4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE NXT TakeOver: WarGames 2020

NXT's annual spotfest TakeOver labours under the weight of WarGames.

By Andy H Murray /

WWE.com

NXT's annual WarGames edition of TakeOver has suffered the same fate as the main roster's gimmick pay-per-views in that it is now just another date on the calendar rather than the organic product of a story hot enough to demand it, but the build to this year's men's match at least warranted the mega-cage.

Advertisement

Pat McAfee and Adam Cole have been at each other's throats since summer. When McAfee refused to accept his TakeOver XXX defeat, he built an army. The hatred between these sides was real, tangible, and well-played heading into the event, setting them up for a blistering main event. The women's build hadn't been as compelling, but screw it: four of the same wrestlers worked the best match of the night at last year's WarGames supercard and the division is well booked, for the most part. The ceiling was higher than the cage itself.

The presentation was on point throughout, with WWE nailing the Capitol Wrestling Center aesthetic. Sparks of pyro shot from the cage, Black Sabbath's seminal War Pigs rang through the arena, and the tight, closed-in confines created a nastily claustrophobic atmosphere. TakeOver: WarGames felt edgy, which isn't something you can often say about a modern WWE product.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the rest of the evening was largely a case of the bookers getting in the athletes' way...

Downs...

5. Marathon Night Drags Hard

WWE.com

The WWE Network runtime for TakeOver: WarGames 2020 sits at just 3:03:18 - just under 35 minutes longer than last year - but it felt at least an hour longer than that.

Advertisement

Though only five matches deep, this TakeOver dragged. Hard. There was no sense of pacing as the night shambled from one overlong bout to another, with all but perhaps the Strap Match going around 20-25% longer than needed. In the WarGames matches, crescendos were teased, built towards, and abandoned, before the cycle repeated ad nauseam. Neither match broke into a higher gear as a result of the writers and road agents shooting for "epic", resulting in a show that produced nothing even close to the word, even as wrestlers soared off cages and took crazy, career-shortening bumps.

"Too long" isn't a specific runtime, but something has been stretched beyond its natural conclusion. It is a feeling rather than a number - and therefore subjective. Still, almost everything on TakeOver: WarGames suffered from being a little too ambitious, attempting six or seven dramatic peaks when two or three would have done.

Advertisement

Three hours should never feel like a long night, particularly given the colossal lengths of WWE's pre-pandemic pay-per-views.

4. Broken Psychology

WWE.com

WWE set themselves up for WarGames failure by having the babyface teams score the numerical advantage in both matches ahead of the event, breaking the stipulation's inherent psychology.

Advertisement

The 2-on-1 pendulum should usually be swung in the heels' favour. This is pro wrestling psychology 101, and allows the villains to unfairly beat the babyfaces down before the final participant makes a big, heroic entrance, and those no-good punks finally get what's coming to them. As with any other trope, there should be room to subvert this, but WWE systematically failed to do so last night and dug their own grave by trying to be too subversive.

The women's match was largely pointless until all participants were in the ring. It was a long, unengaging series of worthless face control sequences broken, temporarily, by a new heel's arrival. WarGames is supposed to be a heat stipulation, but you can't generate heat when the alleged sympathetic parties are in total control.

Advertisement

Raquel Gonzalez could have been thrown in as the first heel: she's a monster, so having two faces work her over is believable, and she'd look like a beast by stifling both, leading to Rhea Ripley entering to nullify her. Alas, WWE went with a less compelling option. Later, they tried to dig out of their own psychological mess by delaying Io Shirai's entrance, succeeding only in making their Women's Champion look like a dope.

WWE got too cute in trying to work around the babyface's advantage in both WarGames bouts. Each suffered until we hit the old Match Beyond, though neither ended up troubling the stipulation's classic offerings.

Advertisement

3. Joyless Characters Yield Joyless Match

WWE.com

Tommaso Ciampa vs. Timothy Thatcher moved like a snail encased in treacle, stuck inside a glacier.

Advertisement

Opening with admittedly snug grappling that lacked purpose and precision, it was a long, arduous chore throughout its first and second acts. They deserve credit for at least making it look ugly, and worked in nice touches like Ciampa disrespectfully slapping Thatcher's face while controlling the leg, but no TakeOver: WarGames match suffered more from the night's bloat than this one. Rather than delivering sick, targeted, and brutal joint manipulation, the two gurned and growling through the chess match to con you into buying into the "intensity" the commentators put over, but no. The opening 10 minutes or so were a total bore.

The match opened up nicely when one of Thatcher's cauliflower ears exploded, splashing the bout with colour. This made for a grisly visual as Ciampa locked his opponent in a particularly tight Bulldog Choke. Alas, though, it was too little too late, and the wind was already out of the sails by the time Ciampa hit his rope-hanging DDT for the win.

Advertisement

Tedious, sleepy grapplef*ck killed Timothy Thatcher's popularity in EVOLVE. He has been good in WWE so far, with the Fight Pit one of the promotion's best matches all year, but he is in danger of reverting to old habits again.

2. Io, Undermined

WWE.com

WWE's way of eliminating the babyfaces' advantage in the women's WarGames bout was to have Io Shirai continually fail to enter the ring, forcing her to go to extreme lengths to finally have an impact on the bout.

Advertisement

They succeeded only in making the NXT Women's Champion look like a prize fool.

Imagine the dumbest person you've ever met, multiply them by Ryback, then sprinkle a dash of Drake Wuertz's social media activity on top, and you have Io in this match. She passed up the opportunity to enter the bout and regain the advantage in favour of pulling plunder from beneath the ring. Sidelined for an unordinary long time, she unwittingly handed Raquel Gonzalez a kendo stick, then went back to the weaponry when she could have entered. Several minutes of this elapsed. Eventually, Shirai realised she could scale the cage wall... and got knocked off.

Advertisement

Cool.

Io later got into the bout by diving from the top with a trashcan over her head, but looked like a total dummy in the finish as well, willingly scaling the cage wall to allow Gonzalez to powerbomb her through a ladder and take the fall.

Advertisement

NXT succeeded in establishing Shirai's next challenger here, which is good. Making the champion of your supposedly immaculately-booked women's division look like a dolt to get there? The opposite of good.

1. Spots For Spots' Sake

WWE.com

Last year's women's WarGames match was a fantastic story-driven and psychology-rich battle sparked by Dakota Kai's betrayal of Tegan Nox, forcing Candice LeRae and Rhea Ripley into a two-on-four battle with some of the baddest women on the planet. It was comfortably the best thing on the card and offered a glimmer of hope that perhaps WWE's take on WarGames wouldn't always mean a mindless, weapon-heavy spotfest, but those hopes were dashed last night.

Advertisement

Both of these matches were empty calories. Were they fun? Sure, and they certainly fired up the endorphins, but so will a massive bag of Skittles, and like a massive bag of Skittles, there was no nutritional value to any of this..

There was zero connective tissue lacing any of Team Shotzi vs. Team Candice's big, explosive spots together. It was spots and kickouts on top of spots and kickouts, all for the sake of capturing a sick gif or "creating a moment," and suffered from a near-complete lack of storytelling beyond the expected Gonzalez vs. Ripley monster showdown. The men's match had similar issues, though at least the character dynamics were on point.

Advertisement

WarGames should be beyond this. More satisfying spotfests than this go down on indie shows every single weekend. A stipulation that used to be about intense anguish, drama, and emotion felt cheap, nasty, and disposable last night... and the worst part? WWE can pull WarGames off. The women proved it last year.

They just chose not to.

Advertisement

But perhaps we should have expected this from a match that exists because one grown woman took a tantrum when another broke her toy tank.

Ups...

4. Can't Knock The Hustle

WWE.com

The women's WarGames match's flaws have next to nothing to do with the performers themselves.

Advertisement

It's important to point this out, as while the bout was a big, messy shambles, the wrestlers entered strong performances. Ultimately, they were undone by whoever's clumsy hand put the damn thing together.

Though made to look incompetent, Shirai was a woman possessed once she got rolling. The trashcan dive was ridiculous, she took an insane bump for the finish, and she was fired up and energetic when allowed to be, particularly after finally getting into the cage. Elsewhere, Gonzalez looked like a destroyer, Ripley felt dangerous again, Blackheart was her usual untamed self, and Kai quietly posted one of the most impressive performances of her career. She was a dynamo.

Advertisement

Nobody in either WarGames match left anything in the tank. In the opening, the tortured howls and screams resonated as strongly as the big spots, and perhaps even more so in some cases. With a better layout, we may have been looking at an all-timer here.

3. Characters Dominate The Triple Threat

WWE.com

Leon Ruff, Damian Priest, and Johnny Gargano worked a Triple Threat informed more by story and existing character dynamics than high spots and hot action, and benefitted because of it.

Advertisement

Gargano isolated Ruff as the weak link early on, focusing his assaults on the former EVOLVE man while keeping Priest as out of the way as possible. Priest, meanwhile, treated Ruff as if he were a bug on his windshield. His goal was to tear Gargano to pieces, so he became progressively annoyed with the North American Champion's gumption throughout - and Ruff isn't one to be put in the corner. He kept stepping to Priest, looking to prove himself worthy of being in the ring with the big man and Gargano.

This earned him a Razor's Edge through the barricade.

Advertisement

Selling regret, Priest gave Johnny a way back into the match, but eventually fought a horde of Ghostfaces off, thwarted Ruff's comeback, and looked to have victory secured. Cue: Austin Theory as the final Scream, a lead pipe to Priest, and One Last Beat on Ruff for Gargano's victory.

This was a fun, fluid, and well laid-out match from start to finish, and keeps another Gargano vs. Priest singles match on the table as well, as Damian wasn't involved in the finish. Here's hoping this is the end of the Ghostface stuff, though.

Advertisement

2. Grimes & Lumis Overdeliver

WWE.com

"Overdeliver" might seem like faint praise, given the putrid build to Cameron Grimes vs. Dexter Lumis, but this was a genuinely well-worked strap match that utilised the stipulation well and delivered a level of animosity appropriate to the feud.

Advertisement

Grimes, terrified of facing Lumis in a fair fight, jumped the former Sam Shaw at the bell, ambushing him with the strap he'd brought to the ring, before Dexter could even tether himself to the heel. He was suitably intense as he put a beating on Lumis, though Dexter eventually strapped in, got to work, and started closing the distance, putting the fear of god into Grimes, who mounted several failed escape attempts over the barricade.

Lumis' slowly creeping his face over the barricade like a movie monster was premium cheese, though his performance was bruising and hard-hitting. Grimes blinding his opponent with a sack over his head showcased the performers' creativity. In the end, however, he was felled, with Lumis locking Cameron in Silence, wrapping the strap around his face for extra torque.

Advertisement

Lumis vs. Grimes was everything it needed to be and not a drop more. It was the only thing on the card that didn't overstay its welcome, and must be considered a success because of this.

1. Fun, Despite Everything Else

WWE.com

The same complaints regarding the lack of psychology, excessive runtime, and everything else apply to Undisputed Era vs. The Kings of WWE NXT as they do the opener, but to a lesser degree. For the most part, these wrestlers did a better job of delivering a main event that actually felt like WarGames.

Advertisement

Pete Dunne and Kyle O'Reilly's opening grapples were more purposeful and compelling than anything offered by Timothy Thatcher and Tommaso Ciampa. The same two wrestlers got into it later in the bout as well, offering a thrilling preview of what a long singles bout may look like, as their finisher kickout spots were well-built and suitably dramatic.

While Danny Burch pulling out the cricket bats (because he's British, lol) and Pat McAfee's named Undisputed Era tables were too cute for their own good, the plunder brawl was lots of fun. McAfee was tremendous. Whether begging and stooging off or flinging himself from the cage with a senton, he strengthened his Rookie of the Year case once more, and Undisputed taking it in turns to whoop him around a circle felt earned.

Advertisement

Cole's Panama Sunrise on McAfee after Pat had attempted the move would have been a good spot to end this, but Oney Lorcan ended up taking the fall to KOR. Regardless, this was an adrenaline-pumping spotfest with plenty of character, and an enjoyable watch if you can forgive its flaws.

"Great" would be a stretch, but nothing on this show was, so...

Advertisement