5 Biggest Winners & Losers From WWE In 2024

Which WWE stars had a great and prosperous 2024, and which ones struggled and failed this year?

By Anthony Mango /

2024 was a massive year for WWE in many ways, with the company achieving more good will across the board than many previous years combined.

Advertisement

Nearly every week was some sort of record-breaking success in one way or another, and it has led to a rather unpredictable first year under The Paul Levesque Era.

But of course, it hasn't all been rainbows and sunshine. Often, when someone paves the way for a big win, someone else has to take a loss to make room for it.

For every monetary boost, there are cost-cutting procedures. For every wrestler's championship win, a title-holder has to drop their belt. Some people achieve Hall of Fame worthy highlights or turn their careers around and save themselves. Others came to a harsh reality in 2024 that they aren't the golden children of this new regime, or suffered significant setbacks that they'll have to work hard to turn around for the better in 2025.

Whether they thrived under the spotlight or faltered when opportunity knocked, let's look at some of this year's biggest winners and losers on the WWE roster and break down what made them so triumphant or heartbreaking in 2024.

10. Winner: Cody Rhodes

Cody Rhodes may be leaving 2024 on a stretcher from a piledriver delivered by one of his good friends Kevin Owens, but he is unmistakenly one of the biggest winners of this year.

Advertisement

Only the purposefully contrarian wrestling fans who have to reject the mainstream and find something to complain about 24/7 will roll their eyes at this assessment, because it is just a fact that he's had a monstrously successful year.

At WrestleMania 39, he came up short, had a rubber chicken thrown into the ring as he cried in his loss. In 2024, he became a back-to-back two-time Royal Rumble winner (putting him in a league with only a handful of Hall of Fame legends), superseded The Rock of all people to dethrone Roman Reigns 1000+ day reign as double champion, in the main event of WrestleMania XL—a tentpole, new era birthing event—and has since retained that title all while also winning the first-ever Crown Jewel Championship to further cement his status as the top dog in the company.

His merchandise sales remain in the top tier, his popularity is barely wavering in the mainstream sense, and he's even managed to temporarily live out another dream with the one-off resurgence of the Winged Eagle WWE Championship title.

This has been The American Nightmare's year, and here's hoping 2025 is another great one for Cody Rhodes.

9. Loser: Giovanni Vinci

This list isn't ranked, but if there had to be a spot for the overall biggest loser of 2024 in WWE, Giovanni Vinci stands out as the top candidate. Ironically, it's the one thing he could actually win this year.

Advertisement

Out of 26 matches this year, Vinci was on the winning side a whopping two times. Those wins weren't anything to be excited about, either, as one was over Apollo Crews (also on this list) on an episode of Main Event—a show nobody watches, to the point WWE barely ever acknowledges its existence—and a tag team match from February alongside Ludwig Kaiser.

The latter was before Vinci was booted out of Imperium, where he was made to look like a complete and utter failure that Gunther and Kaiser were better off not having around, as he was more of a nuisance than a helper.

He was then missing for the next few months, only to come back with vignettes of his old gimmick from NXT that never worked the first time.

Upon returning, Vinci lost two matches to Crews immediately, being absolutely humiliated, and was promptly sent back to losing dark matches instead of remaining on television.

At no point in 2024 was Vinci to be taken seriously, and it's doubtful that will change in 2025.

8. Winner: Liv Morgan

Who would have thought Liv Morgan would be the primary focal point of the Raw women's division for essentially the entire year and still be on top as its reigning champion heading into 2025?

Advertisement

While she's had success before, cashing in her Money in the Bank briefcase to win her first world title in 2022, she had a rough 2023 and bounced back from her injury hiatus with The Liv Morgan Revenge Tour. This angle of getting back at Rhea Ripley for causing her injury, subsequently injuring Ripley herself in the process, and taking that heat into beating Becky Lynch for the Women's World Championship was a blessing in disguise.

By now, Morgan and Ripley have reached a status where they are among each other's greatest career enemies, and Morgan's spent all of 2024 retaining her title by hook or by crook, stealing away Dominik Mysterio, becoming a de facto leader of The Judgment Day, reaffirming her friendship with Raquel Rodriguez who is now acting as her bodyguard for extra protection, and has also won the Crown Jewel Championship to further establish her as a legit champion, rather than someone who won the title on a fluke like the last time.

7. Loser: Odyssey Jones

Was Odyssey Jones just doomed to fail in WWE, as if he were cursed, or did he make this bed himself and was forced to lay in it?

Advertisement

This guy had some charisma to him and moved impressively well for someone his size. On paper, he looked like a big star in the making with the potential to go far. And after being missing in action for over a year and a half for unknown reasons, WWE finally decided to use him as a new member of The New Day.

By all accounts, it seems the story would have played out where he would have become Big E's replacement, gotten a lot of heat during their heel turn, and been a big focal point. Instead, just a few weeks into this push, Jones was abruptly fired from WWE after allegations of domestic abuse came out against him.

To go from being injured in January 2022 and taking all the way until August 2024 to get back on track, just to throw it all away makes Jones one of the biggest busts from this year.

6. Winner: Nia Jax

How did Nia Jax go from consistently being on everyone's "worst" list and effectively being celebrated when she was released, to having as great of a year as she's had in 2024?! It's wild the transition that's happened, but she's strangely picked herself up and improved in ways that it feels earned that she's been so successful this year.

Advertisement

Nia's two major accomplishments in 2024 were winning the Queen of the Ring tournament back in May—which could have easily gone to plenty others, like runner-up Lyra Valkyria, and no one would have batted an eye—and not dropping the ball with that crown for long enough that when it came time to have Bayley drop the WWE Women's Championship, Jax was the most logical next in line.

Since then, Jax has held that title with a level of poise she didn't have in her last run back in 2018. She's also already doubled her time as champion, only lasting 70 days originally before dropping it back to Alexa Bliss, but now sitting at nearly 140 days as the top woman on SmackDown.

Her in-ring work has improved, her promos are the best they've ever been, and she's been able to silence a lot of haters while holding gold. What a great year for Nia Jax!

5. Losers: LWO and Legado del Fantasma

These two factions might as well be tied on this list, as they've accomplished about the same level of success in 2024—meaning, basically none whatsoever.

Advertisement

Arguably, if one has to top the other, Legado del Fantasma would be the worst. At least LWO won their match at WrestleMania XL, even if Andrade needed to step in to be better star power than the rest of the group. Legado had Dominik Mysterio swapped in just the same and still couldn't garner much heat.

Santos Escobar, as talented as he is, can't catch a break and actually get the job done on any given week on SmackDown. Worse are Elektra Lopez, Angel, and Berto, who have among the worst win-loss records in the entire company this year. Los Garza even had to create their own shirts, as WWE won't invest in giving them dedicated merchandise.

LWO doesn't have much more to offer, as the only accolade they've collectively had all year is Dragon Lee winning the meaningless Speed Championship. They've done nothing but fill in the blank on Raw, arbitrarily feuding and mostly losing to random opponents.

In a kayfabe sense, Carlito even saw it as an upgrade to leave that group and be a joke in The Judgment Day instead. If that's greener grass on the other side, yikes!

4. Winner: Damian Priest

Damian Priest started off 2024 already with riches in his hands as Señor Money in the Bank and one-half of the semi-unified Raw and SmackDown tag team champions alongside Finn Balor.

Advertisement

While WrestleMania XL would see him lose those titles, that loss was quickly brushed aside for trading in that Money in the Bank briefcase for the World Heavyweight Championship at the start of WrestleMania Sunday. In one fell swoop, Priest went from a tag team champion and upper-midcarder to a world champion who had one of the most effective and interesting cash-ins to date.

This not only broke a curse that had been plaguing Money in the Bank winners for several years of failures, but allowed him to walk out of the biggest event of the year at the start of a new era as the top champion on the flagship show Monday Night Raw. Talk about impressive.

Priest had an enviable run with the belt, lasting all the way until the midway checkpoint of the year at SummerSlam, where he lost to one of the most dominant wrestlers of the past decade, and only because of interference. He still remains a top guy who will hopefully continue to stay in the upper echelon for quite some time.

3. Losers: The Final Testament

How does a group like The Final Testament, who has a Hall of Famer talker, a skilled manager in Scarlett, one of the most imposing tag teams in Akam and Rezar, and at one point, the most dominant person in NXT, Karrion Kross, perpetually look like fools? They're supposed to have this dark, edgy, vicious mystique to themselves, but they end up coming across like a bunch of pitiful try-hards who claim to be a force to be reckoned with, but have nothing to show for it.

Advertisement

At the start of this year, they had some momentum in their feud with The Pride, but that quickly dissipated with their loss at WrestleMania XL. Since then, they've mostly been obsessed with trying to recruit other losers to their ranks, and they've mostly failed at that, too!

Their biggest win in all of 2024 has been barely sneaking a victory over The Wyatt Sicks, who could arguably also be on this list, so that win ultimately means nothing.

The Final Testament has proven itself to be less about biblical wrath and doomsday prophecies and more of a cautionary tale about being lost wandering in the desert of the roster.

2. Winner: Tony D'Angelo

While there are others on the main roster who have had a great year, like Gunther, Bron Breakker, and The Bloodline as a whole, NXT shouldn't be overlooked, and there is a case to be made that no one has had more overall success in quantity than Tony D'Angelo.

Advertisement

The Don of NXT hasn't made as big of a splash at the forefront compared to the top champions of Roxanne Perez and Trick Williams, but he has made waves in every other aspect, and more consistently.

At the start of the year, he was a reigning tag team champion alongside Channing "Stacks" Lorenzo. After dropping those titles, he defeated Charlie Dempsey to win the NXT Heritage Cup—something that doesn't regularly fit his character at all.

That wasn't long-lived, but he then turned things around again after dropping that back to Charlie Dempsey, by beating Oba Femi to win the NXT North American Championship, which he currently still holds. Not only is it impressive to win a title, but to beat the unstoppable record-breaking champion, who has never lost to anyone BUT D'Angelo, is crazy.

If D'Angelo wins the NXT Championship at some point in 2025, he'll have achieved a Grand Slam status that no one else has, and it's certainly within his grasp after his tremendous 2024.

1. Loser: Apollo Crews

Is there a less impactful member of the main roster right now than Apollo Crews? It's sad to say, as he's extremely talented, but if he weren't even in the company right now, most people wouldn't even notice.

Advertisement

Despite his impressive athleticism, Crews has struggled for the majority of his WWE career. His pushes ebb and flow, where he's had some years winning Intercontinental and United States Championships, and other years—like this one—where he has nothing to show for it whatsoever and it's a surprise he's survived the latest rounds of being released.

At this time of publication, Crews has wrestled 27 matches in 2024. He's only won 9 of those. All but two of them were dark matches (meaning they don't air, ever, and effectively don't count). Those two he did score on television were against Giovanni Vinci, of all people. Every single other win was also either against Vinci, or equally low-tier talent in Angel, Berto, Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson.

It's sad that the highest point of his career in 2024 was when he was randomly paired up with Baron Corbin for a few weeks in a team that gained no ground, as after Corbin's release, Crews has been largely unseen.

Advertisement