4 Ups And 6 Downs From NXT Vengeance Day

Titles change hands, the cage gets a workout, Toxic Attraction turns toxic on each other.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

NXT stepped out from the friendly and cramped confines of the WWE Performance Center Saturday for its latest PLE, Vengeance Day, delivering a mixed bag of a show that despite its shortcomings still needs to be considered a success for the brand.

Advertisement

A hot crowd, energetic efforts from the superstars and some surprising title switches definitely contributed to the aura surrounding the event. This wasn’t an overly stipped-up show, and it wasn’t overbooked with nonsense. Most of the matches saw the “right” person win, and the show closed out with the NXT Champion’s next challenger – Carmelo Hayes – stepping out to make his presence felt.

Match of the Night honors have to go to Wes Lee and Dijak, who opened the show and set the bar so high that no one could top it. Had half the matches even reached their level, this would have been a huge, unqualified success. But the women’s tag title match was a bit sloppy and disjointed, the NXT Women’s Championship match was disappointing, and the vaunted 2-out-of-3-falls match between Hayes and Apollo Crews underperformed lofty expectations.

Still, nothing was actively bad, the energy was high, and there were some really enjoyable moments. It’s something to build off, and it gives you hope that you’ll see improvement every few months as these shows continue.

Let’s get to it…

DOWNS…

6. Sloppy Tag Action

WWE.com

It’s understandable that when you’re in a title match on a PLE that you’ll want to do something special and fantastic every chance you get. It’s a big spotlight, so go big. Fair enough.

But you’ve got to deliver, and the NXT Women’s Tag Team Championship match did not deliver its big moments. It was a sloppy match at time, with tentative moments and some herky-jerky action.

It wasn’t a bad match per se, and we’ll give some praise later on, but either the women had butterflies in front of a big crowd, or they were aiming too high with some of the spots, which pulled you out of any willing suspension of disbelief. That’s never a good thing. It defeats the purpose of a wrestling match and instead becomes a series of attempted spots to hopefully go viral.

Advertisement

NXT is technically supposed to be a developmental territory, so why are they going for these huge spots when you can still see the wires? If they hit, then you get a great 20-second clip for social media. But if not, you get exposed.

5. Ignoring Your Own History

WWE.com

WWE is famous for acknowledging its own history when it’s convenient, and then ignoring other parts of its lineage for the same reason. They’ll find various modifiers or qualifiers to shoehorn some random statistic, like “Dolph Ziggler has lasted the longest in a Royal Rumble after entering at the #4 spot on an even-numbered day!”

But the announcers harped on a stat that didn’t sound true the minute they said it: NXT Women’s Tag Team Champions Kayden Carter & Katana Chance were the longest-reigning tag champs in the women’s division in WWE history… and that included the main roster.

A quick check revealed that they had indeed passed the Kabuki Warriors’ 180-day reign in 2019-20, but the stat completely ignored the women’s tag division from the 1980s. Literally every women’s tag team champions except the Jumping Bomb Angels held the tag titles for longer, with the Glamour Girls’ first reign lasting nearly five times as long.

Of course, WWE could easily cover and say they were talking about the two active women’s tag titles, but that’s not what they said. It might seem nitpicky, but you don’t get to tout history and then selectively ignore it at the same time.

4. Dabba-Who?

WWE.com

If this were AEW, fans would be piling on on social media about the late-match appearance of Dabba-Kato to help Apollo Crews deal with Trick Williams’ interference… just seconds before Carmelo Hayes defeated Crews nonetheless.

And moments after the match, Kato turned on his friend with a chokebomb onto a steel chair. But who is Dabba-Kato, and why should NXT fans know and/or care? We casual fans can’t be expected to know who he is and his backstory.

That’s a common criticism from AEW haters, but it’s not entirely wrong here. WWE either expects fans to remember that this was Commander Azeez, who seconded Crews during his Nigerian Prince gimmick, rarely wrestled, and hasn’t been seen on WWE TV in more than seven months. Throw in that Kato was no longer dressed as a Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band rip-off and actually looked like he’d leaned out, and you might not have recognized him at first glance.

Advertisement

Vic Joseph yelling, “Dabba-Kato!” like he’s a household name was just silly. This isn’t like an international megastar coming to AEW. Kato’s barely even known to WWE fans by that name, unless you were a Raw Underground aficionado.

3. Crews, Melo Underperform

WWE.com

Let’s get this out of the way: There wasn’t anything technically wrong with the Apollo Crews/Carmelo Hayes 2-out-of-3-falls match. It was mostly very well wrestled and delivered some good action.

But after being built up as a potential instant classic, what we got was far short of that. While the action was good, it wasn’t great. The first fall – with Crews tapping out to a crossface – came out of nowhere, and not in the sense that it was a surprise fall/tapout. It literally came at a point where it seemed like a resthold and transition.

The second fall was disjointed and uneven, and the got marred by some outside interference, with Dabba-Kato returning to help his former running buddy… and Crews still losing the second fall just seconds later.

You almost have to wonder if the match was cut for time, or if someone was injured, because this felt like an underwhelming match from two guys who could have very easily had the match of the night. Not a bad match at all, and a good one at that with the right outcome, but not the classic a 2/3 falls between these guys would theoretically generate.

2. The Least Interesting Team Won

WWE

Of the four teams in the NXT Tag Team Championship four-way match, which one did you least want to see win the titles?

It’s not that Gallus is a bad wrestling duo. It’s that they just… exist. New Day is New Day – they’re an all-time great tag team. Pretty Deadly is highly entertaining and fun. Chase U is quirky and there’s the added question of Duke Hudson’s loyalty.

Gallus is just there. And it’s not like they’re some wrestling machines that are low on personality but grind out these fun, exciting matches. It’s not like their these despicable villains that get you fired up to boo them. They just seem to take up space.

Advertisement

And they’re your new NXT tag champs, pinning Xavier Woods in the process. Let’s cross our fingers that they’re transitional champs to someone else, because this was a head-scratching decision from both a critic’s view and a fan’s perspective.

1. What’s My Character Direction? Oh, SCREAM!

WWE.com

To say that the remainder of Toxic Attraction without Mandy Rose is a listless ship veering toward an iceberg would be an understatement.

Jacy Jayne and Gigi Dolin have underwhelmed since becoming a duo, and their first big moment at Vengeance Day was a big disappointment. The two spent a good chunk of the match chewing scenery, screaming and licking their hands in a bizarre display that felt like they had gotten a last-second direction at gorilla to show their unhinged by doing just that.

The NXT Women’s Championship match felt like it was wrestled at half-speed half the time, with Roxanne Perez slowing down her usual smooth action to accommodate Jacy and Gigi. Then you had the “drama” of the Toxic twosome breaking down and turning on each other, only to suddenly reconcile and gang up on Perez just moments before the finish, to no avail.

Advertisement

The entire ordeal was painful, from the “breakup and makeup” to the C-level acting. The fact that the in-ring action was also just a step above pedestrian didn’t help. Here’s hoping for better things for the Prodigy very soon – she’s mint and should have an opponent who showcases her talent, rather than her having to carry the day.

UPS…

4. A Major-League Feel

WWE.com

Ever since the pandemic shifted NXT back solely to its smaller arena (first Full Sail, then the Performance Center) for all of its shows, the brand has felt much more minor league than its Raw and SmackDown counterparts. Even the PLEs have felt smaller.

But Saturday’s Vengeance Day brought NXT back out of the Performance Center and into an arena with 5,000-plus screaming fans. It featured a staging somewhat different than what we see on NXT, Raw or SmackDown. And it put forth a lot of solid in-ring action. While there were criticisms of several matches earlier, the overall attempt was good and it was a net positive.

Taken together, this felt like a big win for NXT in terms of getting out of its little, insular shell in the PC and back into the wrestling world. There are definitely some improvements that need to be made to reach the level of a TakeOver, but this was a step up from the PC PLEs and a breezy, fun show to watch overall.

3. Underhanded Title Win

WWE.com

You might think the Kiana James/Brooks Jensen storyline and the ongoing “Can they get along?” story with James and Fallon Henley are basic and boring, but it’s at least a story you can follow.

James and Henley won the NXT Women’s Tag Team Championship at Vengeance Day, ending Kayden Carter & Katana Chance’s modern-day record reign for women’s tag champs, but they didn’t do it cleanly. Henley had made it clear beforehand and during the match that she didn’t want to cheat to win, but when she got a pinfall attempt on Carter, James grabbed Kayden’s feet to prevent her from kicking out, doing exactly what Fallon forbade.

So now you have an interesting dynamic: Henley is clearly elated to win her first gold in NXT, but is the reward worth the price? Will she give in and just accept the results, or will she demand a rematch to do it “the right way”? How will this impact Kiana’s relationship with Brooks Jensen?

Advertisement

You could go about 20 different ways with either woman changing their ways, the titles being flipped back to the KC twins, new contenders swiping them quicky from squabbling champs, or even the titles being vacated because Henley refuses to hold them dishonestly.

It’s not Bloodline/Sami Zayn by any stretch – and it might be downright cringeworthy at times – but it’s at least a story to follow, with plenty of options.

2. A Lot Of Bashing And Smashing

WWE.com

The NXT Championship cage match could have gone with a lot of gaga – plunder, other dramatic interventions – but it was a surprisingly simple power battle between Bron Breakker and Grayson Waller.

Waller was never going to be able to match power with Breakker, but he was cagey (pun intended) in picking his spots and using the cage – and the no-DQ stipulation – to his advantage to make the match more competitive. Because the match only could be won via pinfall or submission, it eliminated the trope of slow climbs out or going for the door.

Instead, both men threw each other into the cage walls liberally. Bron overcame a couple last-ditch efforts by Grayson, brought him back into the cage with a superplex, and then delivered two spears (with some unfortunate Shawn Michaels-inspired dramatic dialogue interjected) to retain his title.

Advertisement

It wasn’t a classic, but it was a good, solid match that didn’t overstay its welcome. Waller didn’t look any more overmatched than he might have on paper, and he actually hung with Breakker pretty decently.

1. Underdog Babyface Triumphs

WWE.com

Show of hands: When Nash Carter was released last year and Wes Lee was left on his own, did anyone think he’d be holding the NXT North American Championship and wowing fans in singles action at a PLE?

But here was Lee on Saturday, leading off Vengeance Day, fighting from underneath against the much bigger and stronger Dijak to defend his title. Since his return to NXT, Dijak has been cast (whether deliberately or ironically) as every '80s action movie villain. And Lee is the undersized, unlikely North American Champion.

The two slammed on the gas Saturday, wailing on each other, with Dijak using his size early on to dominate, until they flipped a switch. After struggling several times to muscle him over, Lee nailed a bridging German suplex for a 2-count. From then on, it was a sprint of counters, dazzling offense (including a Space Flying Tiger Drop) and shows of strength from Wes, who hit Dijak with a variation of Landslide for another close pinfall.

Advertisement

Lee refused to give up and kept fighting from underneath, finally overcoming Dijak (with some help from Tony D’Angelo and Stacks) to retain his title. It was a really good showcase for Wes, and it showed that NXT can book a smaller babyface against a larger heel, which has been a blindspot for WWE forever.