5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (8 Feb - Review)

The Good, The Bad & The Jericho of a show that offered the full AEW experience for better and worse.

By Michael Hamflett /

AEW

Dynamite has been on a creative roll lately.

Advertisement

Ahead of February 8th, the Revolution card wasn't crystal clear beyond the main event, and numbers for the flagship or Dynamite having exactly been soaring, but the product overall hasn't given any cause for concern. Tony Khan is - as we are insufferably reminded every other second on the socials by terrible stan accounts - cooking.

In MJF and Bryan Danielson, he's made impeccable use of two polar opposite characters with the knowledge that fans know much of the bluster is a red herring. The 60-Minute Iron Man match stands to rule, and the booking of the 'Salt Of The Earth' against can't-miss factory Konosuke Takeshita was designed to hide that in plain sight.

Advertisement

All of that was there to double down on what we already knew. What else did the company have in mind for one of the more predictable shows in recent history. Championship Fight Night had more to it than your average Battle Of The Belts, and the outcomes weren't anywhere near as obvious as you might have thought.

Let's light the fuse...

Advertisement

Downs…

4. The One True King Of...What, Exactly?

AEW

Samoa Joe and Wardlow didn’t need revisiting, but it’s happening anyway with or without obvious or clear motivation.

Advertisement

In contrast to the largely electrifying Darby Allin TNT Title reign (and Joe’s place in that) the feud between the Joe and ‘The War Dog’ never generated the sort of pulsating moments that performed the necessary duties of a) elevating the newcomer, b) obscuring the limitations of the veteran or - and this is most important - c) being particularly entertaining.

Joe callously toasted taking everything from Wardlow already to - dignity, title, man-bun etc. There’s reason for MJF’s former ally to want a piece of the champion but actively the opposite the other way. The wrong guy said the wrong stuff in what’s increasingly feeling like the wrong feud, especially if this is the plan for Revolution.

Advertisement

3. Brand New Time Slot, Same Old Problems

AEW

50% of Jaime Hayter and The Bunny was gobbled up by adverts unless you were watching on Fite, and that felt particularly frustrating when the return from break brought about the finish almost immediately.

Advertisement

A second exploder suplex from Champion to Challenger went badly wrong, and though The Bunny was able to recover enough to take Hayter’s ripcord lariat for the finish, she didn’t seem to be able to throw herself into it with much gusto.Rushed when it looked like it had to be, this was pedestrian stuff when it actually had time.

The picture-in-picture portion may have felt frustrating for those watching on TBS, but the really bad news was that nothing happened in the break anyway. And undercooked and underserved viewer experience overall, the placement of the match in the first hour betrayed the eventual outcome.

Advertisement

Saraya and Toni Storm’s attack on Leva Bates was cheesy and forced too. Just because the story is clear and focussed, it doesn’t mean it’s all that good at the moment. The tale could do with some development at this point, and precedence within the company’s history doesn’t suggest we’ll get any.

2. Throwing Down The Gauntlet

AEW

Count the ways this sucked, and don't even include the hack alliteration that plagues the very worst of wrestling since Vince McMahon fooled generations of fans into thinking it was artful.

Advertisement

The positive first, because it's hard to see obscured by all the muck; Ricky Starks at long last has believable motivation to fight Chris Jericho at Revolution in the storylines. His bullsh*t insult exchanges alongside Absent Andretti weren't doing the job, and defeat here now becomes the reason for the pay-per-view match. But ahead of time, you could read that bit like a book. And not a very good book. Certainly not Bravo Two Zero by Andy McNab. Which, unlike a Chris Jericho storyline treatment, actually improves with every read.

Daniel Garcia is supposed to be getting over within the body of this story, providing Jericho his next breakout star to dampen the enthusiasm for when he's finished with 'Absolute'. Getting this victory should have put him over as the real threat within the JAS, but a masked Jericho helping him win with the Judas Effect...undermined that completely?!

Advertisement

This felt like it was booked by AI - the majority of it looked right in theory but it still required a genuine human being to finish the job. With Jericho in charge, that's one of the many things this storyline is short of.

1. (Hot)ShotGunn

AEW

Oh boy.

Advertisement

One of those decisions that'll either divide opinion or - and this could be the worry - not divide it at all, The Gunns' Tag Team Title victory was not so unpredictable that top podcasts weren't calling it before the show, but actually seeing it happen left a lot to be desired and bigger questions about the booking of the division at large.

The Gunns won cheaply and it already feels as though the reign exists to be ended by an Acclaimed rematch or returning heroes FTR more than anything else, but that "this is so sh*t you'll never see it coming" meta booking move is a mistake WWE made so often that they ended up with Jinder Mahal being so useless as Champion that Brock Lesnar laughed off the idea of even facing him.

Advertisement

That comparison might scan as harsh, but it's a slippery slope, and not one AEW necessarily even needed to entertain with their titles. Another troubling question - would the company have gambled with the prestige of their doubles belts if Trios ones didn't exist too? The straps held by The Elite suddenly feel like the ones that matter, but they're being contested for in matches that don't. The tag straps can't be serious with The Gunns, while the three-man ones won't be as long as the matches only exist for adrenalised quick hits.

Ups…

5. The Heavyweight Champion Of The World

AEW

Maxwell Jacob Friedman doesn’t miss.

Advertisement

The most brilliant detail about AEW’s most brilliant character remains the fact that he can go as hard - if not harder - than 90% of the roster and simply chooses not to.The AEW World Heavyweight Champion was in sublime form again here - the type that could be taken for granted (more on that later) if he wasn’t so smart and heavily limited how often we even get to see it. Konosuke Takeshita has a hit rate on par with the challenger and yet again worked a contest that positioned him as a video game wrestler with all attributes set to 99.

Pivoting from sympathetic to sh*t-kicker as and when MJF’s thuggish intent required, Takeshita’s inability to build on the momentum of his win last week didn’t scan as weak but bold. Particularly at the finish - MJF pounced on a slip by his opponent with ruthless efficiency, earning a Salt Of The Earth tap-out having already worked the arm exactly as he will against Bryan Danielson at Revolution. Beyond the moments he was a dirty cheating rat b*stard, there was yet again zero to fault from a performance that was as ruthless as it was flawless.

Advertisement

And his night was only just getting started.

4. Crash Decisions

AEW

The best promo in All Elite Wrestling might be even better when he’s in recovery mode.

Advertisement

MJF gave one of the most powerful speeches of his career following a seminal victory over Darby Allin at Full Gear 2021, and though this had more of his familiar sh*thouse flavour than that, it carried the energy and verve of a man absolutely believing that he’s the very best in the world at all of this. As well he should.

The long story short is that the entitled pr*ck crashed his car while receiving oral sex, then shifted his severely injured partner into the drivers seat before the police arrived so he wouldn’t suffer the consequences. Naturally, he wasn’t the loser of his own story - he framed this as putting over his survival instincts and will to win as if he was Bret Hart finally overcoming his father in the dungeon.

Advertisement

Heinous, despicable, and yet more warped backstory for a character with a mythology that’s frankly not credited enough.

And he still wasn’t done…

Advertisement

3. Details At The Death

AEW

A "you-have-to-fight-X-people-to-get-to-me" story is just about the most predictable in AEW outside of indentured servitude or climbing up ladders to grab sh*t, but expectations have been raised enough elsewhere over the last four years that it's okay to want more than the inevitable babyface triumph from the run of matches.

Advertisement

Between the match and the last angle that built to it, Dynamite provided a perfect and memorable finale.

Having saved Konosuke Takeshita from a further beating earlier in the night, Bryan Danielson was being interviewed by Renee Young in the trainers room when they were locked in from the inside. As cameras rolled on the three, Rush's music could be heard playing in the building, and the challenger was clearly in trouble.

Advertisement

In the arena, MJF returned and hassled Aubrey Edwards into trying to count down Danielson before he was able to get to the ring after barging down the door with his injured shoulder, but her deliberately pace paid off the referees' longstanding dislike of the 'Salt Of The Earth' and added yet more drama to the upcoming encounter.

2. Death After The Details

AEW

Bryan Danielson's latest television masterpiece was also possibly (probably?) the best match Rush will have all year even if Danielson could top it over 60 engaging minutes at Revolution next month.

Advertisement

With a kayfabe half a million dollars awaiting him if he could rise to MJF's challenge and finally beat Bryan, Rush wrestled as if every penny was real. Violent and pulsating in his prolonged assault, the freedom expression on offence and defence from the heel and babyface respectively was the type that could only really exist in All Elite Wrestling, and not because Danielson bled buckets after a brutal attack on the floor. This was spectacle, theatre and combat sports so seamlessly meshed that it asked questions of non-fans. Principally, why do you not watch wrestling?

Fighting one-armed throughout with a health meter that started empty stayed there, Bryan bled so effectively that it literally coloured the lens at one point, but fought through a losing game of human Splatoon to kick Rush's f*cking head in and beat him with the Busaiku Knee.

Advertisement

MJF bludgeoned him more with the Dynamite Diamond Ring and refused to release a Salt Of The Earth to inflict yet more damage on the arm as the best week for the story yet reached a thrilling and captivating climax.

1. Pulling Up Threes

AEW

Never has an Elite match delivered such a forceful b*llocking to fans about wanting what you have rather than having what you want.

Advertisement

Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks’ Trios Championship match with AR Fox and Top Flight was maybe the best Elite TV clash of their most recent run, which says something considering that six of them fed into an iconic best-of-seven series and another got something surprisingly fun out of Matt Hardy and The Firm.

It was something even more incredible.

Advertisement

Breathless near falls towards served as a reminder that this was a match still taking place on earth rather than the moon, such had been the consistency and connectivity of the gravity-defying and jaw-dropping offence from both sides. The result wasn’t really in doubt when the referee’s hand rapidly slapped two, but the ride was so fast and exhilarating that everybody gasped along with them all the same.

If any of that sounds like faint praise for such exceptional action, perhaps that’s the subjective “problem” at the heart of what The Elite are currently doing. Kenny Omega showed the world the top star version of himself on January 4th, and The Young Bucks had a tag match with Top Flight several weeks ago that approached the quality of this encounter without need for belts or two extra wrestlers.

Advertisement

Unusually for the group, it feels right now like there’s nothing of narrative substance really happening for them beyond kick ass match after kick ass match. “But isn’t that enough, you spoiled entitled pr*ck? Are we not all just Homer Simpson eating the donuts in hell now, anyway?” Probably. But there’s surely a happier medium than a genre that's already threatening to feel mid without something meaningful.