5 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Extreme Rules 2020

Poor finishes drag down show, but at least it's a short PPV.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

It’s tough to categorize Extreme Rules as anything other than a disappointment. Sunday night’s PPV failed to deliver one of its title matches and was littered with poor finishes and unsatisfying results.

Advertisement

You basically turned off the PPV wondering what happened rather than reflecting on a really good, entertaining and satisfying program. No one was expecting to see a ripped-out eyeball, but what we did get after weeks of promises, was a hugely disappointing result. And that’s never a good sign, though it’s far from the first time that’s happened.

Once again, the women carried a large chunk of the program well, delivering two solid matches, one with a very messy finish that was really overdone. And once again, WWE dipped its toe into cinematic matches, which once again missed the mark. At this point, the company has used up its goodwill from the Boneyard Match and they’re just desperately trying to capture lightning in a bottle twice.

However, there was some decent wrestling here to enjoy, and the event itself was pretty short and easy to get through, so that’s always a positive thing.

With that said, it’s time to dive in and see how things shook out. Let’s get to it…

DOWNS…

6. What’s Next For New Day?

WWE.com

This writer is a big fan of New Day, and the trio (currently a duo) are merchandise mavens. They easily are one of the biggest – if not the biggest – and most successful tag teams of the past decade.

But at the same time, watching their sixth SmackDown Tag Team Championship reign come to an end Sunday night, it still makes you wonder: At what point will they transition to something else? Whether it’s a Big E singles run or even just a switch back over to Raw, you can’t help but feel like the act is becoming a bit stale on the blue brand. They’re almost the permanent fallback option to hold tag team gold.

Consider that during the past three years on SmackDown, they’ve held the tag titles six times, clocking 377 days, which is more than one-third of the time. If you take into account their time on Raw, they’ve held tag team gold for more than 45% of the time the past five years.

That by itself is not the “down” here. The negative mark is that that is all there seems to be. Kofi Kingston had a six-month run with the WWE Championship, and a month after losing the title, he transitioned right back to being a tag champ again.

Advertisement

It would be nice to see something new for New Day, some new evolution of this long-running, very successful stable, rather than just counting on every few months they’ll end up with their brand’s tag titles.

5. Crews MIA

WWE.com

It’s been a few weeks since we’ve seen Apollo Crews on WWE programming, but he was still scheduled to defend his United States Championship against MVP at Extreme Rules.

Instead, after two weeks of plugging the match, we were “treated” to an announcement that Crews had been injured last month by Bobby Lashley’s full nelson (no, seriously) and that he wasn’t medically cleared to compete. MVP came out to have the new title strapped to his waist and declare himself the new champ, which probably isn’t going to stick.

When Apollo switched to Raw earlier this year, he finally seemed to be getting his footing after years on the main roster. He won the US title and finally looked like he was getting a shot to prove himself. But since Paul Heyman’s ouster, Crews has been treated as an afterthought, and Sunday’s absence only added to the woes.

Advertisement

Now, it goes without saying that it’s possible that Crews tested positive for the virus and is off TV for that reason, but if true, then the weeks of building up a PPV match that you couldn’t deliver is in itself a “down.”

4. Our Kingdom For An Authority Figure

FOX

Never thought these words would be written: We could really use an authority figure in WWE right now.

Without someone onscreen booking matches and maintaining a semblance of order, we had MVP crowning himself the new United States Champion via forfeit and strapping a new title that he had made himself around his waist. We also had Bayley ripping the shirt off a downed referee and counting a pinfall after knocking Sasha Banks’ opponent Asuka out, declaring Banks the new Raw Women’s Champion.

A GM would have been running out of the back to declare that finish null-and-void and demand the match be restarted with a new ref. But instead, the segment ended with Banks and Bayley leaving with all the gold, and we were left to wonder what the hell just happened.

Sure, the writers believe this means fans will have to tune in to Raw Monday night to find out what happens, but if you paid for this PPV, you’re probably throwing popcorn at the TV.

3. A Bait-And-Switch Finish

WWE.com

To be fair, had WWE gone the full horror movie route and had Seth Rollins pull Rey Mysterio’s eye out of its socket, then this would have been an all-time negative.

But WWE booked an “eye for an eye” match, then delivered a finish where Rey’s eye was pushed into the corner of the steel steps (again), he covered up for a few seconds and screamed for a doctor, and the referee called for the bell. We never saw anything more than some white in Rey’s gloved hand, no blood, no gore… but Rollins did vomit because what he saw apparently was so disgusting.

That was the big special effects, horror show match for this feud. WWE advertised a stupid stipulation and then didn’t deliver, didn’t follow through on their crappy idea – at all.

Advertisement

The worst part is that Rey and Rollins had a pretty good match overall. If you removed the stupid stip, this would have been a good blood-feud match.

2. What Did We Just See?

WWE.com

Ever since the Boneyard Match, WWE continues to chase the dragon with its cinematic matches. And while the Swamp Fight was decent from a visual standpoint, it was utterly pointless and overall boring.

Yes, boring.

Bray Wyatt delivering one of his “classic” rambling sermons while he has Braun Strowman tied up was a definite low point, and the jumping from situation to situation was poorly done. Wyatt had random goons attack Braun at random points, but they were nowhere to be seen when Bray actually needed help. And just to drive the point home that this “match” didn’t matter, The Fiend showed up at the end to close the PPV, as we were left to wonder if the WWE Universal Champion had been drowned.

Sorry, cool lighting and some decent camera tricks doesn’t make for an interesting feud or match. The Boneyard Match had the benefit of being first, and now every cinematic effort is just trying to replicate that success, but it’s obvious they’re trying to copy that one good idea with a couple small changes.

Advertisement

And it didn’t work Sunday night.

1. A Horror Show Of Poor Finishes

WWE.com

Extreme Rules will go down as the ultimate placeholder show, a PPV where some wrestlers gave some good efforts, but ultimately, the show was dragged down by unsatisfying finishes and poor booking. Nothing really of consequence happened beyond one minor title change.

Several matches – Braun Strowman versus Bray Wyatt, Sasha Banks versus Asuka, and Seth Rollins versus Rey Mysterio – had bad endings. The two in-arena matches were chugging along well before the wheels fell out for the conclusions, dragging things down. Another announced title match didn’t take place. The only title change took place in a tables match, which is possibly one of the worst stipulation matches, because it’s literally building to one spot – putting an opponent through a table.

The “eye for an eye” match didn’t deliver on its stipulation, and the Swamp Fight was a poor imitation of previous cinematic matches. That’s not a good look when two of the most-hyped matches are subpar.

If you were watching this PPV thinking there would be some conclusions reached, you would be wrong. Aside from Dolph Ziggler being Claymore kicked back to the midcard, there wasn’t a lot definitively resolved. And there wasn’t a lot that is going to matter during the next couple months. This will be forgotten in a few weeks.

And now to the positives...

Advertisement

UPS…

5. From Lackeys To Champs

WWE.com

Cesaro and Shinsuke Nakamura have had a weird, meandering ride through WWE. The two are among the most athletically gifted wrestlers on the roster, and yet they’ve never reached the mountaintop.

In fact, Nak and the Swiss Cyborg have spent more time as glorified enhancement talent to top-level stars than as dominant acts themselves. They were Sami Zayn’s muscle as he ran his mouth for months, and after he disappeared, they spent some time inexplicably backing up King Corbin, because why not?

Sunday night, the duo got to shine a bit on their own, capturing the SmackDown Tag Team Championship by knocking off the New Day. Better yet, the win came somewhat decisively in a tables match. It wasn’t a fluky victory or some underhanded tactic that led to the win: Kofi Kingston went for a rana off the top rope to put Cesaro through a table stack on the outside, but Cesaro overpowered him and powerbombed Kofi through the tables for the titles.

Advertisement

It’s good to see Nakamura & Cesaro rewarded with a tag title reign after spending months being under-utilized. Hopefully, they’ll get the chance to turn in a decent run with the straps.

4. A Stipulation That Works

WWE.com

The outcome was never in doubt, but the only piece of the puzzle that could have made the match between Drew McIntyre and Dolph Ziggler interesting was the stipulation that the challenger would choose.

Ziggler weaseled his way into a WWE Championship match, then goaded McIntyre to let him pick the stip, which he held close to the vest until the start of the match. The stipulation: Extreme Rules, for Dolph only. If Drew was counted out or disqualified, he would have lost the title. The unique stipulation led to a match where McIntyre could be counted out, but Dolph couldn’t, so Drew had to scramble to get back in the ring. Ziggler could use a steel chair, but McIntyre had to avoid using a chair or suplexing Dolph through a table.

The match was actually pretty decent, as Drew shrugged off Ziggler’s onslaught at the climax – a Fameasser, Zig-Zag and Rock Bottom on a chair – to kip up and hit a Claymore for the win. Knowing that there was no way Dolph was leaving Extreme Rules with the title might have taken away any mystique – and Ziggler was a terrible world title contender – but it was at least a tolerable match.

Advertisement

Now, get Ziggler away from the world title scene, please.

3. Just Keep Fighting

WWE.com

An argument could be made that Kevin Owens is being wasted by being in an unannounced match on the kickoff show of Extreme Rules, and that argument would be correct.

But on a night of crappy finishes and bad cinematic “entertainment,” a clean finish to a short but solid match will get a thumbs-up here. Owens and Murphy had an energetic opener, with the disciple getting to show off a deadlift suplex to the bigger KO.

Owens showed off himself, hitting a double-jump moonsault before closing out the match with a superkick/Stunner combo to finish Murphy.

Advertisement

Overall, this was perfectly fine for what it was, and at least there was logic, with the seconds to the Rey Mysterio/Seth Rollins feud getting their own match.

2. Asuka, Sasha Have Mad Chemistry

WWE.com

The title says it all. Asuka and Sasha Banks delivered a really solid match that featured a ton of nifty moves, stiff strikes and crafty counters. Aside from the screwy finish, this was looking like a pretty damn good match.

Asuka came into Extreme Rules holding the Raw Women’s Championship, but she left without it, though whether it remains that was will have to be determined later. But the match itself was good fun, with Banks turning up her vicious streak by working on the Empress’ arms and shoulders, even at one point stealing a page from Pete Dunne and bending Asuka’s fingers back.

But Asuka kept fighting back with her usual flurry of kicks, knee-strikes, hip attacks and German suplexes to put Sasha on the mat. It just got really messy at the end with title belts, green mist and a stolen referee shirt really dragging everything down.

Advertisement

Still, overall this was an enjoyable match for the most part, and we’d love to see them run it back with a cleaner finish.

1. Bayley Ascendant

WWE.com

It really deserves mentioning that Bayley has really come into her own as a heel in recent months.

When the former Hugger originally turned heel, she looked like a completely ineffective villain, getting shown up constantly and looking unsure of herself. But alongside Sasha Banks, she has grown into a true villainess.

Witness during her SmackDown Women’s Championship match against Nikki Cross. Bayley won a couple early lockups and cheered herself, then mock encouraged Nikki. As the fans began to clap for Cross, Bayley turned to the audience and mocked them. Later on, she took an unnecessary swipe at Rey Mysterio's eye injury, which was the perfect "jerky" heel move.

Her mannerisms as a dominant heel champion and self-proclaimed role model have been spot on in recent months, so much so that her and Sasha’s appearances on Raw have been rare consistent bright spots on the red brand.

Advertisement

Sooner or later, her title reign will come to an end, but it’s good to see Bayley grow more into this role and become more of a complete wrestler.