6 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 4)
Roman Reigns showed why he's the best character in wrestling on SmackDown.
SmackDown has been killing it recently.
No, ratings aren't exactly through the roof, but WWE have been producing a solid pro wrestling show on Friday nights since they rid themselves of cross-brand warfare in the lead up to Survivor Series. Last week was a stunning step in the right direction that earned more than three times as many 'Ups' as it did 'Downs'.
Of course, follow up is everything. The good news? This week's show did follow up on last week's fun in a big way, and there's a little sprinkling of positivity surrounding things heading into TLC on 20 December. The main reason for that is Roman Reigns; he's transformed from an occasionally yawn-worthy babyface into wrestling's best character.
There are no exceptions.
Friday proved that yet again, and WWE even managed to go beyond their usual tributes for fallen greats elsewhere. Pat Patterson was given an emotional send off by a company that adored him - his memory also managed to integrate itself with current storytelling and progress the product. Pat would've been proud of that.
Here are all the 'Ups' and the 'Downs'...
Downs...
3. The Street Profits
This wasn't good enough.
During a listless backstage segment, WWE seemed to suggest that The Street Profits will defend their SmackDown Tag belts in some sort of multi-team effort at TLC. That's all they have for these guys after that 'passing of the torch' moment at Survivor Series? Seriously?
That's bad enough, but Dawkins and Ford reverted to type on Friday by becoming glorified shills for other storylines again. Despite having bags of personality and charisma for days, the pair cannot be expected to work miracles with material so paper-thin - where's that fire they showed at the start of their New Day feud?
The Profits lost last week, and Robert Roode cheated to do it, so they should've been p*ssed about that rather than yakking wastefully about why fans already watching the show should be excited for SmackDown. This was total rubbish.
2. Oh-no-tis
Some will point out that Otis, for all his ongoing problems, did have a (temporary) spot in the main event. Sure, mixing it with essential characters like Roman Reigns can't be a bad thing, but the one-time Mr. Money In The Bank just feels so directionless right now.
Teaming with Chad Gable won't ease his plight.
WWE should not have given Otis the MITB briefcase or so much shine over the summer if they didn't have a long-term plan for the guy. It's hardly like he crapped the bed during skits with Mandy Rose. In fact, Otis was one of the most popular stars in the company at one stage, and he's not to blame for how badly things have regressed.
Splitting him from Tucker was another mistake. Neither man feels like they're going anywhere, and this thrown-together tandem with Gable is a borderline insult from creative.
1. Bayley Loses (For Some Reason)
The ultimate goal for Bayley's feud with Bianca Belair must be to elevate the latter.
If so, it's a winning idea that could help Belair become the star WWE believe she can be in this division. The truth is that she also needs someone strong to beat, and SmackDown's writers aren't exactly giving her the strongest Bayley possible - this week's show was a step in the wrong direction.
Bayley jobbed to Natalya, and then Bianca laughed at her. That was it. If WWE think a loser version of the longest-running Women's Champ of her generation is going to help Belair bed in on SmackDown, then they need to reevaluate how they plan to build fresh faces.
If anything, Bayley shouldn't have lost until facing Belair one-on-one. Any chance of building a believable story that sees this ex-champ cut down to size by a super-talented newcomer has been lost. Now, Bianca beating Bayley means less. Great.
Ups...
6. That Opening Segment
Roman Reigns treating Kayla Braxton like he's above her interviews has legs. Credit must also go to Braxton for playing her role perfectly and not getting sniffy herself about suggestions she's not as good at her job as Michael Cole once was, because that dick move from Reigns cemented this segment's excellence.
So did Kevin Owens calling him a big bitch.
WWE's show-opening promo trains are so formulaic by now that they often fail to spark much interest. Generally, fans know what they're getting from these things: Wrestler A does some talking before Wrestler B comes out to help set up a match later on. It's standard stuff, but works a treat when the characters are as strong as these guys.
This company functions best when characters are clearly defined too. Roman is a sneering overlord, Jey Uso a put-upon family man, Paul Heyman a hanger-on, Kayla a professional only trying to do her job and Owens someone who sees through the bullsh*t.
5. Subtly Smart Diva Framing
Apparently, Carmella's defined role is 'Diva' to Sasha Banks' serious pro wrestler.
That's fine, 'cause both women suit those roles nicely. Hardcore fans do view 'Mella as someone WWE routinely push despite a lack of stunning in-ring skills, and Banks is seen as someone who credibly established herself as a worker in NXT. They clash nicely as natural rivals.
The pair's sit down interview was well-worked for what it was. Explaining why both had to talk from separate locations (they've been attacking one another for weeks and would likely scrap again) was smart, and it's genuinely nice to have a fresh-feeling opponent for Sasha after months of Bayley.
Their insults were predictable here, but that doesn't mean they were bad. Again, this was exactly what it needed to be, and framing Carmella as the antithesis of Banks should work out well when they finally square off at TLC.
4. Forgotten No More
It always felt slightly harsh that Wesley Blake and Steve Cutler suffered because of Jaxson Ryker's social media rants. Their momentum as the Forgotten Sons was completely destroyed once Ryker decided to play keyboard warrior and irk many backstage, and that wasn't fair.
They're back though, and about time.
Though it remains to be seen what aligning with 'King' Corbin will do for the former bikers, at least they're back on TV. Both must've been fearing the worst after becoming collateral in their old leader's Twitter-based nonsense, so it'll come as a relief that they could be reborn as some sort of royal tag-team.
It's cheesy as hell, but WWE could do worse than repackaging Blake and Cutler as royal minions of Corbin who do his bidding and challenge for the SmackDown Tag Titles into the bargain. They're a talented duo, and they deserve another shot at glory.
3. That Pat Patterson Tribute
WWE's video team are peerless.
The tribute video they put together for company lifer Pat Patterson cleverly fused archive footage with clips of the man himself singing Frank Sinatra's 'My Way'. There was something poignant about that, because Pat really did do things his way, and the bravery he once showed should not be overlooked.
Coming out as gay during a time when that was very-much frowned upon in wrestling circles was remarkably courageous. WWE didn't really lean on that for their tributes on SmackDown, but they did spin through several cheery photographs showing how much Patterson meant to the industry overall.
It takes a lot of skill to edit tasteful tributes that whisk viewers on a journey this lengthy in just three short minutes. That speaks to the talent of WWE's production staff. They should take a bow for how elegant and charming this video was.
2. Intercontinental Integration
Then, Bruce Prichard (assuming he was the one responsible here) should get a pat (ahem) on the back for integrating Patterson's tribute with ongoing storylines. The way WWE seamlessly transitioned into the bubbling Daniel Bryan vs. Sami Zayn feud whilst still paying homage to Pat was beautiful.
It didn't hurt that the talent level was so high either.
SmackDown featured a six-man tag match that exclusively housed former and current Intercontinental Champions. Zayn, the guy holding Pat's old belt now, teamed with Dolph Ziggler and Shinsuke Nakamura to wrestle Bryan, Big E and Rey Mysterio in another fitting show of appreciation for Patterson's legacy.
This wasn't the exhibition-style send off it could've been. WWE had Bryan go over Sami to send a message to the current champ, and that's booking Pat probably would've been proud of. His memory was aptly used to build towards the future.
1. Making A Monster
Someone hit up a thesaurus, because this writer might need some more superlatives to help describe the job WWE are doing with Roman Reigns. In fact, add both Jey Uso and Kevin Owens into that, because they too are on top form.
Following the main event tag (that turned into a two-on-one handicap situation), Roman and Jey bashed a helpless KO with steel chairs. Then, to remind Uso who calls the shots around here, Reigns blasted his cousin from behind and started laying into him too. Without missing a beat, Roman then told Kevin not to target his family.
The genius of this is that Reigns believes only he can beat up Jey - not out of rivalry, but to steer him on the right path. This one plot point vindicates what KO has been harping on about, and it makes Roman look like a heartless beast who believes his own hype.
According to Roman, coming for the Universal Title is akin to coming for his spot, and he can't have that. Brilliant stuff.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 7 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Nov 27) and 10 WWE Matches The Undertaker Wants You To Forget!