6 Lowest Attended WWE Pay-Per-Views Ever
Talking people out of the building.
By all accounts, Stomping Grounds was a solid pay-per-view inside the ring. It yielded a handful of entertaining matches, crowned a new United States Champion and provided one of the most inventive Steel Cage finishes in years. Outside the ring, and in the stands, things weren't so rosy for WWE.
According to Wrestling Observer Radio guru Dave Meltzer, the show pulled in around 6,000 fans, only around 4,500 of which were paying customers. Others got their tickets for free, and things become even more embarrassing when realising that the Tacoma Dome venue can hold up to 18,000 people for wrestling events.
This got us thinking about other pay-per-views that flopped when it came to ticket sales. Generally, WWE has done well at the box office for its major shows since 1985, with few exceptions. These are the biggest exceptions, and most prove that fans demand something more than a thrown-together card for their money.
However, if you're sitting there thinking that approx 12,000 empty seats is some kind of company record, think again. There have been worse examples of curtained-off sections, tarped-over seating and dim lighting so (hopefully) nobody would notice...
6. In Your House 12: It's Time
Attendance: 5,708
On commentary, Jim Ross told viewers of In Your House 12 that the WWF could've "sold a lot more tickets if we had a lot more room". The card took place in the modest West Palm Beach Auditorium in Florida before a crowd of 5,708 fans. That was a respectable 292 people off capacity in the 6,000-seater venue.
Not bad if you consider the size of the building, but don't be fooled by JR's bold claim. There wasn't much on the card that'd convince people to flock to West Palm Beach and plonk down their cash to be in attendance. Had the show taken place in a bigger venue, it would've looked pretty empty. Still, Ross was only doing his job by talking things up.
It's worth noting that Sycho Sid vs. Bret Hart wasn't the original main event plan either. Subtitled "It's Time", the show was supposed to be another coming out party for monster heel Vader. He didn't even appear, and focus shifted off his push onto Sid vs. Shawn Michaels at January's Royal Rumble instead.
5. In Your House 6
Attendance: 5,500
By contrast to IYH 12, the sixth entrant in the pay-per-view series did have a lot to offer. Bret Hart vs. Diesel inside a cage, Shawn Michaels vs. Owen Hart and Razor Ramon vs. The 1-2-3 Kid were all worthwhile offerings, and there's a chance this show could have played before a larger audience.
Sadly, the WWF's crew booked the 6,000 capacity Louisville Gardens instead.
Again, drawing 5,500 was hardly a disgrace, but this is another example of where company business was during this period. Things were a struggle and confidence was low; not quite on par with 1994-1995 (we'll get to that), but a struggle nonetheless. It's a shame too, because Bret vs. Diesel in the cage was one of the year's best match, and is arguably Kevin Nash's best pay-per-view performance ever.
To put this house into perspective, the next month's WrestleMania XII would draw over 18,000 fans to the old Arrowhead Pond (now the Honda Center). It's easy to think they could pulled a bit more in a bigger building here.
4. In Your House 3
Attendance: 5,146
In September 1995, the budget range In Your House pay-per-views were still a new concept. For the third installment, the WWF had Shawn Michaels and Diesel beat The British Bulldog and Yokozuna to become new Tag-Team Champions. Bulldog, in case anyone was wondering, was a late replacement for Owen Hart.
5,146 fans took this in. That number is interesting, not least because the Saginaw Civic Center (now the Dow Event Center) in Michigan can hold 7,647 for concerts, 6,217 for basketball and 5,527 for hockey. With more room to work with than either of the two sports mentioned there, the WWF still didn't top those numbers.
The next month's In Your House 4 show pulled 10,339 and the previous SummerSlam had drawn 18,062. So, it was again confusing that the WWF, even in the midst of a mid-90s lull, picked out a smaller venue. Worse, they didn't even manage to sell it out with a stronger card than the next In Your House served up.
3. Ground Zero: In Your House
Attendance: 4,963
And back we come to the humble Louisville Gardens in Kentucky, this time during a period the WWF should've known better. Unlike in 1995 and 1996, the product was starting to heat up again by late-1997. Characters like 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin and D-Generation X had started to change the game. They phased out old kid-friendly elements and were a bit raunchier.
For some reason, in between drawing 20,213 for SummerSlam '97 and a massive 21,151 for the first Hell In A Cell match at In Your House: Badd Blood, the WWF decided on the same 6,000 capacity venue that had hosted IYH 3. It's weird to watch a big match like The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels, just one month before HIAC, work in front of a house show-worthy 4,963 fans.
Hell, the company even managed to lure in more than double that (11,000) to the NEC in Birmingham, England for the house show-tactic One Night Only just 13 nights later. This wasn't great planning from a promotion who had lost faith in their own IYH idea; note the show was dubbed Ground Zero: In Your House. A subtitle came first.
2. ECW December To Dismember 2006
Attendance: 4,800
It might be considered cheating by some, but we're going to let both the One Night Stand 2005 and 2006 events off the hook here. That pair of ECW revivals took place in the old Hammerstein Ballroom in front of around 2,500 each, and that was essential to their success. WWE wanted to give the shows that old-school original ECW flavour.
Apparently, they didn't come December To Dismember in late-'06.
The James Brown Arena in Augusta, Georgia was chosen as the ideal site to hold this WWE-ECW failure. The card was a shocker, which didn't help, and WWE's new format for a beloved hardcore niche product was already flopping less than six months in to its proper run. That must be why only 4,800 fans attended the show.
Hey, wait, that's almost double what One Night Stand 2005 and 2006 got, right? Yes, it is, but they took place in the smaller confines of Hammerstein, and the James Brown Arena could hold 9,167 punters. That means WWE didn't even manage to half-fill the place.
1. Taboo Tuesday 2004
Attendance: 3,500
Here it is, the lowest-attended WWE pay-per-view in company record books outside of those aforementioned One Night Stand ECW tributes. For those, WWE made a production choice. At Taboo Tuesday 2004, they simply experimented and it didn't work. The audience did not buy into this show at all.
Taboo Tuesday '04 was held in Milwaukee's Bradley Center. The place, which once hosted the NBA's Bucks, has a capacity of 18,800 for pro wrestling. Remember that, because it's important. Previously, WWE had drawn 15,291 to the same venue for No Way Out 2002, and they'd go on to pull 15,306 for Elimination Chamber 2012 and 15,785 for Fastlane 2017.
This show, meanwhile, had a measly 3,500 folks in the stands. That's pretty pathetic considering the star power that was on hand. Check this out for a list: Chris Jericho, Triple H, Shawn Michaels, Randy Orton, Ric Flair, Chris Benoit, Edge, Kane, Trish Stratus. All of those and more were on the card.
Something went badly wrong with promotion. Either that or the new pay-per-view voting concept didn't connect with fans.
Were you in attendance for any of these pay-per-views? If so, are you surprised at how low the crowds were? Let us know down in the comments section below!