5 Ups & 8 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Jan 8)
Big Jon Moxley/Inner Circle segment highlights a dysfunctional, misfiring episode.
AEW rebounded with aplomb on 1 January, batting recent criticisms back with one of the strongest Dynamites yet after being slaughtered by NXT in their last head-to-head battle, bringing hopes of an upturn after losing more than half their televised audience since launching in October.
The numbers were strong, with 967,000 viewers tuning in. Sure, beating NXT's clip-heavy year-end award show meant next to nothing, but the recovery from 683,000 on 18 December most certainly did and last night, with the Wednesday Night Wars back in full effect, AEW had a chance to build on that momentum.
This article's title should indicate how they fared in this regard.
It was a night that promised much, with Jon Moxley set to answer Chris Jericho's Inner Circle invitation, Cody's response to MJF's outrageous Revolution match stipulations, a Women's World Championship bout pitting Riho against Kris Statlander, and the Rhodes Brothers facing off against the Lucha equivalents. Elsewhere, Christopher Daniels wrestled Sammy Guevara and the malfunctioning Hangman Page/Kenny Omega met wrestled Private Party.
A very disappointing night, unfortunately. Dynamite just didn't sizzle like it did last week. Let's break down why...
Downs...
8. Diminishing Returns
Sammy Guevara vs. Christopher Daniels was a fine little TV match for most of its duration. Cocky little c*nt vs. broken veteran hero is such an easy dynamic to spin, it had a bit of heat from last week's setup segment, and there was the added bonus of CD's ongoing story, with the SoCal Uncensored man out to prove he's still got it after botching an Arabian Press while wrestling Pentagon Jr.
The problem was the finish. Daniels was undone when Pentagon came out with a microphone, dared the 'Fallen Angel' to hit the top rope, and facilitated the distraction finish. Guevara took the pin after booting Daniels' head off.
Sure, it continues the Daniels/Pentagon feud, but does that rivalry really need another chapter? It also came straight after the screwy finish in Riho vs. Kris Statlander. Two-in-a-row is grating, particularly in a company that once trumpeted a "real-sport feel," and Guevara vs. Daniels didn't hit.
7. Brandi's Burials
AEW's decision to bring wrestlers into the announce booth on Dark has worked well for the B-show, though Brandi Rhodes' stint on Dynamite commentary was wholly destructive last night.
Brandi was in full-on burial mode. She trashed Riho, Kris Statlander, and even the match's very existence, saying that she wasn't even interested in it, and that the most interesting thing was finding out why she was out there. She even shovelled Excalibur and his mask for no good reason... and, just, why?!
This was a distracting, disruptive performance for both the viewers and Brandi's fellow announcers. It felt like the rest of the team were struggling to work around her derailments. Regardless of that, wholesale burials that detract from the action without supplementing it should never happen, particularly in a division that's still growing.
6. Where Was The Follow-Up?
Kenny Omega and Hangman Page barely had a moment to celebrate their victory before PAC appeared on the big screen, stretching the life out of Michael Nakazawa. Omega's goofy little buddy was trapped in his Brutalizer, an army of officials were trying to pry 'The Bastard' away, and when he got up, the intense Brit growled that things like this would keep happening until Omega gave him his rubber match.
'The Best Bout Machine' then ran to the back, and that was it. There was literally nothing else from this programme on the whole show. AEW left the thread hanging without tying it up, as they did a few weeks ago when PAC seemingly kidnapped Nakazawa on Dynamite ahead of a limp Dark payoff.
This would've been a nice opportunity for Omega to rush backstage, find that PAC had left the locker-room, then cut a promo on the former Neville. Lord knows Kenny needs more time on the microphone and it would've wrapped things up in a neat little bow. Instead, this unsatisfying development existed in a bubble, meaning another week passed without any real growth.
5. DDP/MJF Confrontation Falls Flat
Bringing Diamond Dallas Page into the Cody/MJF feud makes sense, given his Nightmare Family affiliation, though the in-ring confrontation between him and 'The Salt of the Earth' fell flat after a promising start.
MJF cut a textbook promo to kick things off, calling Cody a "little b*tch" when he failed to answer a 10-count to come out and accept his stipulations, drawing DDP from the back. Page rambled. He put himself over, put DDPY over, and put AEW over while MJF tweeted away in the background. Then came the toilet humour, with Page calling Wardlow "Wardblow," though things looked like they'd heat up when MJF brought The Butcher and The Blade out, telling DDP To kiss the ring or hit the dirt.
A cold, cold brawl followed. Page, at 63 years old, single-handedly took out The Butcher and The Blade, and came close to blasting MJF as well. An MJF low-blow drew QT Marshall and Dustin Rhodes out for the save to set up what should be a fun trios match next week, though the whole thing was surprisingly lukewarm for such a big storyline. Disappointing execution all-round.
4. What's The Point?
After the grand nightmare that was the 18 December closing angle, AEW needed to do something different with The Dark Order on their next live appearance. Unfortunately, they swung too far in the opposite direction.
The Dark Order were mauled here. Evil Uno tried to recruit Christopher Daniels with his corny-*ss delivery after the Sammy Guevara loss (which makes sense), indoctrinating CD with poisoned words, though his group was eventually beaten down by both SoCal Uncensored and The Young Bucks, with Daniels hitting his Best Moonsault Ever to close.
This went over like a fart in an elevator, with the crowd popping for Scorpio Sky's dive and little else. Things aren't clicking with The Dark Order. Presenting them as ineffective wet blankets after destroying the company's biggest stars in December won't help with that and, at this stage, they probably need repackaging.
3. Another Week...
... another cold introduction.
First it was The Dark Order, then it was The Butcher and the Blade, and last night it was Dr. Luther. Announcer Excalibur put the man over as a "Japanese deathmatch wrestling legend" as he crawled out from under the ring during Kris Statlander vs. Riho. That he may be, but this means little to the audience, who responded with a level of indifference suggesting few had a clue who the guy was.
AEW must stop doing this. The "hey, here's an act you don't know... please react to them!" approach failed The Dark Order on their debut, did the same when The Butcher and the Blade attacked Cody, and we're now seeing it with Dr. Luther. It's no good.
It doesn't help that Luther looked like someone who'd appear on a low-level indie show, not national television. Regardless, the writing is the biggest issue here. These debuts are colder than the shady side of an iceberg.
2. Another Week... (Part II)
... another bait and switch.
Last week saw Jon Moxley postpone his decision on joining the Inner Circle, claiming he wanted to give Chris Jericho a face-to-face answer on yesterday's show. This time, it was Cody, whose interview with Tony Schiavone was interrupted by Arn Anderson. The legend claimed MJF had no stroke to lay down stipulations for their pitched Revolution bout, then said they were still thinking about it, would talk it over next week, and get back to us.
Technically, AEW also did the thing with the promise that they'd celebrate the legends of Memphis wrestling, saving the bulk of that content for Dark.
Rather than delayed gratification, these feel like full-on WWE-style bait and switches. They have advertised these segments and decisions in advance only to pull the rug away when Dynamite hits the airwaves. It's cheap, it's unsatisfying, and it's a waste of time for disappointed viewers.
1. A Good Match Undone
Kris Statlander vs. Riho was an omni-fail of a bout, but that had absolutely nothing to do with the wrestlers. The AEW Women's World Champion and her challenger worked hard. There were signs of a great, great wrestling match unravelling and they did well to at least try to get around the overbooking, though there was little they could do in the end. The nonsense conquered all.
Nightmare Collective members Awesome Kong and Mel hit the ring relatively early on. Mel was the first to interfere, throwing Riho into the barricade, before Statlander went face-to-face with Kong. Brandi then marched down while the referee took an ice age to attend to Riho, facilitating the listless Dr. Luther introduction and while the action resumed thereafter, the f*ckery wasn't over. Mel distracted the referee, Kong grabbed Statlander, and Riho took the win. Bleh.
A classic case of bad writing getting in the way of a good match, the wretched "storyline development" wasn't worth derailing what looked like one of AEW's better women's bouts. Big Swole, Sonny Kiss, and Hikaru Shida running the heels off after the bell did nothing to ease the disappointment either.
The women's division did not need this angle at this specific time. It doesn't need The Nightmare Collective, period.
Ups...
5. More Of These, Please
Dynamite's slick, well-produced Kip Sabian/Penelope Ford video package wasn't anything fancy, but it hit all the right notes. "We're trying to bring some sex appeal back to this loser-infested company," Sabian said over highlights of last week's low blow on Joey Janela amongst other things, and it worked, putting their double-act over as one to watch.
The real Up here is that the vignette existed in the first place. AEW's video production team are great, so why aren't they utilised more? Packages like this should have featured heavily on every episode of Dynamite since the show's inception, particularly for midcard acts like Ford and Sabian, and it'd be great to see them used more going forward.
4. Go Out There & Have Some Fun
A match seemingly custom-built to trigger a certain type of wrestling fan saw Jurassic Express meet the Best Friends and Orange Cassidy in trios action, and while seeing Marko Stunt and 'Freshly Squeezed' sharing a ring probably made this an insta-Down for many, that it was so over with the crowd sees it finish as a positive here.
The audience was all the way into this. They loved everyone involved, broke out a "this is awesome!" chant, and seemed thoroughly entertained. If the objective measurement of a performer's success is how they entertain their consumers, this was a triumph, and anyone readying a "casual fans don't want to see these guys" argument (which isn't without merit) better come armed with a previous show's quarter-hour viewing figures or other non-anecdotal evidence.
The bout itself was a fun little break from some of the dreck on last night's Dynamite, with the Luchasaurus/Cassidy showdown drawing particularly big pops. Jungle Boy scored the pin, too, continuing his recent mini-ascension, and showing that AEW respect the trio's popularity.
3. Omega & Page Overcome Tension
While not quite the most compelling tag bout Kenny Omega and Hangman Page have wrestled together, their opener with Private Party worked, fit recent storylines, and got over.
Though not exactly an imposing brute himself, Page worked hossy offense against the smaller Private Party, who lit the Elite duo up with signature cocaine-fuelled tandem work. As can be the case with them, there were times when the work looked a little too cooperative to fit what is still supposed to be a scripted fight. Regardless, they worked hard, were effective foes with Omega and Page, and got the crowd buzzing - as they always do.
The slow-burning Page turn continued with a few moments of miscommunication. Hangman almost murdered Kenny with a Buckshot Lariat when Mark Quen ducked out of the way, and another spot saw Omega accidentally kick the Private Party man into Hangman. They got the job done in the end, though, with 'The Best Bout Machine' nailing the One Winged Angel following a Buckshot/V-Trigger combo, slapping hands with Page after the bell.
A well-paced storyline, this one still has a few weeks left to sizzle before Page finally pulls the trigger.
2. The Rhodes & Lucha Brothers Light It Up
The best match of the night saw the Lucha Brothers face off against Cody and Dustin Rhodes and while the outcome leaves Fenix and Pentagon feeling a tad directionless, it's hard to complain too much about what was effectively a ***1/4-***1/2 clash.
Penta and Fenix ran their usual formula. All fast action, danger, and fluid exchanges, they worked Dustin over for the hot tag, with the elder Rhodes an exceptional face-in-peril. This southern-style layout built to a nice, explosive hot tag from Cody, who had the building buzzing as he laid into Fenix with a ten-punch. Easy, timeless stuff, and it worked.
There were a couple of mistimed moments, with Pentagon sitting around waiting after what looked like an attempted synchronised Fenix/Dustin tag in one. Still, while these dulled the bout's shine, they didn't derail it outright. It was a fine TV match that Dustin won for his team after hitting the Final Reckoning on Fenix, putting him in a good position ahead of next week's six-man tag.
1. Moxley Swerves The Inner Circle
One might expect a glowing review for the biggest Up in a weekly column that leans positive more often than not. Not this week, though. The Jon Moxley/Inner Circle segment was good and yes, it accomplished what it needed to, though it wasn't anywhere near as electric as some of AEW's other big angles.
Nonetheless, this was a decent execution of a classic layout. The Inner Circle buttered Moxley up, with Chris Jericho putting him over as his "friend and protégé", and the ruse was well-played. The group celebrated with a little bit of the bubbly after Moxley unzipped his jacket to reveal a custom Inner Circle tee and pledged to stand alongside "the most dominant and influential force in AEW," and his music hit, signifying would usually be the end of the segment. Not this time, though.
"I forgot one thing," Mox said. "Chris, I was just kidding. I would never join the Inner Circle; it's a stupid group and you have nothing that I want... except that."
He was, of course, talking about the AEW Championship, and the segment finally heated up as Moxley smashed the bubbly bottle over 'Le Champion's' skull, then hit the bricks before Jake Hager could cave his skull in.
Predictable? Perhaps. Fun? Absolutely, and the Jericho vs. Moxley feud can now begin properly.