4 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE NXT WarGames 2021

Johnny Gargano's WWE swansong; NXT's new breed "TakeOver"; Cora Jade breaks out.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

The main hook heading into NXT 2.0's first pay-per-view presentation was a battle of old school vs. new. Brand veterans like Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano would re-align to put breakout stars like Bron Breakker and Carmelo Hayes in their place - this was NXT's TakeOver classics vs. 2.0's newbies.

Advertisement

Anyone who has tuned into WWE's version of the famous WarGames match knew what they were getting here. The company bookended this card with two weapons-filled cage brawls, and sprinkled in a few other distractions to pad things out. In isolation, both of the titular multi-wrestler scraps had merit, but the rest of the show was...mediocre at best.

That's become a real problem for NXT. Vince McMahon has changed the show from a tight-knit celebration of everything that was right about independent pro wrestling (with WWE production); instead, now, the place is a mish-mash of gimmicks and meandering newcomers who lack the polish of their predecessors.

Advertisement

WarGames 2021, and the looming threat of several departures, should concern those already worried for NXT's future. Or, taken another way, it could be the making of fresh stars. McMahon seems determined to make this work regardless of short-term grumbles.

Downs...

6. The Tag’s Overall Lack Of Threat

WWE.com

If Vince is going to make NXT 2.0 a success though, he'll need to do more to make people care about characters like Von Wagner. Right now, the dude is a rather nondescript, stereotypical WWE-style big man, and that's not great. He was the definite weak link in Sunday's tag title match.

Advertisement

Wagner and Kyle O'Reilly had seemed like a weird unit from the beginning, and that was exacerbated by Von showing up on SmackDown randomly. From that moment on, it's been clear that WWE were never 100% into this thing full time - it's a vehicle to get Wagner started, and WarGames proved that.

There was just no way these dudes were beating Imperium.

Advertisement

Wagner and O'Reilly's title shot lacked any and all drama then. Everyone worked hard, but this wasn't a patch on some of the tag-team bouts NXT's old TakeOvers produced. Imperium need more satisfying/less thrown-together challengers if they're gonna succeed as champs.

5. Von Wagner Looks Daft

WWE.com

Also, this was some of the most counterproductive booking you're likely to see.

Advertisement

Right, WarGames could be the start of Kyle O'Reilly's WWE exit. If so, then it makes no sense to have him palm off Von Wagner's turn attempt then throw up some Undisputed Era signs. Is that cool, and does it give him some closure? Yes, but it doesn't make one lick of sense.

Twitter is going wild for O'Reilly's Undisputed nod and Adam Cole sharing love hearts in response. Erm...great? Those lads were literally in a bitter feud towards the end of Cole's NXT run, and now (with Kyle seemingly on his way out too) WWE are making Wagner look like a giant chump.

Advertisement

Listen, everybody loves a reference to the past every now and then, but NXT 2.0 is supposed to be about the brand's future. Sadly, at WarGames, the only guy staying put on the show was made to look like one of its biggest afterthoughts.

4. Skewed Psychology

WWE.com

Typically, WarGames matches work best when the babyfaces are at a numbers disadvantage and have to fight from underneath until the end. For some reason (maybe to differentiate it from the other cage bout?), WWE flipped that reliable format and gave the faces that constant leverage.

Advertisement

Bit of a wasted opportunity, that.

Fans fell quiet when Kay Lee Ray and Cora Jade were double-teaming Dakota Kai during the early stages of the women's match. Then, they didn't seem to know how to react when Gigi Dolin evened the odds and helped out her heel partner for the night. That odd presentation continued for the bulk of this 30-minute melee.

Advertisement

This didn't completely wreck the match or anything, but it did hold these women back from a psychological standpoint. It's baffling that WWE didn't think to give Toxic Attraction, who use the numbers game weekly, the edge throughout.

3. Total Filler

WWE.com

Nothing on the card aside from both WarGames matches felt essential.

Advertisement

If anything, Cameron Grimes vs. Duke Hudson should've been kept aside as a featured match on Tuesday night telly. It came across as filler immediately, and never really kicked into a higher gear before Grimes rolled up Duke for the win. Then, WWE sorta reneged on the advertised stipulation.

This 'Hair vs. Hair' gimmick was supposed to see one man get shaved totally bald. That didn't happen. Hudson scarpered before Cameron could finish giving him the barber treatment; it was hard enough to care about the visual of an already short-haired Duke getting a little trim anyway.

Advertisement

It's not like he was ever going to look radically different, which is surely the purpose of these things. Now, Hudson will show up on NXT TV sporting a baldy, and he might even shave off his goatee. How that drastically alters his or Grimes' fortunes is anyone's guess.

2. Another Nothing Match

WWE.com

Grimes vs. Hudson wasn't the only story that was half-baked heading into WarGames - Roderick Strong's angle with Joe Gacy was another bout that lacked some sizzle before the show. WWE's inclusivity approach is rather underdeveloped, and it reeks of the company trying to seem trendy or current.

Advertisement

Also, after all that, the Cruiserweight Title is still the...Cruiserweight Title.

Strong's defence was another match that had free weekly television written all over it. There was nothing about the eight-minute scuffle you should go out of your way to see. Honestly, nothing. This dime-a-dozen showing made a mockery of the title represented, and WWE are no further forwards with changes they obviously want to make.

Advertisement

Perhaps the only slightly interesting aspect was big Harland almost putting his hands on Ivy Nile. Other than that, this was skippable. Christ knows where Gacy goes from here, or what Roderick's Diamond Mine will do if WWE whips the Cruiser belt from their midst.

1. No Big Time Presentation

WWE.com

Perhaps the biggest issue with this inaugural NXT 2.0 "supershow" is that it came across as little more than an extended episode of weekly NXT TV. Presentation-wise, everything looked the same as it does on Tuesday nights. In fact, had the WarGames cage not been there, nobody would've known this was a pay-per-view.

Advertisement

That's a bit rubbish.

WWE must go more to give these shows a grand feel. That could mean moving out of the Capitol Wrestling Center for bigger events quarterly. If not, then the promotion must tart the place up to give it a unique aesthetic. Currently, it's like TNA's Impact Zone without the personality.

Advertisement

That sounds so harsh, but yours truly is very frustrated by the lack of effort that went into WarGames' presentation. Larger-scale events on paper need to look bigger and better than their regular TV counterparts. If not, then what's the point?

Ups...

4. Cora Jade’s Gutsy Effort

WWE.com

Finally, some positives.

Advertisement

Despite the heftier 'Downs' count, WarGames wasn't a terrible show. The opener's psychology was all over the shop, but Kay Lee Ray looked strong, Io Shirai did her thing, Raquel Gonzalez had fun and Cora Jade managed to break out from the pack and look like a real superstar.

Her flip bump from the top of the cage through a table was downright scary. Though seeing Io pop it back into socket almost made the whole exercise look like a work (there are no reports of lasting injuries to Cora post-show either, which is great), Jade did everything to sell her pain for the rest of the night.

Advertisement

The guts she showed really helped to establish a never-say-die attitude. It's perhaps surprising that she got the nod to bag the winning fall for her team, but nobody should hate the thought that WWE are trying to line up multiple challengers worthy of going after Mandy Rose and her title.

3. DIY Reminiscing

WWE.com

That could be a wrap for Johnny Gargano in WWE. Assuming his post-show comments on the mic are totally genuine (you never know in wrestling), it looks like 'Johnny Wrestling's' NXT run has come to an end after years of stellar work. He and his current employer will probs address that on Tuesday.

Advertisement

If he's on the way out-ski, then Gargano deserved one last hurrah with old partner-turned-rival-turned-partner Tommaso Ciampa. Together, they reunited to hit the old DIY finish on Bron Breakker during the main. There was something deliberate about that, not least because Breakker is clearly the emerging face of NXT 2.0.

Gargano would/will be a huge loss to NXT, and yet...what more does he have left to accomplish? The man has burned through almost everything on this brand since 2015-2016, and it might be the right time to move on from WWE as a whole. Besides, it's not like he'd ever get house room on Raw or SmackDown anyway.

Advertisement

At least he, Ciampa and DIY's fans got this moment.

2. Bron Breakker’s Dominance

WWE.com

Speaking of moments.

Advertisement

Bron Breakker smashed, stomped, suplexed and destroyed everyone in his path, which is exactly how Rick Steiner's boy should be booked. It's a real credit to his dangerous aura that the main event noticeably picked up some steam when he entered the match too.

Seeing Bron rampage out as the final man on 'Team 2.0', and cut a bolt that was blocking entrance to the cage, was dramatic. One half-expected them to go Mark Henry with the musclebound f*cker and have him rip the cage door clean off. Thankfully, WWE restrained that over-the-top side to their writing for once.

Advertisement

Breakker didn't look weak once he was in WarGames anyway. He tossed everybody around, and only got cut down when Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano started working together like it was 2016, this was TakeOver: Toronto and they were in there with The Revival/AEW's FTR.

1. Pinning The Right Man

WWE.com

No-one watching WarGames was left with any doubts about the future of NXT. WWE painted a clear enough picture here: 'Black & Gold' is dead, and 2.0 is where it's at heading into 2022. Being honest, the company had to put all their eggs in that particular basket - some sort of 50/50 old-meets-new wasn't going to work for longer than one major show.

Advertisement

Breakker pinned Ciampa to end the night, and that surely means he'll get another NXT Title match somewhere down the road. That's fine, not least 'cause everybody could see it coming a mile off. It's also not like Bron is terrible. He deserves this push, and he'll only improve the more faith WWE shows in him.

2.0 haters might turn their nose up at this brand's new style, but few could piece together a convincing-enough argument to suggest that 'Steiner The Younger' shouldn't be pushed to the f*cking moon and supplant Tommaso as NXT's main man.

Advertisement

It's inevitable, and this was proof of that inevitability.

What did you think of NXT WarGames 2021? For more like this, check out 5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 3) and 5 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Rampage (Dec 3)!

Advertisement