5 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE Battleground 2017
When the return of the Great Khali is your top highlight... you've got problems.
So… Battleground just happened.
And what else can you say about it? Kevin Owens and AJ Styles had another solid match with an out-of-the-blue finish, which hopefully means a bigger, even better match is one the horizon. Sami Zayn won a PPV bout. The New Day brought the goods in their SmackDown Tag Team Championship match and left Philadelphia with the hardware to prove it.
But as you can see, the highlights of the night are more of a “look for the silver lining” basis than legit great moments. And the negatives just piled up in this lackluster show, which WWE will undoubtedly plug as an outstanding night, but anyone watching had to agree that this wasn’t WWE’s finest hour.
Baron Corbin might be miscast as a top heel right now. Tye Dillinger is being completely wasted. Five women fought in a forgettable #1 contender’s match as the M.O. seems to be “stick all the women on PPV” rather than booking a one-on-one match fans might care about. John Cena and Rusev slowed things down with slow climbs to retrieve the flag.
And Jinder Mahal is still your WWE Champion. So chew on all of that.
With that said, let’s see what worked and what didn’t. Let’s get to it…
Downs...
7. Punching Above His Weight Class
After watching him for the past year, it’s hard not to get the feeling that Baron Corbin is miscast as a top-level heel.
Corbin clearly relishes playing a villain, but it just feels like he would be better suited fighting for (and possibly holding and defending) the United States Championship rather than holding the Money in the Bank briefcase and being billed as a future world champion. You just get the feeling after watching him hang with Shinsuke Nakamura Sunday that WWE is grooming him for a run at the top, and it also feels… not right.
It’s not that Corbin is a flop – though he isn’t setting the world on fire either – or that he shouldn’t be a featured player, but consider this: When Edge, Rob Van Dam, CM Punk and the like won the MITB briefcase, felt like they could be believable champs.
Corbin is a believable villain, but this writer is not convinced that he would be an upgrade over Jinder Mahal… and Sunday’s match didn’t change that feeling. Maybe it’s just a bad gut reaction, and this writer would love to be proven wrong.
6. A Perfectly Forgotten 10
It’s scary to think that Tye Dillinger had only had two televised matches in the past two months before Sunday. It’s scarier to realize that his three previous televised matches more than two months ago all were against the man he faced Sunday, Aiden English.
In short, Dillinger is sputtering. Despite routinely getting a huge reaction from fans and being perfectly suited for a midcard role, the Perfect 10 has been largely ignored after coming in hot. And now, he’s losing to a guy he’d beaten three times in a row. Dillinger is being wasted right now, which is just ridiculous.
You would think WWE would be ecstatic to have a guy who came up from their developmental territory and was popular with the fans, but they either can’t figure out what to do with him, or they just don’t care. It’s really a shame.
5. Quarter-Speed
If you saw Shinsuke Nakamura’s NXT debut match against Sami Zayn last year, then you get this reference. Since that match, Nakamura has been wrestling many times at about half-speed, which is still better than most wrestlers on the roster. It’s not a bad thing, but more of a reality of his opponents, and WWE style, etc.
But Sunday’s match against Baron Corbin might as well have been half of that. Corbin cinched in bearhugs to really grind things to a halt, throwing hands while Nakamura threw kicks and knees to stay in the match. Still, it was a slow-moving match that finally started picking up toward the end, just in time for Corbin to counter a reverse exploder with a low blow for the DQ.
Yep, after slogging along, Corbin got himself disqualified and we were treated to that finish – followed by Corbin returning to hit End of Days on an injured Shinsuke. Just in case anyone was confused as to who is a WWE pet project and who isn’t a company creation.
4. Women Fall Like Cards
Elimination matches can be a great opportunity to allow competitors to get revenge on an opponent or get some heat before ultimately losing (see Nia Jax in the Raw gauntlet match a few weeks back). But when the eliminations come rapid-fire, it really negates the whole thing.
That’s exactly what we got Sunday night, with three eliminations happening in the span of a minute (keep in mind there were only five competitors, so there were only four pinfalls/submissions that could happen). Becky Lynch tapped out Tamina and Lana in rapid succession, only for Natalya to roll her up for a pin. That left Nattie and Charlotte Flair to go against each other for a couple minutes before the Queen of Hearts won.
It’s a shame, because the match actually wasn’t too bad up to that point, and the Natalya/Charlotte bout at the end had the makings of a good mini-match. But everything felt rushed toward the end, and it kind of cheapened things with the eliminations going bang-bang-bang like that.
3. (Blank) On A Pole
As a general rule, “object” on a pole matches are risky propositions. They often result in painfully slow climbs to retrieve the object, changing the dynamic of the match and resulting in a lower quality.
That’s exactly what happened at Battleground, with John Cena and Rusev tangling in a flag match. Both men employed their best slow climbs and crawls to retrieve the flags, then crawled their way up the ram to plan their flag in a stand on the entranceway. As a result, we saw less wrestling and more punching. We saw less strategy and moves and more brute force.
It just didn’t really click, which was evident because we’ve seen Rusev and Cena wrestle on PPV before, and it’s been perfectly fine. But this was definitely down a notch or two, leaving fans to cheer simply for the flag itself and the guy who was holding it.
Maybe they’ll put both men’s dignity in a jar and suspend that from the ring next.
2. The Jinder Era Continues
We knew going into this Jinder Mahal WWE Championship reign that we weren’t going to get four-star matches, but did anyone predict we’d have the Indian Honky Tonk Man on our hands?
Seriously, Jinder has managed to turn “escaping with the title” into an art form, with the Singh Brothers becoming increasingly involved in his title matches, to the point where they might as well be booked as handicapped bouts. And now, it looks like the Great Khali has joined Mahal’s stable, adding another heavy to the fold.
Mahal also chose such a dull stipulation that the Philly crowd chanted for CM Punk and urged WWE to “Trust the process,” a reference to a failed basketball GM in the city who asked fans to trust his process that constantly produced poor results on the court and in the standings. Sounds a lot like Jinder’s reign.
1. A Lackluster Show
When a surprise appearance from the Great Khali is the high point of the night, you know you just put on a poor PPV.
Battleground was a subpar event in almost every respect. The world title match was dull and plodding, and it centered on a lot of slow fighting to escape or climb the cages. Only the Singh brothers bumping around like pinballs helped. The flag match between John Cena and Rusev was hampered by the stipulation, forcing both men to abandon and actual wrestling match and to engage in slow climbs and crawls up the entrance ramp to plant their flag in a stand on the stage.
Even the best match on the card, the United States Championship bout, had a finish that left you feeling like they cut the contest short. Only the SmackDown Tag Team Championships match, which opened the PPV, really delivered a solid affair, as well as a fun ending. Crowning new tag champs started the night off on a high point, which was never reached again except for brief periods in the U.S. title bout.
Altogether, this PPV should be forgotten within 24 hours by and large.
Ups...
5. Bulgarian Brute Is Back
Maybe this time will be different…
Even though he lost Sunday night, it was good to see Rusev back in action after being on the shelf for four months. Rusev has long been a guy you can depend on for a solid effort and often times hard-hitting matches that fans are into. And while his match with John Cena at Battleground was disappointing, Rusev didn’t look like he had lost a step.
And hopefully, that will translate into some big wins soon, because SmackDown could always use a guy like Rusev lurking behind a corner. Rusev has been criminally misused in recent months, so hopefully this will change this time around.
4. Zayn Gets PPV Win
What more positive can you say about a throwaway match given the “death slot” between a John Cena match and the main event, other than “good for Sami Zayn!”?
Zayn defeated Mike Kanellis in a nothing match that balanced out a previous loss, and probably will be avenged in the coming weeks as well. While Zayn lost their first match due to Maria interfering, Sami managed to avoid the same pitfalls when Maria interfered again Sunday. Sami hit all his trademark moves and looked fine in victory, but it just didn’t feel like anything special.
And don't get us started on this strange "Power of Love" gimmick with Mike and Maria.
But hey, at least Sami wasn’t a fall guy again. So there’s that.
3. A Legit Shock Hopefully Ends Feud
In an effort to look for the silver lining, we offer up this pro from the WWE Championship match:
WWE did deliver a legit surprise at the end of Battleground, with the Great Khali returning to the company for the first time in nearly three years and helping Jinder Mahal retain his title. Khali looked somewhat mobile (for him) and managed to be the difference-maker, choking out Randy Orton while Jinder escaped the Punjabi Prison for the win.
In addition, this win hopefully will mean the end of the feud with Randy Orton, though you get the feeling we’re due for yet another PPV bout at SummerSlam. Still, if this is the end of this feud, then so be it.
But still, kudos for a relevant surprise run-in. At least we can agree on that.
2. KO, AJ Have Match Of The Night
Given what the main event was going to be, it’s no shock that the secondary championship title match produced the best match of the night.
AJ Styles and Kevin Owens had a good back-and-forth matchup, trading near-falls and submission holds, escaping each other’s finishing moves and coming close to leaving Philadelphia with the United States Championship. Owens, having lost his title at a Madison Square Garden house show earlier this month was looking for revenge, and he got it in a manner or speaking.
KO rolled over a crossface from AJ for a pin from a groggy referee, winning his third U.S. title. It certainly felt like it was out of nowhere, and just as the match was seriously ramping up. While that normally would mean a negative, it also felt like this was unresolved like they needed to have one… more… match… at SummerSlam.
Now that is certainly good enough reason for that finish.
1. New Day, New Champs
The Usos have managed to reinvent themselves in recent months as heel tag champs, and there’s still plenty of gas left in their tank.
But when you pit them against another top-notch tag team, there’s no shame in losing. And that’s exactly what happened with New Day matching the Usos in an electric opening match. The two teams started out strong and then sped up as the match wore on, hitting a series of near-falls that had the Philly crowd buying into several of them. In particular, a superkick-splash combo on Kofi Kingston had the entire audience thinking that was the end.
New Day persevered and hit a Trouble in Paradise and a diving elbow drop for the win, becoming the first tag team to hold both the Raw and SmackDown tag titles. It started the night off with a great little moment and gave fans a great match to boot.