5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (27 April)

An uneven Dynamite highlighted by Dax vs. Cash, CM Punk, Lucha Wardlow, and more.

By Andy H Murray /

AEW

Last night's episode of AEW Dynamite played out in a similar fashion to the previous two.

Advertisement

A top-loaded outing that crammed its first hour with quality content, it unfortunately sagged during the second. This is becoming a habit. Perhaps it's down to the strong Big Bang Theory lead-in, with Tony Khan and co. looking to retain as many viewers as possible by opening hot, or perhaps it's accidental. Either way, it's something to address for a promotion that is still delivering the best weekly show in American wrestling nonetheless.

Reportedly heavily rewritten as a result of World Champion 'Hangman' Adam Page catching COVID-19, this was also a typically chaotic episode. Featuring a return, big stipulation matches, a title change, visually-impressive parlour tricks, elaborate set pieces, and more, a lot happened here. Fortunately, though, this wasn't one of those weeks where it felt like things weren't being given enough room to breathe. The strong segments were really strong - and on par with AEW's 2022 high average.

Advertisement

Sammy Guevara faced Scorpio Sky in a TNT Title ladder match, Serena Deeb and Hikaru Shida settled their long-running beef, Chris Jericho brought the fire, and Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler fought for a spot in the Owen Hart Foundation Tournament.

Let’s light the fuse…

Advertisement

Downs…

4. Dressing Up For What?

AEW

It was good to see Rey Fenix back on AEW television after a lengthy absence. His injury woes behind him, we may now finally see the long-awaited Death Triangle vs. House Of Black trios match that has been building for months. A supplemental Up for that.

Advertisement

But the segment that reintroduced Fenix was cluttered and contrived.

House Of Black came onto the stage, surrounding a downed Fuego Del Sol then threatening to tear off his mask. They were interrupted by who they thought was a robe-clad Alex Abrahantes in the ring. This was a ruse, though. Lured inside, the House were ambushed by PAC, Penta Oscuro, and Fenix, who had disguised himself in Alex's garb.

Advertisement

A disruptive botch in the physical sequence and Abrahantes' explanation of why he had been dressing up like a villain fit for a children's Halloween party dragged this down. Apparently, the Death Triangle affiliate did this to fool the House of Black, which is fine in the moment, but makes little sense the more you think about it. Rey had been sidelined for months. During this period, Alex's goofy costume trivialised Death Triangle's presentation to a harmful degree, particularly Penta's.

At least it's in the past now.

Advertisement

3. Sports Entertainment & Parlour Tricks

AEW

There was some fun stuff in the Jericho Appreciation Society's interactions with Eddie Kingston, Santana, and Ortiz last night, like Angelo Parker shutting the crowd down post-Judas then referring to them as the "AEW Galaxy", though the in-ring segment was awkward, with the protagonists coming off like they weren't on the same page, tripping over sentences and getting in each others' way.

Advertisement

Tony Khan had stipulated that the opposing sides should meet without violence. The babyfaces tested the boundaries by tossing the pre-arranged chairs out of the ring, then cutting into Jericho and co. on the microphone. Kingston, the realest guy in professional wrestling, got right in Chris' face, letting him know that when you "put a hit" on somebody (as Jericho had promised), you have to put them in the ground. Later, the JAS responded by beating Santana and Ortiz down backstage and then throwing a fireball in Kingston's face.

The execution of the in-ring segment was the issue here. This was a messy bit of business that felt inessential, even with the fireball later on. Kingston showed great intensity, Daniel Garcia was obnoxious, and the crew at least did a good job of emphasising that the babyfaces are at a five-on-three disadvantage, but this was the least useful segment from this feud so far.

Advertisement

2. The Least Engaging High-Level Storyline In AEW History?

AEW

The Undisputed Elite's in-fighting and long-running quest for cohesion is the most sports entertainment storyline in a promotion that books the Jericho Appreciation Society.

Advertisement

Rife with forced acting, tired interpersonal dynamics, and a trio of ex-WWE wrestlers who have essentially been playing the exact same characters on television for five years now, it is a weekly struggle - and feels amateur compared to the searing, organic content on display elsewhere in this promotion.

Last night, you were told to believe that the Undisputed Elite are suddenly on the same page because they defeated a crew of undercarders. The fivesome came together after besting the Varsity Blonds, Brock Anderson, Dante Martin, and Lee Johnson, having struggled to get it together early on, eventually scoring the win via Adam Cole's boom following a four-way BTE Trigger.

Advertisement

Now, suddenly, they are a well-oiled unit of mates.

It's a leap, and unfortunately typical of a feud starring some of the biggest names in the company. Hopefully it turns out to be no more than a placeholder for Kenny Omega's eventual return.

Advertisement

1. Sky Topples Guevara In Lacklustre Ladder Match

AEW

All spots, no substance.

Advertisement

That was the story of Scorpio Sky and Sammy Guevara's TNT Championship ladder match. A poor main event that saw both characters abandon any semblance of ring smarts in the name of elaborate stunts, it was, unfortunately, the kind of empty calories that mobilise that bot army that lives to see this promotion fail.

Countless moments saw Sky or Guevara spurn clear opportunities to reach up and grab the belt in the name of doing something that'd look good on a gif. Guevara was the chief offender here. If it happens once, you can attribute it to his character, saying that he isn't all that intelligent and would rather catch the eye than seal the deal. Go beyond that and the match barely resembles a competition.

Advertisement

Credit to the wrestlers for putting their bodies on the line here. Scorp deserves a special mention for getting over as a babyface in the closing stages, too, though the character dynamics caused issues early on as well. Ostensibly heel vs. heel, it sounded like Philadelphia had little interest in getting behind either of them.

Paige VanZant's interference drew a pop, at least. She and Sky vs. Guevara and Tay Conti is the ultimate destination. This shouldn't have required the needless hot-shotting of the TNT Championship, though. This year might only be four months old but it has already seen five individual reigns.

Advertisement

Ups…

5. Wheeler Yuta Downs A Giant

AEW

We got another good Blackpool Combat Club trios match this week. While a little less kinetic than the previous show's, this had a clearer dynamic, with The Factory's combination of heel stooging (Aaron Solo and QT Marshall) and outright brawn (Nick Comoroto) meshing well with William Regal's violence gang - and Wheeler Yuta received like a hero in his Philly hometown.

Advertisement

Yuta provided much of the meat on this match's bones, taking heat from Comoroto before tagging in to a mega-pop later on. He ended up putting the big man away, too, hammering him with Bryan Danielson-esque elbows when trapped in a hold, forcing Comoroto down to the ground, then rolling him into a seatbelt pin while Danielson and Jon Moxley neutralised Marshall and Solo.

A nice showcase for Yuta, with AEW continuing to do right by its wrestlers when swinging through their hometowns. The Factory did a good job doing the job too.

Advertisement

4. Fiery Babyface CM Punk

AEW

There's no telling what AEW originally had planned for its World Championship program last night, as Hangman Page's COVID confirmation robbed audiences of another interaction between him and CM Punk, but at least the match was put together. Punk and Page will face off at Double Or Nothing 2022, as confirmed following Dax Harwood vs. Cash Wheeler.

Advertisement

Punk responded to the news with a great, fiery babyface promo. While the feud's latter stages will likely require him to tap into heel qualities, he was a great time-filler on Dynamite, saying that he set out on a quest to discover if he was still capable of standing there as 'The Best in the World.' He might not beat Page in Las Vegas, but he'll give him a fight - and he'll go until the wheels fall off.

As always with things like this, the quality primarily comes from the delivery. This is never in doubt with Punk. He and Page are going to sell the hell out of what might be the least predictable World Title match in AEW history.

Advertisement

3. Serena Slays Shida, Moves On Up

AEW

Hikaru Shida and Serena Deeb's fifth AEW battle could have perhaps benefitted from greater babyface intensity, as there were moments where Shida's comebacks felt a little soft. While Deeb tortured her in submissions and holds, Hikaru battled back often with mere whispers of violence, her strikes occasionally lacking gusto when they needed them most.

Advertisement

Other than this, the match was great. Building on their longstanding, match-to-match story of Deeb going after Shida's knee, having injured it several times in the past, it worked best when 'The Professor' was picking the former Women's World Champion to pieces. Serena continually went after the joint, creating great drama worked around the Street Fight stipulation, which meant the ropes could only be used for leverage rather than complete safety.

Shida fought bravely, coming close with an avalanche Falcon Arrow and numerous kendo stick barrages, though she was eventually felled after kicking out of a Deebtox onto a chair. The Serenity Lock sealed the deal with Deeb who, with Thunder Rosa watching on, will presumably be the next Women's Title challenger.

Advertisement

A sharp and satisfying end to a feud that suffered through the wrestlers going missing for weeks on end, but ultimately reached the right conclusion.

2. Murderhawk Murdered

AEW

Wardlow's monster hunt continued last night. Lance Archer was presented as a bigger hurdle than The Butcher, but, with MJF and Shawn Spears watching on from safety, the Murderhawk Monster was felled by the babyface stud's incredible bursts of athleticism.

Advertisement

Lance set the tone by diving on Wardlow as his handcuffs were being removed before the bell. That's when Lucha Wardlow came out. MJF's former bodyguard dazzled with a ridiculous running headscissor takedown, shockingly quick transitions, and more, demonstrating agility and poise belying his colossal frame. Archer, meanwhile, showed he was no slouch in this department either, delivering his trademark rope-walk Moonsault from the top rope.

But Wardlow edged him out. The senton not employed since he wrestled Cody Rhodes in early 2020 subdued Lance enough for Wardlow to conduct the Symphony. Five powerbombs later, Archer was beaten, with Wardlow's thunderous reception marking this another complete, objective success in making him look like the baddest man on the planet.

Advertisement

Next week, another very large human being enters the fray in IMPACT Wrestling's W. Morrissey, the former Big Cass, who was teased in a backstage segment later in the night.

1. Shot Through The Hart

AEW

This was perfect.

Advertisement

Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler couldn't have crafted a more fitting Owen Hart Foundation Tournament qualifier. From fellow Hart devotee CM Punk's commentary spot and FTR's Hart Foundation-inspired attire to the careful, nuanced, detail-rich work put forth between the ropes, they nailed it.

Shades of Bret and Owen's classic WrestleMania X opener permeated this. There were teases of nastiness as Dax and Cash flirted with violating their unwritten sportsman's code, most notably when Wheeler became flustered with a roughhouse moment in the corner. Later, both hesitated to take the kind of advantages they would against opponents they have less respect for, though their approach was careful. Not once did it come close to entering tedious "why am I so violent?" territory. The heel swings were as meticulous as the wrestlers themselves.

Advertisement

Wheeler hurting his leg early on then selling it throughout paid off in a Sharpshooter spot, which Harwood didn't want to lock in for fear of hurting his partner and best friends. Dax retained enough presence of mind to win from there, however, reversing Cash's own attempt at an inside cradle to score the pinfall.

Cue: an emotional post-match embrace.

Advertisement

This match may not have gone down in the tournament proper, but it's hard to imagine the competition will yield a bout more in-touch with the Hart wrestling legacy. Dax and Cash did a fantastic job. This was pure, uncomplicated professional wrestling, classical in style and execution, with a timeless quality that will ensure its rewatchability for years to come.