4 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Backlash 2025 (Results & Review)

Cena's "ruin wrestling" tour drags down latest PLE while Lynch, Valkyria shine.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE

For the second WWE PLE in a row, John Cena’s quest to “ruin wrestling” sunk a show that would have been more highly regarded if you could fly in a typical Cody Rhodes world title defense.

Advertisement

Backlash wasn’t a bad show by most metrics, but the final act of the five-match event was embarrassingly bad – and long – thus negating any goodwill that had built up in the hours prior. Regardless of WWE’s revisionist history of their rivalry, Cena versus Randy Orton never was going to be a classic, but it apparently was too much to ask for them to have even a passable main event title match without utilizing booking shortcuts galore.

By far, the best effort on the show came from the women, with Becky Lynch and Lyra Valkyria wrestling a really good “mentor versus mentee” match that should silence The Man’s critics about her role in WWE these days while elevating the Women’s Intercontinental Champion.

The rest of the card was mostly inoffensive, but it also wasn’t consequential. Post-WrestleMania PLEs often run the risk of being meaningless, but WWE had compensated in recent years by doing shows in underserved, white-hot locales (Puerto Rico and France) with really good in-ring action.

Backlash this year was neither in an exotic venue (St. Louis), nor was the card brimming with excellent wrestling. Some fans might have come away feeling satisfied but no one should be saying they were wowed by this show.

Let’s get to it…

DOWNS…

4. Penta’s Slide

WWE

Just four months into his run with WWE, Penta has gone from a revelation “taking WWE by storm” (as Michael Cole noted), to being on the losing end of several matches and becoming another guy with a really cool entrance.

Penta lost an Intercontinental Championship match to Dominik Mysterio at Backlash, which wasn’t a big surprise – Dirty Dom wasn’t going to lose the title this soon. Sure, they protected Penta by having the entire Judgment Day and El Grade Americano interfere to thwart the masked luchador, but it’s not going to lead to Penta getting his revenge on everyone and capturing the title.

Instead, he most likely will transition to feuding with a masked Chad Gable, which might produce really good matches but ultimately will only serve to shunt Penta further down the card. The singles run that started with some surprising promise is very quickly reaching the point where smart fans are asking, “When are they getting the Lucha Bros together?”

It’s a shame, really. Penta came into WWE on fire and they burned it out before WrestleMania. After this past month, he doesn’t feel like he’s going to progress beyond a certain point as a singles competitor. This isn’t doom and gloom – Lucha Bros could dominate the tag scene – but it’s disappointing (though not surprising) to see how he’s become “just a guy” as a singles wrestler so quickly.

3. McAfee Hangs Around

WWE

There will be some praise for the sideshow match on the Backlash card, but first we have to get some criticism out of the way.

Yes, Gunther toyed with Pat McAfee throughout the match and never really was in danger of losing, but this ran completely counter to the message that the Ring General delivered just five days earlier on Raw. Gunther said he was going to maul McAfee and would need to be pried off the announcer’s limp body.

Instead, the former World Heavyweight Champion spent the majority of the match allowing Pat to take swings (and chops) at him and then tormented Michael Cole, all of which allowed McAfee to get back into the match and score a couple hope spots. A match that easily should have been a sub-10-minute sideshow lasted for 14 minutes.

Cole getting involved in the match – first as a ringside cheerleader and later by grabbing Gunther’s foot ala Bobby Heenan and Ultimate Warrior – has to have consequences. There’s no way an announcer coming off the desk like that should be brushed aside, even in storyline. Put him on probation or something silly, but not acknowledging it was wrong would be dumb storytelling by omission.

Finally, McAfee lasting as long as he did in Gunther’s sleeper was ridiculous when you consider how quickly established wrestlers have tapped/passed out in that hold. It’s understandable that WWE wanted to portray McAfee as capable and heroic, but going toe-to-toe in a chop battle with Gunther and then flailing and fighting in a sleeper for a solid minute? Come on.

This should have been a mugging, with Gunther chopping McAfee until his chest was hamburger, Pat landing a lucky blow and jumping on his one opportunity, and then Gunther slamming the door shut, with Cole begging him to end the match until the Ring General finally finished him. A crisp seven minutes would have worked just fine.

2. ‘THE Rivalry’

WWE

To hear WWE tell the story this past month, John Cena versus Randy Orton is a storied rivalry that has defined wrestling for the past 25 years.

And honestly, the company can be excused for leaning into the history between the two future Hall-of-Famers. They have 31 world title reigns between them and have battled each other 23 times in televised singles bouts through the years (and an additional 69 times in multi-man and tag matches).

But their rivalry simply hasn’t been that good. They don’t have a tremendous amount of chemistry together; they’re certainly not wrestling soulmates. Too many of their matches have been snoozers, and showing clips of previous bouts only reminded longtime fans just how bad some of these contests were.

However, they’ve only had one singles match in the past decade, so a significant portion of the current WWE fandom likely has only seen those highlights rather than the entire matches and boring promos that longtime fans experienced. The problem is that then WWE tossed out that match at Backlash, thus rendering all the hype moot.

Even if fans bought into the “storied rivalry” aspect of the match, many had to be groaning by the end of that debacle and wondering whether Cena/Orton was as good as WWE sold it.

1. Ruining Wrestling

WWE

When John Cena started on his path down this heel run, he proclaimed that his goal was to “ruin wrestling.”

He might have said that he was going to accomplish this by retiring with the Undisputed WWE Championship and breaking its lineage, but Cena also must have meant that he was going to ruin wrestling by competing in the worst, more horribly overbooked championship matches seen on North American television in years.

Cena’s title match against Randy Orton wasn’t just bad; it was comically terrible, with a pace that made “methodical” look rushed at times and a ref bump that lasted longer than the Intercontinental Championship match earlier in the night.

The first half of the match leaned heavily on staredowns, stalling, punches, headlocks and sleeper holds. They segued into a blitz of signature moves, followed by Cena and Orton spamming finishers to artificially juice the crowd. Just when it couldn’t get more predictable, we got the referee bump, which inexplicably led to Orton RKO’ing an entire slate of backstage officials, followed by an R-Truth run-in, and Cena delivering a low blow and title shot to pick up the pin (as the ref finally revived to count the fall).

Unless they are trying to produce some kind of performance art with deliberately bad matches as part of Cena’s “ruin wrestling” mantra, this is unsustainable in the long term. Cena’s WrestleMania 41 main event against Cody Rhodes was universally panned, and while the Backlash match against Orton didn’t feature Travis Scott making a five-minute entrance, it still was a similarly overbooked, terrible mess.

No one was expecting a classic match here, but if this is the new normal for these Cena matches, it’s going to be a brutal main event scene in 2025 and a black hole of suck for everyone involved. Something is going to need to change, and fast.

UPS…

4. Another Bloodline Twist

WWE

Just when fans thought that the Bloodline saga was done and dusted, WWE found another way to pump some life into it.

During the United States Championship four-way match, Solo Sikoa inserted himself into the situation by saving Jacob Fatu from LA Knight, drawing the Megastar straight into an attack from Jeff Cobb, who proceeded to demolish Knight outside the ring. This allowed Fatu to pick the bones and finish Knight off with a hip attack and moonsault and retain his US title.

Cobb joining Solo’s version of the Bloodline is a nice little twist, with Fatu saying he didn’t want help but getting it nonetheless. With both Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa on the shelf, Sikoa was going to need some backup for when Jacob eventually turns on him, and Cobb provides that muscle. In the short term, a trio of Solo, Cobb and Fatu is a pretty intimidating group.

Cobb looked good here in his WWE debut, and he now has a ready-made feud with Knight and is associated with one of the company’s biggest rising stars in Fatu. That’s not a bad first night on the job.

3. The Right Result

WWE

For all the criticism leveled at Gunther versus Pat McAfee, there was one aspect that WWE got correct about the match and feud: the tone.

Gunther is flailing after losing a title for the second WrestleMania in a row. He’s underestimated Sami Zayn and now Jey Uso and paid the price on wrestling’s biggest stage. He can call himself the Ring General and back it up 364 days a year, but on that one night the past two years, he’s fallen short.

Rather than go after Jey to reclaim his title, Gunther has chosen to lash out at Raw’s announcers for pointing out that he tapped out and has struggled at Mania. All of that fed into Saturday’s match against McAfee.

The crowd chanting, “You tapped out” certainly didn’t help matters for Gunther, and neither did Michael Cole standing at the desk and yelling, and then going to ringside to cheerlead for McAfee. There’s an easy argument that Gunther should not have allowed McAfee to hang around, but the former world champion still hasn’t learned humility from his defeat. Instead, his arrogance shined through.

Hopefully, this little side quest is now over and Gunther can move on to more traditional wrestling matches. Hopefully, WWE is not going to have him doing sideshow bouts forever (though recent reports about Goldberg make one wonder).

2. Dominik Shows Out

WWE

Dominik Mysterio has been a guilty pleasure for WWE fans for quite some time now, but he has slowly and sneakily getting better in the ways that could make him more of a mainstay after this Judgment Day run eventually ends.

Mysterio’s Intercontinental Championship match against Penta Saturday provided glimpses of that future, with Dirty Dom turning in one of his better singles performances to date. He matched Penta with running headscissors, nailed a diving tornado DDT to the floor and kept pace with his challenger throughout the contest. Dominik also survived a Mexican Destroyer on the apron before picking up the completely clean win.

Obviously, that’s nowhere near true, as the entire Judgment Day and El Grande Americano interfered on Dom’s behalf to put Penta away. Still, Mysterio held his own here and this was a perfectly fine, fun little match.

1. Lynch, Valkyria Deliver

WWE

At some point, the wider wrestling universe needs to have a conversation about Becky Lynch and her contributions to the industry these past few years. Arguably one of the biggest figures of the past decade, she has repeatedly used her star power to elevate other wrestlers, and Saturday night was no exception.

Lynch challenged Lyra Valkyria for her Women’s Intercontinental Championship at Backlash, trying to wrest the title from her former mentee but failing to get the job done. Lyra immediately outwrestled Becky from the jump and constantly had answers for Lynch’s best offense. She escaped a Bexploder and a Disarm-Her, countered multiple Manhandle Slam attempts (and kicked out of others), and repeatedly frustrated The Man.

The finish looked a bit janky, with Valkyria grabbing a rollup almost immediately after it looked like Becky might have inadvertently broken Lyra’s nose. Still, the story of the match, with the student outclassing the teacher, was on full display here. Becky showed a fair amount of tail in losing cleanly, and it wasn’t like Lyra “escaped” with the win either.

What’s more important is that Valkyria has managed to get herself over on the strength of her matches, not her character. This feud with Becky increased fans’ connection with Lyra’s character the past couple weeks, and then they delivered in the ring on Saturday, rallying the fans behind the champ. Really solid stuff overall.

Advertisement