5 Ups & 7 Downs For WWE Raw (8 Sept - Results & Review)
AJ Lee shines in WWE Raw return amidst stale main event scene.
In the span of a couple of weeks, WWE has managed to turn its programming from a stale, hamster wheel-treading product to a stale, hamster wheel-treading product with some fireworks and fun side quests.
Becky Lynch aligning with her husband and AJ Lee’s subsequent return to WWE provided the company with a much-needed shot in the arm that livened up a rivalry that was veering into the absurd. Monday night saw AJ’s return to the red brand for the first time in a decade, and that showdown between Lee and Lynch (and their husbands) did not disappoint. Also, Jey Uso added a wrinkle to his character that could go in one of a few different directions. His one, deliberate spear in the post-main event scrum could be a one-off, or it could signal a big character shift.
However, Raw continued its pattern of mostly bang-average wrestling, with most of the matches being booked during the show, with one bout coming together a full hour into the episode. The company continued to verbally fellate Brock Lesnar, as they’re clearly charging ahead with this embarrassment of a project. And the main event scene for the past three months has been dominated by six or seven wrestlers, competing in various combinations of matches that almost never have any real stakes and just as rarely go to a clean finish. Then, most of these matches are followed by a brawl that sees the heels stand tall.
Where have we seen that kind of booking before? Oh, 1997-98 WCW called. They want their royalty check.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
7. Just A Match
On paper, Penta versus Rusev should be one of WWE’s better midcard matchups, a first-time-ever pairing that they could book with a stipulation such as a future title shot on the line.
Instead, WWE threw this match out there just minutes after Raw GM Adam Pearce booked it because the two wrestlers were squabbling backstage. Even though both were arguing about wanting to wrestle for a title, Pearce did not add a stip that the winner would challenge Dominik Mysterio for the Intercontinental Championship.
The match itself was bang-average, though it went less than nine minutes and featured a run-in from the New Day and Grayson Waller, which provided the distraction necessary to allow Rusev to nail a leaping Penta with a Machka Kick for the win.
This makes little sense for WWE to throw this out there with zero fanfare or planning, and then having no stakes and booking a run-in distraction means that everyone can shrug off the result. It wouldn’t be a surprise at all if they simply booked a rematch next week and added the IC title stipulation while banning New Day from ringside. Because that’s how WWE operates these days.
6. Woof
Wade Barrett caught some flak for saying that Nikki Bella might have been one of the best of her day, but the competition was stiffer in 2025 WWE than it was a decade ago. That’s a true statement that puts over today’s wrestlers while acknowledging the Hall-of-Famer has to work to reclaim glory.
In that vein, Nikki versus Asuka on Monday night was a great case study. However, the result was a match with Asuka working at half-speed and pulling her strikes and kicks. With a character getting as much focus as Asuka and being poised to be a killer in the women’s division, she should be like a buzzsaw through opponents, not fumbling around into wrestling holds.
The match wasn’t terrible, and Bella gave Asuka plenty before tapping out, but in 2025 with the talent on the roster – particularly the women’s division – this was a subpar effort.
Perhaps Nikki would be best served in a tag team with a “young lioness” so she can continue to ramp up without having to stand out for the entire match.
5. El Grande Conquistadors
Maybe this is just a personal gripe and the entire El Grande Americano saga just isn’t for this writer, but the continued story with Ludwig Kaiser under a mask just isn’t doing it.
Grande suffered his first loss on Raw Monday night when AJ Styles defeated him, with a little help from Dragon Lee, who neutralized a second El Grande Americano (likely Pete Dunne). The entire story has transformed from the original Chad Gable trying to learn how to beat luchadores to a German wrestler who has been under-utilized getting a second life as an American luchador.
The match itself was fine, with a pretty sweet reversal series for the finish, but it just feels like everything is on a hamster wheel, spinning around and going nowhere. They’ve just brought Styles into this vortex to freshen up the matchups somewhat.
Wake those who aren’t buying it when something fun and interesting happens. There is still hope that something will spark.
4. Bayley’s Struggles Continue
"I'll make it right."
AdvertisementYou good, Bayley? ? pic.twitter.com/HOZnziGnP7
— WWE (@WWE) September 9, 2025
There is a very real chance that once the vignettes end and Bayley returns to WWE to portray this Jekyll-and-Hyde character in person, everything will click and it will all make sense. You’ve got to imagine that Two-Face doing a pre-taped interview wouldn’t work well, but the live portrayal works just fine.
Still, that doesn’t excuse another video that featured Bayley talking about not knowing what her next step is, while Hugger Bayley and Role Model Bayley argued as inner monologues. Bayley insisted that she’s a good person, but she doesn’t know if Lyra Valkyria will ever forgive her. After a lengthy back-and-forth between the voices, Bayley declared that she’ll “make it right” with Lyra.
The funny part about this is that the vignette aired just moments after AJ Lee spoke about her mental health struggles and how she had to go to therapy to get right, and then there was Bayley playing a character in need of her own mental health interventions, but it was being played for entertainment. Even Corey Graves made a light “joke” about Bayley needing to consult AJ for a therapist.
Poor timing there, and a silly concept. Get it back in person and see if it works. If it doesn’t, WWE needs to pivot or mercy kill this.
3. Booking On The Fly
When Raw went on the air Monday night, it had two matches announced, plus the Raw return of AJ Lee. That’s not terrible, but that’s also not enough to fill 150 minutes of programming.
During the course of Raw’s first hour, GM Adam Pearce booked three more matches, all of which occupied Raw’s final hour, including the main event. And these weren’t aired as “earlier today” backstage confrontations – they all took place in real time during the show.
That means – in kayfabe – that Raw went on the air Monday night with only a half-booked show and then just slapped three matches together during the program to fill out the episode. That’s insanely ridiculous and isn’t serious scripting. At least when they do the “earlier today” shtick, it partially absolves the image of not having a plan for the show when it begins.
Doing this is also lazy booking because you don’t have to employ foresight or even modest advance booking to announce a match the week prior (or even during the week). Even if they just announced the card at the beginning of Raw and it was a couple random pairings, that would at least feel like a competent program.
Instead, it’s just Pearce relying on the chaos backstage to generate enough confrontations to fill out his card.
2. Brock Ruins Everything x 44
BROCK LESNAR. ?SMACKDOWN. ?THIS FRIDAY. ? pic.twitter.com/nb4N8Uhypw
Advertisement— WWE (@WWE) September 9, 2025
Brock Lesnar’s appearance on SmackDown was insidious, bordering on diabolical. The video recap of his interference in the United States Championship match between John Cena and Sami Zayn prompted this Raw reply.
Without even touching on the obvious issue of WWE continuing to employ and use Brock on television, his run-in on SmackDown was just a tired, decade-old playbook being recycled to diminished effect. When Lesnar first returned and showed up to wreak havoc, it was new, fresh, and exciting. In 2025, blowing up the last-ever Cena/Zayn match as part of an angle is just plain dumb. It doesn’t generate “heel heat” – it creates “f*** off heat.”
But let’s talk about the more sinister aspect of this, with Lesnar’s name appearing 44 times in a suit Janel Grant filed against McMahon and WWE alleging sexual abuse and human trafficking.
WWE bringing Brock back is bad enough, but the sports entertainment juggernaut that’s too big to fail clearly feels it’s untouchable these days. They ran Lesnar out there Friday night in a situation where he was guaranteed to get booed mercilessly – breaking up an all-face match will do that – and had the temerity to book it on the same show as AJ Lee returning after a decade-long absence.
As Michael Hamflett noted on the WhatCulture SmackDown Review podcast, this is WWE’s version of sportswashing, called “Brock-washing,” because the company knew AJ’s return would dominate the headlines and attention of fans, sucking all the oxygen out of the room and diminishing the pushback against Lesnar’s continued use on WWE programming.
It’s disgusting, and it should continue to be called out, not ignored for the sake of reviewing the product.
1. Stale Main Event Scene
Oh look, it’s another Raw main event featuring some combination of members of The Vision squaring off against a combo of LA Knight/Jey Uso/CM Punk/Penta! That’s new, fresh, and exciting…
For the seventh consecutive week (and 10th in 11 weeks), Raw was main-evented by some combination of those wrestlers, battling in matches that mostly ended in disqualifications, had shenanigan finishes, or were booked as no-DQ matches in the first place. That’s a run that stretches back to 23 June, when Cody Rhodes defeated Jey in the King of the Ring tournament.
(The outlier match in that run? Iyo Sky versus Stephanie Vaquer on 23 July, which ended in a no contest.)
What makes this main event scene more monotonous is that the matches tend to follow the same pattern: the outcome is irrelevant, but The Vision will oftentimes put the faces down in the aftermath with a series of spears and tsunamis. Only two of these 10 matches actually carried stakes: a World Heavyweight Championship match between Knight and Seth Rollins (ended in a DQ) and the world title gauntlet match Punk won.
Otherwise, it’s a meaningless crush of 15-20 minute matches where the outcome is secondary, the beatdowns are mandatory, and everything resets after Raw ends.
Ups…
5. "Therapy! Therapy!"
A quick note separate of the AJ Lee/Becky Lynch segment…
During her promo, AJ Lee spoke about how she retired from WWE 10 years ago and went on her own “mental health journey.” She spoke about how she needed to take care of herself and went to therapy, eliciting cheers from the crowd, and even a “Therapy!” chant. AJ spoke to those struggling by saying she had turned her mental chaos into her superpower, and that anyone else going through it should know that getting help is worth it, and that they’re worth it.
Whether WWE as an organization truly believes in this in 2025, it’s a far cry from the company’s historic treatment of mental health. AJ herself was booked as a “crazy chick” for the majority of her run. Stories of the company not treating mental health seriously have surfaced numerous times.
The WWE of a decade ago never would have allowed a wrestler to go on television and speak so openly about their mental health struggles (without being mocked about it), and for the fans to unironically applaud Lee’s declaration also shows how far society has come. Normalize this stuff. It’s okay to not be okay.
4. Raquel Clips Lyra’s Wings
Few wrestlers have undergone such an incredible transformation in such a short time as Raquel Rodriguez. Since taking some gentle criticism from Kevin Nash a few months ago to heart, she has changed her in-ring style and become the “big woman” that her frame suggested, and she’s benefited from that evolution.
Raquel squared off with Lyra Valkyria on Monday night in a battle between power and speed. Valkyria relied on her agility and strikes to keep Rodriguez off-balance, but Big Mami Cool consistently snuffed out rallies with brute force. A few points looked a bit rough, but it also felt more like a struggle than a botch in those circumstances.
Lyra had an impressive power moment herself when she tried for a sunset bomb out of the corner and hoisted herself back up to give added momentum and pull Raquel off the turnbuckle. However, it was Raquel plucking Lyra off the top rope for a Tejana Bomb and picking up the win.
Even in defeat, Valkyria looked great as the smaller face-in-peril, fighting from underneath, while Rodriguez picked up a singles win that added to her status as an imposing figure in the women’s division.
3. Asuka Dominates Everything
One of the more wonderful things about WWE in recent years has been its willingness to let its international wrestlers cut promos in their native languages. It adds a more global and authentic feel to the product.
But it has also been great to see someone like Asuka mixing in more English into her conversations, which has allowed for more interactive and deeper confrontations. Monday night, the Empress of Tomorrow mixed it up backstage with Nikki Bella on two separate occasions, as well as Rhea Ripley. She warned Bella to stay away from Iyo Sky and laughed when Nikki told her that she would respect her. Asuka then threatened to beat the respect out of her.
Later, Asuka refused to shrink away from Rhea, calling her and Bella “problems” and declaring she’s the top woman in WWE, standing up to the statuesque and imposing Ripley.
The way Asuka is being presented right now, she feels more dominant and threatening than at any point since her first year on the main roster. Chalk up a few big wins, and she would have “final boss” vibes as an opponent.
On top of that, she’s got a great little gag with Kairi Sane, calling for her demure tag partner offscreen to follow her. It adds a bit of a**hole while being humorous.
2. Jey’s Had Enough
Since losing his World Heavyweight Championship in June, Jey Uso has struggled to regain his footing. He’s fallen short in the King of the Ring tournament, the world title gauntlet match, and the fatal four-way at Clash in Paris.
Throw in the constant beatings from The Vision, and it’s understandable that Jey has been tiring of the cycle of fighting with no ascension back to the world title. Monday, he gave pretty strong Roman Reigns vibes – with Jimmy Uso calling it out – when talking about why he didn’t care about LA Knight or anyone else who didn’t acknowledge the Usos. This came after a miscommunication between Jey and LA that saw Uso splashed in the corner.
That set the stage for the post-main event scene when Knight and Jimmy tried to fight off Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed, only to be overcome. Jey ran down for the save, and the faces cleared the ring, only for Main Event Jey to spear Knight and declare that they were good now.
While it might not be a full-fledged heel turn for Jey, it serves as a fly in the ointment, a bit of an edge or a question of whether he can be fully trusted by any of his former or current allies – including his brother Jimmy.
What will be interesting is whether the fans follow suit and boo Jey, or if they insist on “yeeting” along with everything he does.
1. AJ Lights It Up
Seth Rollins and CM Punk have been feuding off-and-on for nearly two years at this point, and in the span of eight days, it all suddenly feels fresh and invigorated.
The moment Becky Lynch aligned with her husband to cost Punk the World Heavyweight Championship, it opened the floodgates to AJ Lee returning to WWE, adding a new wrinkle to this rivalry and breathing life into a Raw main event scene that’s desperate for a shot of adrenaline.
Lee made her return to Raw and spoke about her journey during the past decade before deciding to come back to WWE. She lamented that she and Becky have a lot in common and could have been friends, which brought Lynch out to rant and rave about how AJ was wearing her Intercontinental Championship.
AJ was fantastic here. During her last run, she played either the deranged, unhinged woman or the quirky nerd. Monday, she updated her character to be quirky and mischievous, bringing elements of her past run forward without the obvious politically incorrect baggage. She talked about how she wore the IC title around the house all weekend, slept with it on, but it got weird when she was getting dressed Monday morning…
When Becky took off her ridiculous sunglasses and screamed, AJ noticed her black eye and wondered aloud whether it was “one of my tiny fists of fury” that did that. She apologized, noting that “Sometimes I go feral and blackout.” Rollins came out to defuse the situation, but when he entered the ring to retrieve the title, AJ stepped in front of the belt and playfully blocked him (like Lynch did to Punk last week).
All of this led to Rollins being run off by Punk and agreeing to a mixed tag match at Wrestlepalooza. Great stuff all around, but the real story here is that AJ felt like she was fully part of the show again, not a special guest star. She was authentic on the mic and comfortable mixing it up. This bodes well for the coming weeks and months.