4 Ups And 4 Downs From Last Night’s WWE SmackDown (Sept 10)

A wild Rollins vs. Ryback Lumberjack match headlines Smackdown.

By John Canton /

This week's SmackDown was another average show that continued the build up to WWE Night of Champions next Sunday. As usual, several of the biggest names in the company were missing, but at least the WWE Champion Seth Rollins was there. WWE once again teased the idea that Sheamus is going to cash in the Money in the Bank briefcase at Night of Champions. The show progressed the current storylines in some ways, but then they took some step backs by booking some odd finishes or completely ignoring the idea of booking a finish. Here are the match results from this week's show: Cesaro defeated The Miz by submission using the Sharpshooter. Paige and Sasha Banks had a match that ended in a No Contest when they wouldn't stop brawling. Roman Reigns, Dean Ambrose & Jimmy Uso wrestled The New Day in a match with no official ending due to mysterious interference from The Wyatt Family. The Ascension pinned The Lucha Dragons by pinfall. Seth Rollins beat Ryback in a Lumberjack Match with no titles on the line. Kevin Owens grabbed Ryback's leg, which led to Ryback nailing a Pedigree to win. Here are the four ups and four downs from this week's Smackdown.

Downs...

4. Booker T Is Back On Commentary And Felt Out Of Place

When Booker was on Raw, he fit in well with Michael Cole and John Bradshaw Layfield. He was the face announcer that was there to root on the good guys while JBL supported the heels. It was a natural thing for him. On Smackdown this week, Booker made a lot of comments that suggest he's now a heel announcer. He defended Big Show even though he nailed Mark Henry with a punch to knock him out. At the end of the show, he was saying how Rollins won clean even though it was a cheap win. There was really no warning for Booker's turn, but WWE must have encouraged him to be more of an argumentative heel announcer instead of being a face like he was before. I just don't think it's the best way to utilize Booker as an announcer.

3. Inconsistent Booking Of The Ascension

This past Monday on Raw, The Ascension were put in a tag match against the duo of Roman Reigns and Dean Ambrose. The result was a short match that Reigns/Ambrose won in about three minutes. There was no doubt who was going to win either. It's also noteworthy that Stardust didn't have any involvement in that match. On Smackdown, The Ascension won clean in under three minutes in a match against the Lucha Dragons. Stardust was at ringside, caused a distraction and then Konnor/Viktor won with the Fall of Man finisher. It's as if WWE is telling the fans that due to these guys being losers, Stardust wants nothing to do with them against a good team. However, against a bad team he's happy to be there. A lot of people that watch Raw don't watch Smackdown, so all they will remember from this week is that they lost to Reigns and Ambrose easily. That's a problem that WWE has to fix by making them look like bigger stars on EVERY show not just one of them. No wrestler or team is really going to make a connection with the audience as long as they are booked inconsistently. Want The Ascension to be considered threats? Book them that way.

2. Teasing Another Big Show Feud With Mark Henry

During the Lumberjack Match, Big Show pulled Ryback out of the ring and tossed him into the barricade. Then Mark Henry got in Show's face, which led to Show knocking out Henry in one punch. That's a feud that I don't want to see again and I doubt many other people want to see either. We have seen enough Show vs. Henry matches to last a lifetime. It's also tough to figure out what WWE is doing with Big Show right now. It appeared as though he was going to be turning face, but seeing him act the way he did in this match made him look like a heel again. Based on what happened here, it's very possible there might be a Big Show vs. Henry match on Raw. I can hear the audience groaning already. Please WWE, make it stop!

1. Match Result Don't Seem To Matter

There were five matches on this week's show with the following results in order: Submission win, no contest or announcement of a result, another match with no announcement, pinfall and pinfall due to interference while the heel announcer called it clean. When a show is struggling for ratings the way that SmackDown is, the best way to get fans back is to put on great matches with results that mean something. Having two matches end without any result is a message to the fans that if they choose to skip the show they are missing nothing because the results matter so little right now. Hey WWE, do you want people to care more? Show us you care by booking better finishes. Every match should have an announcement telling us who won or why the match ended in a disqualification or countout. Just going to a commercial isn't enough. They have to be more consistent with this stuff.

Ups...

4. Cesaro Found Somebody He Can Beat

One of my complaints in this space over the past couple of months has been about WWE not booking Cesaro strong enough. The crowd loves the guy, but they just don't book him to win enough matches. This week on Smackdown, he faced The Miz in singles action and won clean with the Sharpshooter. It wasn't just any Sharpshooter either. He won the match by applying the Sharpshooter while he was on his back, then he got back to his feet and Miz was forced to tap out to it. https://twitter.com/WWECesaro/status/642282430272028672 What WWE needs to find next for Cesaro is a feud that can really elevate him. Having good midcard matches is fine, but what's it leading to? He should be doing more. I'm not sure what's next for him and I don't know if creative has any idea either. He should be treated as a priority rather than afterthought.

3. The New Wyatt Family Continue To Look Unbeatable

It was frustrating to see how WWE didn't even care to book a finish for the six man tag match that I mentioned earlier, but there was something to like too. The Wyatt Family have looked so strong ever since they added Braun Strowman to the group. It continued with the way that they were booked on SmackDown. After nearly 15 minutes of intense action, the Wyatt Family logo appeared on the screen and then Jimmy Uso went missing. He was being held in the arms of Braun Strowman as a way to knock out Jimmy while reigns and Ambrose couldn't save him. As Uso laid there on the ground, Wyatt said: "They all fall down." The story is that the Wyatt Family are going to attack anybody that teams with Reigns and Ambrose just like they attacked Randy Orton on Raw. I like that angle a lot because it really puts over the Wyatts as a dangerous heel group that aren't going to be stopped easily. WWE doesn't always book their heels to be that strong. With the Wyatt Family they are doing just that and it's a pleasure to see.

2. Intense Divas Brawl Was Excellent

The divas did a great job on SmackDown. The match was Paige vs. Sasha Banks, which looked like any regular match with their allies getting ejected early. Then it turned into a huge brawl with the match ending in a disqualification. Then the other PCB and BAD girls went out to continue brawl. The best way for WWE's Divas Revolution to grow is to have segments like this where they are allowed to have intense battles the same way the guys have. If they only have tag matches on every show then it gets repetitive and boring, which is what has happened. Fans reacted to this in a positive way because we really haven't seen something like this with the divas that often. Girls fighting with intensity is exactly the way WWE needs to promote the women on their show. They need more segments like this one for the divas. It felt more real than anything they've done in months.

1. A Chaotic Main Event That Was A Lot Of Fun

Seth Rollins brings out the best in Ryback. He's probably Ryback's best opponent and they proved it again with an entertaining Lumberjack match in the main event of Smackdown. This was a rematch from Raw, which is fine because Rollins was pinned by Ryback after the distraction from Sting. Sometimes WWE overdoes rematches. In this case, I didn't mind it because we should have seen a resolution from Monday. For the finish, Kevin Owens tripped up Ryback while he was doing a move and then Rollins nailed the Pedigree for the win. I didn't like that they made it look like it was a cheap thing behind the ref's back because there were guys interfering in the match the whole time. I like that Owens cost Ryback, though, because it furthers that story. Rollins almost never wins clean and this wasn't clean here, but it was close enough. At this point, let's just be happy that he won a match since he's booked to lose so often like his two losses on Raw.