5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw: Day 1 (Results & Review)

Rock returns, Rollins rolls, Awesome Truth reunites, Ivy Nile arrives. A good, but flawed show.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

On paper, three good-to-great matches and the surprise return of The Rock should make for a home run of a WWE Raw, correct?

Advertisement

Well, yes and no.

Day 1 Raw was a good offering in that it gave fans two really good title matches and a fantastic grudge match that would be fun to revisit down the line. The episode also delivered on Triple H’s promise of a “former WWE champion” returning to the fold, and he made sure to make some news while he was in town.

But Raw also produced some completely skippable material, including the reunion of the Awesome Truth, which was about as mind-blowingly stupid of a self-own as WWE could produce. Rather than being a Mega Powers-adjacent reunion, it just reminded fans of how dire 2011 WWE really was.

Cody Rhodes seemed… distracted to say the least, which given The Rock’s promo was understandable. But that didn’t help his segment in any way. And Rock’s promo material was C- at best but elevated with his usual A delivery.

As a special episode of Raw, Day 1 was fine, and it certainly was newsworthy, which is probably more important than the show itself being remembered fondly. Overall, there were enough good moments here to overcome the skippable ones, but that’s only if you’re able to fast-forward through the dreck.

Let’s get to it…

DOWNS…

5. Flubbed Cash-In… Again

WWE.com

How many times must Damian Priest be thwarted in trying to cash in his Money in the Bank title shot?

Priest stormed out during the Seth Rollins/Drew McIntyre World Heavyweight Championship match and attempted to cash in, but McIntyre hit him with a Claymore to put him down for the remainder of the bout, which Rollins won.

This has to be the fifth or sixth time Damian has come out to cash in, only to be stopped in some manner, leaving him looking foolish in the aftermath. In this case, Priest looked even worse, standing there holding his jaw and watching a wounded Rollins celebrate in the ring. How hard would it have been for him and Dominik Mysterio to rush the ring and attack Seth and then hand over the briefcase?

Advertisement

Instead, Priest looked almost impotent at ringside as Raw went off the air. Thankfully, WWE has booked Damian strongly for much of the past year, but this was a notable failure in how to handle the situation.

4. The Sounds Of Silence

WWE.com

One can’t help but feel bad for the four women in the tag match situated in the death slot Monday night.

Tegan Nox, Natalya, Shayna Baszler and Zoey Stark were sent out there to die in front of a live audience just moments after they spent 20 minutes screaming their heads off for the return of The Rock, and just before a highly anticipated World Heavyweight Championship match. They never had a chance.

It didn’t help that the tag match itself was sloppy, heatless and emotionless. It was impossible to invest in a match between two duos that are barely tag teams other than being seen backstage together over the course of several weeks. Michael Cole said he’d been impressed by Nattie and Nox as a team, which was hilarious when you realize they’d had a grand total of three tag matches at that point, losing two of them.

Advertisement

WWE really needs to figure out how to book this tag division, because it’s just not clicking.

3. Skippable Material

WWE.com

When The Rock returned out of nowhere on SmackDown last fall, it truly was a magical moment.

When Jinder Mahal came out as the announced “former WWE champion” and was interrupted by Rock Monday night, it felt like fait accompli. There was no way Mahal was the surprise return, and Rock’s appearance to defend the people and America against the foreign heel was necessary by wrestling booking standards.

That was all fine and good, but on its face, Rock’s promo was not. Sure, fans cheered, laughed and chanted along to his direction, but it felt like Rock was spitting all the material they had cut from his previous 10 appearances because it wasn’t good enough. If you just wanted the experience, you could have fast-forwarded after the surprise pop died down to him dropping the predictable People’s Elbow to get to the newsworthy stuff.

As a moment, this will get a lot of clicks on social media and get fans juiced, especially the pointed comment about Roman Reigns. But for as much of Raw programming as this segment ate up, it frankly was not his best material. Diehard Rock fans will love it though.

2. Even Cody Seems Bored

WWE.com

The Cody Rhodes/Shinsuke Nakamura feud seemed like a good idea to occupy Rhodes during the December doldrums before Royal Rumble season takes over and dominates the American Nightmare’s focus.

But the rivalry has been a rollercoaster of mini-developments, riding up and down week to week, but never peaking very high. It’s been nothing more than a placeholder feud, and it’s never felt like anything more than that, despite WWE’s insistence otherwise.

Monday, Cody talked about being stuck on Shinsuke because “this should be over.” Saying it that plainly and then insisting Nakamura come out to end the feud that night felt like a bit of reality seeping through, like he was done with playing along with the vignettes and comic book animation segments and wanted to skip ahead to the last page of the chapter.

Nakamura, of course, was having none of it and offered up a pre-taped, subtitled video telling Rhodes that he’d have to wait one more week before they tangled. Hopefully, that ends this feud and they don’t bait-and-switch things again, because it clearly doesn’t have the juice, which is a shame because there was a chance of this being a fun distraction.

1. Romanticizing Awesome Truth

WWE.com

To quote the Miz, “Really?”

The WWE Universe has officially gone through the looking glass, as they’ve reached the point where the Awesome Truth, a short-lived tag team of Miz and R-Truth, was being remembered fondly during a “reunion” of the duo Monday night. The occasion included Michael Cole romanticising about how they caused trouble a number of years ago, with Wade Barrett noting that they held WWE hostage at one point.

Yep, newer fans heard that correctly. Miz and R-Truth once held WWE hostage and nearly shut down an episode of Monday Night Raw. They completely befuddled Triple H and prompted a walkout of superstars, referees and announcers. They were so dominant a duo that John Cena had to pull The Rock out of retirement to vanquish Awesome Truth at Survivor Series 2011.

Advertisement

This is the kind of memory WWE wants to pull up in 2024? When Truth is a complete comedy character and Miz is only a step or two above that? They want to remind fans that they once booked these goofs to overthrow the authority and hold the entire roster at bay.

Next they’ll be lionizing the Social Outcasts as a faction that walked their own path.

UPS…

5. Looking Out For Vinci

WWE

It would be unfair to give the Imperium/Jey Uso and Kofi Kingston match anything less than good vibes after what happened just a few minutes into the bout.

Kofi was getting battered by Giovanni Vinci and Ludwig Kaiser when he countered a diving crossbody attempt from Vinci with an errant dropkick that apparently hit him in the jaw. The kick and impact on the mat knocked Giovanni out of it, and the ringside doctor and referee almost immediately waved off the match, awarding it to Kingston and Uso.

It was a disappointing finish, but you have to tip your cap to WWE personnel for looking out for Vinci and protecting him rather than trying to soldier on.

4. Ivy Nile Gets Her Moment

WWE.com

Those who have watched NXT know that Ivy Nile has loads of potential and could be a breakout star on the main roster in 2024.

Monday, the rest of the WWE fanbase got to see that firsthand.

Nile challenged Rhea Ripley for the Women’s World Championship, and the undersized superstar hung in there and put the champ back on her heels a few times, including countering a superplex with an elevated German suplex for a close two count. Ivy showed fire and perseverance, getting fans to rally behind her… right up until Rhea headbutted her out of the sky and put her away with a Riptide.

Advertisement

For Ripley, this was a solid start to her 2024 after spending the first half of 2023 rarely defending the title and getting over more for her role in Judgment Day than as a dominant wrestling force. For Nile, this was a great way to get her over with fans and show that she belongs.

3. Rollins Gets Another Notch In His Belt

WWE.com

Say what you will about Seth Rollins or the world title he holds that should’ve never been created, but he’s done a solid job as Raw’s top champion trying to make the World Heavyweight Championship feel important.

He and Drew McIntyre had another really good TV main event for the title Monday night, countering and kicking out of each other’s best shots. They also gave fans the biggest heart-stopping moment for a title switch in a minute when McIntyre nailed the Claymore and pulled a deep cover… for two, as Drew had yanked Rollins’ foot onto the ropes inadvertently. That one had fans gasping.

Rollins would make the comeback and pick up the win – with a bit of inadvertent help from the Judgment Day – starting 2024 off right and giving him another big match victory.

Advertisement

For McIntyre, it will be interesting to see what WWE does with someone who has been one of the most well-rounded characters in recent memory. Losing his first title match to Rollins sent him down this dark path, but losing again like this has got to sting even more.

2. Rock Puts Down Jinder, Sets His Sights

WWE.com

If one were to transcribe The Rock’s promo Monday night, it would have been a sloppy, silly mess that anyone reading it would have thrown it in the trash and declared there was no way they could get that material over with fans.

But Rock isn’t anyone, and he managed to have the San Diego crowd eating out of his hand as he played the hits with Jinder Mahal, shredding the former world champion. (Incidentally, that was a masterful troll job from WWE by having Mahal announced as the touted “former WWE champion” returning to Raw.)

Rock channelled the Iron Sheik, came up with a childish nickname for Jinder, led the crowd in a sing-along chant, and put Mahal down with a People’s Elbow. As mentioned previously, this wasn’t his best stuff and was skippable for anyone outside of devoted Rock fans.

What came next is the thing that will be talked about for days and weeks ahead, with Rock asking if he should sit at the head of the table. The obvious implication here is that the Brahma Bull has now thrown himself into the mix with Roman Reigns for WrestleMania season, but the question remains whether it will be for Mania itself or the Elimination Chamber, which is looking like a major show in Australia.

Advertisement

The newsworthiness of that closing comment is what will fuel WWE and get fans excited. It also will make some fans anxious about how Cody Rhodes’ story fits into everything, but that is something that will unfold in the coming days and weeks. Love it or not, this will generate a buzz heading into the Royal Rumble and Mania seasons.

1. Jax Has Working Boots On

WWE.com

Who could have predicted that since returning Nia Jax would be one of the most impressive superstars on the roster?

Before being released two years ago, Jax was rightly derided for her questionable work – both in terms of quality and safety. She was poorly booked and simply wasn’t worth fans’ time when onscreen. But upon returning to WWE last year, Nia has become the catalyst for a Raw women’s division shakeup, first providing focus by being the villain everyone could focus on, and now as Becky Lynch’s great white whale.

Monday, Jax and Lynch finally had their long overdue one-on-one match, and it did not disappoint. The two threw haymakers at each other from the opening bell, with Lynch busting out a Diamond Dust and a Molly-Go-Round, while Nia used her size – but not in a slow, plodding way like one might imagine.

The final quarter of the match – beginning when Jax punched the ring post and missed a cannonball into the barricade – was tremendous stuff, with Becky desperately trying to get a Disarm-Her and Jax powering out twice, then countering an Avalanche Manhandle Slam with an Avalanche Samoan Drop… for a two count.

Advertisement

Finally, it was Jax landing that fabled punch, bloodying Becky, and dropping her with an Annihilator that gave Nia the elusive win. Great stuff from both, and it sets Jax up for a title match, and it forces Lynch to regroup before WrestleMania season.