5 Things AEW MUST Do In 2021 (And 5 They Must Avoid)

Putting the AEW World Title on Sting in 2021? That's not Dynamite...

By Andy H Murray /

AEW

An eventful first full year of operations brought triumph and tragedy to All Elite Wrestling, a promotion that has already weathered more storms than one would expect in a lifespan ten times as long.

Advertisement

2020's end changed AEW's tone forever. Brodie Lee's passing means things will never be the same on Dynamite, and nor should they be. A 41-year-old father, husband, and professional wrestler beloved by his fans and peers universally, his Celebration of Life was as beautiful as it was gutwrenching. May AEW continue to honour his legacy throughout this new year, whether that means a simple "it's Wednesday, you know what that means" each week, realigning The Dark Order, or more. Either way, the group will keep doing right by the Huber family.

In business terms, AEW and TNT must be pleased with how things have done in this pandemic-stricken world. Gates are down, depriving Tony Khan's company of an important revenue stream, but with Dynamite beating WWE NXT in every single week of the Wednesday Night Wars, pay-per-view buyrates staying steady, and buzz peaking with Sting's debut in early December, things could be a lot worse.

Advertisement

Things are trending in the right direction as AEW strides into what looks like another difficult year. Here's how they can keep it that way...

AVOID...

5. Replacing 'The Exalted One'

AEW

Replacing Brodie Lee is a bad idea. There isn't another Brodie Lee.

Advertisement

The Dark Order's 'Exalted One' was a unique performer. Characters like his namesake, Bruiser Brody, have done the "intelligent monster" thing before, but not with Jon Huber's range. P*ss-funny one moment and utterly terrifying the next, he was well-spoken, razor-sharp, and captivating. A four-dimensional performer, his in-ring was just as varied and not just to the usual "agile for a big man" degree, as the 41-year-old proved himself a match layout master. Inside the ring and out, his mind was his most potent tool.

Whatever AEW does with The Dark Order going forward, a new 'Exalted One' isn't the move. Lee is irreplaceable. As sweet and kind as the idea is, Erick Rowan shouldn't sweep into AEW, and neither should John Silver, Evil Uno, or even Hangman Page. Only Brodie, whose ultimate endgame was to take these downtrodden souls and lift them up, can hold that mantle.

Advertisement

A completely new direction makes more sense for the Order, who should now press forward as a babyface unit. Besides, why would they need a new leader in the first place? With each member considerably stronger than before they met Lee, Brodie accomplished his mission. He did it.

4. Cinematic Fluff

AEW

The pandemic forced wrestling promotions to great creative with how they presented matches. Keen to bring variety to an audience turned off by lifeless empty arenas, they looked to Matt Hardy's Deletion saga, the original Halftime Heat, and WCW's so-bad-they-were-kind-of-hilarious mini-movies of the '90s for inspiration, resulting in the divisive cinematic match trend.

Advertisement

WWE peaked early, with WrestleMania 36's Boneyard and Firefly Fun House bouts head and shoulders above anything the promotion has attached the cinematic label to since then. AEW, meanwhile, delivered the rollicking Stadium Stampede at Double Or Nothing in May, then lapsed, badly, with Tooth and Nail and the Elite Deletion.

The overwhelmingly poor reception to those last two matches means AEW should steer away from such things in 2021. Besides, the cinematic trend within its first two months of existence. Everything since then has ranged from "meh" to "abysmal," regardless of promotion, proving that even with diminished crowds, nothing works better than traditional wrestling done well.

Advertisement

3. Kenny Omega: Sports Entertainer

AEW

That Kenny Omega won the AEW World Championship in a very un-AEW manner rang early alarm bells amongst purists who'd rather All Elite stuck to its original promise of sport-like presentation.

Advertisement

With Omega wiped out after being launched into a heater, Impact Wrestling's Don Callis hit the apron, distracting the referee long enough to slip 'The Best Bout Machine' the microphone he used to fell Jon Moxley. It made sense in-character, as winning this way after making a "gentlemen's agreement' with Mox gave Omega the opportunity to add hypocrisy to his growing list of heel traits, and the match was generally well-received. Regardless, the villainous 'Cleaner' was still a new character in this universe. There are currently few ways of telling whether this will become a habit or not.

It shouldn't.

Advertisement

Rather than putting heat on Omega and Callis, regularly resorting to tired, Sports Entertainment tropes would make fans weary of Kenny and his World Title reign, despite his popularity. AEW is a clean finish territory. On occasions, they will use a distraction, countout, or disqualification to further a storyline, but going full Bullet Club (who got over because their Western heel tactics clashed with NJPW's clean presentation style) won't work here.

AEW has built a great level of trust with its audience, who tune in safe in the knowledge that matches will actually finish. They'd be wise not to violate that.

Advertisement

2. A Complete Impact Wrestling Invasion

AEW

The Impact Wrestling/AEW deal is ticking along nicely.

Advertisement

Don Callis' union with Kenny Omega was born of a red-hot angle drawing from years of history, and their promos have been excellent. Jon Moxley is established as the perfect face to chase 'The Best Bout Machine'. Last week's "Bullet Club: reunion was hot, with Karl Anderson and Doc Gallows a perfect tandem to bring over from Nashville. On Saturday, the follically-challenged duo team with Kenny to face Rich Swann and the Motor City Machine Guns at Impact's Hard to Kill pay-per-view.

At this stage in the game, it's important not to overcook it. A full-on WCW/WWE style invasion of either promotion would be just that.

Advertisement

Nevermind that such storylines rarely play out in a satisfying way, Impact's star power, unfortunately, isn't there. The promotion doesn't have an army strong enough to compete with AEW's biggest and baddest. Women's division aside (Jordynne Grace and Deonna Purrazzo would both rule AEW's scene), Impact's thin top-of-the-card ranks host Sami Callihan, Eddie Edwards, Moose, and others. Good wrestlers, but stars the calibre of Jon Moxley, Chris Jericho, and Cody Rhodes?

1. Put The World Title On Sting

AEW

This is it: the big NOPE.

Advertisement

All Elite Wrestling won't put its World Title on Sting. No move would destroy everything that promotion purports to be like a 61-year-old WCW legend sweeping into the main event scene and taking the top prize in a very WWE move, making this comfortably the most obvious thing for AEW to dodge in 2021.

The level of trust Tony Khan and co. have built with the audience suggests they'll avoid this more than anything. Nothing about the company's current booking practices could lead to the 'Icon' taking the World Title from a Kenny Omega or other heel champion. Nonetheless, how bad an idea this would be necessitates its inclusion here.

Advertisement

Sting his a huge global wrestling star whose debut generated mass excitement, but that's the only argue for strapping him. Nothing else stacks up. He hasn't worked a match in years and may not be able to take a bump, let alone compete outside the cinematic arena, so while AEW do need to evolve his role beyond "hits the ring and stares down Team Taz", this ain't it, chief.

DO...

5. Find A More Consistent Tone

AEW

The level of creative freedom afforded to AEW's expressive talent roster is one of the company's greatest strengths, and shouldn't be tempered to the point of autocracy, though the jarring tonal shifts that make so many B-level Marvel movies difficult to take seriously are often prevalent on Dynamite.

Advertisement

Comedy is one of the most subjective artforms, even more so in wrestling. When an AEW card veers from a tough, gritty Eddie Kingston promo to unfiltered wackiness, it feels like an entirely different show. Mimosa Mayhem and Jon Moxley vs. MJF existing on the same card made AEW feel like a boxful of pieces that don't fit together, rather than a complete puzzle.

If professional wrestling is to be a variety show - a buffet - a consistent tone must still run through everything. AEW is getting better at honing this and they get slack for being a young promotion, but it should still be addressed in 2021. Cody Rhodes' sport-like leanings most fit alongside something like the Miro and Kip Sabian vs. Best Friends storyline. That may be more effective at capturing a wider audience than the unkempt patchwork quilt Dynamite resembles at its most inconsistent.

Advertisement

4. Another Major Eddie Kingston Feud

AEW

Eddie Kingston signing with AEW was a rare feel-good moment in a year largely devoid of them, and just reward for almost two decades spent scrapping, clawing, and pulling his way through the independent circuit.

Advertisement

AEW has provided a perfect home for Kingston. Here, he can cut his raw, rugged, industry-best promos without a filter, building himself a new legion of fans in the process. That he's so real and believable on the microphone may eventually prove his greatest hindrance, as AEW know Eddie can eat big losses and immediately recover any lost heat the next time he grabs the stick. Still, he must be pushed into featured feuds and storylines throughout 2021, at least one of which should be as focused as last year's war with Jon Moxley.

Though short, their feud was a riveting, gut-wrenching masterpiece, and a beautiful tragedy in the end, as Mox finally killed King's dream by wrapping barbed wire around his forearm and applying the Bulldog Choke. Realistically, Eddie was never going to win. How could anyone usurp Moxley?

Advertisement

But he made you believe: and that's what professional wrestling is all about.

Put Kingston in more programmes of this stature and AEW's own army of believers will grow.

Advertisement

3. Tiered Television

AEW

We already know that AEW is working on bringing a second show to TNT. The ongoing global health crisis has complicated matters, slowing progress to a crawl, and it may still be later rather than sooner before it sees the light of day, but rest assured, it's coming. Tony Khan confidently reassures us of this whenever the topic is brought up on media calls.

Advertisement

The AEW chief has also spoken on the possibility of reconfiguring the current setup, saying the following on the pre-Winter is Coming call last month:-

"We've built a really big roster and it's hard to use everybody, but at the same time, we do need to keep developing talent and bring people in. That's where Dark has become valuable and I've extended the length of Dark and I'm seriously considering splitting Dark into multiple developmental shows. And possibly even having "one that is more of a developmental show and one that is more established talent, or maybe a mix of the two."

He's onto something here, Tony. This is a very, very good idea.

Advertisement

Often bothering three hours in runtime, Dark is a bloated show that necessitates cherry-picking. It serves its purpose of padding records, giving out-of-work indie wrestlers a payday, and giving AEW the opportunity to scout potential signings in the flesh, but going down the developmental route would at least help with the bloat and give up-and-comers the opportunity to build a rep on their own, without knowing they're going to get smashed by whatever full-time star they face at the moment.

Dynamite should always be the prestige show. The new one-hour broadcast on TNT can represent a level down, and Dark developmental. A fluid tiering system to bolster AEW's robust rankings system and invisible roster hierarchy.

Advertisement

2. Give MJF The Keys

AEW

Professional wrestling is a star-driven business. The sport cannot return to the mainstream without building characters and personalities that people outside the bubble will change the channel to watch, and there is a dearth of those at the moment.

Advertisement

Star creation is often a long, slow-burning process, though AEW has made a good start with people like Orange Cassidy, Darby Allin, and, indeed, MJF. Deftly using more established names in Cody Rhodes and Chris Jericho to build these performers up will keep the promotion rolling long after the veterans have retired and after doing such a fine job with them in 2020, 2021 is the year they should send at least one stratospheric.

MJF is the shout, here. He has perfected his heel act, cuts great promos weekly, and has demonstrated through high-profile matches with Rhodes and Jungle Boy that his in-ring is quickly catching up with the rest of the act. Furthermore, his current role as a gloriously insincere Inner Circle member sets him up for the perfect trigger-pulling moment, turning on Jericho to leave AEW's signature faction in ruins, hopping closer to megastardom in the process.

Advertisement

A run with the AEW World Title wouldn't be the worst idea either, perhaps taking it from Hangman Page after the former Elite man ends Kenny Omega's reign.

1. Build The Women's Division

AEW

"Give them more television time!" is frequently spouted as a solution to AEW's women's division woes, often without taking business into account. Pundits often fail to note that Britt Baker aside, Dynamite quarter-hours featuring women's wrestling suffer regular viewership drops, so the solution isn't as simple as increasing match counts and runtimes.

Advertisement

Baker is the blueprint for recovery.

Britt sparks growth because she is the one woman in the company that AEW has gone out of its way to develop. She has a clear, understandable character and a strong personality, having been granted more opportunities to build herself up than anyone else. Even Hikaru Shida, the long-reigning Women's Champion, has struggled to develop any discernible character traits. Who is 'The Full Metal Champion'? What makes her tick? Why should we invest in her as a person, not just a fighter?

Advertisement

Nobody knows, because AEW hasn't tried to answer these questions itself.

Having a subpar women's division isn't good enough in 2021. AEW's task is to build it into a money and audience-drawing part of their product by building personalities and leaning on fully-formed performers like Serena Deeb and Thunder Rosa to lift a green roster up. Let's not forget that many of these people are wrestling on television for the first time.

Advertisement