5 Ups & 10 Downs From WWE Royal Rumble 2022
Creatively devoid, disappointing Rumbles lack substance, go with obvious winners.
Welcome back to the dumpster fire that is WWE.
The company that prides itself on “telling stories” proceeded to waste one of its best vehicles to telling multiple stories at once, turning in two hugely disappointing Royal Rumble matches that accomplished the bare minimum of generating two winners, but little else.
The Rumble has always been an opportunity to start new feuds, give wrestlers a big push, or plant the seeds of conflict between competitors. These matches did none of that. Worse, neither Rumble had any suspense in who was winning. Once the eventual winner entered the match, it was readily apparent they were going to WrestleMania to challenge for a title. That’s a damning indictment of the lack of star power in the Rumbles and the piss-poor booking of both. A men’s final four that included Shane McMahon? Come on now…
Even though the women’s Rumble winner made sense and was the right call, it doesn’t make up for both matches under-delivering. The rest of the card was a mixed bag, with the wrestling being largely good, but the booking questionable.
All of this makes the last-minute shuffling at Day 1 look even worse and more short-sighted, just furthering the belief that WWE can’t do any long-term planning.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
10. Lashley Immobilized
Even if you set aside the interference in the WWE Championship match as being overbooked, you have to take note of how long Bobby Lashley had to sell during that ga-ga.
Brock Lesnar nailed an F-5 after escaping the Hurt Lock, but he inadvertently wiped out the referee, leaving only a visual pinfall. But then Roman Reigns ran down and speared Lesnar, wiped him out with the title belt, and walked off with Paul Heyman. All this time, Lashley had to lay on the mat like he had been shot.
While this isn’t a huge sin, it still is a pretty noticeable thing. It shouldn’t detract from Bobby’s big win, but they shouldn’t have booked such a long down period after a single F-5.
9. ‘Blood’ Feud Lacks Fire
WWE would have you believe that Naomi and Sonya Deville are locked in a heated feud, with Deville abusing her power as an official and Naomi constantly unable to overcome the obstacles put in front of her.
Saturday, Naomi got a measure of revenge when she eliminated Sonya from the Rumble… after Deville had tossed Naomi’s friend and former fellow Funkadactyl Cameron. Later, Deville pulled Naomi off the apron, eliminating her despite not being in the match.
Now, how would you react if you were Naomi? If you answered, “Pout, stomp slowly after Sonya, stop, wander around, get held back gently by a referee, then finally sit on the floor instead of chasing Sonya to the back,” you could be a WWE writer.
Seriously, how hard is it to book Deville retreating or having 2-3 refs hold a violently upset Naomi back? She looked like she was going to have a breakdown rather than break Sonya’s arm. Just pathetic and unrealistic.
8. Shane McMahon?
To every fan who cheers when Shane McMahon’s music hits: YOU are the problem.
WWE must hear the pop when Shane-O-Mac’s entrance theme hits and decides that fans love him, so they keep booking him in ridiculous spots like they did Saturday night. McMahon entered the Royal Rumble at #28, shrugged off two Kevin Owens superkicks and managed to toss KO, then went toe-to-toe with Drew McIntyre before he finally was eliminated later by Brock Lesnar.
Just. Go. Away. Seriously. No one wants to see the boss’ 52-year-old son beat up wrestlers who are busting their butts every week and are supposed to be the guys carrying the company the other 364 days of the year.
7. ‘Legends’ Serve As Cannon Fodder
After making a big show of how they had pulled in so many legends into this year’s women’s Royal Rumble match, you’d think that might mean they’d get a nice showing.
But instead, most legends who entered the Rumble was little more than a body in the ring, and in most cases just for a few seconds. Seven legends entered the Rumble and were eliminated before the next countdown had begun: Melina, Kelly Kelly, Cameron, Ivory, Summer Rae, Sarah Logan and Molly Holly.
Admittedly, none of these women really are considered highly revered legends (that would be your Lita, Bella Twins and Trish Stratus, for example), but it became really obvious by the time Ivory was tossed that these women were just there to fill out the numbers and collect a payday. In most cases, they barely got to flash a move.
It really was all about the momentary surprise, the entrance, and then the elimination. And when that happens more than a half-dozen times, it drags the match down.
6. Who Do You Cheer? Who Do You Boo?
The Raw Women’s Championship match was beset with a huge problem from the minute the bout was booked: Both Becky Lynch and Doudrop were ostensibly heels coming in, so it was impossible for fans to really rally behind either woman.
Lynch has been getting cheered, but she most certainly is booked as a heel, being forced to work to get fans to boo her. Doudrop has been a heel for a while now, but fans really don’t have any reason to react much to her either way.
The match between the two wasn’t bad, but the crowd was silent for large parts, waking up for big moves and near-falls. But it was clear that they weren’t energized or hanging on the action or story of the match.
Even then, what was the story? Heel champ Lynch fighting from underneath? The larger heel challenger Doudrop being unable to put Becky down? Those two narratives aren’t exactly compatible, and it showed.
5. A Lot Of Dead Time
The women’s Royal Rumble really could be divided into three sections: a good opening segment when Sasha Banks was in the match (tossed after #7), a star-studded finale (from about #28 on), and a mostly dull, large middle chunk.
Seriously, think back: What exciting moments happened from the time Banks was eliminated until Ronda Rousey came out. Oh sure, there were a couple small moments like Bianca Belair eliminating both Carmella & Queen Zelina at the same time and Naomi getting revenge on Sonya Deville, but it was a really slow, draggy match for a large portion of it.
Nearly half the field was either cameos from “legends” and Hall-of-Famers, or part-timers. Aside from Naomi and Sonya Deville, was there any big development to come from the match?
This was poorly laid out, focusing more on legends getting their bow during that period and some moderate action rather than an energetic, fun Rumble. This is a match where you maybe watch the last 7-8 minutes and that’s about it.
4. Charlotte’s Purpose?
Just trying to wrap some thoughts around Charlotte Flair’s Royal Rumble performance and how it factors into WrestleMania 38 plans, and we’re coming up a bit confused.
Flair entered the Rumble saying that if she won, she’d get to pick her opponent. Obviously, that didn’t happen. Instead, Ronda Rousey eliminated her last to win. Along the way, Charlotte tossed Lita, Rhea Ripley and Bianca Belair, among others.
Logically, the winner of the Rumble could pick Flair to face at WrestleMania, but Rousey just tossed her from the Rumble to win. So that would seem a bit odd. And the money match is Rousey versus Becky Lynch, with Ronda trying to get back her only WWE loss and the title that went with that defeat.
So, what does that mean for Charlotte? There would have been a built-in feud had Flair been eliminated by someone else – say, Lita – which could kick off a feud between them to lead to Mania. Instead, Charlotte tossed three potential challengers and was runner-up, meaning the heel champion has something to hold over all of them. That leaves a returning Asuka or Bayley as potential challengers.
Basically, if Rousey doesn’t pick Flair (which would be a strange move), then Charlotte being in the final two and tossing potential challengers was stupid.
3. Big E Deserves So Much Better
If you tuned into WWE for the first time since SummerSlam, you probably wouldn’t believe that Big E was WWE Champion less than a month ago.
E put Raw on his back the last couple of months and was rewarded with a last-minute decision to beat him for his title at Day 1 with a card change the day of the “premium live event.” Then he lost a #1 contender’s match and then match to Seth Rollins before being shuttled back to SmackDown.
Fans tried to soothe themselves by saying that this all was setting him up for a big run in the Royal Rumble, possibly vaulting him back into the main event scene.
NOPE. Big E entered at #26, eliminated no one, did nothing of note and was tossed by RK-Bro unceremoniously, so he wasn’t even around when Brock Lesnar entered the Rumble. For the record, Bad Bunny eliminated two men, and Shane McMahon tossed one.
A rapper and the 52-year-old son of the boss had better Rumbles than former WWE Champion Big E. But hey, let’s play it out and see where it goes…
2. Creatively Bankrupt Company Defaults
If you ever needed proof that WWE is creatively bankrupt and desperate, look no further than its two Royal Rumble winners Saturday night.
The Rumble long has been an opportunity to elevate a superstar and thrust them into the spotlight. We’ve seen it recently with Drew McIntyre and Bianca Belair. But WWE clearly had a “break glass” moment by signing Ronda Rousey and having her win the women’s Rumble, then have Brock Lesnar do a shock entry into the men’s Rumble, toss five men in minutes and win.
Lesnar had an easy path back to Roman after Reigns cost him the WWE Championship. There was no reason for him to win the Rumble and take away a storytelling vehicle for someone else – unless WWE hasn’t figured out who is going to be challenging for the WWE Championship yet.
Rousey winning isn’t a bad thing, but combined with Lesnar, it smacks of desperation – two wrestlers who had been out of the company for a while and were brought back to juice business, at the expense of elevating anyone else.
1. Creatively Bankrupt Company, Part 2
WWE.comIn addition to how crappy the pairing of the winners were, the worst development of the two Royal Rumble matches is how few actual developments there were. Rumbles are great opportunities to jumpstart feuds, further rivalries, or plant seeds for a future conflict.
Think about it for a second… there were no other big angles to come out of either Rumble: Ripley wasn’t eliminated by Nikki ASH (or vice versa); After a couple weeks of teasing, Rey and Dominik Mysterio weren’t even in the Rumble at the same time; RK-Bro barely had enough time together in the ring to shake hands before becoming cannon fodder for Brock; Bianca Belair didn’t eliminate anyone, despite being on a lot of people’s cards as a possible winner; Big E went out quiet as a mouse four weeks after losing his world title.
Bad Bunny got more attention and time to shine than the vast majority of the roster. Guys like Montez Ford, Rhea Ripley and Austin Theory could have had career-making performances, but they did nothing of note. Again, think for a second: Did anyone have a truly memorable performance outside of the winners?
If you can think of one good undercard storyline that was seeded during either Rumble, please speak up, because none are readily apparent. And that’s a clear sign that WWE was phoning this in and lost all creativity.
Ups…
5. Empty Calories Match Delivers What It Promises
If you were expecting a scientific classic between Miz & Maryse and Edge & Beth Phoenix, you haven’t been paying attention to WWE. However, just because we got a lot of smoke and mirrors doesn’t mean we got something undesirable.
The mixed tag match between married couples was surprisingly entertaining, with a shocking amount of action involving all four competitors. Beth Phoenix mixed it up with Miz quite a bit, powerbombing him at one point. But Maryse also nailed a top rope hurricanrana on Edge, to everyone’s surprise.
The “It Couple” got the upper hand thanks to Maryse’s loaded purse, but it wasn’t enough for them, as Edge eventually kicked out of a Skull-Crushing Finale, giving way to a double team spear from Edge and Phoenix on Miz, and then the “Grit Couple” nailed a double Glam Slam on both heels for the three-count.
4. Rollins With The Callback
Oh, that was good.
Regardless of what you think about Seth Rollins’ chances against Roman Reigns headed into the Royal Rumble, you’ve got to give credit for them to playing up the history between the pair, and Rollins using actual mind games against the champion.
The big moment came when Reigns was waiting for the challenger to make his entrance, but instead of the same crappy music he’s been using, we heard the familiar strains of The Shield’s theme. Rollins emerged in the crowd, wearing the old tactical gear and made a very reminiscent entrance.
Not only did it go toward Rollins messing with Roman’s head, it also was a good way to get Seth cheered from the outset and cast Reigns as the villain. Nicely done.
3. Heavyweight Slugfest
Yes, we gave a “down” earlier to the WWE Championship match for Bobby Lashley having to sell for what seemed like an eternity due to the interference. But we also have to give kudos to Lashley and Brock Lesnar for putting in yeoman’s work in their hard-hitting match.
Brock nailed a bunch of German suplexes, but Lashley also hit a couple of his own, as well as a couple spears. The match had a big fight feel, and both men did their part to deliver with this first-time contest between the two.
It’s a shame that the match was so brief and had such a screwy finish, which is why it’s low on this list, but we’ll still give some positive marks for what we got.
2. Roman Loses It
It’s not often that you can say that a DQ finish in a world title match works, but the Roman Reigns/Seth Rollins finish actually worked, because they (get this!) told a story around it.
Reigns couldn’t get the upper hand on Rollins, as he was constantly one-upped and out-maneuvered during an excellent bout that saw Seth come an eyelash away from beating Roman a couple times. But when Rollins offered a Shield fist bump, Reigns lost it and sunk in a guillotine choke that he refused to break after Seth grabbed the ropes.
This led to a DQ, after which Roman kept the guillotine on for a good while before retrieving a chair and battering Rollins. The other thing that really worked in the match’s favor was the announcers telling the story about Roman not having Paul Heyman or the Usos around to provide a calming influence or direction to the Tribal Chief. Left alone, Reigns came unhinged.
It’ll be interesting to see if that’s followed up on, but if they actually, you know, tell a good story, this DQ would fit in really nicely. And it had the added benefit of making it clear that Rollins was the babyface, at least for this night.
1. Rousey Adds Star Power
Even if you were in the camp that Ronda Rousey had outlived her purpose when WrestleMania 35 rolled around, you have to admit that having her back in WWE adds some much-needed star power to the women’s division.
Rousey powered WWE women’s wrestling into the main event scene during her year on the roster, giving a talented division an extra shot in the arm and making it an attraction rather than a solid complementary part of programming.
If reports are true that she’s sticking around for another full year and going full-time with the company, we could see a similar renaissance – IF WWE can actually book the division properly, and if superstars like Asuka and Bayley return ASAP (or NXT wrestlers like Io Shirai and Dakota Kai get the call), and if WWE can utilize its talent correctly.
Either way, Rousey should be a net plus for WWE, and it’ll be fun to see what comes next.