5 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE TLC 2020
2020 ends in a blaze of... something. Reigns/Owens rules, Fiend/Orton is a disaster.
Desperation must be setting in for WWE after looking at the ratings in recent weeks.
Don’t believe it? How did TLC: Tables, Ladders and Chairs end Sunday night? With a wrestler (or at least a dummy dressed as one) lit on fire in the middle of the ring.
If that doesn’t scream “desperate stunt for attention,” then what does?
TLC wasn’t a bad show overall. It featured a fantastic TLC match for the Universal Championship, with Roman Reigns continuing his march toward superstardom that the company wishes they could have launched five years ago. He and Kevin Owens had a barnburner of a match that is mandatory viewing.
The Hurt Business finally captured tag gold, but the result was tempered by poor booking leading up to the match. A surprise return could best be described as a mixed bag, with some positive leanings. The Miz rendered the Money in the Bank briefcase even more meaningless Sunday night. Drew McIntyre and AJ Styles did their level best in an underwhelming WWE Championship match, but the magic just wasn’t there.
And then there was the main event, which was just bad all around. If someone wants to step up and defend it, go right ahead. We’ll torch it in the column in a bit…
With that said, let’s get to it…
Downs...
7. Remember The IIconics?
Readers of this column know this writer was never a fan of the IIconics – their shrill screeching and subpar wrestling (at least from one of the pair) made for a less-than-entertaining duo.
However, they were a long-established team that could have carried on as a duo or with one wrestling singles and the other serving as manager. Instead, they inexplicably lost a match that forced them to break up, and then drafted them to different shows.
And what has happened since? Peyton Royce (the more talented wrestler of the two) has been largely off TV but is now in another tag team with Lacey Evans (rather than embarking on a singles career). And Billie Kay was seen at TLC once again shopping her resume, this time to Asuka as a potential tag partner. (Spoiler: Her “interview” didn’t go well and she didn’t get the spot.)
Since being drafted to SmackDown, Kay has had three matches… two of which were tag team bouts, and all were losses. Why were the IIconics split up if this is the kind of thing Royce and Kay are doing three months later?
6. Cash-In Wasted… Again
The Money in the Bank briefcase has long since jumped the shark as a plot device in WWE storytelling, but it still can have a useful purpose.
Sunday’s cash-in by The Miz was not one of those good moments for the MITB briefcase.
Miz attacked Drew McIntyre during the TLC match for the WWE Championship, then cashed in to make the one-on-one match with AJ Styles a triple threat. He then did the slowest slow climb ever, giving Omos enough time to lumber into the ring, grab him and toss him through a table on the floor. Afterward, Miz joined in a three-way fight on top of the ladders, ultimately eating a Claymore before McIntyre climbed and retrieved his title.
So after taking the briefcase away from Otis, Miz acted like a goofy midcard comedy guy, not a future world champion, then frittered away his “all-but-guaranteed world title reign.” That means that three of the last four men’s MITB cash-ins have ended with the briefcase-holder failing to win the title.
Yeah, sounds like something to get us all fired up about MITB 2021.
5. Fighting From Underneath
This is not meant to knock AJ Styles, who is every bit a serious world title contender. But Drew McIntyre spending a good chunk of their TLC match fighting back from a knee injury was just too much.
WWE clearly has spent all of 2020 to convince us the McIntyre is the nearly invincible world champion, save for one hiccup with Randy Orton earlier this fall. He’s toppled Brock Lesnar, beaten Orton three times, defeated Big Show and Bobby Lashley, and battled Roman Reigns to the limit.
But then AJ attacked Drew’s knee and the champ spent half the match rolling around on the mat grabbing his leg. The match itself wasn’t bad, but if we were going to have a match with McIntyre having to fight from underneath for so much of it, then someone like Omos or Miz should have gotten involved sooner. Or maybe actually have Styles assault McIntyre’s knee last week instead of chairshots to the back to set up the injury for the TLC match.
Instead, this just felt like the WWE formula for a TLC match pitting a smaller heel against a larger face – chop him down to size and control a lot of the contest.
4. Angle Payoff? What Angle Payoff?
So the longest-running, most consistent storyline on Raw has seemingly ended with not a bang, but with a whimper – or a “Woooo.”
For three months, Nia Jax & Shayna Baszler have tormented Lana, putting her through a table nine times and demeaning her at every turn. All of this led to Lana teaming up with Asuka to challenge for Nia & Shayna’s WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship at TLC. This was a natural conclusion to the story: Lana somehow puts Nia through a table, helping her team win the tag titles.
Instead, WWE booked an injury angle on Raw, knocking Lana out of the match. Asuka then picked Charlotte Flair, and Lana was basically never heard from again as Flair & Asuka defeated the champs to win the titles.
Just like that, WWE’s most consistent angle was basically dropped – or at least, it was brushed aside for now.
3. Charlotte Cena Is Back
We’ll give some love to Charlotte Flair later, but can we just comment her return to action Sunday night?
After six months away, Charlotte teamed up as Asuka’s mystery partner against Nia Jax & Shayna Baszler. The Queen proceeded to run through the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions, barely selling anything from the dominant champs and basically treating them like cannon fodder. Meanwhile, Asuka, the Raw Women’s Champion, got to play face-in-peril and absorb much of the champs’ offense.
In the end, Charlotte shrugged off two Kirafuda attempts by Baszler before nailing a Natural Selection to capture the tag titles, knocking off the champs in barely 10 minutes. And she didn’t even break a nail.
Sorry, one of the criticisms of Flair during her previous run was that she was basically the female version of John Cena during his prime – never showing weakness, always coming out on top, shrugging off opponents’ attacks, etc. On her first night back, she almost single-handedly ran through two imposing villains to dethrone them.
Sound familiar?
2. Fiend Loses, Again
Just a quick reminder that The Fiend is supposedly a near-indestructible villain who was once described as on-par with The Undertaker for mythical powers and resilience.
With that said, Fiend lost another match Sunday night, meaning he’s now lost three of his last six matches (in that persona), including a 3-minute match to Goldberg and a triple threat where he lost the Universal Championship after a weeklong reign.
This time, Fiend lost to Randy Orton in a hastily thrown-together Firefly Inferno match, a stipulation that guaranteed a screwy finish, presumably to “protect” Fiend. But the bottom line here is that Fiend is supposedly this horror movie villain, but he keeps losing when it’s actually time to perform.
Worse, the match itself was comically bad, with Fiend trying to use a pickaxe on Orton, then sitting Randy in a gasoline-soaked rocking chair and lighting a trail of gas, only for the Viper to dive out of harm’s way at the last minute.
Nevermind the ending, which gets its own “down” next…
1. Playing With Fire
Ratings are down? Don’t worry, PAL. Vince McMahon has the cure: Light a wrestler on fire.
No, we’re not just talking about the typical inferno match with a person’s body part being briefly lit on fire and then extinguished. We’re talking about Randy Orton committing attempted murder by dousing The Fiend in gasoline and then lighting him aflame. Well, an obvious dummy dressed like Fiend, but you get the point.
This was beyond stupid, and desperate as hell. Ratings are in the toilet, so the solution is to book an inferno match at the last minute and then immolate a person on television, because that will bring wrestling fans back to the nest.
It can’t be expressed strongly enough how insanely stupid this is, and how this stunt exemplifies how out of touch WWE is as a company if this is their response to falling ratings and getting beat by AEW. Somehow, lighting a person on fire is supposed to be what wrestling fans want to see in 2020, according to Vince.
This is just a really sad statement on the current condition of WWE.
Ups...
5. On The Other Hand…
So after bashing Charlotte Flair’s return, let’s offer the other side of the coin here.
Regardless of how she’s booked, Flair is one of the best wrestlers (not male or female, just wrestler, period) on the roster. She can be counted on to carry a solid match, has a commanding presence, and can elevate matches’ importance by her participation.
Having both her and Becky Lynch out of action for much of the year has definitely hampered a women’s division that was riding high at one point with the two of them, Asuka, Bayley, Sasha Banks and Ronda Rousey all wrestling. Removing three of them from that mix really diminished the division.
Flair could have interesting feuds with Asuka, Shayna Baszler, or even a renewed rivalry with Rhea Ripley if she gets called up. As frustrating as the booking might be sometimes, having her back should be a plus for Raw.
4. Flavor Of The Month Works Fine
Let’s level here: Not every challenger for a title needs to be built up and every match an epic. Sometimes, just having a challenger of the month will do the job.
In the case of the SmackDown Women’s Championship, see Exhibit C: Carmella.
No one was seriously expecting Carmella to dethrone Sasha Banks Sunday night, though they gave her a nice build by having her injure the champ’s back (See? Pre-match attacks targeting one body part!) and allegedly get inside Sasha’s head. The match itself was fine – Carmella isn’t going to deliver a four-star classic, but she’s capable of keeping up and putting together a more than competent match.
The two traded rollups and submission attempts, and Carmella’s sommelier got involved, keeping ‘Mella in the match. But Banks pulled out the win via Banks Statement, allowing her to continue having a proper title run.
3. Here’s To The Next Step
You could easily criticize WWE for stalling on a push for Big E after the forced New Day split during the WWE draft, but they seemingly jump-started things Sunday night.
After Big E tormented Sami Zayn on SmackDown, he then pinned the Intercontinental Champion in an eight-man tag match on the kickoff show. Later on, we got to hear “leaked audio” from Zayn complaining about E upsetting his “Sami Awards” on Friday. This then led to a backstage segment where Zayn confronted Big E, calling him “a joke” who’s been “treading water since you went solo.”
It was a wakeup call of sorts to E, who stopped smirking, stiffened up and told Sami to “keep playing,” because he’d see him real soon. If there’s anyone who can act as a great foil to E right now, it’s Zayn. And it looks like Big E could capture IC gold on Christmas night if the stars align.
2. Hurt Business Finally Captures Tag Gold
Sunday night should have been a banner night for the Hurt Business.
Shelton Benjamin & Cedric Alexander captured the Raw Tag Team Championship at TLC by toppling one of the best tag teams of the past decade, the New Day, in a strong, competitive match. New Day was on fire to start, but the Hurt Business kept pace, finally taking out Xavier Woods before managing to drop Kofi Kingston for the titles.
However, this comes after numerous title matches – won by New Day – and then a series of singles bouts – which Alexander won – to give Hurt Business another tag title opportunity. It was a reverse storytelling method that kind of diminishes this victory. Much like Randy Orton’s WWE Championship win after losing two title matches, this win is significant for the winners, but it doesn’t work in the context of an actual story.
This win just makes you wish the monkeys writing the script could actually map stuff out further than one week at a time, because this could have been special, not just good.
1. Reigns, KO Own The Night
If you want proof that all is not lost in WWE, look no further than the TLC match between Roman Reigns and Kevin Owens.
This match was set up nicely, with KO refusing to stay down, a theme from SmackDown that carried over into the PPV contest. Owens jumped Reigns during introductions and really laid into him, assaulting Roman with cannonballs, stairs and a frogsplash to the floor. When Jey Uso intervened, KO demolished him and Pillmanized his ankle.
Reigns was brutal in this match, just laying in chairshots and a lot of badmouth. Owens fought back valiantly, but Roman kept putting him down (with help from Uso), including a great sequence where he powerbombed KO on a ladder, slammed him through one table, hit a Samoan drop through a second table, and then speared him through a third.
Still, Owens kept coming, and even managed to put Roman through a table via Pop-Up Powerbomb. Nonetheless, Reigns was not to be denied, and he retained the title, but this match was a brutal war in which both men looked great and Roman’s standing as top dog was strengthened.
Outstanding match that made the PPV worth it.