4 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite (15 Feb - Review)

MJF, Mark Briscoe and Wardlow elevate an otherwise flat and lifeless two hours.

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

It was imperative that AEW really started to sell fans on the Revolution card last night, and not merely because some fans think WWE invented the concept of telling stories in the latest chapter of a demented culture war.

Advertisement

AEW should be critiqued on its own terms, and while the promotion is telling stories - what an asinine and deranged thing it is to suggest that Tony Khan isn't - only one is truly connecting with the base to the expected standard.

Mooted attractions for the pay-per-view make it feel uninspired and rematch-heavy. Samoa Joe Vs. Wardlow was difficult to care about before Darby Allin's awesome sprint of a TNT title run killed it by comparison. The women's division feels like a "Fed bad" Jericho Appreciation Society Vs. Blackpool Combat Club retread hinged almost entirely on where Saraya and Toni Storm used to work.

Advertisement

It isn't, to paraphrase the late, great Jerry Jarrett, a personal issue that will draw any money.

Despite an incredible spree of action-heavy shows, it has felt as though a lot of material is waiting to "click". Eddie Kingston has never felt less credible. Chris Jericho has never felt more tedious. What are the Elite - usually very dependable and creative storytellers - doing?

Advertisement

Did that feeling persist last night...?

Downs...

5. Opener Sets Inessential Tone

AEW

The Acclaimed, Daddy Ass and Orange Cassidy Vs. Jeff Jarrett, Jay Lethal, Satnam Singh and Sonjay Dutt was a house show match promoted when AEW needed to unleash its prime episodic TV form.

Advertisement

In and of itself, the opener was a fun enough match for which your mileage will vary (subjectively, there's been a lot of zany material on TV of late, and it's growing a bit thin). The problem is that, combined with a card bereft of real anticipation and quality, and a poorly attended arena that the production crew could not hide, the match set a suboptimal tone. AEW - with Revolution really not too far away at this point - felt like the irreverent, distant number two promotion. There was a hard-to-place smugness about this.

AEW, once the most well-booked promotion on the planet, is losing the battle of perception - and this cutesy opener felt like it was sneering at the critics and not showing them up. Elements of it were fun - how could you not guffaw at the sight of Satnam Singh doing the Jarrett strut on the apron? - and Jarrett himself did well to get through it, God love him. But it was a piss about when the show needed to get serious about making you pay $50.

Advertisement

The finish felt like the US adaptation of the Snowman, edited to remove the heft from last week.

The Acclaimed: they're OK, folks!

Advertisement

They'll be right back.

4. A Well-Booked But Flat Return

AEW

The lack of energy in the crowd was such that it's difficult not to damn even the good moments with faint praise. Looking at the card in advance, you can permit their lack of enthusiasm.

Advertisement

Jungle Boy Vs. Brian Cage was only solid.

The action was decent if entirely unremarkable, and this is another area in which Tony Khan could improve. He becomes periodically obsessed with designating a certain heel as the wrestler who, for weeks on end, eats pins to get multiple babyfaces over.

Advertisement

For a while in 2021, Bobby Fish played that role. Then, for a long time, Jay Lethal replaced him on the spreadsheet. Now, it's Brian Cage's job. The man has lost so often recently that it is impossible to take him seriously, and what's worse is that, while talented, he is an extremely one-dimensional performer. There's only one Brian Cage match, and the audience has watched one too many of late. This was AEW at its predictable, functional, uninspiring worst - until the post-match angle.

Sadly, it barely landed.

Advertisement

Christian Cage has returned, and like the great heel he is, burned Jack Perry's eyes with mace before revealing that his arm has healed. Babyface pursued gold, but was cruelly distracted from goal by arch-rival is the most pleasing means of pivoting to a grudge programme, but this crowd barely cared. The card was weak, almost an insult compared to previous weeks, which might explain things.

That, or the Cage Vs. Perry feud peaked a while back and feels more like a narrative obligation they can't not do than a huge, heated story.

Advertisement

3. Doing Nothing For Nobody

AEW

Tony Khan is usually a strong matchmaker even when his big, long-term stories lack their signature heft, which made Hangman Page Vs. Kip Sabian all the more puzzling. Khan knew it wasn't a hot nor competitive attraction, and thus booked Kip to lay Page out earlier in the show, but that was never going to work.

Advertisement

It wasn't so much a heat angle as an acknowledgement that this match was a poor idea for which suspension of disbelief was impossible.

The match itself was neither nothing nor something. Page proved nothing in winning, Kip showed nothing in losing, and the drama and excitement was minimal. Nobody was actively hurt by it - an off week never matters - but this was a waste of time.

Advertisement

It's obvious that Khan has a soft spot for Kip, who in his defence did very well against Orange Cassidy, but it's obvious to everyone else that he's not a player under this exaggerated, cringeworthy persona.

The post-match scene, in which Moxley challenged Page to a Texas Death match at Revolution, wasn't that great, oddly. This should have sold the final, all-or-nothing chapter of a bloody, concussive war, but both Page and Mox stumbled over their words and fans - this set, anyway - seem to feel that the Page/Dark Order alliance is a selective narrative convenience than a wholesome friendship and heartfelt reunion.

Advertisement

2. "Main Event" Is A Big Self-Own

AEW

If you're going to satirise WWE, sharpen your blade.

Advertisement

The ongoing "homegrowns" versus ex-WWE imports story was advanced in a dire, contrived and heatless way last night via the Toni Storm Vs. Dr. Britt Baker Vs. Ruby Soho three-way match. If the idea is to poke fun at WWE's self-perception of superiority, then don't book a bad cliché of a WWE match; otherwise, it's humiliating.

When Ruby Soho with exaggerated sub-NXT inner conflict wasn't worried about whom to target - "anybody" is the answer; this is the wins and losses matter promotion - two women worked spots as the other took their turn to sell for far longer than they would in the singles context.

Advertisement

This was deeply contrived, and the premise was rancid. Toni Storm voluntarily left WWE because she was booked as a geek who didn't care that she was being embarrassed. Having her play the 'Stand Up For WWE" character is woefully unconvincing, and Soho wondering aloud whose side she's on felt just as fake. The finish somehow scanned as a shock to everybody else.

Soho won a match!

Advertisement

That's what she's supposed to do!

She's the only character with a credible motive, and it took her far too long to arrive at an intelligent decision. The homegrowns and the imports are both self-serving heel characters. What are we doing here?

Advertisement

This feels more like elaborate, indirect punishment booking of Miro and Andrade than a story and mystery that the fans (and indeed the characters) actually care about.

Here's something terrifying: Vince Russo booked women's wrestling better in 2007 than Tony Khan and Triple H are booking it in 2023.

Advertisement

1. A Pointless Segment

AEW

A very quick note here on a segment that was probably too inoffensive to warrant an 'Up' or a 'Down' in and of itself - but this was a flat and boring experience of a Dynamite on the whole, so the unflattering 4:5 ratio is well-earned.

Advertisement

Adam Cole's sit-down interview with Renee Paquette was a nothing segment. It's still lovely that Cole is back, but this felt like procrastination. Nice as it was to see him smiling and in good spirits, that - another clue about his character alignment - seemed to be the entire purpose of the segment.

AEW had an opportunity here to spark conversation about Cole's in-ring return - to build anticipation ahead of it by teasing the identity of his opponent - but literally nothing happened.

Advertisement

Ups...

4. Texas Tornado: Good Brawl, But That's It

AEW

The Texas Tornado match was good without ever feeling like a tumultuous storm of action.

Advertisement

It was a hard-hitting and over contest, hence why it appears in the 'Ups' section, but it didn't approach its ceiling. AEW has a remarkable gift of crafting a sense of unbridled chaos, but that difficult magic spell was not cast here. That this ran through two commercial breaks didn't help the vibe nor the tone; it could never feel like a wild, animosity-drenched frenzy that utterly consumed the characters when the heel team had to slow it all down and pause before the final third, but in general, this wasn't close to bottling the energy of AEW's best brawls.

Blood was shed, chains were wrapped around faces, and certain sequences threatened to drag this into awesome territory - but it never really clicked into a pulsating squelcher of a fight. At times, it tried much too hard to feel like a war. Jon Moxley kicking out of a punch with chain wrapped around Vance's fist might have worked, but the moment was much too rushed. It didn't approach feeling like a shock result. The shot itself wasn't registered well enough for dramatic effect, and the near-fall did not feel last-gasp.

Advertisement

Not the best night for Preston Vance, who had shown promise in the heel role. Weirdly, given his immense size, he's far more convincing at taking a beating than distributing one.

3. Let It Play Out

AEW

On a night on which Revolution badly needed some juice, a cold programme was heated up unexpectedly. The trust that AEW will eventually deliver, and that you need to let things play out, felt crucial.

Advertisement

In an earnest sit-down interview, the meaning behind Samoa Joe cutting off Wardlow's top knot was revealed. Wardlow, who badly needed character development and was humanised here, talked of his complex relationship with his father. He wasn't always there for him, and just as Wardlow embarked on his wrestling career, his father passed from stage four cancer. Wardlow grew his hair out in tribute, and he shared that story with Samoa Joe when they teamed together. Joe knew exactly what he was doing, and to great dramatic effect, via this delayed revelation, the audience knows too.

The plotting here was superb; had we known about this tribute before Joe cut his hair off, it would have felt contrived and cheap. Instead, the pathos elicited here was so effective. At its best, AEW can draw pathos from an out-of-date hairstyle.

Advertisement

That's the expected standard.

2. Mark Briscoe Is A Treasure

AEW

Mark Briscoe's match with Josh Woods was a very good bit of business.

Advertisement

An establishing victory more than an electrifying back-and-forth, that will come later. This was a nice, well-received match that sets Briscoe on his journey. His instant hit of a character is a fish out of water, and the land is the wacky confines of North American wrestling TV. This follow-up to his hilarious Rampage debut was just as charming.

Briscoe is so much more intelligent than he lets on. He doesn't want to dull the charming brilliance of his backwoods fool act, but he's very savvy. He knew immediately that Smart Mark Sterling was full of sh*t, but was nice enough to be nice. He couldn't not do the Jay Driller in the wonderful Jay Briscoe tribute match opposite Jay Lethal - that was the perfect finish - but he only teased it here, and finished Woods off with the Froggy Bow. When he hits the Jay Driller again, it will really mean something.

Advertisement

Over big already, and so entertaining that he had Taz in stitches, AEW has a new cult hero - and it's impossible not to fall in love with him.

1. Another Great Week For MJF

AEW

For further evidence of MJF's brilliance, seek out the Fite feed of his appearance.

Advertisement

Cut from TBS, which went to commercial as he made his entrance, MJF threw his gum on a fan's face. He then feigned to take a selfie with another before throwing their phone to the ground. Then, after throwing a drink in someone's face, he called the lot of them fat pieces of sh*t and savaged the state of Texas for its antique abortion laws (while simultaneously wishing every child in the audience had undergone the procedure). When Dynamite returned from the break, he was showered with jeers.

In his televised promo, the thin-skinned, self-loathing supervillain from the CM Punk feud surfaced. He was better than Bryan Danielson, and paid off Christopher Daniels to make that "fact" a matter of public record. Daniels was having none of it; he put the money away, and in a great promo, put over the talent and man that Bryan is, and MJF could never be.

Advertisement

This infuriated MJF, who kicked him in the balls to summon the Dragon. MJF bailed - the last physical interaction should be saved, if it needs to happen at all - and the feud was advanced in a meaningful, heated way.

AEW has actually told a long-term story with MJF that has spanned almost four years, if we're counting now. MJF, and this is so effective, is such a piece of sh*t that the entire institution can't stand him. Tony Schiavone breaks his impartial role to bury MJF, Paul Turner allowed Cody to give him a cheap shot at Revolution, and now Daniels, Head of Talent Relations, sees right through him, too.

Advertisement

It all depicts MJF as the Big Bad of AEW.