5 Things AEW Must Steal From WCW (And 5 It Shouldn’t!)
WCW is Tony Khan's historical guide to turning AEW into a true WWE competitor.
WCW was derided when it whimpered out of business and got gobbled up by one-time rival Vince McMahon for a modest sum back in 2001. The formerly-competitive promotion's final year was like a handy guide to future promoters on what not to do, but time has been kind to 'Dubya-C-Dubya'.
People miss it, which is why AEW's relationship with TNT/TBS was like a welcome hug for old school fans when Dynamite launched in 2019. Tony Khan's product was immediately presented as the future of pro wrestling, but it did have a retro flair many enjoyed (and continue to do so in 2023).
Now, with Collision launching on 17 June, the WCW comparisons have started all over again. Khan's new show has a distinctly Nitro-esque aesthetic already, but his latest weekly is more akin to Thunder than Eric Bischoff's Monday flagship. That might be true in more ways than one when it properly gets going.
So, what should AEW steal from WCW? Also, what should the company actively avoid doing post-Collision launch? Those who don't learn from the past are doomed to repeat it, they say.
That might not be the worst idea in some respects...
10. Yes: Themed Pay-Per-View Sets
Themed pay-per-view sets are the kind of thing you'll always see pop up on lists like this. Older fans yearn for the magnificence of Halloween Havoc 1998, or the glory of those big swinging hooks from Backlash 2001 over on the WWE side. That'll never change, and it's something Tony Khan should bring back.
Why not? He'd rule the roost here, because WWE is far too obsessed with giant screens and CGI overlays to bother with physical set piece design these days. WrestleMania is a notable exception, but WCW did it better overall. They actually always did, and a quick look back at classics on the Network/Peacock proves it.
There was a unique personality to most WCW sets during the 1990s, and that's the vibe TK should plunder. His pay-per-view stages, sadly, have started to drift into boring WWE territory. That's a missed opportunity when AEW only produces a handful of these specials per year.
They need to feel, well...special again.
9. No: Rampage Lingering Like Saturday Night
Rampage is dying, people.
The Friday night show is turning into WCW WorldWide; all it'd take is UK Channel 5 execs firing up some Batman from the 1960s-style sound effects when someone lands a steel chair shot. "Thwack!", "Crash!", "Thump!" etc. A. fairer comparison might be the old Saturday Night show that died a slow, miserable death.
Pre-Nitro, Saturday Night was the must-see WCW weekly. Whilst Rampage was always in the shadow of Dynamite, it did appear important when it landed in 2021. Less than two full years on, the show is about to usurped by a new addition to the lineup. The future does not look good, basically.
Tony Khan should cut the cord, man. He shouldn't let Rampage hang about stinking up the place like Saturday Night did between 1995-2000. If anything, watching Saturday Night in the summer of 2000 was like watching a totally different promotion to the one shown off on Nitro and Thunder.
AEW don't want that to become Rampage's fate.
8. Yes: Smarter Celebrity Involvement
AEW has hooked up with celebs like Mike Tyson, Shaquille O'Neal, Snoop Dogg and the cast of Impractical Jokers (to name a few), but they're trailing behind WWE when it comes to celebrity involvement. Bad Bunny and Logan Paul, for example, have both contributed massively to McMahon family coffers.
This is definitely something All Elite could be better at.
WCW received a ton of mainstream press when bad boy NBA star Dennis Rodman became an honorary member of the nWo. Hell, they've even had people talking for 23 years about actor David Arquette winning the World Title. Sure, fans laugh at that, but they're still talking.
Not one of AEW's celeb appearances has made anything close to the same impact. If you're going to use famous folks from outside the pro wrestling biz at all, then at least make sure they leave a mark. Who's going to recall JAS beating up the Impractical Jokers 20 years from now?
7. No: The Elite “B-Team”
The nWo will always be held aloft as ex-WCW boss Eric Bischoff's best idea. That rebellious unit still shifts merchandise today - it's a powerhouse of pro wrestling marketing, and the kind of thing Vince McMahon himself wishes he came up with. Of course, like most successful ideas, it was watered down beyond belief.
Remember the nWo 'B-team' goofs like Vincent, Scott Norton, Stevie Ray and the like? They let the nWo name live on via WCW house shows, but they did irreparable damage to the brand by appearing less than compared to top stars like Hollywood Hogan or The Outsiders.
Bullet Club Gold could become The Elite's version of that in AEW.
Jay White and Juice Robinson are soft allies of Kenny Omega, The Young Bucks and Hangman Page. The Elite is AEW's own stamp on the Bullet Club blueprint anyway, so bringing in some of their pals as an offshoot is risky.
Keep them separate, please!
6. Yes: Thunder’s Original Vision
Initially, Eric Bischoff didn't want anything to do with Thunder. Launching another WCW show in early-1998 wasn't his decision, but one handed down from the Turner overlords that he just had to deal with. So, Bisch decided that Thunder would have a chance if he was able to split the WCW roster in two.
That didn't happen in the end, but it was a fleeting thought for 'Easy E'. Bret Hart was supposed to be a linchpin star on Thursday nights, and Goldberg was all over Thunder's early promotion. It was almost like he and Hart would become Thunder exclusives whilst the nWo ran Nitro.
Food for thought, Mr. Khan. Rumours have been doing the rounds that AEW will soon spread its huge roster across Dynamite and Collision. In other words, All Elite would be running a WWE-style brand split, which is an idea Bischoff almost implemented first.
"You can only see CM Punk on Collision" wouldn't be the worst plan.
5. No: Giving Too Much “Creative Control”
Too many cooks, and all that.
WCW's "creative control" powers got out of hand towards the end of the 90s. It seemed like early wrestling news sites online and magazines were rammed full of stories like, 'WCW wanted Hulk Hogan to feud with *insert wrestler here*, but the 'Hulkster' vetoed that idea by playing his creative control card'.
AEW offers significantly more individual freedom creatively than WWE in 2023. Workers like Chris Jericho, Jon Moxley, Saraya and more have hefty input into what their characters do on screen. That's great on paper, but selfishness is a real concern - everybody wants the best for themselves, naturally.
This is presumably why Moxley is allowed to bleed all over the place during random bouts on Rampage, or why Jericho just gets to pick his own feuds. Tony Khan must be wary of handing over too much control, because all those chattering voices could be detrimental to the product.
Some will argue they already are.
4. Yes: Nitro’s 'Anything Can Happen' Style
Some will glance at the above image and start getting PTRD (Post-Traumatic Russo Disorder). No, his reign in charge of WCW creative was hardly sparkling, but Nitro did carry on that 'anything can happen here' style originally drummed up by Eric Bischoff in 1995. Russo married that with his car crash approach to TV.
Tony Khan can learn from the evils of that, but he can also jot down some handy notes when watching WCW's final year too. There was always something newsworthy going on. No, it wasn't always good, but Nitro did have a cliffhanger feel that at least tried to keep people coming back for more.
Meanwhile, Dynamite has become less and less of a must-see pro wrestling appointment for some fans. That's something AEW should look to avoid when Collision launches, because they don't want to see the ratings dwindle on Saturdays as well as Wednesdays.
AEW's weekly TV could do with a shot in the arm again.
3. No: Going 3 Hours On Dynamite/Collision
Sorry in advance for the acid reflux.
Raw has improved under Triple H's watch (for the most part), but WWE's flagship still suffers because three hours is just too long for a weekly wrestling program. WCW learned that firsthand back in the 90s when they turned Nitro into a bloated Monday night epic.
The temptation will always be there for promoters to add another hour. TV executives offer cold hard cash to produce just 60 minutes more, and costs for doing so are fairly low when companies are already set up for two hours anyway. However, most would agree this is something Tony Khan must avoid like the plague.
Dynamite and/or Collision going three hours would be horrific. Two hours is a sweet spot that should be protected, and there's simply no need to oversaturate the core fanbase by flinging even more content their way.
Consider this one thing AEW shouldn't steal from WWE as well as WCW.
2. Yes: The BattleBowl Concept
Tony Khan f*cking loves him a battle royal. AEW has booked endless amounts of the things since launching in 2019, and that'll probably never change. So, why not dig into the WCW archives for something WWE won't touch and bring the old BattleBowl concept to All Elite Wrestling?
No, don't instantly dismiss it. Let's explore!
BattleBowl was messy when WCW tried it between 1991-1993. Randomised teams came together in a "Lethal Lottery" to work odd couple tag matches, then the winners advanced to a souped up battle royal (the BattleBowl) to potentially earn a crack at the World Title.
Sounds convoluted, sure, but it was easier to follow than some might think. AEW adores a battle royal and multi-man tags in general, so Khan would be able to squeeze loads from BattleBowl. Of course, he'd likely have to rename it and put a fresh spin on things, but it's achievable.
Let battle commence. "AEW: EliteBowl", or something.
1. No: A Tony Khan World Title Reign
"Tony Khan has a special announcement" has become meme-worthy. It'd be unfair to say the AEW boss is desperate to push himself onto television, but his appearances have become more frequent over the years since All Elite started. Shivers will go up spines when imagining what could be coming next.
Yes, our Tony could feasibly become AEW World Champion.
If that sounds ridiculous, then examine wrestling's past. Vince Russo held the WCW World belt, and even Vince McMahon had a stupidly-short reign as WWF Champ before that. Khan shockingly winning AEW's top prize is not something anybody should rule out with confidence, 'cause pro wrestling is wild.
It shouldn't happen though. In fact, TK winning gold would be worse than either Russo or McMahon. One was an established onscreen heel, and the other (McMahon) was someone who'd shown his worth in various matches.
Please don't do this, Tony!
What else do you think AEW should and shouldn't steal from WCW? For more wrestling, check out 6 Ups & 0 Downs From AEW Rampage: Championship Friday (June 2) and 5 Ups & 7 Downs For AEW In 2023 (So Far)!