encounter, with Page evidently learning a bigger lesson than his opponent.