5 Most Notable NXT Alumni (Who Never Had A TakeOver Match)
28 Events. 98 Performers. Who never made the cut?
NXT has undoubtedly been the best thing under the WWE umbrella for some time now. Since its debut in 2012, it has consistently garnered acclaim for the quality of its wrestling and storytelling, though many fans are only now experiencing it for the first time following the moving of its weekly show to the USA network and the inclusion of its performers on this year’s Survivor Series card.
The cornerstone of NXT are its TakeOver events. Just 4-5 are held per year, usually with five matches per card. This ‘less-is-more’ approach makes every bout mean something and as a result, every single event from Arrival in 2014 to last week’s third WarGames iteration has been well-received. This is something of an incredible accomplishment given that the company often struggles to put on two great ‘main roster’ events in a row – 28 would be unfathomable!
Now that the majority of the WWE roster (64/109 of Raw and SmackDown’s current ranks) have come through the NXT system, almost everybody has had a taste of the TakeOver spotlight over the last six years, with 98 different performers (active and alumni) in total having performed at least at one event.
There are a handful of exceptions, however. Here are five (technically eight) of the most notable, excluding those that graduated from NXT in 2012/13 before TakeOvers became a thing, such as Seth Rollins, Bray Wyatt, Rusev and Big E.
5. Liv Morgan/Sonya Deville
The majority of NXT call-ups are calculated affairs. The wrestler or wrestlers being promoted typically wrap up their ongoing storyline and have a send-off match either on television or at a TakeOver, more often than not putting over the next talent in line.
Some come completely out of the blue, however, usually when an influx of new bodies are needed for an upcoming programme. The announcement of the first ever women’s Royal Rumble match presumably led to the realisation that there were nowhere near the requisite amount of female performers on the roster and five were hastily drafted in. Just one of these, Ruby Riott, had ever had a TakeOver match, whilst Mandy Rose and Sarah Logan hadn’t appeared on NXT outside of a few throwaway appearances. Liv Morgan and Sonya Deville, meanwhile, were just in the throes of establishing themselves on the brand after a handful of appearances as enhancement talent.
Shoehorned into stables - the Riott Squad for Morgan and Absolution for Deville - the pair probably could’ve used some extra time in Florida to get experience of longer storyline programmes and pay-per-view events. Both have been floundering for some time now, Deville less so than Morgan given that she actually appears on television from time to time. Now that NXT is held in the same regard as Raw and SmackDown, could a move back and an eventual TakeOver spotlight for either be on the cards?
4. Lacey Evans
Another mass NXT call-up occurred in late 2018, when vignettes began to air for the debuts of four individuals and one tag team. Of those, only Lars Sullivan was seemingly planned at first, given that he’d already been subject to a weeks-long hype campaign. Ironically, he has probably fared worst out of any of his counterparts bar EC3 at this point.
Two female performers were part of this group. The first, Nikki Cross, was well-established in NXT, having taken part in several angles as part of the Sanity stable before continuing to jostle for the women’s championship on TakeOvers afterwards. The second, Lacey Evans, was beginning to find her feet on the brand, having established herself as a heel earlier in the year. However, she'd only had one programme of note, a one-sided rivalry with Kairi Sane, which was wrapped up solely on television.
TakeOver opportunities are far more limited for female performers given that there is only usually one women’s match as opposed to four men’s bouts. The only non-title matches that have ever been featured were Asuka’s initial matches (against Dana Brooke and Emma in 2015), Ember Moon’s debut and the recent Io Shirai/Candice LeRae cage encounter. This may change going forwards given the wealth of talent on the roster, but it means that alumna like Evans that were never quite main eventers will always stand out.
3. Heavy Machinery
Otis and Tucker are one of the most popular acts on the SmackDown’s tag team scene at present. Whilst they may become champions at some point, they don’t currently need the titles to be relevant, with Otis’ entertainment value both in and out of the ring is keeping their stock high. Tucker functions as the duo’s straight man and together, they have their act nailed.
Called up to the main roster alongside the aforementioned Lacey Evans at the back end of last year, Heavy Machinery were quite well established in NXT. Their run was probably intended to be much longer, given that they only had a couple of throwaway title matches on TV against the Authors of Pain and the Undisputed Era during the 18 month tenure.
Most notable teams are eventually given at least one proper championship programme that culminates in a TakeOver encounter. Otis and Tucker may have been next in line after the Undisputed Era’s late-2018 rivalries with fellow face teams Oney Lorcan & Danny Burch and Mustache Mountain, but their main roster move curtailed any possibility of that.
As a result, they stand as the only major NXT tag team that never got to enter the ring at a TakeOver event and we’ll never know how a potential title-winning Otis worm would’ve gone down in front of a rapturous Full Sail crowd.
2. Alexa Bliss/Carmella
From a female standpoint, the early years of NXT were dominated by two groups. The first, the trailblazing trifecta of Paige, Emma and Summer Rae paved the way for the ‘Four Horsewomen’ – Charlotte Flair, Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks and Bayley – who have now knocked down seemingly every barrier in their ascension to main event glory.
After Charlotte won the NXT women’s title at the initial TakeOver event in 2014, some combination of the four women were the participants in the championship match at the next six events, freezing out anyone else that came in during that time, including Alexa Bliss and Carmella.
Both were featured more as valets than wrestlers during their NXT tenures, with Carmella accompanying Enzo Amore and Colin Cassady to the ring and Alexa Bliss evolving from ‘glitter princess’ into the heel we know her as today through her management of Blake and Murphy.
The reintroduction of the brand split in 2016 necessitated a mass of call ups and both Alexa and Carmella were drafted to SmackDown. They were both in NXT limbo somewhat at the time given that Enzo and Cass had been promoted, Blake and Murphy had been broken up and Asuka and Nia Jax had come into the women’s main event scene at TakeOvers to fill the void left by Sasha, Becky and Charlotte.
Both have done fantastically since; their somewhat stark NXT runs an afterthought in the wake of their runs with the Raw and SmackDown women’s championships.
1. Elias
Elias is one of the few performers who has fared much better on the main roster than on NXT. This is a rare occurrence, given that almost everybody is elevated and made to look strong during their developmental tenure before they inevitably become mid-carders or jobbers after any initial attention they are given on Raw or SmackDown dies down.
Elias Samson, as he was known before he became subject to Vince McMahon’s random love of monomial names (see also: Cesaro, Rusev, Big E, etc.), was hated during his initial run in Florida, attracting levels of ‘X-Pac heat’ that had only really been seen previously during Bo Dallas’ forceful presentation as a generic babyface.
Booed incessantly during his performances on the guitar or in the ring, ‘The Drifter’ seemed destined for obscurity. Reactions to his initial push led to his announced match with Apollo Crews at TakeOver: Dallas being relegated to television instead. A subsequent injury and general apathy about his return meant he never came close to that level again, though he did win the crowd over with his final appearance (after coming up short in a loser leaves NXT match) as ‘El Vagabundo’, a very thinly disguised take on his persona.
Now that Elias has performed in a high profile slot at WrestleMania, his lack of TakeOver appearances probably doesn’t keep him up at night. He will always stand out as perhaps the most notable name to not have one on his CV, however.