This week's Smackdown took place in the capital city of Canada, which is Ottawa. It was a below average edition of Smackdown although at least there was some story progression. Some weeks it's as if they just throw things together, hope it works and call it a show. It was a rare week where there wasn't a match in the actual main event. It was just a contract signing. There was no John Cena on the show this week, which has become the usual. He shows up for Smackdown only once in a while. Since he was off house shows last weekend that meant he only worked on Raw. Getting some rest is nice. Here are the results from the show: - Dolph Ziggler d. Bad News Barrett by DQ - Dolph Ziggler & Adrian Neville d. Bad News Barrett & Sheamus - Luke Harper d. Fandango - The New Day d. Kidd, Cesaro & Ryback - Naomi d. Emma - The Lucha Dragons d. Los Matadores Those were the six matches. As mentioned, a contract signing ended the show. Here are the ups and downs from this week's Smackdown.
Downs...
4. Sin Cara Missed A Dive While Los Matadores Blame El Torito For Losing
It's nice to see a tag match featuring teams that aren't in the title picture, but this story is pretty ridiculous. When Lucha Dragons faced Los Matadores, it was a very good match for the time given. They got about seven minutes. The problem with a match like this is that Los Matadores are barely used, so there's barely a crowd reaction for anything that they do. At least with Lucha Dragons the crowd is very interested in what they do, especially when Kalisto was in the ring. Kalisto is so exciting when he gets the hot tag. His athleticism is unparalleled. At one point near the end of the match, Sin Cara went for a dive outside the ring. His legs didn't really clear so his leap failed to really make contact. Thankfully for WWE, this is a taped show. They only showed his back during the dive so we didn't see how far he missed one of the Matadores outside the ring. If that happened on Raw it would be the talk of the show. On Smackdown it's not as noticeable. The story here is that after the win by Lucha Dragons, El Torito was blamed for the loss even though it had nothing to do with him. According to reports, Torito is turning face and will be paired with Lucha Dragons because they're the more popular team. It's that simple sometimes.
3. Tamina's Pairing With Naomi Feels Like A Repeat
When AJ Lee was booked as the dominant top diva in WWE for most of 2013 and into 2014, she had Tamina at her side as the bodyguard type. The story should have been that AJ kicks her to the curb, Tamina turns face, wins the title and becomes a bigger star after that. It didn't happen. During this week's Smackdown, Naomi wrestled Emma with Tamina looking on at ringside. Naomi still has some work to do in terms of her heel offense because there are times when her taunting just doesn't come across well and the match stalls big time because of it. I saw her at a live event last week and felt the same way. There really wasn't much flow to the match. Emma barely got a comeback in as Naomi got the win with the Rear View. Post match, Tamina and Naomi attacked Emma and it ended with a Tamina Superkick to knock Emma out. While Tamina is far from the most charismatic woman on the roster, having her walk out there with a serious expression on her face is not going to get her over. It's the same thing she did with AJ Lee. No offense to Naomi, but her heel work isn't close to as good as AJ Lee either. Consider this pairing a work in progress at this point.
2. The Tag Match Formula Strikes Again
The biggest problem with WWE programming is that their shows are too predictable and formulaic. Smackdown is the most predictable of their shows because nearly every week they either do a promo or some sort of segment to lead to a tag match. It's as if they have no idea how to set up these matches without reverting to this formula. This week they went to the formula again after the opening match with King Barrett taking on Dolph Ziggler. They worked for about four minutes when Sheamus showed up to attack Ziggler and double team him with Barrett. Neville made the save, which led to a tag match between these guys. The tag match was good and will be mentioned in the Ups section, but certainly WWE could have set it up in a less predictable way. Is the creative team paid to be creative? It comes off as so lazy. A lot of people used to joke about how Teddy Long would always book tag matches when he was GM, but the creative team is still doing it even after Long is gone. Old habits die hard as they say.
1. Contract Signings Should Not Main Event TV Shows
WWE loves contract signings. We all know that. They use them as a way to have competitors brawl in the ring to set up a future match. When fans hear that a Contract Signing is set to take place they know what to expect because it happens nearly every time. We see them almost every month. It's too often. With that said, WWE made a mistake in putting this as a main event segment. Yes, it makes sense to put Rollins, Orton, Ambrose and Reigns in a segment to hype up the Payback main event, but it just didn't feel like a main event. I can remember going to a Smackdown taping in 2011 where the main event of the broadcast was Randy Orton doing a contract signing with Mark Henry. It was such a boring segment that it made people walk out early even though there was a 45 minute Edge appreciation night after the show was over. Contract signings aren't that exciting and when they are the main event of a show it's a turn off for the fans. We don't want to watch 15 minute promos to end the show. We want action. Give us that.
Ups...
4. Neville And Ziggler Work Well Together Again
It was the third time in the three last weeks that we've seen Ziggler and Neville team up against Barrett and Sheamus. It happened on the April 23 edition of Smackdown and they did it on Monday's Raw too. Every time they have a match it's very good, though, so they are definitely in the "up" part of the show. The difference between this match and their other matches was that this one was a lot shorter. It only got about six minutes. Ziggler got the pin on Barrett in the match. The immediate thought when seeing that was that it was stupid to have Barrett lose because the guy has all this new momentum as the King of the Ring and then they booked him to lose. However, it's not a major complaint.If the work in the match is really good like it was here then that's really all that matters just as long as Barrett isn't losing every week. They need top heels. He's a good candidate. Book him to get some meaningful wins, please.
3. Seth Rollins Ended The Night Looking Like A Champion
The Contract Signing segment shouldn't have been the main event, but it was still a well booked segment that ended in a positive way. WWE hasn't done a great job of booking Seth Rollins as the WWE World Heavyweight Champion. We know they're trying to paint him as a cheap heel that finds ways to escape with the title, but he's been losing too many matches. Whether it's tag matches or losing clean to Dean Ambrose in a non-title match this past week on Raw, Rollins just hasn't had the look of the best wrestler in the world of late. After all four guys signed the contract (Rollins took his time to get into the ring with the other three guys) and the fans chanted "Justin Bieber" at Rollins again, it turned into a wild brawl as expected. Ambrose had a funny line about how "we all know how this is going to end anyway" leading to the brawl. The purpose of this segment seemed to drive home the point that Rollins was the smartest guy out there and he tried to manipulate the situation by ripping on the other three guys with a scathing promo. Ambrose shoved Reigns, so Orton hit a RKO on Ambrose, Reigns hit a Superman Punch on Orton and then Rollins took down Reigns with a flying knee attack as well as a superkick. Rollins ending the night as the last man standing was a good booking decision. They needed him to come out looking like the best wrestler during this segment. That's what happened. It shouldn't have been the main event, though.
2. Putting Harper And Rowan Together Again Is The Right Move
Luke Harper won a short match with Fandango in about two minutes. They were rushing through spots so quickly because they knew they only had a couple of minutes to go through a match. Harper was able to slam Fandango off the top, then he hit a superkick and a spinning clothesline for the win. When the match was over, Harper celebrated the win and then his former partner Erick Rowan walked down to the ring. The reaction of the crowd at first was a cheer because they thought he was going to attack Harper. Instead, he attacked Fandango. He stomped on him and then hit a Full Nelson Slam. Harper just looked on with a puzzled look while Rowan walked away alone. Since Rowan flopped as a face, WWE would be smart to turn him into a heel that is aligned with Harper and possibly Bray Wyatt again. They could put these two back together as a heel team because they were among the best teams in WWE when they teamed together regularly. Breaking up the Wyatt Family last year was a mistake. Putting them back together is the right move, so the sight of Rowan surprisingly coming out to help Harper is definitely an "up" from this week's show.
1. The New Day's Feud With Cesaro/Kidd Is The Best Thing Going In WWE
The best match on the show wasn't longer than the main event talking segment, but it was another week where The New Day's feud with Tyson Kidd and Cesaro was a highlight of the show. Instead of just doing a regular tag match, they booked a six man tag with Kidd and Cesaro joined by Ryback. It was teased going into it that we didn't know who the partner was going to be. Ryback fit just because he is a power wrestler that matches up well with Big E. There was a really cool spot in the match where Cesaro and Ryback hit delayed suplexes at the same time while Kidd looked at them, then realized he probably couldn't do that, so he hit a quicker suplex. The crowd was really into it. Right before the finish, there was a scary moment. Cesaro walked on the guardrail outside the ring and went to hit a DDT on Big E, but he didn't turn well and it looked really bad. Good thing nobody got hurt.The match didn't have a clean finish. Towards the end of it, Bray Wyatt's graphic appeared on the screen, that distracted Ryback and allowed Kingston to roll up Kidd in the ring while grabbing the tights. It wasn't a strong show in terms of very good matches, but once again the New Day's feud with Cesaro and Kidd was a highlight this week.