6 Reasons Sting Should Not Win WWE Title
The WWE isn't that desperate, right?
The big reveal last Monday Night for Seth Rollins was not a statue, but the legend Sting!
For ruining their amazing ceremony - and robbing Rollins of an actual statue - Triple H instantly booked him in a title match against Seth Rollins. The theme here is that Triple H didn't finish off Sting; so now it's up to Seth Rollins to finish the job.
The storyline makes sense; Sting has a history with Triple H thanks to their WrestleMania 31 match, and continues to be a thorn in his side by going after his protégé, Seth Rollins. The match-up itself is fresh and should help draw more eyes to towards the WWE Network with a rare Sting appearance. This is all great stuff, but there is no way Sting should end up actually winning the WWE World Heavyweight title; no matter how long his run ends up being.
His age is probably the most obvious reason why a title run would be silly, at 56 years old is this really who WWE wants as their champion? He would likely take on a part-time schedule much like Brock Lesnar did with the title for much of the past year. Is that something fans really want again?
Let's take a look at those and a few other reasons why Sting shouldn't win at Night of Champions.
6. His Age
If Sting won the title he would become the oldest wrestler (56) to ever hold this title. He would beat out Vince McMahon who won the title at the age of 54 back in 1999. Mr. McMahon won it from Triple H and lost it back to the same man 6 days later. Amazingly, if you look at every world title winner ever, Sting would become second only to Mr. McMahon who held the ECW title at 61 years old.
Sting is in great shape for his age, but unfortunately his in-ring abilities have dropped significantly over the years, which would put a lot on his opponents to carry each match. If "believably" is going to be a factor in all of this, should a 56 year old man really be the champion when there's an entire roster of capable title holder? That might be something many fans have a hard time accepting.
5. He's A Part-Timer
Fans tend to be split on the topic of part-time wrestlers, especially those put in the main event scene. On the plus side, they bring in fresh match-ups and draw new eyes; typically causal or old fans that have lost interest in the product. On the other side, they tend not to show up at every show and it's a foregone conclusion that the will disappear once their big match is over.
Brock Lesnar was WWE Champion for 224 days and made just a few sporadic appearances in that time; usually when a PPV was around the corner. His presence made up for the lack of appearances, but I'm not sure if Sting can pull that off. When Brock did show up he would "hulk smash" anything in his way. Can Sting realistically do that now? Plus, his promo ability has always lacked and at this point is a pretty outdated style. Without a Paul Heyman to keep people hyped up his reign could become lackluster in a hurry. Fans can only see him show up and point a bat so many times.
4. Hurts The Locker Room
If WWE had a shallow roster and the product needed a boost, maybe this idea would work. At this point their roster is the deepest it's been in years. Looking over the roster there's easily 5 guys that are deserving of a title run. Not that every wrestler is worthy of being champion, but when they full-time workers and Sting gets to just roll in to become champ that could bring morale down a bit.
If I could channel the ghost of CM Punk for a moment; this was his main complaint that a guy like The Rock or Batista could just hop back in the company and take away the biggest spots from others who worked hard all year for that chance. You could say “well, that’s just life”, but in wrestling – where everything is predetermined – then it’s “well, that’s just Vince”.
3. He's A "WCW Guy"
From a fan's perspective this doesn't really matter; there have been plenty of wrestlers who worked for WCW that had a solid career with the WWE. Not to mention it is cool seeing Sting finally in the WWE. Aside from AJ Styles, he's one of the biggest names to never previously work for WWE. Unfortunately for Sting, being a major player in WCW matters a great deal to someone like Vince McMahon. He always tried to downplay anyone who came from there and thus it would be very surprising to see him give Sting the title.
Just look at how “The Stinger” was treated in his feud against Triple H. They eventually spun that whole silly feud into basically a "WWE vs. WCW" battle. Once that came to light you knew there was just no way Sting was going to win that match at WrestleMania 31 - and with a lot of outside interference - he didn't.
2. WrestleMania 31 Performance
Speaking of WrestleMania 31 his match against Triple H was an overbooked mess, but it was done for a reason. Slotted as just the third match on the card, Sting and Triple H couldn't put on much of a show without some help. By the time the match was over Billy Gunn, Road Dogg, X-Pac, Shawn Michaels, Hulk Hogan, Scott Hall, and Kevin Nash were at ringside. That's a whole lot of D-Generation X and n.W.o. nostalgia to get these two over.
Oh yeah, weapons were needed as well: Triple H's sledgehammer and Sting's bat went to war.
All of these theatrics can't be used every time Sting has a match, which is going to make for some very ugly matches in the future. He can barely squat down to do his finisher - The Scorpion Deathlock – so if he does show up a lot expect plenty of shenanigans to follow.
1. Transitioning The WWE Title To Sheamus
So the previous reasons are focused more on Sting having a somewhat lengthy title reign. There is also the possibility that when Sting gets the big win, Sheamus instantly shows up to cash-in his opportunity and ends up winning the title. First, do fans really want Sheamus as champion? It doesn't seem like it, even though he's turned heel there's not much buzz around him aside from "you look stupid!" chants. Since he's a heel, the likelihood of a legit match with Rollins is slim, but why couldn't he just take it from the champ when he's beaten down?
Second, it makes Sting just look dumb, as he literally becomes a transition champ simply to get the title on Sheamus. Not only did he lose the "WCW vs. WWE" battle, but now he's just a patsy to get the title off Rollins and on Sheamus. This happened to Daniel Bryan, but by the time his story was finished he was raising the titles above his head at WrestleMania. That ending seems very unlikely for Sting.
To sum things up; I like Sting, I'm glad he's in the WWE, but he shouldn't be WWE champion whether it's for one minute or a few months. I know there's plenty of Sting fans out there, so I look forward to your thoughts in the comment section.