5 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE WrestleMania XV
The Ragin' Anti-Climax.
The incredible conclusion to WrestleMania XIV was just another 1998 moment made perfect by one of Jim Ross' iconic calls. "The Austin Era has begun" was the sort of line 'Good Ol JR' was always excellent at deploying at exactly the right time. His storytelling did as much - sometimes more - as the wrestlers themselves when it came to getting over the chaos and carnage of the day.
It was for that reason Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock insisted upon his presence for their WrestleMania XV headliner. 'The Rattlesnake' knew his close friend would do much to flesh out the lashings of daftness that defined the time and at least make their brawl feel like the main event on a 'Show Of Shows' full-to-bursting with weirdly similar scraps.
The best of the rest of the Attitude Era were ready to cap off a tumultuous decade of WrestleMania's with the most barmy of the lot - even if it meant sacrificing in-ring quality almost entirely. Typically, it fell to one man to save the show on that front, but we'll get to his unenviable task a little later.
(Want more WrestleMania Ups & Downs? We got 'em: I, 2, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, 13, 14)
Downs...
6. Three Times As Stupid
The Hardcore Title triple threat match that opened WrestleMania XV offered the first problem with Vince Russo's scattergun booking taking over the biggest pay-per-view of the year.
The contest itself was a little on the silly side thanks to the some of the cartoonish weapon shots, but was dead before it came to life thanks to Billy Gunn's late insertion in place of his New Age Outlaws partner Road Dogg.
This will come up later too, but the Outlaw Hardcore/Intercontinental switch before the 'Show Of Shows' destroyed the chemistry (and storyline reason to be) of two separate matches on the card. Billy Gunn had been feuding over both the Intercontinental Championship and Ryan Shamrock's heart in the weeks leading up to the show - this served only as a destination for 'Mr Ass' to lose a title he didn't even want.
5. Double Or Nothing
Owen Hart and Jeff Jarrett were great Tag Team Champions in yet another dire time for the doubles division in WWE, but the problematic lack of opposition resulted in pre-show battle royal co-winners Test and D'Lo Brown earning spots on the biggest pay-per-view of the year despite not remotely being able to get along throughout.
It was another typical Russo flex. Almost as if he was a man that struggled with friendships, he seemed to love scripting tag partners to not get along. Pitched as a byproduct of the chaotic times, teams' inability to coexist became the rule rather than the exception, to the point where fans were all too willing to accept D'Lo and Test's failings as a pairing, even if it undermined the excellence of the Jarrett/Hart pairing. Which it did.
There are several points during this WrestleMania that the whole event feels like a supersized edition of Raw. This match might have actually benefited from a commercial break.
4. Dogg Rough
Lumbered with the same issues as the opener, Road Dogg's successful retention of his Intercontinental Title went to waste thanks to the fact he wasn't feuding with the other three men.
There was thus a shred of logic to him at least having his eyes on the prize long enough to actually keep hold of it, but Road Dogg - particularly this iteration - wasn't so much part of his own match as he was trapped in it. Ken Shamrock's sister Ryan had been curtly courted by Val Venis and Goldust (and Billy f*cking Gunn) beforehand, but even her tryst with 'The Bizarre One' and his own sidekick The Blue Meanie fell away under the blunted lead of Russo's pencil.
The storyline actually warranted a four-way finale. It was just a shame it wasn't this one.
3. Turn, Turn, Turn
Triple H and Kane's match was an objective stinker before the complex character arcs were wrapped up in a closing stretch that wouldn't quite hang together until later on that night.
To recap: Babyface DX Chyna had turned heel to join The Corporation in January, but within the stable had joined forces with trapped babyface Corporation slave Kane. Meanwhile, babyface Triple H fumed, promising revenge on Chyna (reasonably so) and, subsequently, Kane (less so).
Ultimately, there wasn't really a true heel in the match until Chyna appeared on the scene, but her role was to turn babyface (?) on the quasi-babyface Kane to help babyface Triple H deliver a decidedly heelish beatdown to Kane as part of a mammoth babyface triumph. Were they in cahoots all along, or had they mended fences? It wasn't clear until later. Little was.
It was a lot to keep track of, and barely saved by the mammoth pop for Chyna's supposed rejoining of DX at the contest's conclusion.
2. Bass Drop
Sable's Women's Title defence against ex-stalker Tori was a total mess long before the inexperienced Nicole Bass made the jump from Howard Stern's show (via ECW) to destroy the challenger in a lame finish.
The Champion was half out of the door thanks to a monumentally successful Playboy spread that month, and relations with WWE were about to get worse before they got better later that year. The match - already up against it - suffered accordingly.
The entire spectacle foreshadowed the disarray the division was about to be plunged into as result of impending backstage explosions. Sable's rank indifference for the task at hand was all too obvious by this point, regardless of the reactions her call-and-response intro generated even after a heel turn.
1. Hung Up
Considered by most fans to be the worst Hell In A Cell outing in the gimmick's history, Big Boss Man's battle with The Undertaker is only really remembered for the horrifyingly stupid post-match sequence in which the Cobb County lawman's head is chucked into a noose.
The visual is memorable for all the wrong reasons, not least in considering how 'The Deadman's feud with The Corporation played out. He wasn't just content beating Boss Man here, he had to try and actually murder him to make his point crystal clear - he was coming for Vince McMahon and prepared to kill his henchmen along the way.
Or he was actually working for him all along and this was all just a sh*tty game of chess to get to Steve Austin. One or the other.
Ups...
5. Knockout
Bart Gunn didn't deserve to be fed to actual boxer Butterbean as a "reward" for his Brawl For All victory the prior year, but after the tournament tanked many an episode of Raw in 1998, it was nice to see this kept relatively short a year later.
As a spectacle, it had all the ingredients required for making a legitimate WrestleMania moment. It fused old and new - the Attitude Era-esque carnage was watched by an aging Gorilla Monsoon making his final appearance at the 'Show Of Shows' before his sad passing later that year. It had celebrity involvement thanks not only to one of the combatants but referee Vinny Pazienza and guest judges Chuck Wepner and Kevin Rooney. Most important of all was the red hot finish - Gunn was looking at the lights but left seeing stars.
The sheer violence was exhilarating, even in spite of the rather cynical undercurrent.
4. A Big Show
There was something broadly sweet about Mankind's desperation to make it into the WrestleMania main event any way he could (and it did at least provide a narrative thread to his controversial return the following year), but more impressive was Mick Foley's ardent effort to get The Big Show following a ropey first month with the organisation.
Despite his imposing size and equally massive reputation thanks to nearly four years in WCW, Paul Wight had spent his first thirty days getting bantered off by The Rock and beaten by Stone Cold Steve Austin. Kicking the f*ck out of Mick Foley - as it did for many - almost turned things around.
Foreshadowing the rest of his career, the contest concluded with him slapping gaffer Vince McMahon after getting himself disqualified by hurtling backwards into a pile of steel chairs with 'Mrs Foley's Baby Boy' on his back. A turn here was greeted with joy and surprise rather than an almighty groan.
3. He Rose Again
Pete Rose's second WrestleMania appearance was almost as funny as the first. What he lacked in wit was made up for in wile - even if his cunning was quickly undone by 'The Big Red Machine' once again.
The San Diego Chicken had been bothering Brawl For All referee Vinny Pazienza earlier in the night, but little care was paid to the mascot until he returned to deck Kane from the darkness. As the advantage was rapidly reversed, Kane ripped the chicken's head off before he could snap it revealing his old nemesis 'Charlie Hustle'.
Rose was brilliant again. He'd proved a natural wrestling heel when Kane too was on the dark side. Here against Corporate tweener Kane, he was even easier to laugh at and loathe.
2. The Money
Long before Shane McMahon realised he could simply jump from or off great heights to generate the pops and ego-boosts he craved, he genuinely attempted respect the storytelling art of professional wrestling. Fortunately, he was in there with the industry's finest fabulist.
X-Pac and 'Shane O Mac' assembled a glorious war in which the former European Champion got to be goliath in an effort to take back his stolen prize. The title didn't normally matter, but was the second most-treasured prize on the entire event as a result of the electric chemistry between the two.
It all ended in heartbreak for the challenger - his best friend and DX leader revealed the true nature of his reunion with Chyna. They had both turned heel. A Pedigree floored X-Pac long enough for Shane to steal the win, before a DX/Corporation war triggered Kane's remergence and the first embers of yet another powerful programme later that year. This, in defence of the much-maligned (elsewhere in this piece, no less) Vince Russo, was Very Good Sh*t.
1. The War Is OVER
Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock assembled an energetic effort in their first of three WrestleMania epics, but injuries and the era itself reduced the match to a relentless series of scintillating spots and boy-popping near falls as every f*cker took their moment alongside the two biggest stars in the industry that had been comprehensively reclaimed by a WWE now firmly shaped in their image.
The aforementioned announce booth return of Jim Ross kicked off the procession of pre and mid-match returns. Vince McMahon was out next to proclaim himself guest referee for the clash, only for Commissioner Shawn Michaels to turn up and boot him from the scene. Mick Foley was out later as McMahon tried and failed with every last trick to keep Austin away from the WWE Championship.
His plans - as they always ultimately did - failed. WrestleMania XV wasn't entirely a world worth returning to, but the days of authority figures actually losing was a nice reminder of how well the idea used to actually work.