6 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Late Night Dynamite (Sep 22)
#SignBenCarter.
The Wednesday Night Wars resumed with both AEW Dynamite and WWE NXT returning to their regular timeslots last week, though sports coverage continues to have an impact on the weekly wrestling schedule.
This special Late Night Dynamite was filmed last week. AEW captured the footage in the event of an NBA playoff series between the Houston Rockets and Los Angeles Lackers going to seven games, which would have meant moving off the regular Wednesday slot. The Lakers put the Rockets away, ending the series at five, and AEW decided to air this hour-long show on Tuesday as planned, meaning two consecutive nights of Dynamite.
Anna Jay vs. Brandi Rhodes, Matt Sydal vs. Shawn Spears, and Scorpio Sky vs. Ben Carter were all announced last week. Each brought varying levels of appeal, from the intrigue of seeing can't-miss indie prospect Carter in a bigger spotlight to the ongoing Rhodes family/Dark Order storyline, and with Chris Jericho returning to the announce booth, the end product was a lot of fun.
Airing after midnight means Late Night Dynamite is almost certain to suffer from diminished ratings, though the show largely delivered. Let's light the fuse...
Downs...
1. Confused Narrative Stifles Jay Vs. Rhodes
Anna Jay vs. Brandi Rhodes suffered not for a lack of effort, as both wrestlers worked hard through the six minutes they were given, but because Brandi's role in their storyline is all over the place.
Getting choked out after selflessly leaping to her fallen husband's aid should have babyfaced Rhodes instantly. Instead, Brandi has barely shifted her Nightmare Sisters heel character, having become increasingly villainous throughout her unlikely allegiance with Allie. Here, she was heelish throughout. Her facials, trash talk, and projected cockiness told you, definitively, that you cannot root for this person, despite her opponent.
This was particularly problematic when it came to the finish, which saw Evil Uno and Stu Grayson distract the referee before Jay kicked out of a pump kick and scored the submission via her Queen Slayer choke. The story here is that Brandi had Jay beaten until The Dark Order intervened. This is a fine way to put further sympathy on a babyface, but it doesn't work here. At all.
Jay continues to stand out as a wrestler far above her experience level, with her performance skills particularly impressive and her control segment well-worked. It'll be a while before she's anywhere close to the finished article, of course, but she looked good last night - in spite of everything.
Ups...
6. A Glimpse Of The Future?
Lord knows when AEW's oft-reported second network show will debut, but Late Night Dynamite was an encouraging preview of what it could entail once the market research is complete and Tony Khan and TNT are ready to pull the trigger.
Coming in at just 44 minutes without commercials (shout-outs to FITE.tv for trimming those), this was one of the year's breeziest wrestling shows. Not a second of it dragged. With only three matches and a handful of small storyline developments, LND was fun, easy to watch, and everything got as much time as it needed. A solid audition for what could come in the future - and definitely preferable to throwing something akin to Dark on TNT.
AEW's second show probably isn't happening anytime soon, though the promotion could do worse than following this blueprint.
5. BFF's
Alex Marvez caught up with Scorpio Sky after his victory over Ben Carter, with the SoCal Uncensored man putting his opponent over as a "stud with a bright future," then reaffirming his desire to become TNT Champion. Matt Sydal showed up mid-sentence. The duo talked each other up, with Sydal set to face Shawn Spears, then agreed to hit the bar after the show, going their separate ways to close.
Nothing particularly complex, here, but this simple segment accomplished two goals:-
1. Established the Sydal/Sky friendship ahead of the post-main event angle.
2. Dolloped extra heat on Sydal vs. Spears by acknowledging that Matt eliminated Shawn from the recent Casino Battle Royale.
Quick, effective booking.
4. Hyping Brodie Vs. Orange
The short Brodie Lee vs. Orange Cassidy hype piece was well done, with Taz putting the TNT Champion over as a mega-threat, interspersed with footage of Brodie's title win, victory promo, and various bruising victories. It was then asserted that Cassidy would likely need to drop the comedy shtick and get serious to avoid becoming another Cody, setting an appropriate tone ahead of their showdown on tonight's episode of Dynamite.
Again, nothing exceptional here: just good, solid work. Hype segments don't always need to be melodramatic five-minuters with butt-rock soundtracks. Sometimes, a few talking heads and highlights will do.
3. Matt Sydal Gets Gloved
It was refreshing to see Shawn Spears outside of Dark, where he squashes an endless stream of jobbers through methods that rarely change, letting himself get frustrated by their spirit before putting them away and loading up the black glove.
The glove came into play for the finish here. Chris Jericho put the gimmick over as Spears was coming out, establishing Chekhov's Gun, but Shawn chose to load it before the bell, not after. Slugging Sydal in the face and hitting his C4 finisher was enough to end the high-flyer's night. Scorpio Sky saved Sydal from further punishment afterwards, running Spears and Tully Blanchard off to set up another potential singles clash.
A very good match, this. Spears is always going to work in a certain grindy fashion, but that doesn't mean he can't be compelling. Here, his gameplan was constantly foiled by Sydal, whose technicality opened doors for his elite athleticism to step through, leading to him controlling longer portions than the heel may have expected. This informed Spears' decision to load the glove and cheat to win.
2. Sign Ben Carter
There's a strong chance that AEW has already signed Ben Carter to a contract, given that he was put in this Dynamite spotlight in the first place. If they haven't, they must do so before a competitor steps in and takes him out free agency. It's that simple.
Having excelled in his Dark debut, Carter was outstanding against Scorpio Sky, proving his mastery of the things that really matter in professional wrestling. Yes, he can flip and fly, and he's great at those aspects, but bumping, selling, and being able to tell a story are more important. Carter has these skills in droves.
An ideal world would see Carter spend another couple of years honing his craft on the indies before making the step up. Professional wrestling is different now, though. Competition means anyone who builds even a slither of hype is immediately on the radar, so AEW must act now before WWE, NJPW, or Impact are hitting Carter up. Nobody can afford to let this guy slip away.
1. Sky Fliers
So, Scoprio Sky vs. Ben Carter.
It f*cking ruled.
Built around the simple story of the young newcomer pushing the veteran to his limit until his heart ran out and the victor's savvy took over, this was brisk, exciting, and super crisp. There's a snap and a pop to Carter's work that gives the impression he has been wrestling far beyond his actual experience level. Paired with Sky's trademark smoothness, it made for a can't-fail combination that pulsed with energy as the fighters struggled to break parity and take control.
Having forced Sky to rethink his gameplan on several occasions, Carter eventually came to life with explosions of offense, scoring a great near-fall from a Frog Splash. That Scorpio picked up a cut beside his eye helped the bout feel more intense, physical, and attritional, and while Ben's fight left the SCU man in disbelief after he kicked out of a Fisherman's Buster, he eventually scored the TKO for the win.
Without a drop of hyperbole, this was one of the year's best Dynamite matches. Miss it at your peril.