5 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite Grand Slam 2023 (Results & Review)
On a special Dynamite, MJF and Eddie Kingston lift the black cloud that cloaked New York City.
AEW had to accomplish the following at Grand Slam 2023:
MJF had to defeat Samoa Joe after convincing the crowd that he was going to lose - basically work the idealised television pro wrestling match and extract drama from a predictable scenario.
Jon Moxley had to wrestle an ass-kicking match. Nothing less. With no long-term arc even hinted at as International Champion, his run risked a diminished return of his predecessor's. Orange Cassidy wrestled excellent matches weekly, and threaded everything together with a body that had begun to fail him. Thus far, Mox's defences have peaked at "fine".
Chris Jericho and Sammy Guevara had to wrestle a great match - one that fans weren't especially mad about going in - and make you want to see a more violent sequel at the same time.
Saraya, bluntly, had to do something worthehile. The entire division has been warped to her role since last year's event. She failed as a babyface, and so she turned heel and became the fulcrum on which everything else hinged thereafter. It was time for Saraya to provide a return on the investment.
Eddie Kingston had to defeat Claudio Castagnoli. Long-term storytelling for the sake of it has rendered AEW, all too often, a meandering, not particularly vital experience. The Mad King had to finish his story.
Did these things happen - and did Grand Slam generate the atmosphere necessary to lend the event the special feeling missing from AEW's recent TV output...?
Downs...
2. Chris Jericho Vs. Sammy Guevara Underwhelms
Chris Jericho Vs. Sammy Guevara was deflating. Some of the work was good, many of the ideas even better, but this suffered from three flaws.
One, the adrenaline dump following Eddie Kingston's euphoric win flattened the atmosphere.
Two, realistically, if fans were that into Le Sex Gods Explode, they'd have got up for it anyway. It wasn't the end of a long night.
Three, the work, at times, was actively bad.
Jericho collapsed into the ropes when trying to duck under Guevara's leapfrog and back-flip routine. He couldn't get under Guevara in time, and it's not the first time they've blundered through a rough version of that sequence.
Deeper into the match, something went awry when Guevara tried to cut off Jericho's springboard apron dropkick. Whatever they were trying to do, they missed it by - no hyperbole - several feet. Many of the moves were executed well, but because nobody cared about the story, the match felt off. Disjointed. The soundtrack inside Arthur Ashe was a loop of eerie hum/pop for high spot/eerie hum.
The middling execution also ruined a top rope cutter spot, even if it actually went well enough in the end: because the action wasn't tight elsewhere, watching Jericho and Guevara scale the top turnbuckle was frightening. That's meant to be the point, yes, but you're meant to be in suspense, not in fear for their safety. It just never came together, and it's a shame. Four long years went into this. Sammy's top-rope lionsault idea was an outstanding means of trying to put across that he thinks he's outgrown and is a literal level above Jericho. The match ventured into "oof" territory too often.
The finish and the post-match, however, practically salvaged the whole thing...
1. Something Worse Than A Farce
What happened here, and more specifically, how was it allowed to happen? When did Jon Moxley suffer a concussion?
After taking a (spectacular) Fénix dive early, he looked wobbly. Excalibur even remarked as such on commentary. Did the story of the match camouflage the problem? Mox at times countered Fénix's propulsive high-flying nonchalantly. Was this meant to be an attempt at deadpan wit, or was he just not quite right?
Elements of the match were very good regardless, somehow. Fénix is just so damn quick that his convoluted move set-ups actually look as though they'd catch his opponents off-guard. But none of that matters.
What matters is that, if it wasn't clear how and when Mox suffered a head injury in the moment, it was obvious to Frank Gotch that the lights were out after that first piledriver. In a cryptic clue, he was motionless, lay down flat on the mat, and didn't get up for the planned near-fall.
Referee Rick Knox didn't count the three, so, in a monumentally reckless moment that undermined the vibe of the rest of the show - and endangered Moxley's wellbeing - Fenix hit him with another pildedriver. An audible had been called, coronating a new champion. Watching Fénix celebrate was bizarre. He couldn't not celebrate, but the histrionic acting was a brutal contrast to the visual of Mox, not moving, in the middle of the ring, when it was hard not to think of the worst. Mercifully, Mox left the ring under his own power, and Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter reported that the concussion he suffered was only mild.
A serious inquiry must take place, and at an absolute minimum, fines, dressing-downs and training courses must be paid, doled out and completed.
An accidental new International champion, a near vibe-ruiner of a reckless incident, and a total disaster.
Ups...
5. Roderick Strong Remains A Total Joy
Roderick Strong & Adam Cole still have mixed emotions as Strong lays helpless in a hospital bed.
AdvertisementWatch #AEWDynamite #AEWGrandSlam LIVE ON TBS!@AdamColePro | @roderickstrong pic.twitter.com/cBdCetEgot
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) September 21, 2023
Everything to do with Roderick Strong was sensational.
First, following the events of last week's Dynamite, the Kingdom tended to him by his bedside in a hospital. A panicked Adam Cole entered the scene. Roddy, wailing, asked here he was. Roddy wasn't in some metaphysical realm twixt between earth and the afterlife. He just had his eyes shut. This man's attempts at drawing sympathy are a stitch. What an inspired role and casting of it this whole arc is.
The moment in which Strong tried to get Cole's attention by rising from the electronic bed was awesome too. He looked, with a wonderful note of physical comedy, like the old, annoying friend whose presence you almost resent. He is the friend with an inconvenient problem, and with his lurch upwards, you could almost feel Cole's inner dread. The comedy in this saga is just note-perfect.
Later in the night, viewers saw the moment in which Cole, joining MJF as he recorded his pre-tape promotional promo, was called to the hospital - and heard Cole say to Roddy "You're not dying" on the phone. This was another exceptional gag. Being invited to imagine what that sounded like was better than even a Roddy Strong line reading.
4. Saraya Delivers Her Best AEW Performance
Toni Storm Vs. Saraya was a very entertaining and over match.
In a testament to the strength of Toni's incredible performances of late, the match was more over than a big Chris Jericho singles affair. Given the bleak extent to which fans have been conditioned not to care about the women's division, Toni is - quite literally - box office. It wasn't perfect.
The in-vogue "Do I really want to hurt my friend?" hesitation spot has infested wrestling, and this match and feud didn't need it. If everything is grey, there are no meaningful shades. This also infringed on the neck health-based drama of the main event, but that was probably justified, given Saraya's documented history. Beyond those flaws, this was in fact Saraya's best AEW match, and by some distance.
She played a rotter of a heel role like a true pro, and Toni was priceless. Mostly. In crawling under the ring to retrieve shoes - shoes that doubled as missiles - she proved that she can weave her scene-stealing character work within the body of a wrestling match. She was already quite awesome at the in-ring aspect to begin with, and proved it again by pacing the overdrive of the finishing sequence to perfection with an array of convincing near-falls. Saraya won with an avalanche variation of her Knight Cap finish. This protected Toni, though you could make the argument that she looked foolish. She had removed the turnbuckle cover and was further outsmarted when Ruby Soho took the spray can from her hand.
Also: yes, Storm is playing an unhinged character, but a kiss nobody else asked for is not OK in any context.
That ugly overtone aside, not exactly helpful on a night on which a black cloud lingered over the New York sky, this was a fabulous hybrid of in-ring over-delivery and sports entertainment smoke and mirrors.
3. A Superb Twist
As mentioned, Chris Jericho Vs. Sammy Guevara was a sloppy match mostly bereft of heat.
The finish and post-match was excellent, though. Guevara had worn trunks inspired by the same colour palette Jericho had worn against Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XIX. This was a neat bit of foreshadowing that Excalibur deftly obscured. He said that Guevara wore the attire in tribute because he saw Jericho like Jericho saw Michaels.
At the finish, Jericho countered Guevara's shooting star press with a codebreaker. This, mercifully - at the last - was perfect. They couldn’t have executed the most important part of the match better had they attempted it another 100 times. Jericho proved that he's still better than Sammy, but Sammy could not reconcile the loss. Mirroring WrestleMania XIX, in a stunning bit of continuity, Sammy kicked Jericho in the balls. This was all kinds of brilliant.
The angle might have made you feel old, but it also reminded you that your lifetime of watching wrestling has mattered. This was hidden in plain sight by Guevara's insistence that Le Sex Gods pursued the Tag Titles after they got this match "out of their system". AEW has a habit of telegraphing plot developments, and this twist worked in subverting that beautifully.
2. Eddie Kingston Gets His Moment
Early in the Grand Slam opener, Claudio Castagnoli systematically attacked nearly every part of Eddie Kingston's upper body.
With a brutal, enterprising backdrop suplex onto the ramp, and some wicked blows with his fists, he worked the back of Eddie's head. He worked the face. He worked the chest with uppercuts. He then damaged Eddie's arms and stamped out the use of his hand. It was a gruesome scrap sprinkled with beats of wit and hope. Eddie fired back with pissy shots to the gut, but he was lashing out more than anything. He was physically outmatched, and on his big night to boot - but that story was told to convey that you could bruise every bone in Eddie's body, but never his spirit.
Deeper into a beautiful display of wrestling in every definition of the word, Kingston again attempted a hurricanrana. Playing further off the finish to their match at ROH Supercard Of Honor, Claudio again reversed it into a pin of his own. Eddie kicked out; he would not be denied. His spirit could not be broken.
On the night of the hero's journey culminating, Eddie paid tribute to his own hero Toshiaki Kawada by slaying his final boss with a power bomb and high stack pin. The sort of match in which a desperate punch to the gut got a huge reaction, the Arthur Ashe crowd was locked into this on a deep emotional level from minute one.
Special, immersive, important: how wonderful that Eddie Kingston embodied the qualities of mainstream wrestling at its best.
1. MJF Proves Himself As THE Ace Of AEW (Again)
MJF Vs. Samoa Joe was an excellent main event that was significantly more dramatic than it had any right to be.
This was a TV defence, albeit in a stadium on a themed Dynamite. As well told as the story was, dating back to 2016, nobody - much as they were gripped by it - would have put significant money on a title switch.
At several points, the end felt close. The match was built around MJF's neck. The dovetailing here, weaving between that weakened body part and Samoa Joe's signature arsenal, was impeccable. If Joe couldn't choke MJF out, he could always draw upon the muscle buster. The match was crafted, meticulously, around the idea that MJF could not survive, much less win.
The damage MJF took was as nasty as it was compelling. He took a positively deranged death valley driver on the apron to heighten the idea that the end was nigh. Fans are desensitised to apron bumps now, but that spot was so sickening that it restored the danger. After a great, suspenseful struggle, Joe also struck MJF with a piledriver on exposed concrete. Subverting the rule of three, MJF also, with a 2.99 kick-out for the ages, kicked out of the Muscle Buster.
His comeback was superb. His float-over counter into a powerbomb was better for not being ultra-smooth; by accident and by design, MJF sold the struggle of a duel against a monster impeccably.
Joe trapped MJF in the Coquina clutch near the finish, but Adam Cole sprinted to ringside to lend him the support to break free. That Cole injured his own leg on the way to the ring lent this sequence a certain pathos. He cared more about MJF's storyline injury than his own real injury.
In a great callback to his first match against CM Punk in Chicago, MJF used tape to choke Joe out. What a finish; as "your scumbag", this MJF character can cheat and get over, and the nature of it also protected Joe.
A just astonishing amount of thought has gone into this twisting, intricate story, and their reward was a booming reaction to a stunning main event.