4 Ups And 4 Downs From WWE NXT DEADL1NE
The Iron Survivor Challenge makes its debut; Breakker defends; New Day, new champs?
NXT as its own brand is a decade old, and it still can’t decide what it wants to be.
Technically, it’s a developmental territory for WWE, training the next generation of wrestlers for the main roster. That’s become more apparent during the past year as they shed a lot of independent talent and have focused more on younger superstars.
But they can’t help themselves trying to deliver these epic matches that would rival what you see on Raw, SmackDown or a main roster PLE. And that’s what we saw with NXT DEADL1NE, the last big show of the year.
NXT introduced a new match concept, the Iron Survivor Challenge, which produced mixed results. Overall, both matches were good, with the men’s being more dramatic and fun, while the women’s felt more like a collection of spots loosely tied together by Roxanne Perez’s journey.
New Day and Pretty Deadly were a riot, and hopefully we’ll see more of the two teams interacting.
However, Bron Breakker’s NXT Championship reign continues to be defined by these attempts at big, dramatic title matches. As gifted as he clearly is, Breakker is still young and not yet able to pull these off. This is where that “NXT can’t decide what it wants to be” become apparent. You can’t keep throwing young talent out there asking for stuff you expect from 10-year veterans.
We’ll give DEADL1NE passing marks for delivering overall, but it would be nice if we knew what we were supposed to be experiencing.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
4. A Hot Mess
It’s tough to accurate judge the very first Iron Survivor Challenge match in WWE/NXT history, because there’s nothing to compare it to.
But the women’s match really was a hot mess of a match, with action all over the place, making it difficult to find a thread to follow. The story of the match was Roxanne Perez entering first and pulling out the win at the end. She was down for a good chunk of the match, but once she tied it up on the back end, it was a melee for someone to get the advantage.
To be clear, this wasn’t a bad match – there was plenty happening and some impressive moments, such as Kiana James hitting a Spanish Fly – but even with that narrative being obvious, it wasn’t a really well-told story.
Call it a good effort, a good hot mess, but we’re still going to have to give it a mild down for the disjointed nature of the match.
3. Going For Epic
The higher-ups in NXT should really figure out what they’re doing with Bron Breakker. He’s immensely talented and capable of impressive raw power and athleticism.
But this desire to make every title defense some epic confrontation doesn’t work. While the Goldberg method isn’t necessarily a blueprint, there’s value in having some of his title defenses be shorter, more hard-hitting matches.
Apollo Crews was an interesting opponent, as he mirrors a lot of what Breakker offers in the ring: a mix of power and high-flying capability from a larger wrestler. But the build itself was so awkward that this was kind of lost here.
They probably would have been better off doing a Goldberg/Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania war where they threw bombs at each other for 5-10 minutes rather than going 15 minutes. Have both men counter each other’s moves, mirror several holds, and then have Bron slip out of a press slam and nail a lucky spear. Or have him overpower and dominate after some back-and-forth.
This was trying to be another “epic” title defense for Breakker, and it didn’t reach that level. Good match, but not what they clearly were aiming for.
2. Stilted And Unnatural
If NXT really is supposed to be a developmental territory, one of the areas they need to improve on is wrestlers coming across naturally on camera.
Ivy Nile, Katana Chance and Kayden Carter have been on NXT television for a while now, but their backstage interaction looked like first-year drama students reading lines off a cue card offscreen. Carter especially sounded wooden reciting her comments about respecting Nile for reporting Julius Creed’s injury. Ivy also sounded stilted as she had a “totally natural and unplanned” conversation backstage.
Not everyone is going to be gifted on the mic, but if you’re going to insist that wrestlers cut promos, either help them rehearse better, or find ways for them to sound like human beings interacting with other human beings.
1. The Return Of Black Goo!
The ThunderDome Era is not looked back on fondly for several reasons, not all of which were under WWE’s control.
However, one of the stranger aspects of taping Raw and SmackDown without a live audience was the use of “black goo” with some of their wrestlers. Alexa Bliss managed to make Randy Orton vomit goo during a backstage promo, and the viscous liquid would resurface a few times during this era.
The return to live crowds should have signaled the death of the goo, but it returned Saturday night at DEADL1NE. Isla Dawn and Alba Fyre were having a pretty competitive grudge match when Dawn grabbed the referee seconds before eating a Swanton Bomb. Instead of counting the fall, the ref stood in the corner spitting up black goo.
He was incapacitated, and despite then having two more refs at ringside, they both missed Isla shoving Fyre into an exposed turnbuckle to pick up the win. If you’re keeping score, this was a mystic wrestler using dark arts to make a referee spit up goo, but she needed to use a metal turnbuckle ring to win a wrestling match.
This is why this stuff almost never works these days, because it just sounds so insane to say out loud.
UPS…
4. Kiana James Gets Some Shine
One thing you can do in a multi-person match is get multiple people over with the fans.
Roxanne Perez won the first Women’s Iron Survivor Challenge at DEADL1NE, but Kiana James got a chance to stand out a bit Saturday night too. James was the only one to not score a single pinfall in the match, but she had some of the more impressive moments.
James and Zoey Stark were brawling outside the ring when Stark tried to whip Kiana into the barricade. Kiana jumped to the top of the barricade and hit a moonsault press off it onto Zoey, which was the first time she really went for a highspot like that. She later nailed a Spanish Fly on Stark, with Cora Jade trying to steal the pinfall.
While you can’t really call it a breakthrough performance, you can tell that James is certainly athletic. She’s still very early in her career – her Cagematch profile has fewer than 50 matches – and she’s still learning, but it was good to see flashes of something that could blossom.
3. The Right Call
Really, it’s surprising that WWE has waited this long to potentially pull the trigger on Roxanne Perez.
The prodigy has been on the cusp of breaking through a couple times since debuting in NXT, but they’ve managed to pump the brakes on her so far. Saturday’s win in the inaugural Women’s Iron Survivor Challenge match – after entering at #1 – seems like a reignition of that rocket push they clearly want to give Perez.
Honestly, Roxanne has all the natural gifts to excel as a pure babyface champion, and she pulled through at DEADL1NE, overcoming an early deficit, taking the lead late and playing defense enroute to winning a shot at Mandy Rose’s NXT Women’s Championship.
Saturday’s win hopefully is the start of this push to the top, and not a stutter-step. Perez has proven she’s capable beyond her years, so why not go all-in?
2. And New!
The idea of a well-established main roster tag team coming down to NXT and capturing the tag titles might be divisive, but there is a rationale behind it.
While New Day came late to the party and there was zero build-up to their NXT Tag Team Championship win at DEADL1NE, the notion that one of the most decorated tag teams in WWE history wanted to become triple crown tag champs lends value and credibility to the developmental tag titles – if NXT doesn’t screw it up.
New Day could bring more eyes to NXT even in the short term, especially if they show up on SmackDown with the tag titles and encourage people to tune in on Tuesdays to see them defend the championship.
Pretty Deadly also looked right at home battling the accomplished duo, not at all looking overmatched or out of place, which bodes well for their future as a WWE tag team. There’s always a good chance they get their titles back sooner rather than later, which would make for a big milestone in their careers.
And for the record, if you didn’t laugh at the four-way Eddie Guerrero tribute with the title belt, you just aren’t a wrestling fan.
1. Waller The Opportunist
Contrary to the women’s Iron Survivor Challenge, the men’s match had a really nice couple threads running through it, most notably Grayson Waller playing his character perfectly.
Waller has always been something of an opportunist, so it was only natural that he won the match by scoring three pinfalls in extremely fortunate methods. He entered the match with the other three participants down and rushed in with a rolling double stunner, pinning both Axiom and JD McDonagh to put him up with two falls.
Late in the match, with four men tied with two falls apiece, Waller picked his spot, yanking Carmelo Hayes out of the ring after he had knocked Axiom out, stealing the pin and getting the decisive third pin. Grayson then played defense by racing around ringside, evading everyone until the clock ran out.
It was exactly the kind of performance you’d expect from Waller, and it gives him something to crow about for weeks on TV, which will be both unbearable and glorious.