5 Major Mistakes WWE Made With The Superstar Shake-up
Aha Shake Heartbreak
The 'Superstar Shake-up' represents one of WWE's least jarring linguistic quirks. Whilst "building momentum" "creates separation" between one's self and sanity, the rebadged draft actually kicks open a few declarative doors.
At home with the fun of a pun, cups runneth over with possible wordplays thanks to the prevalence of 'Shake' in the history of pop culture. Others on this site and elsewhere will have made lemonade with Raw's lemons and chicken salad from Miz' exceptional turn as SmackDown Live!'s newest chickensh*t - the Superstar Shake-up is indeed kind to the layman lexicographer.
It's supposed to be nice to the performers too.
It seems safe to presume with relative assurance (the only true assurance in 2018) that Shelton Benjamin won't be headlining a pay-per-view in the near future, but even he got some microphone time before re-announcing himself as a singles star with a choice contest against Jeff Hardy. He lost his partner Chad Gable to Raw via a post-show announcement on WWE.com - a fairly clear indication that WWE are making some of this up as they go along.
Maybe that's why they were in some cases so negligent? SmackDown Live! looks on paper to house one of the most talent-heavy rosters in recent history, whilst Raw's bloat wasn't reduced by taking the blue brand's scraps 24 hours earlier.
Perhaps the company booked the entire thing to vindicate Triple H's pre-WrestleMania remarks about Kurt Angle being an 'idiot'. It would at least offer some storyline justification for some fairly significant slip-ups.
5. Redistribution Of Dearth
The undercard quotient on both Raw and SmackDown Live! was worryingly high before this year's Superstar Shake-up. Few performers these days are permitted to breakout stars on their own steam as it is. Lower card performers are invariably booked as struggling losers.
In certain cases though, it's an understandable and necessary evil of having such large rosters, and one of the reasons why such these annual switch-arounds are a necessity in the separate brands era.
Unfortunately, most of the rank-and-file jumped with little or no fanfare, suggesting that they'll take up exactly the same talent enhancement role but on a different night of the week.
Did you give a sh*t that The Ascension moved to Raw? Did you even notice that Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows went in the opposite direction? R-Truth was probably only in Wednesday discussions due to a bizarre oversell from The New Day that seemed intent on teasing Hulk Hogan before revealing the shambling fool to engage in some lame handshake craic with Tye Dillinger.
In hindsight, less was probably more on the lower rungs of the ladder. Make changes, sure, but 19 and 17 switches on Raw and SmackDown Live! respectively seemed unnecessarily high as it was happening. Halving the number of journeymen travellers could have calmed that down.
4. Trial Separation
WWE were keen to promote the usual 'anyone can move' malarkey ahead of this year's shake-up, but few trades actually made use of the potentially chaotic circumstances.
Shelton Benjamin and Chad Gable - a pairing stuck together with chewing gum when Jason Jordan went off to Raw to deal with his daddy issues - were pulled apart at their weak seams despite only just recently getting over. Why waste this gimmick on a duo with gas in the tank?
Titus Worldwide have been a long-abandoned punchline on Monday Night Raw for so long that they were somehow deigned as being below new blue brand refugee Dolph Ziggler on the WWE totem pole. How, logically, can Apollo Crews think affiliation with Titus O'Neil has helped his career?
Meanwhile, Sheamus and Cesaro look to have exhausted most or all opponents thanks to a largely prosperous last 18 months. The time - if not now - was very soon for the 'Swiss Superman' in particular to have another bite of the cherry as a solo star. Sheamus wasn't likely to prosper, but coming off the best main roster run of his career would have given him the best possible chance.
3. Locked Up
God bless Jimmy and Jey Uso for sticking with WWE when virtually the entire fanbase were no longer attached to them.
After years of fighting hard for an opportunity only to end up playing hard in the f*cking paint, The Usos' summer 2016 heel turn didn't just reinvent a knackered act. It revitalised an entire division.
Taking tips from some of the dynamic duels in NXT that year, Jimmy and Jey set about turning 2017 into the year pairs gained primacy on a main roster ran by a man that doesn't like to waste wages on tag team wars.
This in itself wasn't remotely problematic, but The Usos have ran through so many teams so often now that there seems so little for them to even do on SmackDown Live!, regardless of the new blood.
Even blue brand newbies The Bar had a one-off with them so memorable that a 'new' feud this year would have that WWE 'superservice' rematch stench about it.
An explosive programme awaited with The Revival on Raw, not to mention their first significant interactions with Roman Reigns since they got to play Steiner Brothers to his Lex Luger back in 2015. Jimmy and Jey will have to confound expectations for another year, instead of being presented with their just rewards on the red brand.
2. Boots To Lasses
Becky Lynch has been the quiet cornerstone of SmackDown Live!'s inconsistent women's division since the shows first broke apart in mid-2016.
As inaugural Women's Champion, safe pair of hands and all round good egg, the 'Irish Lass Kicker' was never not assured if a little underwhelming as a spunky babyface without strong heels. When she finally encountered one in Alexa Bliss, 'The Goddess' was unfortunately too good at being bad. Lynch faced off with a better Sports Entertainer and lost, and was shunted back down to just being a great wrestler for the remainder of the year alongside eventual new blue brand leader Charlotte.
Though always over with audiences, she never returned to such heights, and could have injected much-needed life into a Raw women's division still on life support thanks to months of abysmal booking.
A swap with either Bayley or Sasha would have actually been the ideal - keeping the Four Horsewomen apart allows for the eventual buzz of a Shield/3MB-esque potential reunion. Though frozen for now, the four are anything but fresh in their roles, and just as likely to go stale as they are to get reheated.
1. No Quips, Just Sh*t
The biggest indictment of the NXT-to-WWE treadmill (as of this writing, anyway), The Revival's injury-hit 2017 doesn't compare with the creative brick wall that's been 2018.
Crack after crack in their once rock solid visage was papered over with the usual 'let it play out and see where it goes' patter - particularly prevalent after D-Generation-X and The Bálor Club squashed them like bugs in a deeply dispiriting jolly boys outing on the wretched Raw 25.
Triple H was front and centre of the assault, marking rare time he was willing to dust off his old shovel on one of his NXT success stories. If Dawson and Dash have even lost 'The Game', they've lost the war.
A move to SmackDown Live! regardless of those that got to stay put on the blue brand would have been the quickest of fixes for the talented old-time twosome. The shorter run-time doesn't downplay the importance of in-ring action - the main area in which The Revival thrive.
As is, they'll remain on Raw wrestling (and potentially still losing) short television contests to an even more inferior crop of doubles acts than those there before.