4 Ups & 4 Downs From Last Night's WWE NXT (Nov 18)

[AIR RAID SIREN] Oh god, Eva Marie's getting pushed!!

By Adam Blampied /

Yes, nothing else in your tiny life matters now. We are on the brink of the End Times. The seas are boiling, the clouds are weeping blood and all the birds have gone mental. Eva Marie's going for the title. Hug your loved ones. As boos rained from on high, All Red Everything announced her candidacy for a title shot, thereby making everything else that happened last night seem small and trivial in comparison. This is a shame, because it was solid, if unspectacular night at Full Sail: Bayley retained her belt in a match that was pretty good, if several notches below Bayley/Sasha in terms of quality, Gable and Jordan knocked off the Ascension, and Nia Jax ran through a game Carmella. Last night's card (w/finishes): Carmella vs Nia Jax Jax drops the leg on Carmella for the pin. The Ascension vs Gable & Jordan Gable pins Viktor after the Grand Amplitude. Emma vs Mary Kate Emma submits Mary Kate to the Emma Lock. Dawson & Wilder vs Hollis & Skyler Dawson pins Skyler after hitting the Shatter Machine. Bayley vs Alexa Bliss - NXT Women's Championship Match Bayley hits Bliss with a Bayley to Belly for the 1-2-3.

Downs...

4. Brooke vs Asuka 2

Give the people what they want, WWE. The people have a fever, and the only cure ... is more Dana Brooke. Now, I was a fan of Asuka chewing through Dana Brooke like a tapas platter, everyone was. There's a genuine, visceral catharsis to watching an annoying wrestler getting their arse stomped all the way in, but does anyone really want to see Asuka tangle with Brooke and Emma for any longer than is necessary? Last night, while Tom Phillips was conducting a strange interview with a masked Asuka, Dana appeared and (in as wooden a voice as she could manage) challenged Asuka for round 2. Cue legions of fans going "...really? Well ... ok I guess." Now, Brooke is getting better in the ring. In fact, she's probably learning a lot from sparring with as canny a ring veteran as Asuka, but this program really feels done. Brooke's passionless delivery doesn't help matters. Emma is good, Asuka is great, and Brooke is on the verge of ok, so chances are that what unfolds, from an in-ring perspective, won't be terrible, but Asuka deserves more than just knocking around Brooke and Emma for a few more weeks.

3. Underwhelming Promo for Alexa/Bayley

Full credit to WWE for attempting to make the Bayley/Bliss feud feel important, but shame about the execution. The WWE video editing department have long been the MVPs of the company, conjuring momentum and excitement every single month, often fashioning a gourmet meal out of mouldy ingredients. Alas, they couldn't quite pull it off here. Simply put, the feud between the two women never reached fever pitch. There was some belt-snatching, some scampering, and some mean words, but other than that, very little for the editors to work with. If anything, the feud would have seemed more legitimate had WWE just left well enough alone and not tried to make it a grander spectacle than it actually was. It was a filler feud, and that's fine. No one in their wildest dreams thought that Bliss could ever dethrone Bayley. This isn't to say that it was wrong for the producers to make an attempt at hype, but nothing about the shenanigans between the two ladies suggested that a grand video package was wanted or even needed.

2. Joe And His Shirt

The hot feud of the moment is Samoa Joe challenging Finn Balor for his NXT title, after turning heel and attacking him a few weeks back. The feud has betrayal, ambition and in-ring credentials for days, which makes it doubly painful that the only glimpse of either man this week was Joe giving an interview in a mundane outdoors location, wearing a lime green polo shirt. After all, nothing says submission machine like a buttoned-up, pastel-coloured reebok number. This was a weird choice. I get that not every week can prominently feature every storyline (in fact, not over-exposing stars is part of NXT's charm) but this interview was just so strange in its mundanity, that it let quite a bit of air out of the feud's tires. The company could have spent their editing budget here instead, perhaps with a hard-hitting retrospective of Joe's career, and all of his most vicious moves. But no. Instead, he rocked the lime tee. Thrilling stuff.

1. Alexa Deserved more

Alexa Bliss had a TOUGH job going into this match. Bayley's last feud with Sasha Banks was monumental. After all, everything that the Four Horsewomen did in NXT throughout 2015 turned to gold, and the Bayley/Banks feud was the zenith of their work. It was a perfect storm of first-time-ever excitment, media attention, and two astonishing workers. Then Sasha left for her permanent home on the main roster, leaving Bayley behind to accept new challengers, who could only try to top her last dance partner. And yes, Alexa Bliss is no Sasha Banks, but considering the inevitable comparisons, Bliss acquitted herself very well, working a less physically co-ordinated but still psychologically-sound match, targeting Bayley's hand throughout and telling a great story with her facial expressions. What a shame then that not only did Bayley abruptly end the match with a SuperCena-esque finishing move out of nowhere for the win - undoing all of Bliss's work - but as soon as the match was over, Alexa was no where to be seen. She didn't get a good final shot on camera and her work in the match was immediately overshadowed by the entrance of Eva Marie. She should be rightfully Blissed off at that.

Ups...

4. The Bizarre But Fascinating Push Of Eva Marie

I struggled with this one, I really, really did. I flip-flopped for ages, deliberating whether Eva Marie's push despite an astonishingly negative reaction from the fans belonged at the top of the Downs pile or the bottom of the Ups. In the end, this is what I chose, because it's just so compellingly weird. Last night, as soon as Bayley was done seeing off Alexa Bliss, Eva's music hit and All Popularity Everything descended to the stage amid howls of derision from fans. Then she tried to cut a promo. Let's see how that went: https://youtu.be/w2-B2R2VsPg?t=115 Wow. Lynch mobs are more measured than that crowd. So why is it on the Ups part of the list? Well, isn't it just so fascinating? I haven't seen a crowd reaction this vocal in years. It's kind of amazing, and there's a despicable part of me that wants to see what happens if they put the belt on Eva Marie. It's schadenfreude at its worst, but you have to admit that you want to see how nuclear this heat can get. Also, I loved it when she called them "dorks". That was really funny. It's hard to tell which fans are buying into Eva's entitled botcher angle and are booing because that's servicing the story in an entertaining way, and which fans just hate her and want her to go away forever, and that blurred line is just so compelling. I'm looking forward to next week, what else can I say?

3. Solid Destruction From Dawson & Wilder

Hot off their dominant victory over The Vaudevillains last week, Dawson & Wilder ran through a team of hapless jobbers in a solid furtherance of their 'No Flips, Just Fists' gimmick. The two roughneck, old-school bruisers crushed their competition in smart, logical fashion: work a body part for a while, and if that fails hit them with the double finisher. Is it hipster to like Dawson & Wilder? Their wrestling style was the mainstream model for many decades, made famous by teams like The Minnesota Wrecking Crew & The Horsemen. It was so much the norm that the more acrobatic style propagated by young high flyers emerged as an alternative to it. But now that style has become so popular that the bruiser style has emerged as the alternative to that, as an almost ironic affectation. That's really odd, and makes my brain hurt a bit. Still, there's no doubt that the so-old-it's-new approach is working gangbusters for Dawson and Wilder right now. As long as they remain strategic in approach and focused in attack, their anti-charisma charisma should carry them to a permanent place at the top of the NXT tag division.

2. The Ascension + Gable & Jordan = Success

Speaking of future tag team elite, Gable & Jordan have been the hottest young prospects for a while now. For the last month, they've consistently put on the match of the night, whether it was their showing against Baron Corbin and Rhyno at TakeOver Respect, their astonishingly good match against Ciampa and Gargano, or last night's offering: a stellar bout against NXT royalty, The Ascension. Konnor and Viktor returned to the land they once ruled to put over Gable & Jordan, and what a sweet homecoming it was. Partially born of parental pride, and partially of anger at how dreadfully The Ascension have been booked on the main roster, the NXT universe welcomed the two men with a rapturous ovation. Almost every strike was greeted with a loud 'Ja' from the crowd, and considering that they've also lost none of their love for the World's Greatest Tag Team Tribute Band, the NXT crowd were electric throughout. It's time for me to eat some humble pie now. Last week, I called the Ascension rubbish and that they almost deserved the treatment they were getting on Raw and Smackdown. Well, they proved me wrong last night. This was the best The Ascension has been in well over a year. Every move they made was crisper, and had more passion behind it. They ran faster and jumped higher. Against any team other than Gable and Jordan, they would have been dominant fan favourites, but G&J would not be denied. It was a stellar encounter. The Ascension should stay. Don't go, boys, not back to the main roster. There's nothing for you there.

1. Last Night Belonged To The Women

Most of the Horsewomen may be gone, but NXT sure ain't finished with the Women's Division. The ladies of NXT dominated last night. 3 of the 5 matches were Women's matches, there was a video package for Bayley and Alexa, individual backstage promos from the two women, a segment with Emma, Dana and Asuka, AND the Championship match closed the night. And I don't think there was a single mention of the word, "Revolution." NXT has quietly re-balanced the scales so much that a card made up of 3/5 women's matches didn't feel in any way like a huge shift. It was not a publicity stunt, a transparent attempt at injecting artificial importance into women's wrestling (hello there, Paige and Charlotte), it was simply another week at the office. Brilliant.