6 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (17 May - Review)

The Elite is complete, Pillars unite against MJF and Chris Jericho & Roderick Strong touch grass.

By Michael Hamflett /

AEW

More on Tony Khan's big smiles later in this article, but he was more than entitled to be sporting them after AEW's latest money-spinning television venture was revealed at WBD's upfronts just hours before the May 17th Dynamite hit the air.

Advertisement

Collision will launch on Saturday 17th June, and unconfirmed figures circling in all the usual places ahead of the news had the number of zeroes at nine. It's a big figure, a big story and a big moment in the company's history. But we are not network executives (apart from the ones reading in between meetings - hello!) or billionaire businessmen. We are wrestling fans being asked to part with money for a pay-per-view in two weeks. It's possible to celebrate the good news for the long-term health of the company while panicking slightly about the short-term after one of the weaker supercard builds in AEW's history.

May 10th's turbocharged Kenny Omega/Jon Moxley steel cage main event was a statement of intent from build to shocking conclusion, but could Khan build on that and everything else on his show to prove that his creative head was still as switched on as his commercial one?

Advertisement

Let’s light the fuse…

Downs…

4. Wardlow & Christian Spit Fire, Stipulation Douses Flames

AEW

It was disgustingly in-character of Christian Cage to promote that he was coming to Dynamite to spit in Wardlow's face, and equally believable that the TNT Champion wasn't prepared to hang around and wait for such a gross fate.

Advertisement

As such, the talking segment between the two made narrative sense and played out to a hot and receptive crowd, proving yet again that the injection of Arn Anderson to Wardlow's act might have been one Tony Khan's greatest Hail Mary passes and Christian Cage is one of the most valuable players on any team.

The quickie build has been effective, but Wardlow's promo later in the show laying the challenge down for a Ladder Match was disheartening. The stipulation feels more of a curse than a blessing in 2023, with climbing contests and needlessly intensified danger taking away from what stood the chance of being a uniquely poised singles match. Cage's experience with the gimmick might enhance the rub he'll give Wardlow in defeat, but his dark arts in-ring genius could have achieved that too.

Advertisement

3. Sammy Guevara Vs Exodus Prime

AEW

Sammy Guevara making short (extremely short, 26-seconds-short) work of Exodus Prime wasn't the story, but what exactly is at this point?

Advertisement

'The Spanish God' becoming a situational babyface in the Four Pillars feud just about makes sense after his original plan to make big money alongside MJF failed, but the recklessness around Guevara as a character has badly diluted ahead of this this latest beat.

'The Salt Of The Earth' was less than impressed with his lot - and more on that later - as a result of the gentleman's agreement to topple him that's seemingly been established between the challengers, but Guevara feels on the fringes of the headline clash anyway. This constant confusion around his alignment really hasn't helped.

Advertisement

2. Jay White Vs Ricky Starks

AEW

That a match ending in a disqualification or count-out still feels like a transgression is a credit to AEW's booking and may be a Jay White staple based on this being the second match to get thrown out since he landed a full time spot with the company. However, this one felt much, much closer to the sort of finish WWE would roll out in order to "protect" one wrestler or extend the programme towards a less satisfying sequel.

Advertisement

The excitement of this being brought forward to a Dynamite two weeks before Double Or Nothing centred around the idea that neither man could really lose. Starks was the hometown favourite and White was the new hot heel. Something had to give, and...nothing did.

There were flashpoints where the pair luxuriated in their natural gifts too, and more's the pity after it was thrown out to tee up something else down the road. Starks' babyface run hasn't been as smooth as hoped, but few heels have complimented and stifled his fire quite like 'Switchblade'. But it wasn't close to hitting projected heights before then, and trying to find a personal issue in a post-match only acted as reminder that they've failed to do so along the way.

Advertisement

1. Tony Khan "Elaborates"

AEW

On last week's Dynamite, Tony Khan's big announcement was that he had a big announcement this week. During this week's big announcement he left a big announcement on the table for next week and look - the lame joke has already written itself.

Advertisement

Something feels awry.

A beaming Khan was buzzing to reveal the Collision news and various dates either side of June's Forbidden Door in Canada, but Excalibur's early clarification that he'd be "elaborating" on big news felt like an attempt to get across a letdown before it aired.

Advertisement

The detail Khan left out was exactly where the show's June 17th debut would air from. This despite news already being out there that the United Centre in Chicago was booked for that specific Saturday. As rumours swirled that CM Punk's return might not be as nailed on as first thought, this delaying tactic had an uneasy and disappointing air about it. Next week should bring about an end to this run of public addresses too - if faith in their size and scale wasn't already shaken, it is now.

Ups…

6. Orange Cassidy & Darby Allin Vs Lee Moriarty & Big Bill

AEW

Though not dropped in as the hot Dynamite opener on a technicality (Wardlow's words with Christian Cage opened the show proper), this joyous tag bout captured the magic of the old formula and disguised some genuinely impressive booking and matchmaking within the body of a fun knockabout tag.

Advertisement

Who knows what's happening with The Firm after the latest calamity with Matt Hardy, but Bill and Moriarty have the sort of big man/little man chemistry that shouldn't be thrown away in the aftermath. This was a showcase for the heroes, but - much like The Butcher & The Blade's killer offerings - such a thing can only be as good as those on the other side of the ring.

Allin winning with a headlock takeover was cute foreshadowing of a white hot spot to come in the Double Or Nothing main event, whilst this entire match allowed for Orange Cassidy to remain on his 20th title defence until the pay-per-view where he'll work against the same number of opponents in his latest (and 21st) workhorse challenge. Between the beloved characters, surprise package opposition and careful plotting, this was AEW back operating at peak.

Advertisement

5. FTR & Triple J Brawl And The Champions Don't Count On A Karen

AEW

The FTR/Triple J brawl was red hot from the moment it started, because it started with Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler pushing Satnam Singh off the stage through a table.

Advertisement

With the giant temporarily disposed of thanks to some old school skullduggery from the wily Champions, the gripping brawl delighted the Texas crowd until the Challengers revealed the ace up their sleeve. Karen Jarrett's arrival in All Elite Wrestling may be greeted with the same caution Jeff's was, but look how that worked out. She proved herself a fantastic heel alongside her husband in Impact Wrestling and especially in Jarrett & Lethal's run in with Ric Flair for 'The Nature Boy's last match special in 2022. A low blow here put over the possibilities, as did dual guitar shots to Dax and Cash to illustrate a togetherness that equals their own.

Karen gets the pantomime of it all, and will matter where it counts. She'll provide yet more infuriating distraction for Mark Briscoe to worry about during the chaotic Double Or Nothing clash, almost certainly extracting yet another exhilarating near fall from a Jeff Jarrett title challenge.

Advertisement

4. Toni Storm & Ruby Soho Vs Dr Britt Baker DMD & Hikaru Shida

AEW

It was late on Wednesday that Tony Khan confirmed that AEW Women's Champion Jamie Hayter hadn't been cleared to wrestle on Dynamite, and the switching of the match from trios to tag should have resulted in this match falling short.

Advertisement

If anything, the opposite was true. The Outcasts/Homegrowns feud has worked, and this was some objective proof. The crowd came unglued for the entrances and stayed electric for a bout not short on slick sequences and stiff shots. Saraya's interference to set up the victory for the heels felt a bit played out, but this was presumably the destination anyway based on what we got later.

Toni Storm being confirmed as the Double Or Nothing challenger for Hayter presents the best possible singles combination out of all six, and while a title change feels unlikely, the lingering possibility of a Baker turn keeps the whole programme hot.

Advertisement

3. Roderick Strong Vs Chris Jericho

AEW

Perfection.

Advertisement

This was perfection. Roderick Strong and Chris Jericho battled for 14 scintillating minutes and every second of it was perfection. Juggling strong style with arena brawl chaos and just about every genre in between, the two had a war so epic that their names will be inexorably linked together forever.

A chop fight Gunther himself would be proud of spilled into the stands in short order as the Falls Count Anywhere stipulation gifted them the freedom of the building and their own creativity. Tables, stanchions and ice cream were all key weapons as the action never once let up, and a sequence on a stairwell somehow balanced heart-in-mouth terror with the comedic-feeling sensibilities of DDT and the last two minutes of an All Japan strike war.

Advertisement

The finish being exactly what everybody predicted was made sweeter by Jericho himself not seeing it coming. The battle needed to be out of the building for Adam Cole to extract some revenge for the JAS leader's recent crimes, and he got to do just that to steer Strong to a major win in his own debut. Run it back or just rerun it forever because if there is still such a thing as a spirt of AEW four years into the organisation's existence, it burst forth during every sensational second of this.

2. Jungle Boy Jack Perry Vs Rush

AEW

Shooting for a memorable beatdown of the babyface, Rush bloodying up Jack Perry just two weeks from his biggest ever match was absolutely the move here. For a match featuring two men that don't necessarily have the most consistent record on television, this was best possible version of what they were able to achieve.

Advertisement

The finish was - in contrast to the muddled Sammy Guevara stuff earlier in the show - intriguing too. Perry scoring a win with a sneaky roll-up showed ingenuity but also a sly side that he might need and exploit during the Four Pillars main event.

And about that. The close of this match saw Darby Allin and Sammy Guevara chase off the heels as they tried a post-match beatdown on Perry, seemingly in an effort to show broad solidarity between the challengers ahead of Double Or Nothing. MJF fumed in the aftermath, aggressively slapping the microphone out of Renee Paquette's hand when she asked for his response to the scene. The idea of the Challengers finally out-thinking the Champion this close to the show is a great one, especially if it turns out to be Jungle Boy who breaks the union for his own gain.

Advertisement

1. The Elite Is Complete

AEW

Don Callis had only just started gaslighting Kenny Omega when 'The Best Bout Machine's arrival triggered a chain of events that paid off weeks of teases, twists and turns just in time.

Advertisement

Omega hadn't yet finished battering Callis' security detail before The Blackpool Combat Club launched a four-on-one attack that brought The Young Bucks back out after they'd taken their own backstage beating earlier in the night. Anticipation built magnificently as the numbers left space for Hangman Page's epic return, and the Texas crowd roared their approval when Omega extended a violent olive branch in the form of a barbed wire broom.

The ensuing four-on-four decided to show what was on the docket for Double Or Nothing before Page told The BCC what was coming their way in Las Vegas. Being given the microphone and all the agency that entails, the former AEW Champion issued the challenge and confirmed that the company's middle initial was back to full strength. Anarchy In The Arena was at long last locked in, and for a refreshing change, The Elite were given a gloriously cathartic moment to live up to their prestigious name.

Advertisement