4 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (June 11)

Cesaro returns; WWE get very last-minute before Hell In A Cell; SmackDown's undercard sags.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

SmackDown's writers are lucky they have stars the quality of Roman Reigns and Rey Mysterio who can pull the nose up on shoddy booking. They really, really are, because shoving some random combo together for a hasty Hell In A Cell match could've been disastrous for the brand and next Sunday's pay-per-view.

Advertisement

As it is, booking Roman like an afterthought is worrying.

Are WWE running out of decent scenarios for the 'Tribal Chief'? In the short term, yes, although it is obvious that Reigns is still enjoying himself and capable of riding this out. Plus, it's not like he and Mysterio will disappoint in-ring come HIAC - it's just...well, they don't have a feud worthy of being locked inside that once-peerless gimmick.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, SmackDown was decidedly mediocre. There are some fun things happening in the tag division (albeit without the champs being involved, which is weird), and Cesaro returned with a vengeance, but the undercard could use some inspiration overall. Interest in the women's division is also evaporating at a quite alarming rate too.

Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from Friday's latest...

Advertisement

Downs...

4. 50/50

WWE.com

"Interest in the women's division is also evaporating at a quite alarming rate too".

Advertisement

This is indicative of that. Carmella beat Liv Morgan last week, which raised concerns about how the ex-Riott Squad member would fare without Ruby. Then, typically, WWE reversed things and put Liv over in a rematch on Friday night. What was the point, and where is this going?

Trading wins won't get either of these women over. It's too wishy-washy, and one win apiece has kept 'Mella and Morgan firmly at the bottom of the discussion for title shots. After all, if they're struggling to beat each other, then why should fans believe either could topple Bianca Belair? It's problematic.

Advertisement

The pair aren't even meshing anyway - both bouts have suffered from the same problems, and they're fairly boring despite the shorter length. That's not a great sign, especially if WWE hope to turn this into a full-blown feud eventually.

3. She Just…Laughed

WWE.com

Last week, Bayley and Bianca Belair offset crummy booking by injecting their feud with some personality. The former acknowledged how much fun she has annoying the latter, and WWE got creative with the ThunderDome screens. That was fine, but their latest work was a step backwards.

Advertisement

Make that two steps backwards.

Belair appeared on the ramp after Bayley's 'Ding Dong, Hello' skit with Seth Rollins went awry (more on that later) and...laughed. Then, she laughed some more. And some more. And, well, you get the picture. Seriously, what the f*ck was this all about? Following Cesaro's intense beatdown with Bianca cackling sucked.

Advertisement

Besides, Belair shouldn't be on some crusade to give Bayley some of her own medicine here; the champ should be more concerned with beating her challenger in a match at Hell In A Cell and proving why she was a hot ticket after WrestleMania 37.

This was a quite rubbish misuse of both women.

Advertisement

2. ‘Battle For The Crown’

WWE.com

So, WWE's creative team think a fifth match between 'King' Corbin and Shinsuke Nakamura is the way to go. Colour this guy unimpressed. Like Carmella and Liv Morgan, Shin and Corbin aren't even having good matches to make up for the lame crown-stealing sideshow that stopped being mildly entertaining weeks ago.

Advertisement

At least they're not sticking that crown on a pole. Yet.

SmackDown's scriptwriters still haven't really explained why viewers should give a toss about the air-guitar-loving Rick Boogs, or even why he's suddenly become top mates with Nakamura. Also, Shinsuke is actually coming across as more of a heel than Corbin, and that says it all right there.

Advertisement

Don't be totally shocked if next week's show features a screwy finish that leads to yet another bout between these men at Hell In A Cell. F*ck it - just put them in the cage. It's not like any of this year's other Cell bouts actually belong in there anyway.

1. Rather Last-Minute

WWE.com

Speaking of...

Advertisement

Again, as mentioned in the intro, Rey Mysterio and Roman Reigns are only guilty of doing their best with some very last-minute storytelling. It's like WWE suddenly realised they needed a pay-per-view match for the Universal Champ, panicked, didn't want to plough through a bout with Jimmy Uso and plucked Rey out of nowhere.

Mysterio's promo work was good, but he should be defending the SmackDown Tag Titles with his son and furthering that story. Instead, he's working random-ass HIAC matches and being asked to punish his body when everybody knows that this mini-feud will be forgotten about by Money In The Bank.

Advertisement

As good as Reigns vs. Rey will be bell-to-bell, fans shouldn't give WWE a pass here. They could've given Roman a pay-per-view off and booked this as a TV rivalry in the short-term. Alas, no, he and Mysterio are expected to work miracles and promote a Cell encounter at short notice.

Ups...

4. A-List Alphas

WWE.com

Worse, WWE can't even claim that they don't have worthy challengers for Rey and Dominik in the tag-team scene. Both The Street Profits (if they're up for some babyface vs. babyface interim stuff) and Alpha Academy (if they'd rather have something more substantial) would work as rivals for the father/son duo.

Advertisement

They're proving it with their own feud.

Otis and Chad Gable have clicked as a unit, and Gable vs. Montez Ford was a neat little match that's worth checking out for the first few minutes alone. Sure, Otis appeared to be late coming out for the finish, but then he wrecked shop and redeemed himself by looking like an absolute killer during that injury stuff with Ford.

Advertisement

This was a great piece of business overall. WWE managed to extend the feud without a proper tag-team match, and they're one step closer to establishing the Alphas as a credible enough threat to the reigning champions. More of this booking, please.

3. Commander > Conspiracy Theorist

WWE.com

Admittedly, there isn't much of note going on in the Intercontinental Title scene. Apollo Crews is still champ, but neither Big E or Kevin Owens work as opponents for him anymore - even so, one can't deny the quality of that trio's tag match alongside Sami Zayn on this week's show.

Advertisement

It was predictably good.

Crews then blaming Zayn for the loss and challenging the E/Owens combo to a rematch next week also works well. Next time, Apollo wants the imposing Commander Azeez by his side rather than Sami. That efficiently furthers Zayn's conspiracy theory character and buys WWE some time to come up with a new challenger for Crews.

Advertisement

Being honest though, they should've have any of this on next week's pay-per-view. Crews vs. E or KO is played out, and Apollo vs. Sami doesn't feel right. Hopefully, WWE have somebody else in mind for the champ going forwards before Money In The Bank.

2. Take The Power Back

WWE

Nobody in WWE does backstage segments like Roman Reigns.

Advertisement

SmackDown's top dog laces his bits with so much character. He's even great when he isn't saying a word, and he knows when to shut up and let others have the floor. This week, after Jimmy Uso cut a stronger-than-expected in-ring promo, Roman tried to wrestle some slipping influence back over Jey.

Interestingly, Jimmy called himself Jey's keeper, which is something worth keeping tabs on as the story develops more. Is Jim positioning himself as someone who can replace Reigns as his sibling's overlord, or was this just a throwaway phrase?

Advertisement

The fact anyone is questioning that in the first place is positive.

Later, Roman was irked when Jey told him to go find Jimmy himself. WWE are sprinkling in some subtle rebellion to this one that suggest Jimmy will be successful in his bid to steal back the power. Literally everybody involved is playing this to perfection.

Advertisement

1. Cesaro’s Comeback

WWE.com

Praise the lord that Bayley's 'Ding Dong, Hello' chat with Seth Rollins actually went somewhere. Everyone must've been worried when the pair started laughing in stereo, but that was a false flag before Cesaro's big comeback and beatdown of Seth.

Advertisement

Yours truly could watch these guys wrestle every month and it wouldn't bother him. They're that good together, and there's more to come. OK, so maybe the segment didn't need the old trouser-less heel getting bounced around trope, but that's the most minor of minor complaints.

Cesaro looked like a star yet again.

Advertisement

If WWE could only resist the urge to put those little splashes of ill-needed comedy in, then maybe they'd be able to properly put together a must-see card for Hell In A Cell. Despite that annoying foible, they do have something to work with between Rollins and Cesaro.

They'll have another belter if it's on the HIAC line up next week.

Advertisement

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 6 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (June 4) and 10 Annoying Traits That Are RUINING WWE Characters!