5 Ups And 3 Downs From Last Night’s WWE SmackDown (Aug 27)

How did the Dudleys do in their first WWE match in ten years?

By John Canton /

This week's Smackdown followed a very newsworthy Raw show that featured the return of Sting, the Dudley Boyz coming back to WWE after ten years away and Braun Strowman debuting as a new member of The Wyatt Family. Since Sting is obviously not going to work on Smackdown, the focus on this week's show was on the new Wyatt Family. Wyatt opened the show talking about the "black sheep" Strowman while also targeting Roman Reigns and Dean Ambrose following this week's main event. As for the Dudleys, their last official match prior to Smackdown was back on June 12, 2005 at the ECW One Night Stand event when they beat The Sandman and Tommy Dreamer. Now in their mid-40s, they apparently signed a multi-year deal while also working a full time schedule that includes weekend live events, so they'll probably be in the tag team title picture immediately. Here are the match results: The Dudley Boyz defeated The Ascension when Bubba pinned Konnor after hitting 3D. Kevin Owens defeated Neville by pinfall. Charlotte and Becky Lynch defeated Nikki and Brie Bella when Charlotte pinned Brie. Ryback and Dolph Ziggler defeated Big Show and Rusev when Show knocked out Rusev and Ziggler pinned Rusev. Sheamus defeated Dean Ambrose after The Wyatt Family distracted Ambrose and Sheamus nailed a Brogue Kick. Since it was a slightly better than average show this week, here are the five ups and three downs for this week's Smackdown.

Advertisement

Downs...

3. The Divas Match Was Too Short

The divas continue to be used in an inconsistent way. Some weeks they are booked in long matches that are good to great and the crowd responds well, but sometimes it just feels like they have made little progress. One of the problems is the way the Bellas are booked as faces one week and then heels the next week like they were booked this week. This week's tag match was booked weird with multiple sequences that looked sloppy and then Charlotte won with a takedown while doing an athletic pinfall. The match was done in about four minutes, which felt way too short for the kind of match they were doing. At least there was a highlight in this match when Naomi offered up this gem while on commentary: "I'm trying to figure out what the Bellas are good at because they're not that good in the ring." There are definitely some people that would agree with that.

2. Seth Rollins' Promo Felt Repetitive

I like Seth Rollins and I think he's probably the best overall performer in WWE right now. However, I felt his promo in the middle of the show was too repetitive with what he said on Raw. For whatever reason, WWE believes that their top heel performers need to do the same promos over and over on both Raw & Smackdown nearly every week. Rollins spoke for about seven minutes all by himself with no interruption. On Raw, he went nearly as long. There were even points in this promo that were about the same subjects he mentioned on Raw as well, so as I watched it all I wanted to do was hit fast forward. This is coming from a fan that loves Rollins, but why do we need to hear it again? I think what WWE should have done is put Rollins in a match that went about four minutes that he won clean. Then after the match, he could have done a one minute promo about how he's going to beat Sting so badly at Night of Champions that we won't see Sting in a match again. Repetitive promos and video packages are a problem with WWE right now. They think fans are stupid and that we need to hear the same things repeatedly. It's a shame because they could make better use of their time.

1. Dolph Ziggler Looked Weak Despite His Win Due To Big Show Turning Face

One of the new directions that WWE is heading in following SummerSlam is Big Show turning face. That's the kind of thing that makes me want to groan because I really don't want to see it. Show is much more effective as a heel, yet WWE is booking him like the guy that can't do anything right and when he has a partner like Rusev he ends up getting beat up. During this tag match with Show teaming up with Rusev against Ryback and Dolph Ziggler, the heel duo had problems all match long. Rusev tagged himself in and he didn't want Show to tag into the match. What bothered me so much was that Ziggler was booked like a babyface that didn't mean anything as he got a fluke win only after Big Show gave Rusev a KO Punch while Ziggler was trapped in the Accolade. Why book Ziggler in such a weak way? I know it was done because the main purpose of the match was to accelerate Show's turn. I just think Ziggler should be treated as a more important figure. This win by Ziggler came off as a fluke and shouldn't encourage any fan to think that he has a shot against Rusev in a singles match even though he should be booked to competitive against him. The guess here is that Show will help Ziggler beat Rusev when the Ziggler/Rusev feud ends so that Show can feud with Rusev, which really doesn't excite me that much at all.

Ups...

5. Rich Brennan On Commentary

This week on Smackdown, Rich Brennan was the main play by play guy for the show. According to a WWE.com article, he's taken over as the lead announcer on Smackdown effective immediately. I really like Brennan; maybe it's because I love NXT and Brennan's been the main voice of that show for so long that I've gotten used to him. In addition to NXT, Brennan had been the main commentator on Main Event with Jerry Lawler, so they've built up some pretty good chemistry. Jimmy Uso serves a purpose as an active wrestler that gets excited about everything, so I don't mind him. It was noted that Brennan was from Rhode Island, so he got to host the show from his home state. I just thought Brennan does a better job of any current WWE play by play guy in terms of calling the moves and handling the guys he's working with. Brennan is also very good at getting excited at the right time and speaking with a serious tone when he needs to as well. If this is a permanent move then that would suck for Phillips because he's pretty good at his job, but I think Brennan is better long term.

4. A Clean Victory For Kevin Owens Over Neville

Kevin Owens is starting to get momentum again. He won a crucial match against Cesaro at SummerSlam and then he beat Neville clean on Smackdown as well. This match was a lot of fun because they made the most of the nine minutes they were given. Neville's fast paced offense is a nice alternative to the power of Owens, who showed off some really impressive moves during the match like a spinning neckbreaker when he had Neville on his shoulders. Neville made the comeback, looked like he might win after a great German Suplex and then an impressive superkick outside the ring. He went for the Red Arrow, but Owens was able to avoid it. Owens nailed a huge superkick of his own, then connected with a Popup Powerbomb and that was it. Owens is well on his way to solidifying his spot as a successful upper midcard wrestler in WWE. I don't know if he's being positioned for it, but I think he'd be perfect as the next Intercontinental Champion. We'll see if it happens.

3. Sheamus Got A Quality Win Over Dean Ambrose

It wasn't clean, but it's nice to see Sheamus getting a win in a main event match against Dean Ambrose. They've had a few matches in the past and every time I've enjoyed it. This is a feud that could be great one day if they ever build it up as a personal rivalry. In their match, the Wyatt Family showed up to distract Ambrose just as he started his momentum and looked like he was going to get the win. When Ambrose was starting at the three Wyatt guys outside the ring, Sheamus capitalized with a Brogue Kick to win the match. Nobody touched Ambrose, yet they did enough just by being there. There are probably fans of Ambrose that are upset about it and I totally get that. It's just that right now the story is about making Ambrose look like a sympathetic figure along with Reigns. They'll get their wins a month or two just like they did at SummerSlam. For now, the goal is to build up the Wyatt Family a bit more. Sometimes distraction finishes are fine. This is one of those instances where it fit perfectly because of the new storyline they are trying to tell with the Wyatt Family. It also gave Sheamus a quality win, which is always a good thing for the guy holding the Money in the Bank briefcase.

2. The Dudley Boys Looked Great In Their First Match Since Returning

"Do you know we are? We're the Dudley Boyz and we're back!" - Bubba Ray Dudley. The Dudley Boyz looked great in their first WWE match in ten years. It was smart of WWE to book them in a match against a bad tag team like The Ascension, who really don't mean much right now. Sometimes when there are matches on Smackdown, you can tell that there's piped in crowd noise and the crowd isn't that into the action. In this case, the crowd was heavily invested in it from the moment the Dudleys entered the arena. It was a clean five minute win for the Dudleys, which is exactly what it needed to be. They didn't need to go longer than that and they shouldn't have been tested more than that. It was over when they hit 3D on Konnor. After the match, The New Day came out with signs to complain about the Dudleys being there and they kept their distance. That's when the Dudleys put Viktor through a table with a Powerbomb much to the delight of the crowd.

1. The Wyatt Family Is Stronger Than Ever

This week's biggest stars on WWE TV are the Wyatt Family because they look to be as stronger than ever. The addition of Braun Strowman is great for them due his powerful look and he fits the role as a powerhouse that will make the "Family" stronger. Bray Wyatt did a good promo talking about how Sister Abigail found Strowman for him and he called him "the new face of destruction." All Strowman has to do is stand there, look mean and he's going to get a big reaction out of people because he looks legitimately scary. Much like on Raw, the Wyatt Family dominated the duo of Roman Reigns and Dean Ambrose. That's exactly how they should have been booked because if WWE had Strowman get knocked down or sell anything, it would have been a big mistake. What this story has done is made Bray look like a bigger and more dangerous star. That's what Bray has needed for months now. His run as a loner didn't really work that well. As an "evil maestro" as Brennan called him, Wyatt is much more important. People will fear the Wyatt Family now, which is the perfect response for the man that calls himself the "New Face of Fear." This could be the start of Bray Wyatt's true ascension to the top of the roster as a main event performer. That's why this angle is so important right now.