5 Ups & 6 Downs From Last Night's WWE Raw (Oct 2)
Huge quality swings define one of 2017's most inconsistent shows.
Last night's Raw was a wild ride through the best and worst of the modern WWE product.
It was a show characterised by huge peaks and valleys, with little in between. For the most part, Raw was either "very good" or "very bad," and while your mileage may vary with many of the night's biggest segments, it's clear that the red brand is struggling for consistency at the moment.
On the plus side, this was one of WWE's most eventful TV episodes in months. Much of it failed, but the three hours were packed with storyline development, and The Shield's hot-shotted reunion took centre stage. Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, and Dean Ambrose all had a rough night, but the show really tied their story together, setting them up for a huge step forward next week.
Away from The Shield storyline, the women's division's major players were all present and correct, with Mickie James getting one over on Alexa Bliss and Nia Jax. Elsewhere, Braun Strowman's rehabilitation continued through a big singles match, the 'Good Brothers' scored a much-needed win, and Enzo Amore's Cruiserweight reign continued in typically annoying fashion.
Which segments raised the bar, and which ones tempered the excitement? Let's take a look.
Downs...
6. Titus Drifts Away
'The Drifter' is a tremendous midcard act. He's one of only a few wrestlers capable of drawing legitimate heel heat in 2017, and his songs always illicit a hateful response from the crowd, no matter the content. This week's was no different, but Elias' contributions to Raw took a nosedive thereafter.
Titus O'Neil interrupted his Alice In Chains knock-off, then fought 'The Drifter.' It was set up when Elias attacked Titus after defeating Apollo Crews last week, but it was too short to offer anything substantial, and the scant action we got didn't deliver. His character is great, but Elias is nowhere near good enough to carry an opponent as clumsy as O'Neil, and it showed.
The one positive is that WWE booked the right finish, with Elias hitting his opponent with a rope-hung Stunner, then pinning him with his Drift Away finisher. Their clear communication issues were on display even as Titus struggled to get himself into position for the conclusion, so here's hoping we've seen the last of this mini-feud from an in-ring standpoint.
5. Nia Jax Reverts To Type
Eight days after impressing everyone with her most monstrous main roster performance to date, Nia Jax defaulted on Monday Night Raw. Her match with Mickie James (one of the most accomplished performers in the division) was no good, and a sad reminder of her in-ring deficiencies following an excellent showing at No Mercy.
Nia looked sloppy throughout. Working with a veteran like James should've helped ease her through her control segments, but no: she struggled to keep things interesting, with a slow-motion mid-match spear the biggest low point. For all the deserved praise she received the other week, she still has a lot to learn between the ropes, as this match starkly reminded us.
Mickie won after executing a sloppy DDT of her own, before Alexa Bliss jumped in for the disqualification. The scene closed with the new number one contender laying the Raw Women's Champion out. There's a chance Nia could be inserted to make this a three-way feud, but if this match is anything to go by, that'd be a bad, bad idea.
4. A Tag Team Snoozefest
Raw's women didn't have a good night. The Susan G. Comen segment was heartening, and there were a couple of strong individual performances peppered throughout the show, but their biggest contributions didn't deliver.
With the main title program out of the way, Bayley and Sasha Banks teamed to face Alicia Fox and Emma later in the evening. This quartet should be skilled enough to produce a memorable bout, but it fell flat, with both teams struggling to inject any drama into what quickly became an overlong plodder.
Emma is underrated, but hasn't delivered since returning, while Fox is wildly inconsistent. Neither was on top form last night, with their heat segment particularly tiresome. It produced a lifeless hot tag from Bayley, which was enough to prompt Emma to say "screw this" and walk out on her partner, leaving her to take the pinfall.
There was no need for the 13-minute runtime, but this could've been mitigated had the performers not sleepwalked their way through the bout. It stunk, and if you didn't catch Raw, you'll miss absolutely nothing by skipping this match and watching the 2:51 YouTube clip instead.
3. The Burial Of Mickie James
Mickie James vs. Alexa Bliss had great potential as a savvy veteran vs. cocky upstart feud, but WWE have poisoned it with a destructive narrative. The "old lady" shtick has to stop. In pushing this theme, WWE are only building the perception that James is over the hill and unworthy of her spot on the card, which does nothing to compel the crowd to invest in her as a babyface challenger.
WWE took it to the extreme last night. Emma mocked James' age early in the show, before the five-time Women's Champion received the "gift" of adult diapers from a "secret admirer." When she wrestled Nia Jax, James was totally dominated through long stretches, which does nothing to refute Bliss' claims her better years are behind her.
The dumbest thing about this angle is that Mickie is only 38, which isn't far from the age many wrestlers peak at these days. Last week's promo showed that she's still strong on the mic, and while she may have lost a step athletically, there's no evidence to suggest that James has clearly declined in the ring. This angle isn't based on reality. It's a mess, and Mickie will be buried when Alexa inevitably wins.
2. Bray Wyatt Being Bray Wyatt
There was a lot of objectively bad content on this week's Raw, and unsurprisingly, Bray Wyatt's contributions sit near the top of the pile. 'The Eater Of Worlds' was at his babbling worst this week, first reciting nonsense in a smoke-filled room early in the show, before interrupting Finn Bálor later on, delivering another of his pointless, meandering diatribes.
The Irishman was cutting a generic teardown promo on Wyatt when the lights cut, and Bray appeared on the tron. He was still sat in his rocking chair, mumbling about Sister Abigail, whom he claimed was "dying to meet" Finn. WWE then amplified the hokiness by using some C-level special effects to transform Bray's face into that of a ghostly young woman, and cackling female laughter closed this insufferably lame feud's latest chapter.
The slight plus here is that we may finally get to meet Sister Abigail, whose arrival has been teased from the moment Wyatt first debuted, but the segment was atrocious. How can anybody take Bray Wyatt seriously at this point? He's a threat-less cartoon character who can't back his nonsensical claims up, and now needs a long, long break from television.
1. Hung Out To Dry
There's a lot to unpack when it comes to Raw's show-closing Cruiserweight segment. We'll get to the good in a moment, but the big reveal was poorly done, and contributed to one of the flattest Raw conclusions all year.
Enzo Amore's proclamation that nobody on the Cruiserweight roster could challenge for his title guaranteed a surprise appearance, and sure enough, the champ's words drew Kurt Angle from the back. Amore threw the pitch, and the GM tried to hit a home run by talking up Enzo's next challenger like a major, game-changing acquisition.
Sadly, Angle struck out as soon as he stepped on the base.
Kalisto was unleashed, and the crowd reaction was embarrassing. There arena went deathly silent as the former Lucha Dragon hit the ring, put Enzo down, then closed the segment standing tall, and WWE should've seen it coming.
The fans have no reason to care about Kalisto in 2017, as the company have done next to nothing with him all year. He's a tremendous wrestler, and somebody who should've joined the Cruiserweights a long time ago, but WWE set him up to fail here. Shame on them for hanging Enzo's next challenger out to dry, putting him in a position that was always going to flop and making him look like a fool.
Ups...
5. A Good Night For Good Brothers
Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows vs. Matt Hardy and Jason Jordan was a perfectly acceptable tag match. There wasn't anything particularly exciting, and you probably already forgot about it by the time you woke up, but there weren't any glaring flaws either. On a show as imbalanced as last night's Raw, that's just about enough to earn a position in the 'Ups' column.
There wasn't much heat, and none of the participants looked particularly outstanding, but it was a decent way to fill 10+ minutes of television. 'The Good Brothers' picking up the win makes sense, too: they're the full-time tag team, after all, so there's no real justification for them falling to a thrown-together duo like Hardy and Jordan.
Matt took the pin, not Jason, which keeps the failing babyface protected. This makes sense if their brief alliance is heading towards Jordan's expected heel turn, as WWE now have Kurt Jr.'s frustration at Hardy eating the pinfall to play on. The sooner that happens, the better, as he still isn't getting the desired crowd reactions.
4. Raising The Bar
Roman Reigns was on the warpath last night. Set to challenge for The Miz's Intercontinental Championship, 'The Guy' battered Bo Dallas and Curtis Axel during 'The A-Lister's' introductions, taking them out of the game completely. This was smart, as it should have ensured his match stayed one-on-one, though that's not how things transpired.
The duo worked a solid bout, and were probably en route to one of the year's strongest TV bouts prior to the interference, but Sheamus & Cesaro's involvement was necessary. They pulled Reigns out of the ring to prompt the DQ, then beat him down after the bell, mocking him with a huge Shield-esque triple Powerbomb to close the segment.
Having already destroyed Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose earlier in the evening, The Bar became The Miztourage's substitutes in the upcoming Shield match by taking Reigns out too. This makes all the sense in the world, and will ensure a far stronger match, though it does feel a little haphazard. Regardless, this is a solid way to maximise the hot-shotted reunion.
3. The Most Annoying Guy In The Room
Say it quietly, but Enzo Amore as Cruiserweight Champion is working.
Yes, he's a shoddy wrestler, but his microphone skills have never been in doubt. His promos are always good, and he's one of the most genuinely irritating performers in the company, which is what makes him such a good heel. Enzo does a great job of making you want to see him get his head kicked in, and he was in good form last night, mocking the division for their decision to beat him down (thus surrendering all future title shots) the other week.
It's great that WWE positioned this segment at the end of the show, too. The Kalisto reveal was horrendous, but the placement shows that they're actually trying with the division now. 205 Live is finally getting some shine, and all it took was the addition of one of WWE's goofiest characters.
Having Enzo defeat Neville seemed like a terrible idea at the time, but he's absolutely delivering, and should continue to draw new eyes to the Cruiserweights if the angle continues down its current path.
2. David Vs. Goliath
Opening Raw with an actual match rather than a repetitive in-ring talking segment is almost worth an 'Up' on its own, but regardless, Seth Rollins vs. Braun Strowman was a great TV bout.
They worked a textbook big man vs. little man format, but they did it well. Rollins plays a solid underdog, and Braun thrives when he's allowed to throw smaller, more athletic opponents around the ring, largely reducing them to hope spots throughout. He kept Seth under control for most of the bout, but 'The Kingslayer' had his moments too, with a late-match Blockbuster spawning an explosive one-count kickout from his opponent.
'The Monster Among Men' scored a necessary victory by crushing Rollins with a clothesline when he went for the ripcord knee, then downing him with the Powerslam. His post-match destruction of both Rollins and Dean Ambrose was a tad unnecessary, but the action before it was excellent, and an important step in WWE's attempts at rebuilding Braun following his defeat to Brock Lesnar. Two thumbs up.
1. The Silent Reunion
Understated storytelling isn't exactly something WWE are known for these days, but they showed remarkable restraint with this week's full-on Shield reunion, closing the show with a brief, silent encounter between Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins, and Roman Reigns.
'The Guy' was in his locker-room, licking his wounds from his beating earlier in the evening, when Ambrose quietly showed up to stand beside him. Rollins soon followed, and the trio dispersed after exchanging a set of knowing glances, setting the stage for a more grandiose coming together next week.
It still feels like WWE are pulling the trigger on this reunion too soon, but they did an outstanding job in piecing it together last night. It feels fresh, exciting, and important. All they've really done is place the trio's individual rivals together and force The Shield to reunite through mutual adversity, but sometimes, that's all it takes. This professional wrestling malarkey really isn't all that complicated...