5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (January 31 - Results & Review)
Even the good stuff wasn't exactly great on a show stolen by Hangman Page...
AEW is in an uneasy place at present.
Tony Khan has recognised that the fanbase wasn't exactly enamoured with what became of his product in the latter half of 2023, and when those fans put their money where their f*cking mouths were, by ensuring the Continental Classic was a relative ratings success on Saturday nights, he set about "restoring the feeling". Roderick Strong, an NXT character in the "sports-oriented" promotion, was stripped of his dire comedy overtones. Samoa Joe - a wrestler nobody hates, an ultra-credible, über-respected safe pair of hands - was installed as AEW World champion. The return of the rankings system was announced. This felt like AEW, but also not: almost as if Khan was making moves to prevent criticism as opposed to inspiring rabid enthusiasm.
The thing is, you can't just say things are going to improve and magically reverse the rot and the stigma at the same time. AEW remains cold - a woolly mammoth entombed in permafrost cold - at the domestic box office. This week's Dynamite threatened a bleak and uninspiring experience.
WrestleTix revealed a bleak, TNA on Tour cap of 2,000 tickets sold. Sometimes, as with the latest Collision taping, this can work in AEW's favour. Oddly, sometimes, a small crop of fans are intent on making the best of it.
The card didn't promise much in the way of energy, though, which in grim tandem with a piss-poor gate, promised very little. Of the six announced four wrestlers in them - Chris Jericho, Jeff Hardy, Rob Van Dam and Tyra Valkyrie - seem like they move through treacle these days.
Ageing, over-exposed stars, novelty attractions, a predictable result in every single match: dread isn't quite the word, but Christ, the announced line-up was hardly consistent with Khan's "2024 is the new 2021" social media posturing.
Was the feeling AEW sought to restore utter apathy, or...?
Downs...
4. Match Was Mostly Just There
The good news is that Deonna Purrazzo Vs. Tyra Valkyrie wasn't too sludgy.
It wasn't a great match, but it was competently worked, and while Purrazzo may have given Valkyrie too much, her Venus de Milo finish is so excellent that it always leaves a strong and definitive lasting impression. She needed the win, now that the rankings system is back in effect, and this is preferable to the stat-padding that used to go on on Dark - but logical and sensible storytelling is no guarantee of a great time.
Hikaru Shida has had her day as the division ace, is forever over, and can always be reheated as and when AEW requires - wouldn't she have made for a more high quality and slightly more unpredictable match-up?
On a show dominated by utterly predictable pairings, Deonna and Tyra had no chance in what is already a death slot, and in general, in this rebooted rankings era, AEW could do with one match per show that is not a complete formality.
Toni Storm was a riot, again, on commentary - especially the line about Tyra needing no invitation to her trademark command of "t*ts out!"
3. A Bad Night For Wardlow
It seems very harsh to give this a Down, since Wardlow clearly jammed his knee when delivering the poor, anticlimactic powerbomb, but it wasn't a strong idea to begin with. Thankfully, as he revealed on Twitter, his knee feels fine.
Komander gave Orange Cassidy a fright on Collision, but was meat for the grinder here. Wardlow's spots looked quite sensational - he threw Komander around like pizza dough with his F10 - but you can never go back. That sort of thing looked all the more impressive when it was new, when you didn't know there was a ceiling on Wardlow as a main event hopeful working back-and-forth matches that never once orbited great. How effective can a good establishing match be when the character has already been established?
What should be refreshing - a break from the relentless lengthy competitive matches elsewhere - just isn't, whether that's a result of the stigma Wardlow developed in 2022 or the one-dimensional ring work. Wardlow doing the vertical leap on the apron to convey that he can neutralise an aerial attack was a great little touch, though. Still, this Wardlow: headliner reboot is not working.
His work isn't on that level, trust issues exist between the promoter and the audience, and the Undisputed Kingdom's origin story is too redolent of AEW at its worst.
2. Is Chris Jericho Finished At Last?
Chris Jericho gave Kyle Fletcher the fabled rub on Dynamite last night by needing two Judas Effect variations to put his young opponent away. He was for a long time thwarted in that effort by the interference of Powerhouse Hobbs who, incidentally, did absolutely nothing of significance after destroying former AEW World champion Chris Jericho late last year. His presence as a glorified bodyguard who like many AEW talents barely actually wrestles just underscored how little this latest chapter in the Jericho Vs. Don Callis story was going to matter in the end.
When will you even see Fletcher on TV again?
When will this bullsh*t six month plus Jericho/Callis programme ever limp to a conclusion that nobody cares about?
Jericho needs to go away for a while. He is profoundly overexposed. People did care about the match, a whopping sub-2,000 of them, anyway. It was hard-hitting, and Jericho at times managed to keep up with his explosive stud of an opponent. Jercho is a grandfather and just as problematic these days, though, and his insistence on being the cool veteran who "gets it" is often his undoing. There's always one scary, immersion-breaking moment in his matches, a reminder that he shouldn't be too ambitious, too desperate to fit in with the cool crowd - and that top turnbuckle brainbuster spot almost went completely awry.
The story told here - of Jericho barely escaping a shoot-out against a younger and faster guy with an army behind him - was undermined by the state of him at the finish. He looked loopy. He looked like his days wrestling at the highest level are as dead as his reputation.
There were some decent near-falls here, and Jericho threw himself very near his neck to sell the idea that he was being blown away before his veteran know-how proved the difference in the end, but it never once even began to reach a level that made you think Jericho shouldn't pack his bags and take an extended holiday as soon as possible.
Belize?
It doesn't matter how politely you ask him, he won't f*ck off for love nor money.
1. What Was This?
The Bang Bang Scissors Gang entered the ring for a segment and did less than nothing.
Remember when the Road To series was on YouTube, and the promos or video packages were so fantastic that they should have been broadcast on Dynamite? But there was no room on Dynamite, which was almost all killer at its peak? Well, those days are f*cking dead.
What was this?
The idea, presumably, was to simply reinforce the "bond" between the teams before Bullet Club turn again to add heft to the conflict. In reality, this was a nationally televised post-show dark segment where the babyfaces riff and thank you all for coming. A definitional waste of time that advanced nothing.
The Acclaimed badly need to return to the tag team division because while all available data must confirm that they're still valuable - otherwise they wouldn't be marched out to do sh*t like this - none of this is good or purposeful and when they finally get in the ring, the fans don't react much to their formula match. The Swerve In Our Glory and FTR belters were a long old time ago.
Unify the belts, base the Trios division on exhilarating action again, reinstall Daddy Ass as manager.
Ups...
5. Opener Is Passable
Jon Moxley, perhaps being readied to work a debuting WillI Ospreay or Kazuchika Okada at Revolution, went over Jeff Hardy in the opener.
After a halfway spirited brawl early, the match, unfolding against a quiet and small crowd so self-consciously lit that they looked ink black, the heat sequence felt like it lasted 10 minutes - not ideal for the hot opener slot.
It went on and on, but after wittily cutting off a comeback by punching Jeff as he flew off the steps, Mox drew inspiration from Randy Orton by working the hole in Jeff Hardy's ear. In a really cool idea, leading the match an improvised feel, he didn't retrieve it from under the ring but rather stole it from Excalibur's hand. When he warms up, Jeff Hardy is of value. He can actually move, for a start, and he can still draw a reaction. Given his poor form since arriving in AEW, in recent weeks, he's looked positively, shockingly dynamic.
After the pen spot, the match lacked any real identity or true deep-in-the-soul emotion - they took it home, as most wrestlers these days do, after an apron spot and an extended finisher reversal sequence - but Jeff's inherent star power and renewed motivation carried this one, albeit narrowly, over the line of the "gentleman's three".
4. An Intriguing Post-Match Angle
With no other members of the BCC to protect him, the Stars of CMLL aren't going to take Jon Moxley's disrespect lightly!
AdvertisementWatch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@JonMoxley | @CMLL_OFICIAL pic.twitter.com/NTvabCm1t8
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) February 1, 2024
During the Mox Vs. Hardy match, after which incidentally Jeff bird-flipped Mox - entitled moaning and obvious politicking works, sadly - Mox drew the ire of the four guests from CMLL. Launched into the vicinity of Hechicero, Mistico, Máscara Dorada 2.0 and Volador, Jr., tension was evident - and in the post-match, with the Blackpool Combat Club absent, they put a beating on Mox to set up a Trios match next week. This was really cool, even if, gauging by the audience reaction, the most acclaimed league on the planet right now isn't as well-known as the hipster's choice rep may have suggested.
Still, this was very interesting - a completely different dimension to the way in which the AEW/NJPW partnership has been presented. The CMLL All-Stars Vs. Blackpool Combat Club Trios match on Dynamite next week looks like a blast, and the Bryan Danielson Vs. Hechicero Collision bout has hardcore fans of submission wrestling purring.
3. A Fun Main Event, Nothing More
Early in the Dealer's Choice match, Hangman Page appeared on the big screen to advise Swerve Strickland that he should have read the paperwork: Page was able to select both the opponent and the stipulation. He selected, as was all but confirmed, Rob Van Dam. The Hardcore match was an unexpected bonus announced at the perfect time.
Until the shortcuts were withdrawn from under the ring, though, Van Dam looked constantly on the verge of falling over when when launching Swerve into the guardrail to create movement for him. Happily, instinct took over when Van Dam ran through his crowd-pleasing spots, and he can still reach impressive distances with his guardrail leg lariat. There was a boggy quality to the match at points, but the crowd's nostalgic affection for RVD helped carry it before some inspired and well-executed set-pieces. It was quite tame by AEW's standards.
Or perhaps that standard no longer exists, at least on television: you can stop making those sh*t Jon Moxley jokes, because the days of Dynamite being soaked in blood are, sadly, over. An almost generic LED sheen has blanketed the promotion, and this match, fun as it was in spots, typified that. Where was the blood?
Also, this was the second consecutive week, in which no match approached great, headlined by the sort of novelty affair that felt more charming a few years ago. RVD doing RVD things is cool, but he's already done it in AEW after doing it full-time for decades. Skippable table-setting for next week's show, all in all. A fitting main event - a crowd-pleaser, but nothing that would capture the imagination of the wider audience.
Dynamite was slightly better than expected, but was hardly the sort of show that will make you rush to AEWTix dot com.
2. You're Lucky To Have Hangman Page
Toa Liona's audition as a potential singles guy went well.
Working in the tradition of the Samoan monster, when Page attempted to roll him up, he did the sit-down on the head spot, the one that a wrestler hasn't landed once. Worse still, that spot only works as a terrifying near-miss, and he missed by miles. Shaky early, he settled into the occasion by, and this was awesome, throwing Page over the ropes and directly to the floor after absorbing and roaring through two luckless second buckle lariats from Page.
That was the general story of the match, in which Page gave Liona loads in a bid to generate a more potent sense of drama than was expected. It didn't really work - the audience played along without truly being swept up in it all - but they played along because the two men did a good, rousing job with the primal savage versus cerebral babyface dynamic. Liona popping right back up after the Dead Eye worked because, as a grunt in a stable, it was so unexpected. Liona does a very good job with the template of the character and updating it athletically - that missed moonsault to the floor was crazy - but doesn't quite have that menacing aura. Also, Page is just so great that you can't tell if Liona will ever have a singles match that good again.
As a one-off to build Page as a continued presence in the main event scene, this very much worked, and that finish was classic Hangman: reversing a Samoan drop at the very last second into a crucifix pin, he played the cunning babyface desperate and smart enough to survive a situation of real peril.
Page, who almost channelled Bret Hart here, is just neat.
1. A Strong Sit-Down
In the high point of the show, Darby Allin and Sting and Ricky Starks and Big Bill sat down to promote their match next week. This was excellent, even if the dialogue was very much in that pro wrestling mode of exposition. It's never subtle is it, this "I'm laying out our history for the benefit of the audience we don't trust to remember" stuff.
Boil it all down, and a conversation in wrestling rarely feels natural. Some are just better at it than others, and this was bloody good. Darby accused Ricky of using AEW as a stepping stone, using that as additional motivation to take the tag team titles from him. Sting looked Big Bill up and down and questioned whether or not he's a killer. They did a very good job of building the tension and making it feel as though it could combust, not that it would purely because that's how these things go. The frustratingly uneven Starks was absolutely superb here.
Sometimes too aloof, he was dialled-in emotionally. This was the right kind of awkward, and when he stopped himself from dropping an F-bomb, after Darby excused him of being an excuse merchant, you could believe it. On that, though: it's a bit weird how Darby, sometimes guilty of worked shoot b*llocks, went after Ricky's rep as the guy forever on the cusp of success. In the fictional world of AEW, as Tag Team champion, he's literally on top of the world. Again, this feels endemic to wrestling, something that is done without pause to consider that it shouldn't be. The lines are too blurred to see the old point.
Sting held Darby back and built the match as a serious deal with his low, well-earned gravitas before quietly retreating, leaving fans wanting for the confrontation like the old master he is. A really well-paced bit of business, this is a simple tap-in of a formula, provided the wrestler is gifted enough at promos - and since the roster is vastly under-utilised in that regard, it should be the norm. More in-ring promos wouldn't go amiss, either.
Build an Okerlund position!