5 Biggest Losers From WWE Extreme Rules 2019

Who took the biggest loss?

By Patrick Pester /

WWE.com

WWE Extreme Rules 2019 is in the books and there are plenty of positives to take from it. The Undertaker didn't die, Aleister Black vs. Cesaro was fantastic, The Club meant business and however you feel about the main event, at least we don't have Baron Corbin and Lacey Evans as champions.

Advertisement

While Corbin and Lacey will no doubt be fine, some of the other losses witnessed on the show felt more significant for the superstars receiving them. Whether it was what they lost, the manner in which they went down or the story-line implications, there were several wrestlers from last night's event who did not look good in defeat.

As AEW rightly tells us, wins and losses are important. Even if WWE does try to wipe the slate clean on some of them with 50/50 booking, people still don't forget losses in a hurry. Especially when the losses take place on a pay-per-view.

Out of the 13-matches which took place on last night's card, there are standout losses which will surely hurt the superstars going forward. Here are the 5 biggest losers from Extreme Rules 2019...

5. Finn Bálor

The match between Finn Bálor and Shinsuke Nakamura was very much thrown together at the last minute. Rather than wait and build to SummerSlam, WWE opted to jump the gun and add it to Extreme Rules. To make matters even worse, the match was relegated to the pre-show and meant a clean loss for either man would not be a good look.

Advertisement

Finn Bálor was rather surprisingly the one to fall, losing the Intercontinental Championship which guarantees a foothold in the company standings. While a title change on the pre-show always leaves a bad taste in the mouth, there was still hope Finn might get involved in something on the main card. Audiences would have soon forgotten the loss if he interjected himself into The Club’s United States Championship match. Unfortunately, this didn’t happen leaving fans to contemplate what is next for The Extraordinary Man.

He could still align himself with The Club or simply continue feuding with Nakamura. However, there is a danger that Finn will simply be cast back out into the muddy open waters of the mid card.

4. Seth Rollins

Brock Lesnar is the Universal Champion once again and we are left to wonder, where does it leave every other superstar?

Advertisement

This includes former beast slayer Seth Rollins. Losing via cash-in to Brock is not exactly a weak way to lose your title and a rematch will almost certainly be made. The big problem for Seth is whether the fans will really care if he gets it back. Since winning the belt earlier this year at WrestleMania, his reign at the top has hardly set the world alight. In fact, the only thing that's really been burned down is ratings.

Now it’s not fair to blame Seth for the falling viewership, as that is mostly the fault of people beyond his pay grade (as high as it may be). But he has also not been especially exciting to watch as of late. The power couple story-line with Becky Lynch has been cringe inducing and what’s worse, is in danger of castrating The Man. If audiences decide Seth is partly responsible, then they may put their stock in one of the many other talented roster members.

3. Nikki Cross

There was much intrigue going into the handicap match for the SmackDown Women's Championship. Among the many questions surrounding this difficult to predict bout, was would we see Nikki Cross emerge from the shadow of Alexa Bliss? In other words, was this going to be a crowning moment for the much beloved Scot?

Advertisement

No, is the answer. Bayley won the match clean, seeing off both competitors and pinning Cross. Sasha Banks wasn’t needed to even the odds and there wasn’t even a hint of dissension between the heels.

This really underlines where WWE see Cross at present. She may be a valued member of the roster but she is going to have to pay a few more WWE dues before reaching the upper echelons of the women’s division.

2. Dolph Ziggler

Kevin Owens destroying Dolph Ziggler in 17 seconds may be viewed as a positive result by many fans, but it’s not a good look for Dolph.

Advertisement

Audiences have grown tired of The Showoff, to the point where his presence in story-lines makes them less interesting. Dolph has suffered from the law of diminishing returns, exemplified by his 4-month hiatus earlier this year. He came back as The #Heel no one really wanted to see and was shoehorned into a couple of predictable WWE Championship matches with Kofi Kingston. Now he's become fodder for a Kevin Owens on the rise.

While the contest at Extreme Rules was not hotly anticipated, a strong match could have reminded fans of how good Ziggler can be in the ring. After all, his epic clash with The Miz at No Mercy 2016 was not that long ago. Being squashed however does nothing for him. The match might have provided short-term satisfaction for fans but Ziggler will continue to be on the roster, only now, people will care even less.

1. Samoa Joe

Samoa Joe has lost yet another big match.

Advertisement

Every time the Samoan Submission Machine is put in a prominent spot, his fans hold their breath. And every time a disappointing sigh is let out across the WWE Universe. At Extreme Rules there were no interferences, no shenanigans, not even a post-match Coquina Clutch to make Joe look better. He simply ate a Trouble in Paradise and was down for a three count inside 10 minutes.

Perhaps Joe will be back on Raw or SmackDown to continue the feud but wins and losses do matter, and this could be the one which finally chokes Joe of main event credibility.

Advertisement