6 Candidates To Improve AEW's Commentary
The best possible solutions to solving AEW's biggest commentary problem!
Those watching AEW have had their ears treated to the sounds of good ol' JR calling clotheslines once more. But your ears may have then started spontaneously bleeding as Alex Marvez interrupted to say one of the wrestlers has a cut on their elbow and that might end things early.
Yes, that is an actual bit of commentary from Marvez himself. And it doesn’t seem like fans are willing to let him learn on the job, especially sitting next to one of the greatest to ever do it.
There is now a thread on Reddit gaining traction titled “The ‘Official’ Please God No More Alex Marvez Thread”. That doesn’t exactly scream “we’re willing to give him a chance” now does it? Repeatedly the main flaw people keep pointing out are the production issues of AEW. So it may be best to just pull the plug now before they further ruin the poor man’s reputation. So here are five potential replacements to join Excalibur and JR in AEW…
6. Joey Styles
OH MY GAWD! Who doesn’t miss that coming through their television? Probably one of the most celebrated commentators ever, it seems a tragedy that we never got a true feel of how he and Jim Ross would work in tandem. The voice of ECW was Wrestling Observer Newsletter’s best television announcer in 1994, 1995, and 1996 breaking Ross’ winning streak that started in 1988. So if you need a talent that is in the realm of a Jim Ross, Styles might be your guy.
And Joey himself even said in an interview with 411mania back in 2016 that “going forward I would like to be the ‘voice of the indies’. Indies that I feel are special or have a good buzz or are people I know and that are Tommy Dreamer approved.” Well, Tommy Dreamer was getting stapled in the head by Jimmy Havoc at Double or Nothing so I think that’s a stamp of approval if there ever was one. And in a way, AEW has really become the voice of the indies in their own right.
And let’s not forget that worked shoot Joey had back in 2006 when he was on his way out of Raw. Styles didn’t get to cover WrestleMania 22 because he couldn’t stop calling wrestling matches instead of telling stories. Although he continued working there, you could see the genuine lack of respect he had for what WWE was doing with their product even back then. He wanted pro wrestlers, not sports entertainment. And that is right on brand with what AEW is all about.
5. Mike Tenay
From the voice of ECW, to one of the many voices of WCW. Mike Tenay has had his own fair share of accolades throughout his tenure with WCW and TNA. He took home the Wrestling Observer Newsletter’s best television announcer while with WCW in 1997, and for three years straight with TNA from 2002 to 2005. In fact, a lot of the worst mistakes made by TNA almost feel forgivable when you have Tenay making the calls. He even managed to make Taz have some of his best commentary moments, which seems like any oxymoron.
Tenay has that classic, boxing blow-for-blow style that just manages to make everything have that big fight feel. And with his knowledgeable approach and AEW’s style of tracking wins and losses, this could be a great pairing. This would also allow Excalibur a little more freedom to explore his character and maybe even play the heel if he so chooses. Or they can remain in the middle and keep it a more traditional sportscast which again plays right into the strengths of a sportsman like Tenay.
The drawback will be that people will say that AEW is TNA 2.0. But when you’re actually taking the things that TNA did right and capitalizing on them, why is that such a bad thing? The great commentary didn’t ruin their company. What channel are iMPACT on now? Anybody know?
4. Tony Schiavone
There really are so many great voices from WCW. Perhaps the greatest in the history of our sport one man might say. Tony Schiavone has stirred up controversy over the fact that he has appeared in some AEW video packages recently. This led to MLW (whom he is under contract with as an announcer) and their founder to issue a statement saying they were unaware. Could this mean a potential defection to AEW is in the works already?
Tony himself did mention previously that he felt he "Schiavonied" by not going to an event where Cody Rhodes and Tony Khan were in attendance. And the interesting thing about Court Bauer's statement was that he left an opening there for AEW to "reach out". After Schiavone had a brief stint of not appearing with MLW, perhaps both companies are willing to part. If a buy out is reached, there could even be enough time for Schiavone to lend a hand with MLW until we get our first AEW television show in October.
This would also mark the first time since the late '80s that Schiavone and Ross have been co-workers. And Ross has nothing but good words for the man. He recently praised his podcast and was quoted before as saying he "truly enjoyed working with" Tony and that he "was pivotal in my growth as a broadcaster". Why not make Jim happy and bring in his old friend?
3. Diamond Dallas Page
People forget DDP's career started not just as a manager, but also a commentator. Page did commentary work in both FCW back in the early ‘90s as well as some work in the booth with WCW as well. Although that was some time ago, almost 30 years of being an excellent entertainer in other areas will hide that rust well. And with appearances at both All In and Double or Nothing already under his belt, the relationship is clearly there.
The nice thing about DDP for this role is that he brings a lively, upbeat personality to a commentary team that is in desperate need of a boost of charisma. You allow Page to be your storyteller who keys in on the drama of it all. Then you have Ross and Excalibur left with the bulk of trading calls on the action which allows everybody to play to their strengths. Balance is the key to a good commentary team, and what better way to achieve that than with a yoga instructor.
Plus, name recognition is a key factor here. Half of the battle to getting people to feel comfortable with a sudden change in announcer is by having a solid reputable name step in. You have that with a Hall of Fame inductee like DDP. And if nothing else, just think of the great yoga banter between him and JR.
2. Matt Striker
From teacher, to wrestler, to announce booth. After about three years in WWE as a wrestler, Striker instead flourished calling the action. He took over commentary work for WWE’s failed ECW experiment back in August 2008. This is where Matt found his true calling. He even won the 2008 Slammy Award (not prestigious by any means but an accolade nonetheless) for announce team of the year with Todd Grisham.
Matt would later move to SmackDown, and remained there until 2011. That alone should show that Striker has the skills necessary but he would do even more to solidify his name after leaving WWE in 2013. He became the lead announcer for Lucha Underground in 2014, then commentated on both AAA’s Lucha Libre World Cup and Triplemania XXIII for the English language team. He would even partner with JR for NJPW’s Wrestle Kingdom 9 and joined Kevin Kelly for their King of Pro-Wrestling and Wrestle Kingdom 10 events.
With such a stacked list of events under his belt, Striker may be one of the most underrated and decorated commentators in the business currently. Add in his familiarity with Ross and plug and play charisma, and he has all the makings of the perfect candidate. Although, sticking with the theme of former wrestlers who commentate there may be one bigger name left that might work…
1. CM Punk
Not the headline you expect if you read CM Punk joins AEW. But after Punk has vehemently denied ever coming back to a wrestling ring, fans may have to just accept this as the best case scenario. Remember that Stone Cold retired at 38 and he has an untarnished legacy as a true bad ass. The parallels run deep here with Punk hanging up his boots at 35. After all, Punk did drop the pipe bomb in a Stone Cold t-shirt.
Austin had many roles after his retirement, appearing sporadically over the years but never anything consistent. If AEW could deliver Punk on a weekly television program to their audience that’d be a significant upgrade. That name alone, just like Austin’s, can put a lot of asses in seats. And Punk has already started doing MMA commentary to a positive reception so far. Why not come back to his roots?
The story is a Hollywood blockbuster in the making. The man who helped to build (and simultaneously was built by) the independent wrestling scene was scorned by trying to join the massive, villainous conglomerate that is WWE. Now he returns to a shining beacon of hope rising from the indies, one which is trying to tear them to the ground. But now his fight is no longer in the ring because he has nothing left to prove. CM Punk is in AEW to be the Voice for the Voiceless.