5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (20 April)

CM Punk edges closer to Hangman Page, AEW & NJPW open the Forbidden Door, Jay White appears...

By Andy H Murray /

AEW

Another loaded AEW Dynamite card played out on TBS last night, with America's second-biggest promotion stuffing its two hours of allotted airtime with seven matches - and more.

Advertisement

The recent trend continues. At the moment, AEW seems focused on filling its flagship show with as much content and as many key players as possible, moving through things at a breakneck pace. Sometimes, this causes problems as moments that could have benefitted from having longer to settle are cut away abruptly. On other occasions, it makes Dynamite an exciting, beat-a-minute show, the like of which doesn't exist elsewhere in episodic American wrestling.

Last night's episode landed somewhere in the middle.

Advertisement

Tony Khan had another of his "huge announcements" on deck, which once again popped his show's core audience huge, particularly the hardcores. Elsewhere, CM Punk wrestled Dustin Rhodes in a classically-styled bout, edging closer to World Championship contention. Two Owen Hart Foundation Tournament qualifiers played out in Kyle O'Reilly. vs. Jungle Boy and Danielle Kamela vs. hometown heroine Britt Baker, wrestling here for the first time since her Revolution 2022 defeat, and more.

Let's light the fuse...

Advertisement

Downs...

4. Hook's Dynamite Debut Underwhelms

AEW

Though well-received by the crowd, which is ultimately what matters most, Hook's Dynamite debut was the most underwhelming of his AEW squashes thus far.

Advertisement

Anthony Henry is a fantastic pro wrestler who should be doing his thing on national television every single week. Here, he was bowled over in around 80 seconds, falling victim to the usual array of ankle picks, throws, crossface clubbing blows, and finally, Redrum. Short but not as snappy or dazzling as some of Hook's other maulings, this didn't hit the usual highs.

Danahausen challenged the Team Taz prospect afterwards, saying that if Hook wouldn't be cursed by Danhausen, he'd have to fight Danhausen. The very nice, very evil newcomer remains supremely over. AEW is also doing the right thing by Hook with this program, which exists on the midcard and keeps him from being overexposed, though the setup here felt awkward and, worse, like it didn't need to exist on this specific show.

Advertisement

If given more room to breathe on a less-crammed episode, this deal would have likely fared better.

3. A Necessary Turn, But...

AEW

Sammy Guevara and Tay Conti going heel was a necessary and welcome move. Swimming against the tide of crowd reactions isn't something AEW typically does, so the promotion leaning into the increased levels of negativity thrown at Tay and Sammy in recent weeks was to be expected. Here, they were total heels, with Guevara dressed ostentatiously, the "be mad" catchphrase for their haters, and continued effort at rubbing their relationship in the fans' faces.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the rivalry with American Top Team is still yielding rough television - and will continue to do so until it is resolved.

Dan Lambert has become a de facto babyface in a promotion he is supposed to be the antithesis of. It happened with Brandi Rhodes, and it has happened again here, with Ethan Page, Scorpio Sky, and the ATT chief forced into an ill-fitting box to facilitate the Guevara program. Fortunately, this looks like it will culminate in next week's TNT Title ladder match and the mixed tag featuring Paige VanZant.

Advertisement

It should be impossible for audiences to cheer Lambert and his crew. His values are the complete opposite of what AEW stands for, while his charges, the Men of the Year, fit the bill as flashy, WWE-style heels. Yet here we are.

2. Kyle O'Reilly & Jungle Boy Misfire

AEW

Kyle O'Reilly needed a big performance against Jungle Boy last night, having largely underwhelmed between the ropes since coming into AEW in December 2021 (Revolution 2022 aside). He won, defeating the Jurassic Express prospect to qualify for the Owen Hart Foundation Tournament proper, but the bout unfortunately fell short.

Advertisement

This was a confused match. Though peppered with visually-impressive technical transitions from O'Reilly and explosive Jungle Boy cloudbursts, the duo never settled into a story. KOR spent much of his time on top working different overhand wristlocks that were never sold by Jungle Boy, who would escape Kyle's clutches, ignore the supposed damage, and fire into his opponent with elbow strikes, undermining the reDRagon man's work. Mid-match leg work barely landed either. The duo ostensibly worked a technical spotfest with little mind for psychology, while the announcers told a story dissonant to the one being told between the ropes.

Jungle Boy was purported to have lost to Kyle O'Reilly for working overly aggressive and confident. This wasn't reflected in the work, which saw the World Tag Team Champion rarely in command, restricted mostly to fired-up outbursts.

Advertisement

An extremely disappointing outing from two of the most talented wrestlers in the company.

1. Coffin Match Falls Short Of Expectations

AEW

Not to give Andrade El Idolo and Darby Allin excuses, but perhaps the duo were marred by time constraints on Dynamite. The speed with which Excalibur raced through the customary late-show match announcements prior to the main event suggested a tight schedule. Then, the coffin match felt shortcutted and insubstantial, concluding as if big chunks of action had been skipped out.

Advertisement

Whatever the case, this had its fun moments. Sting pulling off a Sting mask is always a riot, as is the WCW icon leaping off high places onto bodies below. Andrade's counter of a Coffin Drop into a German suplex on the outside felt like death. Covering the coffin lid with thumbtacks added an extra dimension, too, making the struggle against being shut inside it even more agonising.

But Andrade and Allin merely flirted with tapping into their usually excellent in-ring chemistry. Where previous encounters between these two have boiled over with intense physicality, this match merely simmered. By the end, Allin jumping atop the coffin to secure his rival inside it felt undercooked.

Advertisement

Ups...

5. "Oink Oink, Bitch"

AEW

Wardlow and The Butcher could have worked a more engaging physical contest if allotted more time than the scant few minutes they were given here, but this wasn't the intention. AEW's goal was the continue the Wardlow character arc by making MJF's bodyguard look like as much of a badass as possible. To that end, his night was a total success, continuing his surge to becoming one of AEW's top stars.

Advertisement

It started with Mark Sterling dictating the terms of Wardlow's presence in the building, forcing him into handcuffs when not being escorted by the security crew he has spent the past few weeks decimating. Uncuffed to fight The Butcher (having seemingly completed the remarkable feat of changing from his suit to his ring attire while still bound), Wardlow walked down to no entrance music, then endured short bursts of stiff, clubbing offence before finally conducting the Symphony. Four powerbombs were what it took to put his burly opponent away.

Wardlow looked like the baddest man on the planet as he was cuffed back up, then led up the ramp while the crowd chanted his name, having just floored one of AEW's most ruthless mercenaries. MJF, meanwhile, was fuming, resorting to paying Jake Roberts an extortionate amount of money for Lance Archer's services later on.

Advertisement

4. Brittsburgh, PA

AEW

Let's forgive Britt Baker for her spotty post-match promo after felling Danielle Kamela. The former AEW Women's World Champion came off short of confidence as she addressed her hometown crowd, stumbling over her sentences several times in her diatribe on the rest of the division. Jamie Hayter is going to mop Toni Storm's face with the ring, apparently. Surely even Hayter isn't that strong?

Advertisement

The uncharacteristically poor promo is to be forgiven for the immense carnival atmosphere of Baker's latest Brittsburgh homecoming. Always coming off like a million dollars before her people, Britt was accompanied by a couple of Pittsburgh Steelers here, who handed her the branded glove used to put Kamela away. Short, over, and with Kamela serving up just enough solid heel work to draw heat, this was enjoyable television across the board.

3. Blackpool Combat Club In Full Flow

AEW

Like something pulled straight from WCW television in the early 1990s (an established unit going toe-to-toe with three thrown-together undercard guys), Blackpool Combat Club vs. Dante Martin, Lee Moriarty, and Brock Anderson was a riot.

Advertisement

All six wrestlers understood the assignment here. Particularly Moriarty, who looked excellent in his hometown, showing more fire than at any other time in his AEW career by taking it to the BCC, culminating in him transforming a Danielson pin attempt into the Border City Stretch to tease the upset. Anderson continues to show increased bursts of character between the ropes, showing no hesitation at jumping into the fight, while Martin was his usual stunning self.

A little too stunning, perhaps. Dante's hesitation on the Nosedive led to Jon Moxley recovering, adjusting, and locking him in the Bulldog Choke. Moments later, Martin fell via Paradigm Shift.

Advertisement

Wheeler Yuta's growth continues. Clad in fresh new ring attire to match his rugged stablemates, him partaking in group's now-signature strikes-in-a-submission spot showed, visually, that he is nudging closer to their level and growing week by week.

2. Forbidden Door, Opened

AEW

A collaborative pay-per-view with New Japan Pro Wrestling was Tony Khan's big news on last night's episode of Dynamite, which fits the billing as a "huge announcement" designed to send AEW's core fanbase through the roof.

Advertisement

Forbidden Door takes place in Chicago, Illinois on Sunday 26 June. NJPW president Takami Ohbari was brought onstage for the announcement and to shake hands with Khan, who made a wise move in leaving the talking to NJPW affiliates Jay White and Adam Cole. Khan is great at a good many things - cutting good pro wrestling promos isn't one of them.

Cole and White unfurled details about the event, with the former also confirming that as a Forbidden Door warmup, he'll face Tomohiro Ishii on this week's episode of Rampage. The Stone Pitbull smacking the shocked TakeOver facial expression off the Undisputed Elite man's face should be a riot.

Advertisement

The show itself is tremendous news worth celebrating for anyone invested in AEW on any level. While the lineup itself will likely be a mix of dream matches and politically-fuelled multi-person tags, it's the kind of wild, open scenario that would have been impossible a few short years ago, when mainstream American wrestling was largely isolationist. Khan's announcements continue to bring joy to those who anticipate them in good faith.

1. Never Going Out Of Style

AEW

CM Punk and Dustin Rhodes worked a classical style of professional wrestling that never goes out of fashion, basing their in-ring story largely around Punk, the smaller man, trying to negate his 6'6" opponent's advantages by destroying his left knee.

Advertisement

And it was fantastic.

The format opened the door for Dustin to do what Dustin has always done best: sell and show fire. Rhodes was phenomenal defensively, hobbling around like a broken old man as Punk honed in on his knee. His selling on offense was commendable, too. There were several occasions here when the damaged joint gave way beneath the veteran, preventing him from taking advantage of situations he may have otherwise controlled. This forced him to dig deep, soar on adrenaline and adrenaline alone, outmatched and outgunned against the best in the world.

Advertisement

Fantastic selling carried throughout a match is a timeless way of willing a crowd behind the guy taking the beating. It helps that Dustin has never had trouble commanding an audience in this role, of course, but that the building was split behind him and Punk speaks volumes to his enduring babyface power.

'Hangman' Adam Page emerged after Punk and Dustin had concluded business and shaken hands, going face-to-face with Punk at the top of the ramp. That match looks likely to go down at Double Or Nothing next month.

Advertisement